Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do some people think Corbyn was a ‘terrifying prospect’?

238 replies

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 00:59

Taking a quote from a comment made on another thread.

I am not massively engaged in politics, but from what I understand Corbyn was pro-environment, pro-public services and re-nationalisation, he was a man who lived according to his own values.
He was laughed at for riding a bike and making jam. He was accused of being anti-semitic, though I didn't see any persuasive evidence of this, and- though not wanting to engage in whataboutery- Johnson’s awful racist remarks didn’t prevent him from gaining power.

I understand that people will have disagreed with him in policy. But what about him was did people feel was “terrifying” and so beyond the pale?
If Boris was electable and Corbyn was not I feel there must be something horrific about Corbyn that I am missing?

OP posts:
SeaWitchly · 10/07/2022 06:58

Because they read [and believe] the Mail and the Telegraph.
Again, all you will get is he is/was a terrorist, anti-Semitic and too posh to be a 'man of the people'. These are the dimwits who voted for Boris and have kept the Tories in power for 12 years.
Yes, but just imagine if Corbyn had got in ... Hmm

Icecreamsodaloda · 10/07/2022 06:55

I think in some ways he was the far left version of Thatcher, completely blinkered and determined in his view. He lost two (?) Elections badly and he wouldn't conceded that he was unappealing/unelectable to the majority and rather than doing the decent thing and stepping aside to allow someone else to try he clung doggedly to power and whipped up his core fan base to a frenzy to where he had to be forced out and the Labour party was deeply divided. In the latter he had plenty in common with Johnson.

Fairislefandango · 10/07/2022 06:55

He's just the sort of person you want running a country: intelligent, capable, honest, ie, someone with character, in the old-fashioned sense.

He's a coward who won't admit he knows what a woman is.

TomPinch · 10/07/2022 06:52

What's depressing about this thread is the lack of mention that Corbyn, regardless of his personal integrity and ability to make jam, simply wasn't PM material because he was a career backbench quibbler.

He lost to a journeyman journo who was worse.

Whereas the only mention of Starmer so far is that he's a slippery lawyer. I expect someone will add that he's dull. But Starmer was a highly respected DPP. He's just the sort of person you want running a country: intelligent, capable, honest, ie, someone with character, in the old-fashioned sense.

Politicians shouldn't be curiosities or entertaining. They should be dull and competent.

People's priorities have got way out of whack.

Fairislefandango · 10/07/2022 06:49

Thanks, I guess this explains why he was so horribly unpopular within the party, and why he didn’t appeal to the working classes… but I can’t understand why they would think Eton-educated member of the Bullingdon club would be a preferable choice?

What on earth makes you think that disliking Corbyn means that you like Johnson? It is perfectly possible (and, in fact, probably extremely common) to think both of them (would) have been useless PMs. The real question is why neither Labour nor the Torues were able to come up with anyone better at the time.

flowerycurtain · 10/07/2022 06:42

I always thought his economic policy was pie in the sky. Wasn't one election promise to out fibre broadband to every property in the uk. At the time of just had a quote to put broadband to my midlands based farm not in the middle of nowhere - £20 000. And he wanted to do that to every single remote property?!

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 06:37

minipie · 10/07/2022 02:08

You’ve assumed people who didn’t like Corbyn preferred Boris, but in fact plenty of us didn’t like either option. At all.

You seem to be saying you understand people disagreed with Corbyn’s policies but there’s nothing terrifying about him as a person. You’re missing the fact that for many, it is precisely his policies that were terrifying. Again, I’m not saying Boris was better.

Agree with this.

People voted for Johnson purely because Corbyn really couldn't helm a sinking ship.

Johnson won on personality and yes, it was known that he could be racist and is highly mysoginistic.

And it turns out that Johnson really is not better than Corbyn and as equally reckless and terrifying.

But difference is people still defend Johnson because he has some quality (I don't see) that appeals to some people.

Older generation woman seem to really like him and just see him as a schoolboy who has made a few mistakes (and don't we all 🙄). I think this sines from the bumbling Baffoon with the shaggy hairstyle persona.
From a phycology pov I find that very interesting because the only person he ever really seemed to have a close relationship with is his mum - of the same generation.

The truth really is that as a country we are fucked politically.

The media is too involved, the electorate make too many comments without really having any facts - and as seen here OP when you ask people are scathing about it.

And people want personality over competence.

undermilkjug · 10/07/2022 06:36

"Bumbling Boris the cold, calculating, highly intelligent journalist and politician! He cost Nadeem Zahawi years of a life"

I think this might be Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe. Nadhim Zawari is the Chancellor of the Exchequer today.

JustDanceAddict · 10/07/2022 06:08

Because he’s a supporter of Hamas (the terrorists who govern Palestine) and so obviously a hater of mainstream Jewry as he couldn’t abide Israel’s existence.

Krabapple · 10/07/2022 05:37

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 10/07/2022 01:22

I'm not sure how the OP missed the glaring anti-Semitism and I'm not inclined to do the work for her.

I'm sure many won't agree but I think Boris' racism was more to do with clumsy expression rather actual malevolence- wasn't the letter box remark in response to the French banning burqas and that being something which would not happen in the UK.

i am absolutely gobsmacked at your second paragraph! Bumbling Boris was accidentally racist!!!! Bumbling Boris the cold, calculating, highly intelligent journalist and politician! He cost Nadeem Zahawi years of a life, made the burka comment and also the picanini comment all by accident? He was a blatant racist masogynist twat!

Speedweed · 10/07/2022 05:31

It's a good question to ask OP, and like you I've thought it and have never been able to get to any solid, concrete examples.

My conclusion is that he represented the possibility of real change, and for that alone the media decided he had to be stopped.

Carpy88999 · 10/07/2022 05:25

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 01:47

& how is capitalism working out, @NrlySp? Not for you, who are probably All Right Jack. For the 4 million British kids living in poverty in 2022?

Capitalism isn't perfect but it's the only system that almost works. I can assure you that under a socialist regime it would be many factors more than 4m.

Mousemat25 · 10/07/2022 05:18

You are missing my point. Tell me how Palestine impacts the day to day lives of people in the UK? It just doesn’t. What’s going on in Ukraine does. Jeremy Corbyn didn’t understand how unimportant Palestine is to people, and him raising Palestine made him look out of touch.

Blahblahblab · 10/07/2022 05:18

I wouldn't use the word sinister but I didn't vote labour at the last election (not that it mattered in my constituency, and spoilt my ballot knowing that) because I fundamentally disagreed with his economic policy. It was re-nationalising the post office that pushed me over the edge. I couldn't have any respect for someone who thought that would be a good use of public funds. Then him doing random things expressly for votes like offering additional public holidays with no mention of the cost to the economy, or impact on shift workers who would struggle with childcare etc, just confirmed he was throwing sweeties with no real idea what he was talking about. I do actually believe we'd be in a worse position if Corbyn had been in power over Covid. We're in a terrible position now, but if you look around the world it most definitely could be worse (and could be better).

I got accused of being Tory scum for my position. I've never voted Tory in my life, and don't think I could bring myself to.

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/07/2022 05:14

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 02:02

Thanks, I guess this explains why he was so horribly unpopular within the party, and why he didn’t appeal to the working classes… but I can’t understand why they would think Eton-educated member of the Bullingdon club would be a preferable choice?

Please don't believe the tosh written on here.Corbyn was a deeply principled man who threw the self serving , snout in the trough nature of so many tories , into sharp relief.Thwy were threatened by that, and hence the unrelenting smear dampaign against him.

ExitChasedByABee · 10/07/2022 05:13

Mousemat25 · 10/07/2022 04:51

Many people don’t care about Palestine, They really don’t. They care about Ukraine as they are our European brothers and there is a real chance Putin might fancy his chances at moving through Europe to us if he is not defeated in Ukraine. But Palestine is not important to the lives of the majority of Brits. And yet Jeremy Corbyn kept banging on about it. Talk about things that matter to the day to day lives of people instead!

And socialism? How’s that supposed to work? I’ve got a well paid job which is valued for its use to society, but it took years and years of hard study to qualify. If under socialism it was paid the same as a role with no professional study required at all, why would I bother? Am I merely supposed to put in the graft for the benefit of society? Because I predict that that wouldn’t work out well.

@Mousemat25 It’s not one or the other!! It is possible to be dismayed and horrified by what is happening in Ukraine and be proactive in supporting the effort to support Ukrainians as is equally the same to that of tribulations in Palestine and the plight of Palestinians. We are all humans and opinions like yours @Mousemat25, where people are othered, that causes issues in the first place! We should abhor any human right violations or abuse of power etc.

SpidersAreShitheads · 10/07/2022 05:03

I didn’t like Corbyn and wouldn’t want him as PM. I’m sure there were elements which were genuinely delightful and well-meaning, but there were many things he said and did which I felt were deeply problematic. And I say this as a left-wing Labour voter.

I felt that Corbyn enjoyed being a trouble maker and stirring things up more than he was genuinely interested in becoming PM. He seemed to thrive on deliberately taking the opposite view and just being a bit cantankerous for the sake of it. I always thought he’d have been better as a trade Union leader than an MP.

I actually voted for Corbyn but I am in such a safe Tory seat it was more of a protest vote and I knew it would make zero difference.

I think Keir Starmer is an incredibly intelligent, principled man who always tries to do the right thing. But he doesn’t go in for the kind of loud, braying politics we’re used to seeing so I don’t think he’ll ever succeed. Which is an enormous shame. Mind you, he does need to figure out what a woman is - desperately trying to please all isn’t doing him any favours.

Also for what it’s worth Boris and Co are a giant shower of cunts who are corrupt as fuck. Utterly depressing that they ever got anywhere near government.

It’s possible to deeply distrust Corbyn while also intensely disliking Boris. Lots of us felt politically homeless because we disliked both. And many still do feel politically homeless (because of the woman/GRC issue).

Musti · 10/07/2022 04:53

He promised a lot of things that would have been a hell of a lot more beneficial to us than the lying tories who promised a lot but only made sure the rich got richer.

corbyn is a peaceful and honourable vegan. How the hell he can be painted evil is beyond me.

Mousemat25 · 10/07/2022 04:51

Many people don’t care about Palestine, They really don’t. They care about Ukraine as they are our European brothers and there is a real chance Putin might fancy his chances at moving through Europe to us if he is not defeated in Ukraine. But Palestine is not important to the lives of the majority of Brits. And yet Jeremy Corbyn kept banging on about it. Talk about things that matter to the day to day lives of people instead!

And socialism? How’s that supposed to work? I’ve got a well paid job which is valued for its use to society, but it took years and years of hard study to qualify. If under socialism it was paid the same as a role with no professional study required at all, why would I bother? Am I merely supposed to put in the graft for the benefit of society? Because I predict that that wouldn’t work out well.

NerdleNoodle · 10/07/2022 04:45

OP your question is an entirely valid and thoughtful one. As are your responses. But unfortunately evidence-based, thoughtful discussion is not what guides people, and no matter how hard you push for rational responses you won't get them.

No one will come out and say 'I just don't like the man and Labour's not for me' which is what it boils down to. I'm not a particular Corbyn fan but I cannot imagine anything he would have done in leadership that could have landed us in a worse position than we are in now.

Proof of this are the wild allegations about his privilege vs Boris's, his racism vs Boris's, the allegations that 'slippery Starmer' as a an earlier poster labelled him is just as bad ... There's no point in countering these systematically because most people are not looking for evidence-based debate. All one can do is be aware of one's own biases and prejudices and try to avoid them. Don't bother trying to call anyone else out on theirs.

TheSoundOfLunch · 10/07/2022 04:31

Any decent person’s values terrify the selfish, the privileged and the morally bankrupt.

echt · 10/07/2022 04:27

MarshaMelrose · 10/07/2022 04:18

But the op asked why people didn't like or didn't vote for Corbyn. His extravagant spending promises were part of people's mistrust of him. Your comment about people swallowing Boris's lies is just the same crap as people saying oh but Corbyn would be worse. Why do people always have to bring in another political party to try and make their politician sound better?

Possibly I should have said that the media were out to discredit Corby, so subjected him and his policies to the kind of scrutiny that Johnson didn't get.

What the fuck makes you think Corbyn was my politician? I was making a point of comparison. That is all.

MarshaMelrose · 10/07/2022 04:18

echt · 10/07/2022 03:39

I think the problem came at the election when he just started promising money to everyone and it did lead to questions of how that would all be financed

Whereas Boris Johnson's lies were swallowed whole.

But the op asked why people didn't like or didn't vote for Corbyn. His extravagant spending promises were part of people's mistrust of him. Your comment about people swallowing Boris's lies is just the same crap as people saying oh but Corbyn would be worse. Why do people always have to bring in another political party to try and make their politician sound better?

echt · 10/07/2022 03:39

I think the problem came at the election when he just started promising money to everyone and it did lead to questions of how that would all be financed

Whereas Boris Johnson's lies were swallowed whole.

ReeseWitherfork · 10/07/2022 03:34

I’m with you OP. I can’t work out why he is worse than any other politician. Why is potential antisemitism worse than the racist shit BJ has come out with? JC’s accusations of antisemitism come from the meetings he has had, and support he has shown, for certain people. BJ has been very public and open with his mocking remarks. (To be clear though, I don’t think someone should be PM who has evidence of antisemitism; but I also don’t think someone who uses language like “piccannies” should be PM.)

One prominent thing on the thread that’s stood out to me is PP talking about how there was no confidence in how he’d fund anything. Looking back at the GE, he definitely did promise the world.

But I’m sure under JC leadership, labour support increased. So I don’t think he’s hated as much as he appears to be. Just that his opponents are very vocal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread