Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain is not ready for BAME PM

341 replies

notnever · 10/07/2022 01:06

Rishi might just be voted by MPs but will not win general elections. Already we are reminded he is rich, has an US Greencard, cut taxes, unrelatable, wife is rich and did not pay tax, did not declare tax, etc, as if any different from Boris.

Do you think Britain is ready for BAME PM?
Yes = you are unreasonable
No = you are not being unreasonable

NB, you don't have to explain whether it makes Britain racist or not. I am personally happy he is standing for leadership, it will be his good reminder (as many of us BAME know) racism trumps social class.

OP posts:
milord · 10/07/2022 15:37

notnever · 10/07/2022 15:16

@offyoufuckcuntychops I am not negating my point. I am saying, even before campaigning started we were already reminded of why Rishi is not suitable. Many of the reasons pointed out, weren't any different from Boris.

To prove my point, this thread started with Rishi is wealthy - so unrelatable, but so is Boris - then it moved on to he is too wealthy, rather Sajid - knowing fully Sajid does not stand a chance. Responses on here are an example of shifting goal posts for anyone who is not white.

Boris is racist and but the majority know it and voted for him (yes, I know I will be reminded they voted for Tory not Boris - it's typical racist gaslighting I'm used to)

It's literally not a black and white issue, though. It certainly is naive to think that it boils down to 'If he was white, he could have gotten away with it, but as he is 'BAME' he won't get elected'.

He is actually frontrunner for election DESPITE all of those things you mention. I will be very interested in your response when he - as is looking more inevitable - wins this candidacy. But I'm sure you'll find another way to twist it to your 'white moving the goalposts of racism' agenda anyway...

Boris and Rishi each have their own faults, but they're certainly not a list of identical comparators, with the one difference of skin colour. Now, seems even Boris' skin colour hasn't saved him from being disempowered by his own party...

Leadership elections always bring heavy scrutiny onto the candidates running. You'll find that EVERY SINGLE ONE of them is receiving heat in the press for things they have done and said. That is the press' job to tear them apart to prove that they are worthy candidates to run a country. Mordaunt is receiving heavy criticism in relation to women's/trans rights, for example. Absolutely no one is protected from proper due scrutiny and failings because they happen to be white, which you are conveniently overlooking.

There's been some fascination commentary on left/right ideology and representation in this thread, which is far more interesting to sink your teeth into but which you are not addressing as it doesn't fit in with your narrow view.

In short, you're talking a lot of bollocks.

Theoneinthemiddle · 10/07/2022 15:29

Personally, I think this thread is “testing the waters”- market research as to how he will be received.

One great advantage he has is that everyone knows him and as yet we know very little about some of the other candidates.

So the others need to increase their visibility pretty fast!

notnever · 10/07/2022 15:16

@offyoufuckcuntychops I am not negating my point. I am saying, even before campaigning started we were already reminded of why Rishi is not suitable. Many of the reasons pointed out, weren't any different from Boris.

To prove my point, this thread started with Rishi is wealthy - so unrelatable, but so is Boris - then it moved on to he is too wealthy, rather Sajid - knowing fully Sajid does not stand a chance. Responses on here are an example of shifting goal posts for anyone who is not white.

Boris is racist and but the majority know it and voted for him (yes, I know I will be reminded they voted for Tory not Boris - it's typical racist gaslighting I'm used to)

OP posts:
RewildingAmbridge · 10/07/2022 15:10

I wouldn't vote for him for many of the same reasons I didn't vote for Boris

nuttybranhare · 10/07/2022 15:00

Basically, they type of person who really doesn't like black and brown people (to the point they're unelectable) isn't going to be swayed by that. They just still won't like them, they can never win.

CruCru · 10/07/2022 14:58

I would like to think that Rishi would be elected. He is very rich but so is David Cameron. Although Rishi is much richer, after a certain point it loses its meaning (£3 bn vs. £50m - once people have wealth about about £15 m it almost doesn’t matter how much they have).

He is quite smooth but perhaps it would be refreshing to have a PM who doesn’t do and say mad things.

nuttybranhare · 10/07/2022 14:58

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 14:41

But the answer is obvious: society generally find leaders who are female or people of colour acceptable if they're towards the right; after all, they got there by supporting the white, male power structure; they'd have been booted out long before had they support critical race theory, meaningful feminism etc.

I’d not thought of it that way before but I think you’ve hit the nail on the head.

Reflecting their values makes them ‘one of the good ones of <insert group>’ and distances them from those scary people who think differently and that they should be entitled to the same opportunities.

(also see Raab implying Rayner was a champagne socialist for attending some posh opera, the implication being it wasn’t for the likes of her).

I don't think so. If you're right-leaning or a conservative voter, it doesn't mean you're thinking they're 'one of the good ones', you're just supporting a candidate that believes the same as you!

The type of people who are that against black and Asian people in power will not be supporting them, period. You can't paint everyone the same, that's not accurate.

Being right leaning and traditional is often used as a stick to beat black and Asian communities with, they don't see it as desirable at all. Islamophobia, for a start.

MarshaBradyo · 10/07/2022 14:45

Seems a negative take on diversity

If the left can’t do the same it’s good we have one side where it’s possible

I’m only seeing negativity re this from the left atm

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 14:41

But the answer is obvious: society generally find leaders who are female or people of colour acceptable if they're towards the right; after all, they got there by supporting the white, male power structure; they'd have been booted out long before had they support critical race theory, meaningful feminism etc.

I’d not thought of it that way before but I think you’ve hit the nail on the head.

Reflecting their values makes them ‘one of the good ones of <insert group>’ and distances them from those scary people who think differently and that they should be entitled to the same opportunities.

(also see Raab implying Rayner was a champagne socialist for attending some posh opera, the implication being it wasn’t for the likes of her).

Echobelly · 10/07/2022 14:36

I think UK is ready for this... but ONLY if they are right wing. I saw a post on Tweet going 'Well it looks like the tories are going to have the first female PM and the first non-white PM and the Left really need to be asking why'

But the answer is obvious: society generally find leaders who are female or people of colour acceptable if they're towards the right; after all, they got there by supporting the white, male power structure; they'd have been booted out long before had they support critical race theory, meaningful feminism etc.

IN the US Obama obviously something of an exception, but note how he had to steer clear of race issues, and also from gun control, lest he be portrayed as 'Look, the blacks are taking our guns away!' (when you consider a lot of the laxness of gun law stems from racism).

Wishihadanalgorithm · 10/07/2022 14:30

Not being a conservative, I don’t get a say in who will lead the party but in all honesty, they could be sky blue pink and I wouldn’t care as long as they can deal with the mess the country is currently in.

I did think Sunak was a sure thing for taking over from Bojo - the furlough scheme really helped so many people but I think that has been forgotten due to his wife’s tax “situation.”

In my social circle I genuinely don’t think I know of anyone who would vote based on a candidate’s colour. I could be wrong, but people’s race, colour or religion are never mentioned.

lightisnotwhite · 10/07/2022 14:29

You don’t believe that the more intelligent pupils at your school came out with better results, on average, than the less intelligent ones?

No! And nor does any sane person. Some were undoubtably more intelligent .Some of the people with the best results came from households that paid for tutors, had houses large and comfortable enough to have private study space and opportunities to resources like books and trips that help.
Some intelligent children won’t achieve what they could because they are sharing bedrooms, helping out at home and have parents with other issues.

Wealthy people tend to be elected because of what I said earlier. We don’t like angry politicians pointing out the problems. We like leaders that support a broad church.and look like they can handle life.

Diverseopinions · 10/07/2022 14:28

I can see what that other thread was angling at, 'why isn't racism called out more on Mumsnet?'.

Just the title and premise of this thread is racist. I'll be surprised if it doesn't get pulled. If anyone replies:' No Britain isn't ready for a BAME PM', then they must think ......or assume.....that the bulk of the population in Britain is racist. To make an assumption like that, you must have an idea in your head of on what that prejudice would be based, and have reasons for thinking that such a prejudice could actually exist.

I don't think that sort of prejudice does exist, and I would be seriously concerned about Britain, if it did.

I predict that Sunak will win the party endorsement, and start serving in the role of PM, before October, and with Sajid Javid as his deputy. I think that something even more damaging, to do with Sunak's finances and personal tax, will then come out and scupper his chances and he'll resign.. Javid will take over as PM and be a fantastic one, showing the skills which enabled him to rise from a modest background to a senior role in investment banking. The fact that he went to a state school will play well with the electorate. For the Tories to stay in power, though, they will need to get together a brilliant strategy to beat fuel poverty.

Luxa · 10/07/2022 14:22

In general wealthy people will skew heavily towards being more intelligent and able.

I'm sure we have all met 'Tim/Tara nice but dim many times', not to mention verbose, over-confident average Joes/Josies who think they know it all. Meanwhile, the most intelligent state school students are often failed by an education which allows them to do well enough, but nowhere near reach their full potential.

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 14:22

How so?

If you are intelligent and well-educated you are more able to get a high-paying job.

If you have low IQ and no qualifications that option is less available.

It’s no more prejudiced than saying that good basketball players skew towards being taller.

so what about the intelligent but poorly educated? When do they fit in?

YetiTeri · 10/07/2022 14:16

Luxa · 10/07/2022 11:30

as long as they didn't go to bloody Eton!

If any woman gets the job, problem solved.

Even Nadine?

plugee · 10/07/2022 14:03

You don’t believe that the more intelligent pupils at your school came out with better results, on average, than the less intelligent ones?

No, the ones who revised the most did the best. I also don't think the best way to measure intelligence is our school exams. In one of my A level modules I didn't do any revision & got an E. I retook it 3 months later & got 98%, the highest grade in the school. I revised the night before & got lucky that the paper was based on that. Did I go from stupid to really intelligent in 3 months?

nuttybranhare · 10/07/2022 13:59

Better him than an unemployed single mother with no qualifications who’s living on benefits though.

This isn't even relevant to anything. Did you really have to shoehorn single mother bashing into your post @AnaïsM? Very prejudiced, I'll-informed, outdated and lacking in empathy.

Rosessmelllike · 10/07/2022 13:59

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 13:45

You have cause and effect the wrong way round. If you are very intelligent then you can more easily become a GP, banker, corporate lawyer etc. Intelligence is beneficial if you want a high-paying job.

This isn’t controversial or prejudiced at all. It’s a bit sad that people are angered by simple truths.

Ah, the old classic all cleaners / bus drivers / hair dressers / shop workers / grounds maintenance / keyworker / anyone in a ''nonprofessional'' role or on less than 50 grand a year are stupid and it's their own fault they aren't a lawyer trope, and that no one who is in one of these professions or earning a lot money or the government got a hli hand due to nepotism and connections and going to private school fantasy but through sheer hard work alone, AKA classism, AKA demonisation of working people demonstrated nicely in action by yourself

EstoPerpetua · 10/07/2022 13:58

Luxa · 10/07/2022 11:30

as long as they didn't go to bloody Eton!

If any woman gets the job, problem solved.

Eton is nothing to do with it. There are fuckwits at all schools. One school and its endlessly long list of former and current pupils should not be judged by the entitled idiocy of a vocal and well-known tiny minority.

offyoufuckcuntychops · 10/07/2022 13:56

Already we are reminded he is rich, has an US Greencard, cut taxes, unrelatable, wife is rich and did not pay tax, did not declare tax, etc

You negate your own point, @notnever. The issue is not even remotely the colour of his skin, but his behaviour and policies. Those things are why he's unelectable.

wellhelloitsme · 10/07/2022 13:54

If you are very intelligent then you can more easily become a GP, banker, corporate lawyer etc. Intelligence is beneficial if you want a high-paying job.

You don't seem to understand what people are saying.

Wealthy people aren't automatically born with a higher IQ than non wealthy people.

Wealthy people have more access to good education, parental support, role models in the careers you mentioned, aspirations that are encouraged, their parents can fund their studies, their parents can pay them an allowance while they do internships in a city (something out of reach financially for many people), they have access to contacts through their parents and schools... the list of privileges is endless.

There are always exceptions to this of course, genuinely self made millionaires etc. But for the most part wealthy people don't just happen to have a higher IQ than poor people. That was either a foolish thing to think or you worded it incredibly poorly.

Rosessmelllike · 10/07/2022 13:53

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 13:42

How so?

If you are intelligent and well-educated you are more able to get a high-paying job.

If you have low IQ and no qualifications that option is less available.

It’s no more prejudiced than saying that good basketball players skew towards being taller.

You are confusing success and promotion - well done for recognising there is a barrier against promoting working class people to high positions or government (generalisation) - with innate characteristics of intelligence and ability, as though there is a ''rich intelligence gene''. Frankly abhorrent eugenicism

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 13:52

plugee · 10/07/2022 13:47

And personally I don't align most qualifications with IQ.

You don’t believe that the more intelligent pupils at your school came out with better results, on average, than the less intelligent ones?

That sounds quite unlikely.

The most intelligent from my school went on to good degrees, the least intelligent left as early as they could and did no further qualifications.

ddl1 · 10/07/2022 13:49

Personally, I wouldn't vote for Rishi. But it's not because of the colour of his skin. It's because of the (blue) colour of his rosette.