Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do Grammar schools have better facilities?

71 replies

UndertheCedartree · 09/07/2022 21:44

We've been looking at secondary schools for my DD.

The Grammar school stands out as having better facilities, nicer and more outside space, very good head teacher and pastoral support. I'm just wondering how come Grammar's are so much better? Do they get more funding or do the middle class parents donate to the school?

I hate the Grammar system as it just seems to mean the other schools aren't very good.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JudgeJ · 29/08/2022 20:52

hummerbird · 25/08/2022 19:34

There are vocationally committed teachers who would work in a poor area if they only had the teaching to do. They get so ground down by the lack of support from employers and the Social Work that is expected of them. Can it not be organised differently?

They also get ground down by the expectaion that they alone can solve all the parents' problems at home, in the car park etc.. If teachers were allowed to simply teach standards would rise, as it is they have to waste too much time on external things, eg dealing with pupils' spats on social media which, if the parents could be bothered, would never be a school issue.

C8H10N4O2 · 29/08/2022 17:39

GrammarTeacher · 25/08/2022 17:32

No grammars don't have more funding. They have whatever the local formula says per pupil like other state schools.
One near me is very good at winning bids and has some amazing facilities as a result. On the other hand my classroom was just repainted for the first time in 15 years.

They can often, however, raise more from parents (again this varies school to school) some comprehensives in expensive areas also have this advantage.
But they don't get more funding per pupil.

That isn't entirely true though is it? In one of my neighbouring boroughs the local formula results in more money per head overall in the grammar schools because it has a massive skew to 6th form pupils (much higher than in my borough). I'm surprised they can still get away with it.

In addition the top grammars set the expectation early of very high contributions to the school fund per pupil (not per family). They also have more expensive uniform policies. These two, and the open evenings stressing all the expensive extra curriculars serve to deter poorer families from even applying and reinforce the kind of intake with money and enriched environments at home. Its not unusual for every child entering in year 7 of the top three or four grammars to have been to private primaries or heavily tutored - the parents boast about it.

Not all grammars do this - interestingly another neighbouring borough with a more mixed system and fewer grammars actively works to get a more mixed intake. However for children in the first system the grammars are not offering opportunity they are withholding it.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 29/08/2022 17:20

Because the pupils don’t trash them

LookingforMaryPoppins · 29/08/2022 17:15

I went to a grammar back in the 80's . Everyone sat the 11+, primary schools were able to prep all children and nobody had tuition.

Teachers knew exactly who would pass and who wouldn't / could go either way.

Having had the benefit of a grammar education I was the first in my family to go to university and the first to subsequently qualify in a profession.

Having returned to Kent my eldest two children are both at local grammar schools. The schools certainly don't have more money or better facilities.

Preparation for the 11+ needn't be paid tuition, there are plenty of online resources, past papers and work books. The problem as I see it is twofold - schools are no longer able to prepare children for the test and children are reliant on their parents entering them........ These changes are detrimental to social mobility, children are reliant on their parents to enter them / help them prepare.

The children my eldest two children go to school with are not from super wealthy families. They are from families that value education.

We opted for the local grammar schools rather than the super selective options - I do think they are very different.

MysteriousMonkey · 29/08/2022 14:30

One of my children is at a grammar and it doesn't seem to have more funding to me. In fact in some ways it seems a little run down and old fashioned, but said child loves it.

thing47 · 29/08/2022 14:11

Lots of grammars still where I live. There are a lot of wealthy parents who are so relieved not to have to pay school fees that they are very generous with donations etc. We had one DC at Grammar and one DC at secondary modern at the same time, and the difference in available resources was quite remarkable, and really quite shocking.

Badbadbunny · 29/08/2022 13:35

When we did our local secondary school open days, we were pretty appalled at the state of the grammar, which literally had buckets to collect rainwater coming through the library roof (derelict classrooms in the same very old building), a few very run down "temporary" classrooms, a manky ancient pool, and generally a very run down appearance.

It was in contrast to one of the comps which had virtually been rebuilt, with state of the art theatre, sports hall, brand new classrooms, "atrium" style entrance, etc.

I think it depends more on how good the school management is re applying for grants etc.

I have since noticed that the grammar's oldest building which had the leaky roof and derelict classrooms has finally been re-roofed and one of the derelict wings has been refurbished and is now re-opened as classrooms, and the temporary classrooms have been removed!

AngelsWithSilverWings · 29/08/2022 13:30

@Malie we moved her to private for a number of reasons. She became seriously I'll during the pandemic and now has a chronic condition that requires her to have a day in hospital once a month plus a few other appointments for blood tests and scans every few months. Illness caused her mental health to suffer and she developed awful anxiety and OCD and also experienced quite a bit of bullying.

State school couldn't provide the pastoral support she needed and their strict rules on attendance and having to do catch up work put too much pressure on her. She's much happier at her private school.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/08/2022 13:33

DS's Primary school run an 11+ after school club for the children who want it. No tutoring costs for us.Smile

jessieminto · 27/08/2022 13:28

To all those who say only the rich can afford tutoring: my DS will be doing the 11+ in a few weeks.

He's had a tutor since beginning of year 5. So 1 academic year. It is £60 per month and £40 if he does a mock test with them. We've supplemented the tutor with some practice books from Amazon. 4 x £5 each.

£840 total across 11 months. I know that £70 a month would be unaffordable for some. We knew we wanted DS to try the 11+ and if needed to, would have saved for it. This cost for us has been affordable, but I don't think we could have stretched to much more without saving. Which we've had plenty of years to do if needed.

The only alternative non-grammar school in our area is awful, very much a sink school for those who don't get in to one of the many Grammars. We don't really have a choice if we want DS to do well.

GrammarTeacher · 27/08/2022 12:55

Grammar school classes are not smaller. Well some minority option classes are but my KS 3/4 classes are the same as other teachers of my subject.

WeAreAllLionesses · 25/08/2022 22:05

a lot of very well off parents saw it as they were saving ££££££ on private fees so would donate well.

^^ this. And wealthier alumni.

Malie · 25/08/2022 21:34

Patchworkpatty · 25/08/2022 21:15

My reason for being adamantly against grammars is that you V CANNOT judge a child's academic potential at age 11 !!

I 'passed' my 11+ but failed the report as 'suitable grammar schools character' because I objected to my head teachers physical abuse of my younger brother .. ?this was 1975...

I went to the LSE .. despite being the first year to sit o'levels in 1980 in a secondary modern.. am now a senior civil servant on 73k but has taken 32
Years ... had I been given my 'worth' it would have been half that time ..

Sorry you have said you were denied a grammar school place because of your character (rightly or wrongly) not because of academic ability. So you carry that chip n y our shoulder?

Patchworkpatty · 25/08/2022 21:15

My reason for being adamantly against grammars is that you V CANNOT judge a child's academic potential at age 11 !!

I 'passed' my 11+ but failed the report as 'suitable grammar schools character' because I objected to my head teachers physical abuse of my younger brother .. ?this was 1975...

I went to the LSE .. despite being the first year to sit o'levels in 1980 in a secondary modern.. am now a senior civil servant on 73k but has taken 32
Years ... had I been given my 'worth' it would have been half that time ..

Patchworkpatty · 25/08/2022 21:03

This ^

LakieLady · 25/08/2022 20:47

If you disbelieve me - just stop by TOGS, Judd, TWGGS, Tun Wells Grammar and Skinners in Tonbridge/Tunbridge Wellls and look at the vehicles picking these kids up.. wall to wall Porsche, Bentley, Mercedes' 4x4s... (easily afforded when you are getting a private education on the state)

So true. My DNiece was horribly bullied at TWGGS because her parents were "poor" (they're not, they lived in a house worth £1.2m and had a thriving business) and her clothes came from Next and not Abercrombie & Fitch or Hollister.

RayneDance · 25/08/2022 20:38

Phil the spectators article misses out key issues which renders it almost pointless.

Firty · 25/08/2022 20:32

There’s a state primary school near me that is very good at raising money from parents and local community. They make £20,000 from their summer fair every year. That’s just the summer fair.

Philandbill · 25/08/2022 20:27

Totally agree that it is selection by house prices. Do not agree that grammar schools provide an answer to the unfairness of this.

Malie · 25/08/2022 20:24

AngelsWithSilverWings · 25/08/2022 20:21

My DS's grammar school is always complaining about lack of funds. It's a very old building and is quite run down in places. They request a voluntary monthly donation of around £100 from parents and mentioned at the new entrants open evening that they will call any parents who don't set up a direct debit to discuss further!

My DD was at a state academy until we moved her to private and it was a modern building with great facilities , a swimming pool, a well equipped gym and sports centre. They never asked for a penny from parents.

Why did you go private if the state school was so good?

AngelsWithSilverWings · 25/08/2022 20:21

My DS's grammar school is always complaining about lack of funds. It's a very old building and is quite run down in places. They request a voluntary monthly donation of around £100 from parents and mentioned at the new entrants open evening that they will call any parents who don't set up a direct debit to discuss further!

My DD was at a state academy until we moved her to private and it was a modern building with great facilities , a swimming pool, a well equipped gym and sports centre. They never asked for a penny from parents.

Malie · 25/08/2022 20:14

Philandbill · 25/08/2022 19:18

What reality suggests though by the house prices!

Malie · 25/08/2022 20:11

MardyBumm · 25/08/2022 18:57

The reality is actually many of the applicants can't cope working in a normal school so are actually weaker teachers.

Not my experience. Take it you’re a teacher?

Patchworkpatty · 25/08/2022 20:05

Said so much better than me.. I am only a spectator as I opted out (despite DD1 getting a place - but ending up at the same Uni as her GS friends) ..

lechatnoir · 25/08/2022 20:01

I can only speak about the grammars in Kent but 100% echo at @Patchworkpatty said. I have 3 Dc with 2 Dc grammar. Of course not everyone is wealthy but majority of their friends are well off and we are the poor relations (we are not poor by any means just average - 3 bed semi, kids at local primary, both work ft and earn average wage) . In my youngest child's close friendship group of 7, 5 pals went to prep school and if homes, cars & holidays are an indicator then they are most definitely wealthy. The FSM figures vs local state secondary support this disparity and it's really bloody sad.

Many many kids in grammar were heavily tutored and/or attended prep school and some continue tutoring right through secondary school. My eldest Dc is at a superselective grammar and I know the expectation is parents pay into the school fund by monthly DD (I nearly fell off my chair when one told me they pay £250pm but no one else in the room seemed to bat an eyelid!) The quality of teaching & curriculum might be the same as state secondary but the opportunities, the pastoral care, the expectation on children, the facilities and the career guidance at grammar (particularly super-selective) are much more akin to private than state. I also have a child at non-selective state secondary and he's doing just fine but you absolutely can't compare the educational experience he gets vs his siblings. Facilities there are good but it's a church school so funding comes from additional sources.