Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do some people think Corbyn was a ‘terrifying prospect’?

238 replies

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 00:59

Taking a quote from a comment made on another thread.

I am not massively engaged in politics, but from what I understand Corbyn was pro-environment, pro-public services and re-nationalisation, he was a man who lived according to his own values.
He was laughed at for riding a bike and making jam. He was accused of being anti-semitic, though I didn't see any persuasive evidence of this, and- though not wanting to engage in whataboutery- Johnson’s awful racist remarks didn’t prevent him from gaining power.

I understand that people will have disagreed with him in policy. But what about him was did people feel was “terrifying” and so beyond the pale?
If Boris was electable and Corbyn was not I feel there must be something horrific about Corbyn that I am missing?

OP posts:
User135644 · 10/07/2022 11:49

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:54

He was pro Palestine and presided over a party that became antisemitism to the core.

Pro-Palestine but a lot of Labour MP's aren't. Labour Friends of Israel has a lot of members in the PLP and they were never having Corbyn, or a pro-Palestine leader.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/07/2022 11:33

The admiration for Chavez was surely enough even without the anti semitism on top. To me, a case of worn-out student socialist ideology over reality.

I don’t think he ever truly wanted to be PM though. He’d have had to put his money where his mouth is, instead of just criticising everybody and everything else.

Gingernaut · 10/07/2022 11:15

@TomPinch yes, well aware of the historical context of the Scot crushing verse.

A lot of people don't know about it at all.

HRTQueen · 10/07/2022 11:02

Did you see the press conference when the joke of a report about anti Semitism in the Labour Party was released

momentum heckler attacking MP Ruth Smeeth Corbyn did nothing to intervene we all know if this was a different situation say a Palestinian women being attacked verbally in such a way he would have intervened

again shows empathy for him is always political that’s not what we want from the Labour leader

myuterusistryingtokillme · 10/07/2022 11:01

Oh and I can't stand the bumbling moron Boris either

myuterusistryingtokillme · 10/07/2022 10:59

His policies were too extreme. And on a personal level he very much came across as a weasley little man that would make really shit decisions and dig his heels in just to prove a point and then get cross if someone challenged him on it

BloodAndFire · 10/07/2022 10:58

He was a terrifying prospect to me, my family, friends and community because we are Jewish.

I've had decades of being patronised and gaslighted about antisemitism and I'm not remotely interested in anyone telling me that the evidence of my own direct experience is wrong or untrue.

So I'm just answering the op's question.

If you (anyone reading this) choose to carry on believing that Jews are idiots or liars, that we don't know virulent antisemitism when it's directed at us, that's your choice.

There were many many opportunities to understand and listen at the time but sadly many people weren't willing to do so.

That's it.

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:54

Perfect28 · 10/07/2022 10:51

Corbyn was pro Palestinian, which anyone in their right mind should be too. This is misconstrued as antisemitism. In addition your remarks re socialism vs capitalism are spot on. Everyone screams socialism doesn't work whilst denying the reality that Clearly, neither does capitalism.

He was pro Palestine and presided over a party that became antisemitism to the core.

HRTQueen · 10/07/2022 10:53

Again student politics

all those that disliked Corbyn are bots, love Johnson, are secret Tory voters and so on

sadly Labour will be marked by Corbyn for sometime this is how politics works in the UK can cry all you like that people over look Johnson’s actions you work with what you have and only when in power cna you make changes

Blair understood this as does Starmer unfortunately he just isn’t connecting with voters. Would help if he finally rid the shadow cabinet of all of the far left (Rayner can go back to the benches)

Perfect28 · 10/07/2022 10:51

Corbyn was pro Palestinian, which anyone in their right mind should be too. This is misconstrued as antisemitism. In addition your remarks re socialism vs capitalism are spot on. Everyone screams socialism doesn't work whilst denying the reality that Clearly, neither does capitalism.

StillCuriouser · 10/07/2022 10:43

rushrushflat · 10/07/2022 10:23

And there you go the OP is a troll, it was obvious from the start.

I have made it perfectly clear through all my posts that I despise Boris Johnson!

OP posts:
Fimofriend · 10/07/2022 10:41

His minions harrassed members of Labour who disagreed with him and the harassment was extra nasty towards the female members of Labour. He ensured rhat there were no women in high positions in the party.

He couldn't see the value in trying to engage with young voters. He was invited to speak at Glastonbury before the Brexit vote but couldn't be bothered. He did go the next year but that was because the extensive criticism of his initial refusal.

He claims to be for equality but he clearly means "for all men close to my age".

Also... I don't know why but I have a clear impression that Corbyn simply doesn't understand the modern society ie. Internet, the global village, that women have rights and are seen as human beings, that people in general are more educated than when he was young.

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:35

Got any examples of successful neoliberal capitalist regimes?

The whole rotten system collapsed in 2008 and since then we've had a decade of austerity to try and prop it up and printing endless amounts of money.

It's collapsed.

HRTQueen · 10/07/2022 10:33

*shouldn't matter

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:33

*and no Corbyn

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:33

imperialminty · 10/07/2022 10:30

@User135644 You know Corbyn is actually pretty anti-EU? His lacklustre response in the Remain campaign is probably a key reason why we ended up voting to Leave. He’s a major part of the reason we’re in this mess.

I was talking about 'Chaos with Ed Miliband' not Corbyn. Ed wins in 2015 and there's no referendum to start with.

GrowlingManchego · 10/07/2022 10:32

MacaroniBaloney · 10/07/2022 10:14

Got any examples of successful socialist regimes OP?

Got any examples of successful neoliberal capitalist regimes?

Oh dear, it hasn’t worked out too well for the UK has it?

That you used the word ‘regime’ suggests you are trying to provoke a reaction rather than actually being interested in the answer.

But for anyone else reading who genuinely is interested, look at the social democracies of Europe. More emphasis is placed upon investing in infrastructure and people to result in a society that functions more effectively. Most countries that work better politically than the UK have some form of proportional representation as well.

HRTQueen · 10/07/2022 10:32

TomPinch · 10/07/2022 06:52

What's depressing about this thread is the lack of mention that Corbyn, regardless of his personal integrity and ability to make jam, simply wasn't PM material because he was a career backbench quibbler.

He lost to a journeyman journo who was worse.

Whereas the only mention of Starmer so far is that he's a slippery lawyer. I expect someone will add that he's dull. But Starmer was a highly respected DPP. He's just the sort of person you want running a country: intelligent, capable, honest, ie, someone with character, in the old-fashioned sense.

Politicians shouldn't be curiosities or entertaining. They should be dull and competent.

People's priorities have got way out of whack.

Personality has alway come into politics it’s nothing new just there are more platforms now. To pretend it doesn’t or should matter is naive

and many of us who strongly dislike Corbyn are labour members/supporters that is why we are so angry the party has been dragged backwards and will take years to recover. We didn’t vote Tory and wouldn’t be as are politics are not conservative.

and Corbyn did become a personality leader who can forget the embarrassment of Labour Live the far left and idealists student politics has no place in parliament and certainly not driving the opposition where the fuck has it got us we all know a Tory government with an 80 seat majority

The party membership that Corbyn and co banged on about constantly shows you how ridiculously out of touch they were and now Labour have to recover from that

roarfeckingroarr · 10/07/2022 10:30

Why are PPs saying this govt has taken the Tories further right? I know it's fashionable to say now, but - excepting Rwanda - I see recent policies such as furlough, lockdowns and tax rises as anti-Conservative.

imperialminty · 10/07/2022 10:30

@User135644 You know Corbyn is actually pretty anti-EU? His lacklustre response in the Remain campaign is probably a key reason why we ended up voting to Leave. He’s a major part of the reason we’re in this mess.

CredibilityProblem · 10/07/2022 10:29

theworldhas · 10/07/2022 10:08

I’m just glad we missed out on the “chaos” the Tories warned about under Ed Miliband. Instead it’s been a decade of smooth sailing. Haha.

Oh don't remind me of the Ed Miliband election. Just too depressing to even contemplate that missed opportunity. Some people date the death of David Bowie as the day the world turned to shit, but I reckon it might be eight months earlier, the day Cameron beat Miliband.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 10/07/2022 10:28

Somatronic · 10/07/2022 09:31

Can you provide a source for this? I've never heard of this?

In that sense he really is no different than any other man who has claimed the successful outcome of a woman's work for himself, now is he?

If the work goes pear shaped though, obviously the woman is entirely to blame...

imperialminty · 10/07/2022 10:27

@itsgettingweird I both agree and disagree. As I mentioned in my post, the Tory government have had a terrible way of dealing with Russia since they came into power. Salisbury was a direct result of Litvinenko etc. And dirty Russian money in this country has been a massive problem (and going on for longer - the previous Labour governments were involved in this as well). But for me when Corbyn’s Russian sympathy went somewhere much more concerning and his suggestions in the aftermath of Salisbury were really frightening to me. I think it’s pretty obvious Corbyn wouldn’t have imposed the sanctions that this government have done, for example. And I am very proud to live in a country which has sanctioned Russia in the way it has.

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:26

Oh yes, right on time. Socialism has never been allowed to work by the US. The most predictable line.

I'm not a socialist. I was just pointing out the difference in how our own failing economic model regularly collapses but is bailed out by public money or printing more.

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:25

User135644 · 10/07/2022 10:13

If he'd won we'd be much better off. He'd have renationalised the energy companies (a key policy), would have reinvested in public services and we'd have avoided the national self harm of Brexit and the toxicity of the referendum and been better placed to cope with a pandemic.

Not that it would have been perfect by any means but the media tycoons weren't having him because he demanded the Leveson inquiry and vowed to enact the recommendations which Cameron vowed not to in exchange for Murdoch's support.

He’d have broken up the pharmaceutical companies.

The ones that saved millions of lives with their vaccines.