Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do some people think Corbyn was a ‘terrifying prospect’?

238 replies

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 00:59

Taking a quote from a comment made on another thread.

I am not massively engaged in politics, but from what I understand Corbyn was pro-environment, pro-public services and re-nationalisation, he was a man who lived according to his own values.
He was laughed at for riding a bike and making jam. He was accused of being anti-semitic, though I didn't see any persuasive evidence of this, and- though not wanting to engage in whataboutery- Johnson’s awful racist remarks didn’t prevent him from gaining power.

I understand that people will have disagreed with him in policy. But what about him was did people feel was “terrifying” and so beyond the pale?
If Boris was electable and Corbyn was not I feel there must be something horrific about Corbyn that I am missing?

OP posts:
BrettsBurger · 10/07/2022 08:10

He was unpatriotic, uncharismatic, uncompromising, and crucially incapable of concluding the Brexit deadlock in Parliament or forming a Government without the support of the SNP.

As bad as the past two years have been under Johnson, the country still made the correct decision in 2019.

MarshaBradyo · 10/07/2022 08:07

People who voted for him will blame anything bar him missing the mark, sometimes the person running is responsible for the loss because they don’t get the electorate not the other way round.

I don’t know why individually each person didn’t vote for him, seems a long time after to scrutinise it, but even Labour were keen to move away from what he represented.

tiggergoesbounce · 10/07/2022 08:03

Aishah231 · 10/07/2022 07:40

People believe what they are told OP. That's the problem. Corbyn wasn't anti-Semitic he was critical of the Israeli government which pursues apartheid style policies towards Palestinians. anti-Semitism has been reclassified to include criticisms of the Israeli government. Those saying socialism doesn't work need to research their own history. Corbyn's policies were socialist but so we're the 1945 Attlee government's that set up the NHS. The conservatives through most of the 50s didn't undo those policies and living standards rose more quickly than at any other point in history. Capitalism brought us slavery, imperialism, and endless wars over resources. The good bits are down to the socialists and social campaigners trying to make things better

This is a great post @Aishah321

EricandEnid · 10/07/2022 08:03

Itstrue22 · 10/07/2022 07:31

It doesn’t make sense. No other politician received the same level of negative media attention that Corbyn did. He represented real genuine change and the people who are really in charge weren’t going to allow that to happen.

It’s crazy that we accept the poor level of public service that we receive from the tories. Every time there’s an election they say they’ll reverse some of the cuts they’ve made, they don’t, no one does anything. This countries public services on its knees, the system is completely broken. Then Corbyn offers something different, that’s more in line with what other countries offer, it’s dismissed as poor economic policies. Don’t even give the Labour Party a chance to implement. How bizarre is that? Let’s stick with the shit we’ve got, because what you’re offering sounds too good.

He isn’t antisemitic. He criticised Israel’s policy on Palestine. Look at the rest of the world.. you don’t do that. But tbh people don’t give a shit if he’s antisemitic. They don’t care about Palestine. It’s the same people that don’t care that Boris Johnson is a narcissist who lies, who get blowjobs at work from Carrie whilst his wife is fighting cancer. The reason people are so anti him is because the media and tories told them to be. That is the reason for the public hatred of him. I’m not saying everyone, I’m saying the majority. If everyone did their proper research into all of the politicians and policies there would be a far more balanced view of Corbyn but the majority of people generally don’t.

I agree with this. I remember asking people what they didn’t like about Corbyn and no one could give me an answer that wasn’t ‘I just don’t like him’.

tiggergoesbounce · 10/07/2022 08:02

Corbyn wasnt an anti-semite it was spun that way for obvious reasons.
(Its not like he personally has a history of making such statements on a public stage, that would be disgusting)

Noone mentions the people within the labour government who caused friction within the labour party at the time, straight after the election being made lords by Boris Johnson.

But he was never going to be a viable option, people dismissed him as he was talking like we had a "money tree" the tories outspent them massively, noone cared.

Anyone who did their homework before voting, knew boris johnson was a liar, knew he treated women with contempt, knew he was fickle with his "stances" and would always go with what helped serve his own personal agenda but they voted anyway.
I did see Corbyn as a much better option to the above, (not a corbyn lover) as i felt he really wanted to level the playing field and do better. Noone will ever know how that would have worked out, but its my belief.

You have to remember OP after all what has happened certain people are still defending Boris, its quite scary.

knittingaddict · 10/07/2022 08:02

MarshaMelrose · 10/07/2022 01:32

And I don't for one minute think the op is some political innocent. Lol.

Of course they aren't. It's more difficult to fake the wide eyed innocent look than op was expecting.

Threads like this are aways irritating.

EricandEnid · 10/07/2022 08:01

Sooverthisnow · 10/07/2022 07:29

He had very little policies of his own, and could only protest against the government but seemed to have little alternative suggestions.
He was quite far left and the policies he did have seemed to be similar to those of Venezuela which is never great.
Communism doesn’t work. It’s becomes like Animal Farm with the elite living the highlife at the expense of the workers, but the workers have no opportunities to better themselves because everything is state owned and controlled.

Have you actually read Animal Farm?

Figgygal · 10/07/2022 07:59

Because its what boris and the tories said about him and people lack critical thought. He was pitched as the big bad by Dominic Cummings and people fell for it.

He was a guy of strong personal values which were too extreme for a party which has been pretty centrist for decades and wasnt a good "manager" in terms of the role of party leader.

malificent7 · 10/07/2022 07:52

I thought he criticised Israel's foreign policy....which is fair by my understanding. Wasn't he against a Zionist state as it led to the persecution of Palestinians? How is this anti semetic

Cakeandcardio · 10/07/2022 07:51

NrlySp · 10/07/2022 01:03

Socialism doesn’t work. And Corbyn is dangerously close to communism.

I'm not sure capitalism is working well for many in this country. Although I will suspect they will continue to vote Tory anyway, and keep screwing themselves over. It's unbelievable

Crimeismymiddlename · 10/07/2022 07:51

The reason people did not vote for him was because they were saw that rather than being the man of the people he pretended to be he was in fact an extremely privileged person who seemed determined to take away any privileges from everyone-privileges he himself had gained from.
He is, and allowed antisemitic behaviour.
He did seem to think that home ownership=owner was well off and would be able to take the extra taxes/charges he was no doubt formulating. We all know that is not true.
I got the impression that he had very old fashioned, and patronising ideas of the ‘working class’ and was desperate to ‘help’ them. While knowing nothing of being a working person himself.
He was thick as shit and being used as a straw man for people much more intelligent and dangerous than himself.

Primatrying · 10/07/2022 07:44

His plan to renationalise water was to buy it at less than its value. Had he succeeded, it would have led to all sorts of legal battles.

Aishah231 · 10/07/2022 07:40

People believe what they are told OP. That's the problem. Corbyn wasn't anti-Semitic he was critical of the Israeli government which pursues apartheid style policies towards Palestinians. anti-Semitism has been reclassified to include criticisms of the Israeli government. Those saying socialism doesn't work need to research their own history. Corbyn's policies were socialist but so we're the 1945 Attlee government's that set up the NHS. The conservatives through most of the 50s didn't undo those policies and living standards rose more quickly than at any other point in history. Capitalism brought us slavery, imperialism, and endless wars over resources. The good bits are down to the socialists and social campaigners trying to make things better

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 07:37

Itstrue22 · 10/07/2022 07:31

It doesn’t make sense. No other politician received the same level of negative media attention that Corbyn did. He represented real genuine change and the people who are really in charge weren’t going to allow that to happen.

It’s crazy that we accept the poor level of public service that we receive from the tories. Every time there’s an election they say they’ll reverse some of the cuts they’ve made, they don’t, no one does anything. This countries public services on its knees, the system is completely broken. Then Corbyn offers something different, that’s more in line with what other countries offer, it’s dismissed as poor economic policies. Don’t even give the Labour Party a chance to implement. How bizarre is that? Let’s stick with the shit we’ve got, because what you’re offering sounds too good.

He isn’t antisemitic. He criticised Israel’s policy on Palestine. Look at the rest of the world.. you don’t do that. But tbh people don’t give a shit if he’s antisemitic. They don’t care about Palestine. It’s the same people that don’t care that Boris Johnson is a narcissist who lies, who get blowjobs at work from Carrie whilst his wife is fighting cancer. The reason people are so anti him is because the media and tories told them to be. That is the reason for the public hatred of him. I’m not saying everyone, I’m saying the majority. If everyone did their proper research into all of the politicians and policies there would be a far more balanced view of Corbyn but the majority of people generally don’t.

Great post.

I was never a Corbyn fan (I'm generally left centric) but there's so much truth to this with regards optics and who drives those.m

Heartcare · 10/07/2022 07:32

Sooverthisnow · 10/07/2022 07:29

He had very little policies of his own, and could only protest against the government but seemed to have little alternative suggestions.
He was quite far left and the policies he did have seemed to be similar to those of Venezuela which is never great.
Communism doesn’t work. It’s becomes like Animal Farm with the elite living the highlife at the expense of the workers, but the workers have no opportunities to better themselves because everything is state owned and controlled.

Are the elite not living rhe high life right now? More kids are in poverty, more homeless on the streets and more use of food banks under a Tory Govn.

I'm not arguing that communism is the answer, but the problems you outline are present right now under the capitalist model too

Itstrue22 · 10/07/2022 07:31

It doesn’t make sense. No other politician received the same level of negative media attention that Corbyn did. He represented real genuine change and the people who are really in charge weren’t going to allow that to happen.

It’s crazy that we accept the poor level of public service that we receive from the tories. Every time there’s an election they say they’ll reverse some of the cuts they’ve made, they don’t, no one does anything. This countries public services on its knees, the system is completely broken. Then Corbyn offers something different, that’s more in line with what other countries offer, it’s dismissed as poor economic policies. Don’t even give the Labour Party a chance to implement. How bizarre is that? Let’s stick with the shit we’ve got, because what you’re offering sounds too good.

He isn’t antisemitic. He criticised Israel’s policy on Palestine. Look at the rest of the world.. you don’t do that. But tbh people don’t give a shit if he’s antisemitic. They don’t care about Palestine. It’s the same people that don’t care that Boris Johnson is a narcissist who lies, who get blowjobs at work from Carrie whilst his wife is fighting cancer. The reason people are so anti him is because the media and tories told them to be. That is the reason for the public hatred of him. I’m not saying everyone, I’m saying the majority. If everyone did their proper research into all of the politicians and policies there would be a far more balanced view of Corbyn but the majority of people generally don’t.

Heartcare · 10/07/2022 07:31

All this stuff about Corbyn's policies being bad economically, wasn't this the election were Labour were the only ones that published a costed manifesto?

Ultimately, Corbyn wasn't deemed likable enough and I suspect his proposed changes were too radical. The media completely destroyed him and he was inept at leadership and allowed it to happen.

I do agree with the sentiment on Johnson though. Except he is not ideologically driven and is willing to go down the 'socialist' route if it keeps him popular (i.e. can you imagine Thatcher bringing in furlough?!)

I'm not always impressed with Starmer and I understand why people call him dull. Personally, I want a dull, competent person running the country, particularly one that has had experience running a significant govn dept.

Sooverthisnow · 10/07/2022 07:29

He had very little policies of his own, and could only protest against the government but seemed to have little alternative suggestions.
He was quite far left and the policies he did have seemed to be similar to those of Venezuela which is never great.
Communism doesn’t work. It’s becomes like Animal Farm with the elite living the highlife at the expense of the workers, but the workers have no opportunities to better themselves because everything is state owned and controlled.

jgw1 · 10/07/2022 07:22

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 00:59

Taking a quote from a comment made on another thread.

I am not massively engaged in politics, but from what I understand Corbyn was pro-environment, pro-public services and re-nationalisation, he was a man who lived according to his own values.
He was laughed at for riding a bike and making jam. He was accused of being anti-semitic, though I didn't see any persuasive evidence of this, and- though not wanting to engage in whataboutery- Johnson’s awful racist remarks didn’t prevent him from gaining power.

I understand that people will have disagreed with him in policy. But what about him was did people feel was “terrifying” and so beyond the pale?
If Boris was electable and Corbyn was not I feel there must be something horrific about Corbyn that I am missing?

Because too many of those who own the media and pay the Tories to inact the policies they want, were scared that Corbyn would get in and run the country for the benefit of the many not the few.

notquiteruralbliss · 10/07/2022 07:21

Self interest maybe. Or belief in the narrative pushed by the media. I voted for him as Labour leader and for Labour led by Corbyn in the election. I would have been very happy for their policies to be implemented.

Parkperson00 · 10/07/2022 07:20

As a state school teacher I thought was a hypocrite. He damned private schools but sent his three boys to the independent Queen Elizabeth's Grammar School ( fee paying)
He has been married three times, the last time to a woman twenty five years his junior ( shades of Boris)
He went to a private school himself ( 2 E grades at A Level). Not a man who would do his homework.
Apart from anything else, I never thought he wanted the job. He is anti Semitic and contributed to many Jewish people feeling unsafe in the UK.

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 07:16

TomPinch · 10/07/2022 06:52

What's depressing about this thread is the lack of mention that Corbyn, regardless of his personal integrity and ability to make jam, simply wasn't PM material because he was a career backbench quibbler.

He lost to a journeyman journo who was worse.

Whereas the only mention of Starmer so far is that he's a slippery lawyer. I expect someone will add that he's dull. But Starmer was a highly respected DPP. He's just the sort of person you want running a country: intelligent, capable, honest, ie, someone with character, in the old-fashioned sense.

Politicians shouldn't be curiosities or entertaining. They should be dull and competent.

People's priorities have got way out of whack.

I agree with this. I didn't mention Starmer specifically in my reply but I did add people have their priorities wrong because they want entertaining.

I think someone like Starmer (even if it's not him) who is professional and has integrity is exactly what our country needs.

I think we need that whatever party is in power.

It's should be about party policy not personality.

KweenieBeanz · 10/07/2022 07:11

I'm with you OP - people acted like Corbyn was totally unelectable..... But Bojo wasn't? Despite dishonesty, loads of suspect financial dodgy dealings going on while he's been in power? Do people honestly think Corbyn would have been worse, what planet are people living on 😂

Rosehugger · 10/07/2022 07:03

Because they are numpties, led by numpties, OP.

ZenNudist · 10/07/2022 07:01

It's a bit of a pointless argument now that it's in the past. I CBA to get into it. FWIW I agree with you that anything would have been better than the damage that the Tories have done and I voted for Labour in the GE although I didn't like JC at all he was the lesser evil.

I think Labour were silly to have abandoned the centre ground so hard won under Blair and Brown. An exercise in idealism that has been painful for the country.

However I was glad that the tories landed themselves with dealing with covid because if a labour chancellor had spent like rishi the country would have been up in arms. In retrospect the tories needed to implement brexit as they need to own what a complete mess they have made.

Swipe left for the next trending thread