Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do some people think Corbyn was a ‘terrifying prospect’?

238 replies

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 00:59

Taking a quote from a comment made on another thread.

I am not massively engaged in politics, but from what I understand Corbyn was pro-environment, pro-public services and re-nationalisation, he was a man who lived according to his own values.
He was laughed at for riding a bike and making jam. He was accused of being anti-semitic, though I didn't see any persuasive evidence of this, and- though not wanting to engage in whataboutery- Johnson’s awful racist remarks didn’t prevent him from gaining power.

I understand that people will have disagreed with him in policy. But what about him was did people feel was “terrifying” and so beyond the pale?
If Boris was electable and Corbyn was not I feel there must be something horrific about Corbyn that I am missing?

OP posts:
Nothappyatwork · 10/07/2022 10:25

I spoke to someone who is very Tory and actually a friend of mine which is bizarre, anyway he’s ex-military from what I can gather quite high up back in the day and apparently there was a military coup being planned if Corbin gained Power. I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry.

TomPinch · 10/07/2022 10:25

Gingernaut · 10/07/2022 10:15

I prefer the Wikipedia article, which states that this verse only ever had any use in, about, 1746 (just after an army of Scots approached London) and was never part of the National Anthem.

You and Zarquon didn't do your homework before posting.

rushrushflat · 10/07/2022 10:23

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 10:15

Ha! Mic-drop!!

And there you go the OP is a troll, it was obvious from the start.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 10:17

User135644 · 10/07/2022 09:45

One of the reasons socialism doesn't work is America sanctions any country that imposes it.

When socialism runs out of money the people starve, when capitalism runs out of money they just print more (although that now means butter is 10 pound and energy bills will eat up your wages, woo privatisation).

Oh yes, right on time. Socialism has never been allowed to work by the US. The most predictable line.

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 10:15

imperialminty · 10/07/2022 10:09

Haven’t read the full thread so apologies if this point has been made, but I was particularly disturbed by Corbyn’s relationship with Russia. This country already had a dangerously submissive attitude towards Putin (Theresa May’s handling of the Litvinenko murder whilst she was Home Secretary was appalling) but for me, when the Salisbury poisonings happened it confirmed for me that Corbin was an active threat to our national security. We can’t have a Prime Minister who borderline encourages the poisoning of British Citizens on British soil.

I’ve been proven right now Putin has invaded Ukraine, we need a strong attitude towards Russia and Putin now more than ever. I worry about what would have happened if he had been elected in the current conflict.

I was also disturbed by his response to anti-semitism in the party.

This doesn't hold fire too much when we know how far into Russian money the story's are too.

Russia has far to much power full stop.

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 10:15

theworldhas · 10/07/2022 10:09

We can stop talking about BoJo now. It’s all been summed up in 5 minutes here:

Ha! Mic-drop!!

OP posts:
Gingernaut · 10/07/2022 10:15

TomPinch · 10/07/2022 10:02

Eh? What verse is the Scot-crushing in?

Verse Six, which is often left out now

www.lyricsondemand.com/n/nationalanthemlyrics/britiannationalanthemlyrics.html

MacaroniBaloney · 10/07/2022 10:14

Got any examples of successful socialist regimes OP?

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:13

theworldhas · 10/07/2022 10:08

I’m just glad we missed out on the “chaos” the Tories warned about under Ed Miliband. Instead it’s been a decade of smooth sailing. Haha.

If he'd won we'd be much better off. He'd have renationalised the energy companies (a key policy), would have reinvested in public services and we'd have avoided the national self harm of Brexit and the toxicity of the referendum and been better placed to cope with a pandemic.

Not that it would have been perfect by any means but the media tycoons weren't having him because he demanded the Leveson inquiry and vowed to enact the recommendations which Cameron vowed not to in exchange for Murdoch's support.

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 10:13

Oh absolutely personality has played a huge part in politics the past decade at least.

Fuelled by social media and msm.

It's not a great way to run though.

America did it with Trump. They now have a Starmer equivalent.

We did it with Boris - the next few years will be interesting.

WestHamPam · 10/07/2022 10:12

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:00

He's a local MP and activist, he's not a leader, that was always a problem. It allowed him to be undermined in his own cabinet by his deputy leader among others.

I remember Jeremy Hardy (a friend of his) joking about this- not that he was a poor leader but that he simply didn’t believe in leadership or hierarchical structures. So being “leader” of the Labour Party was always a slightly ironic position.

itsgettingweird · 10/07/2022 10:11

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 09:55

So many interesting and thought provoking replies here. Thank you. Reading through the thread, what’s jumping out at me is how much personality matters. It’s made me wonder whether the rise of reality TV (and maybe the increasing coverage of US presidential politics) is having an impact on the way we view politicians and engage with politics.

I realise that many people disliked both Corbyn and Johnson, the reason I’m saying many preferred Johnson is that the red wall turned blue in parts.

To those who think I’m not genuine- I’m not sure what you think my hidden agenda is? I am interested in politics, but too busy to read much beyond the headlines. I didn’t vote in 2017 election and wasn’t taking a huge amount of interest in politics at the time because of stressful circs in my own life.

I am a Labour supporter - but I am not tribal about it. I asked the question in good faith because I want to understand.

(And I am a regular mumsnetter who name changes a lot. There’s a lovely post that pops up regularly by a lady who thought that she was infertile but found out she was unexpectedly pregnant before Christmas last year. Her first post was asking if there was definitely a second line on the test, I think she took it as routine before going into hospital for a procedure. She took about 6 tests to be sure! And she updates regularly about the pregnancy is going - she’s having a boy and I think she’s due this month. If that helps people to believe I am a real poster 🤨)

That's a brilliant thread.

It's odd how you can feel so happy for someone who is just effectively words on a screen.

imperialminty · 10/07/2022 10:09

Haven’t read the full thread so apologies if this point has been made, but I was particularly disturbed by Corbyn’s relationship with Russia. This country already had a dangerously submissive attitude towards Putin (Theresa May’s handling of the Litvinenko murder whilst she was Home Secretary was appalling) but for me, when the Salisbury poisonings happened it confirmed for me that Corbin was an active threat to our national security. We can’t have a Prime Minister who borderline encourages the poisoning of British Citizens on British soil.

I’ve been proven right now Putin has invaded Ukraine, we need a strong attitude towards Russia and Putin now more than ever. I worry about what would have happened if he had been elected in the current conflict.

I was also disturbed by his response to anti-semitism in the party.

theworldhas · 10/07/2022 10:09

We can stop talking about BoJo now. It’s all been summed up in 5 minutes here:

MarshaBradyo · 10/07/2022 10:09

In pp His dislike..

theworldhas · 10/07/2022 10:08

I’m just glad we missed out on the “chaos” the Tories warned about under Ed Miliband. Instead it’s been a decade of smooth sailing. Haha.

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:07

He would've increased taxes for middle earners (in London terms - not the super rich

The increased taxes would have been levelled out by things like enhanced public services and lower energy bills which it would have paid for.

But the middle classes continue to vote Tory for promises of low tax, yet get poorer every time by stagnant wages and increased cost of living, while suffering a decline in public services.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 10:07

JustAnotherPoster00 · 10/07/2022 09:33

Eh? So youre in favour of mass murder and rendering the world uninhabitable?

Nuclear ‘deterrent’ is designed to do exactly the opposite. The clue is in the name. But the deterrent part only works if armament and disarmament are done multilaterally, as opposed to what Corbyn wanted.

MarshaBradyo · 10/07/2022 10:05

Also, I am coming to see how he was viewed as overly (dangerously?) idealistic, taking pacifism too far.

If he acted on hiss like for NATO this is a very benign way of looking at it

If you follow it through it is weakening security considerably

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:04

It’s made me wonder whether the rise of reality TV (and maybe the increasing coverage of US presidential politics) is having an impact on the way we view politicians and engage with politics.

I think there's a weirdness in the British people that embraces the kind of maverick, flamboyant, scruffy, funny haired chancer. and makes them life This is the country that adored Jimmy Savile when he was alive. Boris Johnson basically used his whole schtick (watch Savile's Netflix documentary) in terms of his public profile, to cultivate his image.

It's more simple than that though. The country does what Rupert Murdoch tells them to and the Daily Mail etc holds a lot of sway. The mainstream media were pathological about Corbyn from start to finish. Whether you like his policies or not, the brainwashing was unprecedented. The likes of the Mail are still drunk on the power now by clinging onto Boris.

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 10:03

Also, I am coming to see how he was viewed as overly (dangerously?) idealistic, taking pacifism too far.

Although I think the Tories have taken us much further right than many expected or comfortable with, they have been in power for a long time now and psychologically people prefer the familiar, so Corbyn’s very left-wing stance though perhaps no more extreme, seems more alarming.

OP posts:
thebellagio · 10/07/2022 10:02

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 09:55

So many interesting and thought provoking replies here. Thank you. Reading through the thread, what’s jumping out at me is how much personality matters. It’s made me wonder whether the rise of reality TV (and maybe the increasing coverage of US presidential politics) is having an impact on the way we view politicians and engage with politics.

I realise that many people disliked both Corbyn and Johnson, the reason I’m saying many preferred Johnson is that the red wall turned blue in parts.

To those who think I’m not genuine- I’m not sure what you think my hidden agenda is? I am interested in politics, but too busy to read much beyond the headlines. I didn’t vote in 2017 election and wasn’t taking a huge amount of interest in politics at the time because of stressful circs in my own life.

I am a Labour supporter - but I am not tribal about it. I asked the question in good faith because I want to understand.

(And I am a regular mumsnetter who name changes a lot. There’s a lovely post that pops up regularly by a lady who thought that she was infertile but found out she was unexpectedly pregnant before Christmas last year. Her first post was asking if there was definitely a second line on the test, I think she took it as routine before going into hospital for a procedure. She took about 6 tests to be sure! And she updates regularly about the pregnancy is going - she’s having a boy and I think she’s due this month. If that helps people to believe I am a real poster 🤨)

I think it’s an interesting point that personality plays a huge part in politics.

take someone like Trump - absolute psychopath. But you can be sure that Putin never would have invaded Ukraine if Trump was still in power because he wouldn’t have been quite sure if Trump would have supported him or immediately hit the red button!

in the UK I do feel that labour MPs are more driven by what they feel is right. They don’t seem to have the self serving ambition that fuels the Tories. That’s the thing that scares me most about the Tories - they will do and say anything if they think it will get them ahead. They are only interested in their own self ambition. and it’s not just the cabinet - our local Tory MPs would throw anyone under a bus if it got them ahead

TomPinch · 10/07/2022 10:02

ZarquonsSandals · 10/07/2022 09:50

I believe he talked with Sinn Fein and Palestine, as he talked with other people.
Boris Johnson has been 'friendly' with Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump and Berlsoconi n the past, but that is missing from the comparison.

As for JC not singing the National Anthem, so what? He hasnt told anyone else not to or banned them from doing so. Its a hymn to a monarch, not a celebration of a nation. Apart from lauding someone with immense privilege, the entire version needs some serious revision with its talk of crushing the Scots.

Eh? What verse is the Scot-crushing in?

SecretVictoria · 10/07/2022 10:01

Luxa · 10/07/2022 02:09

I can’t understand why they would think Eton-educated member of the Bullingdon club would be a preferable choice?

I think it's because Boris 'owns it'. He has never claimed that he isn't privileged. This is more authentic, so goes down better.

Exactly this.

roarfeckingroarr · 10/07/2022 10:00

He would've increased taxes for middle earners (in London terms - not the super rich), he didn't understand international affairs, he was weak on all foreign policy and invited terrorists for tea in Parliament, he allowed anti-semitism to grow under his watch and condoned it online (supporting a clearly antisemitic painting in Islington TH).

I wouldn't let an earnest, well meaning teenager run the country so allowing a pensioner with similar levels of deductive reason and thoughtfulness around policy would be equally undesirable.