Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do some people think Corbyn was a ‘terrifying prospect’?

238 replies

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 00:59

Taking a quote from a comment made on another thread.

I am not massively engaged in politics, but from what I understand Corbyn was pro-environment, pro-public services and re-nationalisation, he was a man who lived according to his own values.
He was laughed at for riding a bike and making jam. He was accused of being anti-semitic, though I didn't see any persuasive evidence of this, and- though not wanting to engage in whataboutery- Johnson’s awful racist remarks didn’t prevent him from gaining power.

I understand that people will have disagreed with him in policy. But what about him was did people feel was “terrifying” and so beyond the pale?
If Boris was electable and Corbyn was not I feel there must be something horrific about Corbyn that I am missing?

OP posts:
TomPinch · 10/07/2022 10:00

RosaGallica · 10/07/2022 09:55

It is also truly remarkable how much clothes matter to the British people.

Not really.

The British are scruffier than some.

They rejected Corbyn, but chose a scruff for PM anyway.

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:00

Gingernaut · 10/07/2022 09:55

His light touch leadership meant he seemed to have no will to sort out Momentum, anti-Semitism, the trans issue and he failed to campaign convincingly during the lead up to the Brexit referendum

Previously anti-Europe, he failed to take a convincing stance for staying in the EU and seemed to take a step back to see what the British people decided.

Aside from socialist rhetoric he seemed to be reciting from text books, he failed to take much of a position on anything even his idiotic brother, Piers.

He failed to lead.

He's a local MP and activist, he's not a leader, that was always a problem. It allowed him to be undermined in his own cabinet by his deputy leader among others.

RosaGallica · 10/07/2022 09:55

It is also truly remarkable how much clothes matter to the British people.

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 09:55

So many interesting and thought provoking replies here. Thank you. Reading through the thread, what’s jumping out at me is how much personality matters. It’s made me wonder whether the rise of reality TV (and maybe the increasing coverage of US presidential politics) is having an impact on the way we view politicians and engage with politics.

I realise that many people disliked both Corbyn and Johnson, the reason I’m saying many preferred Johnson is that the red wall turned blue in parts.

To those who think I’m not genuine- I’m not sure what you think my hidden agenda is? I am interested in politics, but too busy to read much beyond the headlines. I didn’t vote in 2017 election and wasn’t taking a huge amount of interest in politics at the time because of stressful circs in my own life.

I am a Labour supporter - but I am not tribal about it. I asked the question in good faith because I want to understand.

(And I am a regular mumsnetter who name changes a lot. There’s a lovely post that pops up regularly by a lady who thought that she was infertile but found out she was unexpectedly pregnant before Christmas last year. Her first post was asking if there was definitely a second line on the test, I think she took it as routine before going into hospital for a procedure. She took about 6 tests to be sure! And she updates regularly about the pregnancy is going - she’s having a boy and I think she’s due this month. If that helps people to believe I am a real poster 🤨)

OP posts:
Gingernaut · 10/07/2022 09:55

His light touch leadership meant he seemed to have no will to sort out Momentum, anti-Semitism, the trans issue and he failed to campaign convincingly during the lead up to the Brexit referendum

Previously anti-Europe, he failed to take a convincing stance for staying in the EU and seemed to take a step back to see what the British people decided.

Aside from socialist rhetoric he seemed to be reciting from text books, he failed to take much of a position on anything even his idiotic brother, Piers.

He failed to lead.

HMSSophia · 10/07/2022 09:54

Because England is Tory to its bones because of our history.

WestHamPam · 10/07/2022 09:53

His response to the Salisbury nerve agent attack means I’m very pleased he’s not leading the country through the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

cottagegardenflower · 10/07/2022 09:51

@JustAnotherPoster00 Open a dictionary and look up the word 'deterrent '.. worked for over 75 years so far.

MarshaBradyo · 10/07/2022 09:51

I'm a big fan of NATO and he's strongly opposed and is perpetrating a "faults on both sides" view of the Ukraine conflict.

Both are bad but the NATO part is particularly so

ZarquonsSandals · 10/07/2022 09:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I believe he talked with Sinn Fein and Palestine, as he talked with other people.
Boris Johnson has been 'friendly' with Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump and Berlsoconi n the past, but that is missing from the comparison.

As for JC not singing the National Anthem, so what? He hasnt told anyone else not to or banned them from doing so. Its a hymn to a monarch, not a celebration of a nation. Apart from lauding someone with immense privilege, the entire version needs some serious revision with its talk of crushing the Scots.

RosaGallica · 10/07/2022 09:50

People have been brainwashed over the last 4 decades into thinking that only private companies can make public services work, that greed is the only social value, and that exploitation and aggression towards others are the only possible ways society can be made to work. The very possibility of any alternatives to this broken hell hole cannot be raised now. We lack the ability to even discuss it.

Like you I can see that this extreme form of private capitalism has failed, as it has done so many times before.

CredibilityProblem · 10/07/2022 09:49

Corbyn's children went to grammar and then private school but his wife had to divorce him in order to force either to happen. Now you may or may not think that's Ok behaviour, but it definitely doesn't make him a hypocrite.

I can't imagine that a labour government led by Corbin would have been worse than this shower domestically, but I did have serious reservations about his international policy. In particular I'm a big fan of NATO and he's strongly opposed and is perpetrating a "faults on both sides" view of the Ukraine conflict.

When Michael Foot was Labour leader he supported the war to retake the Falkland Islands, and his reason was "I know a fascist when I see one". Corbyn by contrast opposed it because he thought it was a Tory plot. I don't think he knows a fascist when he sees one.

User135644 · 10/07/2022 09:48

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 09:46

People just didn't trust Corbyn.

People did trust Boris.

And that shows just how much people are hoodwinked.

We don't know how well Corbyn would have done.

But we do know Johnson has lied to us continuously and it's now caused further political divide.

43% voted Conservative. 57% didn't trust Boris Johnson.

It became a Brexit election and Labour fell into a massive trap.

billygoatsgruff1 · 10/07/2022 09:47

Mousemat25 · 10/07/2022 04:51

Many people don’t care about Palestine, They really don’t. They care about Ukraine as they are our European brothers and there is a real chance Putin might fancy his chances at moving through Europe to us if he is not defeated in Ukraine. But Palestine is not important to the lives of the majority of Brits. And yet Jeremy Corbyn kept banging on about it. Talk about things that matter to the day to day lives of people instead!

And socialism? How’s that supposed to work? I’ve got a well paid job which is valued for its use to society, but it took years and years of hard study to qualify. If under socialism it was paid the same as a role with no professional study required at all, why would I bother? Am I merely supposed to put in the graft for the benefit of society? Because I predict that that wouldn’t work out well.

Maybe learn the differences between socialism and communism?

User135644 · 10/07/2022 09:47

minipie · 10/07/2022 02:08

You’ve assumed people who didn’t like Corbyn preferred Boris, but in fact plenty of us didn’t like either option. At all.

You seem to be saying you understand people disagreed with Corbyn’s policies but there’s nothing terrifying about him as a person. You’re missing the fact that for many, it is precisely his policies that were terrifying. Again, I’m not saying Boris was better.

The same country that keep voting for disaster capitalists and what is essentially an oligarchy. Corbyn actually wanted to fix the damage that's done.

Stripyhoglets1 · 10/07/2022 09:47

Hes an antisemite. There's plenty info out there about this and why he is, and the problem of antisemitism in the left, if you can be bothered to post here I'm sure you can Google and find out why.

He was awful over brexit. A strong Labour leader who took a proper pro EU stance during the lead up to referendum would have prevented the whole damaging mess in the first place.

I think he'd have taken a mealy mouthed stay out of the Russia invasion and insisted the UK stayed neutral rather than support the Ukraine. I think his tendancy to hang out with terrorists was a security issue.

I'm a left wing voter and despise the tories but Labour were never going to win with him as leader. The idiotic rule change made it possible for him to be nominated and entryist voters kept him in power.

Kier starmer is honourable and intelligent and would make an excellent PM I just hope he gets a chance to do so next election.

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 09:46

People just didn't trust Corbyn.

People did trust Boris.

And that shows just how much people are hoodwinked.

We don't know how well Corbyn would have done.

But we do know Johnson has lied to us continuously and it's now caused further political divide.

User135644 · 10/07/2022 09:45

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 10/07/2022 01:48

And don't forget his admiration of Hugo Chavez in Venezuela.

At the time Corbyn was Labour Party leader Venezuela had been in recession for four years, and according to the IMF, inflation was going to reach 1,000,000% in 2018.

One of the reasons socialism doesn't work is America sanctions any country that imposes it.

When socialism runs out of money the people starve, when capitalism runs out of money they just print more (although that now means butter is 10 pound and energy bills will eat up your wages, woo privatisation).

GrowlingManchego · 10/07/2022 09:43

For me it was Corbyn’s position on Brexit that was a real turn off, and his voting record. Neither Corbin or Johnson appealed as leaders. I voted green at the last election, as I thought that the climate emergency was being largely ignored, oh, and a cat in a blue rosette would win a seat for the conservatives where I live. We need proportional representation, but that’s another thread topic.

But in general, socialism (not communism) has delivered most of the benefits we enjoy today such as the NHS, and capitalism hasn’t delivered because the version of it that we have rewards shareholders whilst simultaneously running down our infrastructure. I’m a business owner and see higher taxes to pay for infrastructure as solid investments that everyone benefits from - businesses, individuals, and the quality of life for society as a whole.

thebellagio · 10/07/2022 09:42

I’ve been politically homeless for years. Generally if I aligned myself with anyone it would be the Lib Dems - I would say I’m central/left at a push

there was no way I could vote Tory because I know Boris would be a disaster. I live in one of the safest Tory seats in the country so me voting is essentially a waste of time.

but I couldn’t vote for Corbyn because to me, he was unelectable. He would have been average on the domestic stage but a disaster on a global stage. As someone who is newly self employed, I personally felt that a vote for Corbyn was a vote against any form of ambition or trying to better yourself. But equally I don’t agree with the Tory style of “helping the rich get richer”….

for me, Corbyn is exactly the sort of person you need in the back benches reminding labour of who they are supporting - being a bit of a pain in the arse to keep people focused on their core values. But that doesn’t translate to leadership capabilities.

I don’t dislike starmer, I feel he would be a competent, safe pair of hands, but he’s so scared to say an opinion in case he pisses off a minority (hence the issues with not saying what a woman is). He’s too much on the fence and I still don’t know what he stands for other than “he’s not Corbyn”

User135644 · 10/07/2022 09:41

TotalRhubarb · 10/07/2022 01:06

There was much about Corbyn’s stated aims that I would agree with and would like to see adopted.

However:’

Unfortunately him and McDonnell together = complete economic incompetence.

Another complete non-negotiable for me was the absolutely shocking anti-semitism.

His views on unilateral nuclear disarmament were also extremely chilling and incredibly dangerous. Naive in the extreme.

He always reminded me of an earnest sixth-former: full of well-meaning idealism, but devoid of pragmatism or common sense. Overall, completely unfit to govern.

I wouldn't disagree with any of that. However, Boris Johnson was even more unfit to govern and just as economically incompetent.

At least Corbyn wanted to redistribute wealth, not just make the rich richer and reward cronies.

I'd rather Corbyn over Johnson but neither were fit to govern.

billygoatsgruff1 · 10/07/2022 09:41

I agree, OP. It's all smoke and mirrors. People have swallowed the daily Mail and if you ever try to get any evidence-based sense out of them over why corbyn would have been unfit, all they can do is repeat the things they have been told 🤔.

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 09:41

His learning difficulties are reason enough to exclude him. Despite a private education and supportive and rich parents he only achieved 2 grade E at A-level then failed his college course on trades union studies.

He has nothing to commend him, and has never met an antisemite that he didn’t like.

Flowergirl89 · 10/07/2022 09:40

Aishah231 · 10/07/2022 07:40

People believe what they are told OP. That's the problem. Corbyn wasn't anti-Semitic he was critical of the Israeli government which pursues apartheid style policies towards Palestinians. anti-Semitism has been reclassified to include criticisms of the Israeli government. Those saying socialism doesn't work need to research their own history. Corbyn's policies were socialist but so we're the 1945 Attlee government's that set up the NHS. The conservatives through most of the 50s didn't undo those policies and living standards rose more quickly than at any other point in history. Capitalism brought us slavery, imperialism, and endless wars over resources. The good bits are down to the socialists and social campaigners trying to make things better

it was more than criticism of Israel,
he defended the artist who drew that blatantly obvious anti semitic mural, he was “present but not involved” at a wreath laying for those behind the murder of Israeli athletes at the Munich olympics, he associated with members of Hamas who call for the death of all Jews not just Israelis. As a Jew I was extremely nervous at the thought of him gaining any power alongside his terror excusing sidekick the brainy wonderful Dianne Abbott

User135644 · 10/07/2022 09:39

NrlySp · 10/07/2022 01:03

Socialism doesn’t work. And Corbyn is dangerously close to communism.

Neoliberalism doesn't work.