Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I being overly sensitive? *TW animal death

213 replies

alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:29

So I live in a small Villiage, as a previous city dweller some of the downsides of living in the countryside have taken a while to get used to, such as cows waking us up at 5am, free roaming peacocks destroying our cars paint on the roof and general manure smells every now and again. But after 4 years we are getting there.

Last night a local farmer had 40 lambs killed, he thinks it was a dog attack, instead of just putting a normal post about it on the local FB group (like he and other farmers have before) his son instead decided to share 20 graphic photos of the dead lambs along with the post asking for information or if anyone saw anything.

Now I was pretty upset to be scrolling through FB and to then see images of lambs ripped apart, insides everywhere, pilled on top of each other and commented this on the post. Reminding him that there are teens and young people in the group and it's maybe not the best thing to put on here, to be fair I'd expect many people, adults included would feel upset seeing these images on their FB feed.

I was jumped on by the farmer, other farmers in the village, the 'we've been here for 30 years, go back to the local city if you don't like it' lot and even accused of being the attacker, despite not owning a bloody dog.

I personally also think 40 lambs in one go is unlikely to be a dog attack, but didn't comment that of course.

Was I being unreasonable or overly sensitive to find this shocking and to maybe suggest it's a bit too much to post in a FB group where local children often post looking for summer work or weekend car washing for pocket money? Am I turning into one of those 'think of the children' people!

OP posts:
QueenOfHiraeth · 09/07/2022 22:11

I think 40 lambs suffering such an awful death and the farmer having that loss when times are hard enough trumps your right to cosy and sanitised FB posts.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 09/07/2022 22:10

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:09

Thankfully FB disagrees with you there, sharing graphic images of dead animals is against community guidelines so am glad to have reported it now

I don't think facebook's community standards have any relevance to the ethics of this incident.

SickKid · 09/07/2022 22:10

I wouldn't enjoy seeing that image on my fb feed, but I wouldn't have commented. Momentary unpleasantness for whoever sees it and then they get on with their day vs the suffering of the lambs and the horror of the farmer on discovering and having to deal with them? Not really comparable are they??

Scianel · 09/07/2022 22:10

What on earth do you think it was if not a dog or dogs? It's not we've got wolves or lions roaming about.
Farmers suffer loss after loss after loss because of dog attacks. No wonder one of them decided to post the reality.
I can't imagine a recent city dweller beaking in that it upset your sensibilities helped much.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 09/07/2022 22:09

Poor lambs, I’m aware of this case. No sympathy for the farmer. 🤐

They were going to die for people to eat, he’s only bothered about the finances. The approved way of killing them at a slaughterhouse isn’t pleasant either and plenty of times isn’t done as it’s meant to be so they suffer even more.

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:09

CaptainThe95thRifles · 09/07/2022 22:07

Shocking people DOES sometimes make people take more care about their precious dog's behaviour. Particularly when they're exposed to the reality of what it's done, and that next time it may well end up shot.

Your attitude is appalling.

Thankfully FB disagrees with you there, sharing graphic images of dead animals is against community guidelines so am glad to have reported it now

OP posts:
alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:08

Eyesopenwideawake · 09/07/2022 22:04

Have you any idea how much money the farmer will have lost from those 40 lambs? Do you know the suicide statistics for farmers? I think you're showing a staggering lack of empathy. Maybe, after 4 years, country life is not for you.

And that has and impact on them sharing graphic images?

Nope.

And suicide rates, you mean the ones that are in line with wider male suicide rates in the UK? And since the majority of farmers in the UK are male this means they are no more likely to commit suicide than the average male.

OP posts:
CaptainThe95thRifles · 09/07/2022 22:07

Shocking people DOES sometimes make people take more care about their precious dog's behaviour. Particularly when they're exposed to the reality of what it's done, and that next time it may well end up shot.

Your attitude is appalling.

Misty999 · 09/07/2022 22:06

YABU it's to show those that don't secure their dogs the damage that can be done.

ohmygash · 09/07/2022 22:06

yabu. It’s the reality

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:05

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 09/07/2022 22:03

If graphic images on FB prevent one person from taking a risk around livestock then it's worth it.

You say that the photos are unlikely to help identify the owners of the dog(s) involved. I disagree. Even responsible owners find their dogs escape/run off. If a dog had been missing overnight and comes home with blood on his face the owner would be made aware of who to contact by the post.

Yeah unlikely, the same as every other dog attack that's left unanswered this will be the same unfortunately. As who would admit that!? Especially as the farmers have now involved the police

OP posts:
Eyesopenwideawake · 09/07/2022 22:04

Have you any idea how much money the farmer will have lost from those 40 lambs? Do you know the suicide statistics for farmers? I think you're showing a staggering lack of empathy. Maybe, after 4 years, country life is not for you.

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:04

Mally100 · 09/07/2022 22:02

Yabu and should have kept out of it. The farmer was clearly upset and wanted everyone to know how serious this was. You should have kept your opinions to yourself.

But why are pictures necessary, they won't do anything to help the situation, if anything it makes it worse as I myself didn't bother reading most of the post neither did many neighbours who just hid the post when seeing those images pop up. So it's preventing people from actually engaging with the issue. Thankfully FB removed the post after a while as it breaks community standards.

OP posts:
IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 09/07/2022 22:03

If graphic images on FB prevent one person from taking a risk around livestock then it's worth it.

You say that the photos are unlikely to help identify the owners of the dog(s) involved. I disagree. Even responsible owners find their dogs escape/run off. If a dog had been missing overnight and comes home with blood on his face the owner would be made aware of who to contact by the post.

Mally100 · 09/07/2022 22:02

Yabu and should have kept out of it. The farmer was clearly upset and wanted everyone to know how serious this was. You should have kept your opinions to yourself.

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:02

CaptainThe95thRifles · 09/07/2022 22:00

YABU - to make unfounded assumptions about the damage that even one dog can do in a flock, let alone a pair or small pack, loose from a single home, and also to think your sensibilities are more important that those sheep's lives, or the farmer's livelihood.

You don't like looking at photos - that farmer has had to clear up that carnage, and watch their already slim profit margins wane even further. Get a bloody grip, or move back to the city.

When did I say my 'sensibilities' were more important than their lives.

Putting those photos up will not help anyone, it will not prevent another attack, it won't help find the person who did it, it serves no purpose than to shock those who wouldn't do this anyway.

Thankfully FB has removed the image as it breaks community standards.

OP posts:
rainbowunicorn · 09/07/2022 22:01

You are coming across as extremely ignorant.

Alfixnm · 09/07/2022 22:00

OP - these dogs were unlikely to have been out for a walk. They're more likely to be dogs whose gardens are not secure.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 09/07/2022 22:00

YABU - to make unfounded assumptions about the damage that even one dog can do in a flock, let alone a pair or small pack, loose from a single home, and also to think your sensibilities are more important that those sheep's lives, or the farmer's livelihood.

You don't like looking at photos - that farmer has had to clear up that carnage, and watch their already slim profit margins wane even further. Get a bloody grip, or move back to the city.

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:00

mizzo · 09/07/2022 21:58

Yeah but it's a bit different seeing lambs who have been literally ripped apart close up on your FB feed. You expect it at the supermarket, you don't expect to see such extreme images on FB as you're scrolling down.

To me dead lamb is dead lamb.
You wouldn't complain about a picture of a lamb roast dinner on fb.

Well no because it's an entirely different scenario. The fact you think they're at all comparable is a bit weird.

Thankfully FB has taken the post down as it breaks community standards.

OP posts:
alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:59

Throckmorton · 09/07/2022 21:56

To be honest, yes it's grim, but many dog owners appear to have no bloody clue when it comes to livestock and maybe pictures like this are what is needed to get it through to them what an unrestrained dog can do.

It's also rather strange that you say you don't imagine it could be a dog - what else could it be? Foxes aren't big enough to do that much damage to so many animals, so unless you think you have a very sick individual killing livestock, it has to be someone's dog.

The villiage is small and mostly old people, so I just highly doubt someone is off in the fields with a dog past midnight tbh.

It doesn't make much sense, why walk a dog in the pitch dark with no lighting in the middle of a 10 acre field. The part of the field they're kept in after giving birth is quite far from the road too. So the dogs would have to be off lead and ran pretty far

OP posts:
Alfixnm · 09/07/2022 21:59

YABU tbh. Dogs can and do kill this many sheep in one go, it's a common occurrence. It's usually a few loose dogs that go together and get into a frenzy. No human could convince them to stop.

These attacks are vicious, brutal and distressing for both the sheep and their owners. Imagine the distress of having to clean up the dismembered bodies of your animals, all while knowing your income for the year has been lost? Imagine the stress of not knowing how you will pay your bills now, and the stress of having to nurse the injured survivors.

And imagine your local village dog owners not caring, and allowing it to happen again and again. Nobody thinks that their cuddly pet could be responsible.

You and your neighbours are seeing the reality of it for yourself now. I'm sorry that you have found the images upsetting, but I hope those images have made a few dog owners near you stop and think.

mizzo · 09/07/2022 21:58

Yeah but it's a bit different seeing lambs who have been literally ripped apart close up on your FB feed. You expect it at the supermarket, you don't expect to see such extreme images on FB as you're scrolling down.

To me dead lamb is dead lamb.
You wouldn't complain about a picture of a lamb roast dinner on fb.

alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:57

Ohfgswhat · 09/07/2022 21:55

Yes, it'll be a dog attack. Frankly, the farmer will be sick to the back teeth of having to deal with the carnage and expense, let alone the heart ache of loosing stock to thoughtless, irresponsible people. Everyone in a rural community has responsibility of making sure this type if attack does not happen. ANY dog is capable of doing this damage, sheep are very vulnerable to attack and stress related death. Seeing the evidence in the published photo's should be enough to make sure you report any loose dog, however small and cute to your local farmer. You need to be part of the rural community not an lily livered, hollow legged visitor. Stop complaining and FIT In! The dog needs dealing with, give farmer a fighting chance to protect his stock.

How is this not 'fitting' in 😂

The only lose dogs round here usually belong to the farmers anyway (not just those ones, but most have working dogs that are allowed to roam free) who is out at midnight looking for dogs in a 10 acre field.

OP posts:
EdithStourton · 09/07/2022 21:56

Dog attacks don't usually happen because a farmer has dodgy fences. They happen because people don't control their dogs, let them off without thoroughly checking and don't stock train them. And it's bloody horrible to find even one sheep killed by a dog.

It's also entirely possible that a dog or two could kill 40 lambs. I know farmers who have lost in the high teens in a single attack. And what else is it going to be? We don't have wolves loose in the UK (which is where I assume you are).

The FB pictures are unlikely to flush out the culprit (I hope that farmer got DNA off the carcasses - it might help secure a conviction). They're there to scare the living daylights out of local dog owners who will think, shit, I'd better keep a close eye on Fido. They might help prevent another incident, not that you will ever know. Better mauled lambs on FB than more mauled lambs out in the fields.

Swipe left for the next trending thread