Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain is not ready for BAME PM

341 replies

notnever · 10/07/2022 01:06

Rishi might just be voted by MPs but will not win general elections. Already we are reminded he is rich, has an US Greencard, cut taxes, unrelatable, wife is rich and did not pay tax, did not declare tax, etc, as if any different from Boris.

Do you think Britain is ready for BAME PM?
Yes = you are unreasonable
No = you are not being unreasonable

NB, you don't have to explain whether it makes Britain racist or not. I am personally happy he is standing for leadership, it will be his good reminder (as many of us BAME know) racism trumps social class.

OP posts:
110APiccadilly · 10/07/2022 07:27

Of course, if he doesn't get voted in we'll never know for sure why not. None of the senior BAME conservatives seem to have put people off voting for them though, so I am not at all convinced that having a BAME leader would do either.

I suspect there's a few racists around who wouldn't vote for him on principle (if you can call that a principle). But I also suspect there's not enough of them to change the outcome of a general election.

However, we've had a long stretch of conservative government and things both domestically and internationally are pretty tempestuous. Labour have probably got the best chance they've had in quite some time of winning an election next time, whoever the conservative leader is.

tttigress · 10/07/2022 07:26

LunchPoems · 10/07/2022 07:21

I was wondering about this.

I think a lot of ordinary voters would vote for a BAME person, but I’m not sure the Tories themselves will, if that makes sense?

I don’t think it’s goady to ask.

Yes, but all of these people have already risen through the Tory party. So as per your theory wouldn't they have been blocked at a lower level?

YetiTeri · 10/07/2022 07:23

ArcticSkewer · 10/07/2022 07:16

Why is your example - Rishi?? You give a ton of perfectly legitimate reasons why people wouldn't like him, none connected to skin colour. Why not Sunak? A lot less negative stuff to say about him (imo)

Anyway ...bame ... a total useless word.

Classic racist micro aggression right there.

LunchPoems · 10/07/2022 07:21

I was wondering about this.

I think a lot of ordinary voters would vote for a BAME person, but I’m not sure the Tories themselves will, if that makes sense?

I don’t think it’s goady to ask.

Fairyliz · 10/07/2022 07:19

So if people don't vote for Rishi because they think he is too rich and out of touch you will assume they are racist?
Isn’t that a bit narrow minded and bending the facts to suit your theory?

ArcticSkewer · 10/07/2022 07:16

Why is your example - Rishi?? You give a ton of perfectly legitimate reasons why people wouldn't like him, none connected to skin colour. Why not Sunak? A lot less negative stuff to say about him (imo)

Anyway ...bame ... a total useless word.

brown543 · 10/07/2022 07:15

But I agree. Brexit Britain won't vote for a brown person.

Come on. Hands up, I voted for Brexit. As did most of my highly educated, work in professional services friends. I only mention this as Leave voters are usually presented as uneducated xenophobes. Frankly it's not really relevant but I also come from a fairly diverse family, my nephew's mum was born in the West Indies and my sister in law in Pakistan.

It's an unhelpful and sweeping statement. And just for the record, I doubt many Brexit voters wouldn't vote for Rishi for that reason. His more centrist views on cutting tax, maybe. He's my front runner at the moment but we'll see.

notnever · 10/07/2022 07:14

@rushrushflat what skills did Boris have?
@safetyfreak So Rishi went beyond party policy and out of his own accord to increase taxes?

OP posts:
Guvner · 10/07/2022 07:13

Dashel · 10/07/2022 07:05

I am white as is my DH and we both think he stands a good chance of becoming the the leader and winning and election - if he can get the party behind him.

Yes he is rich and his wife is even richer, but it seems a bit judgmental not to vote for him on that? I can’t imagine people saying an MP is too poor to vote for.

I have no idea who I would vote for if there was a GE tomorrow but the race of the leader wouldn’t enter into my decision making at all.

I think the issue for most people with how rich he is is that he is so so wealthy that he has only really mixed with aristocratic people, wouldn't have ever had working class friends and therefore, cannot relate to most of us normal working class folk.

Hesma · 10/07/2022 07:11

Personally I think Javid is the best of the bunch so far…

victoriaaurora · 10/07/2022 07:05

I don't care what race someone is, as long as they didn't go to bloody Eton! Maybe someone who has actually faced some hardship would have some more empathy and be a better leader. Would genuinely welcome a competent leader - skin colour or sex would not be the deciding factor for me.

Dashel · 10/07/2022 07:05

I am white as is my DH and we both think he stands a good chance of becoming the the leader and winning and election - if he can get the party behind him.

Yes he is rich and his wife is even richer, but it seems a bit judgmental not to vote for him on that? I can’t imagine people saying an MP is too poor to vote for.

I have no idea who I would vote for if there was a GE tomorrow but the race of the leader wouldn’t enter into my decision making at all.

tttigress · 10/07/2022 07:01

I like the fact that the Tories have such a diverse field.

I the 1970s/80s the people dishing out sexist comments/attitudes to Margret Thatcher were the Labour Party/Unions.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/07/2022 06:51

Guvner · 10/07/2022 06:45

Isn't the term BAME offensive as it lumps all non white people in the same category when in fact they are of wide and varied differing heritages?

Yes. But when you're talking about racism, racists lump anyone who isn't white and English all together. And describing people as non-white, non-English is much worse than BAME. The fact is that a very very rich man, married to a millionaire, whose family is posh Punjabi and is in government, experiences racism very differently to a Black single mum in Croydon who's working a zero hours contract.

She's never going to see the inside of Westminster. He already is.

duvetsonsunday · 10/07/2022 06:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Guvner · 10/07/2022 06:45

Isn't the term BAME offensive as it lumps all non white people in the same category when in fact they are of wide and varied differing heritages?

hotcoldnotsold · 10/07/2022 06:43

I actually think he has a chance tbh and that the UK would be ready for it. Not sure he has the experience or grit tbh but after bojo people may fancy a less conniving politician. I do also note that his wealth and privilege is always talked about as if we don't have plenty of other white politicians who are the same - I mean they're all mostly privileged including Starmer. But a lot of the liberal left like their BAME people in a box, vulnerable and in need of help, where they can play white saviour, and I think it's a new dawn when we suddenly have more minorities in leadership positions than ever before.

YetiTeri · 10/07/2022 06:34

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/07/2022 06:12

Except the 'plantation' reference I agree with you. And I'm a lifelong bleeding heart leftie. I think there's something rotten at the heart of Labour. Not labour, you understand, Labour. A racist, sexist core. And it makes me very very unhappy.

White, male champagne socialism is killing the left.

I agree, I think there is a fundamental problem with Labour that needs to be unpicked. Trade Unions are traditionally strong in male dominated industries and they've allowed professions that have far higher female workers to be ignored and then exploited. They've done that by being gender-blind.

And yet the steps forward under Harriet Harman's direction were huge. Imagine where we could have been if Labour had had the courage to elect her rather than 3 terms of Blair/Brown.

I think Angela Rayner will have a similar effect. She is where she is without confirming to middle England's expectations of how a woman should present and behave. Centrist voters would be far more comfortable with Yvette Cooper as PM but Labour needs AR to modernise.

Rinatinabina · 10/07/2022 06:26

Btw I do think racism is alive and well, it’s just assuming that the entire tory parliamentary party AND all party members are obviously rabidly racist is a bit if a stretch.

Btw Rishi is the front runner atm with MP’s declared for him, those bastards supporting that brown persons candidature!

Flaunch · 10/07/2022 06:25

I wouldn’t vote for him because he’s so privileged and disgustingly rich that he has no idea how the rest of us live.

couldn’t give a shit about his ethnicity.

WeAreTheHeroes · 10/07/2022 06:24

The problem with Sunak is not his colour. It's the privilege his colossal wealth brings. He supported Boris's Tory leadership campaign and I would query his judgement on that and now on financial matters.

Rinatinabina · 10/07/2022 06:23

alilstressed · 10/07/2022 06:18

OP, I hear you and I don't think this is a goady question. I know many Black and Brown people who have been having this conversation.

Really, I’m BAME and no-one I know has said that, more along the lines of “oh god no not Rishi, he’ll keep taxes up”.

Rinatinabina · 10/07/2022 06:21

Are we going to have one of these threads everyday? If they pick a BAME leader it will be because of some nefarious reason like thinking that person may win the next GE.

If they could pick a woman leader (twice vs 0 Labour and have the most gay Mp’s) they can cope with a brown person.

There is something really off about this constant “they hate you!!” Narrative coming out of the left at the moment. I’m waiting for the thread calling all BAME tories uncle toms and coconuts. I just feel like that one is coming.

safetyfreak · 10/07/2022 06:18

I will not vote for Rishi as he has put the highest taxes on us for decades and, if he is leader I bet the living crises will just get worse under him.

Nothing to do with BAME.

alilstressed · 10/07/2022 06:18

OP, I hear you and I don't think this is a goady question. I know many Black and Brown people who have been having this conversation.