Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I being overly sensitive? *TW animal death

213 replies

alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:29

So I live in a small Villiage, as a previous city dweller some of the downsides of living in the countryside have taken a while to get used to, such as cows waking us up at 5am, free roaming peacocks destroying our cars paint on the roof and general manure smells every now and again. But after 4 years we are getting there.

Last night a local farmer had 40 lambs killed, he thinks it was a dog attack, instead of just putting a normal post about it on the local FB group (like he and other farmers have before) his son instead decided to share 20 graphic photos of the dead lambs along with the post asking for information or if anyone saw anything.

Now I was pretty upset to be scrolling through FB and to then see images of lambs ripped apart, insides everywhere, pilled on top of each other and commented this on the post. Reminding him that there are teens and young people in the group and it's maybe not the best thing to put on here, to be fair I'd expect many people, adults included would feel upset seeing these images on their FB feed.

I was jumped on by the farmer, other farmers in the village, the 'we've been here for 30 years, go back to the local city if you don't like it' lot and even accused of being the attacker, despite not owning a bloody dog.

I personally also think 40 lambs in one go is unlikely to be a dog attack, but didn't comment that of course.

Was I being unreasonable or overly sensitive to find this shocking and to maybe suggest it's a bit too much to post in a FB group where local children often post looking for summer work or weekend car washing for pocket money? Am I turning into one of those 'think of the children' people!

OP posts:
8londie · 10/07/2022 09:26

YABU. It's not about you. This farmer lost his livestock, lambs have been ripped apart for no reason at all. It's not about you.

And he's right that people need to see it, and not just a post about '40 lambs' and get on with their day.

MargaretThursday · 10/07/2022 09:18

FB community standards aren't especially a good barometer of whether something is actually offensive.

A friend posted a photo of a large spider in her house and asked for suggestions to get rid of it.
I replied, "Agh.. Burn the house down?"
Yep, that was deleted due to "breaching community standards".

Yes, it was probably a dog or pack of dogs. Probably the owners are actually aware because they'll at best have been missing overnight.
Sheep escape. It is something they're very good at. If you've lived in the countryside for long you'll have seen sheep get into the most ridiculous situations.

Hope they catch the owners.

beautyisthefaceisee · 10/07/2022 09:06

alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:29

So I live in a small Villiage, as a previous city dweller some of the downsides of living in the countryside have taken a while to get used to, such as cows waking us up at 5am, free roaming peacocks destroying our cars paint on the roof and general manure smells every now and again. But after 4 years we are getting there.

Last night a local farmer had 40 lambs killed, he thinks it was a dog attack, instead of just putting a normal post about it on the local FB group (like he and other farmers have before) his son instead decided to share 20 graphic photos of the dead lambs along with the post asking for information or if anyone saw anything.

Now I was pretty upset to be scrolling through FB and to then see images of lambs ripped apart, insides everywhere, pilled on top of each other and commented this on the post. Reminding him that there are teens and young people in the group and it's maybe not the best thing to put on here, to be fair I'd expect many people, adults included would feel upset seeing these images on their FB feed.

I was jumped on by the farmer, other farmers in the village, the 'we've been here for 30 years, go back to the local city if you don't like it' lot and even accused of being the attacker, despite not owning a bloody dog.

I personally also think 40 lambs in one go is unlikely to be a dog attack, but didn't comment that of course.

Was I being unreasonable or overly sensitive to find this shocking and to maybe suggest it's a bit too much to post in a FB group where local children often post looking for summer work or weekend car washing for pocket money? Am I turning into one of those 'think of the children' people!

Sounds more like a fox than a dog.

I agree with you OP. A girl I know kept posting photos of dead cats on the road.

Nobody needs to see that

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/07/2022 08:40

Rural Crime units have been known to share the images themselves precisely because some people don't want to believe or can't accept that their offlead animals are doing anything other than getting livestock a little antsy for five minutes - and where it's been a deliberate choice, it's hoped that somebody who knows of it is no longer fobbed off with a 'He just had a quick runaround, no damage done, it's farmers trying to blame dogs for everything when they're probably just trying to make some money on insurance' and reports the owner.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 08:38

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 00:43

I don't need to be local to answer the OP's question:

Was I being unreasonable or overly sensitive to find this shocking

The OP didn't ask if we all think the farmer's invented a dog attack for some unfathomable reason of his own. The OP asked if they were unreasonable to report the farmer's post because they didn't like seeing it.

Do you understand the difference? You seem to be struggling with the basics here...

I’ve already said the images themselves don’t bother me but discussion moves on and we’re allowed to make other points. That’s what happens on forums so it seems that you are the one struggling with the basics here. But he was actually unreasonable to post them it seems as that sort of thing isn’t allowed on Facebook. Facebook agree as they removed the images.

SlagathaChristie · 10/07/2022 08:33

Just a point: the farmer is entitled to be devastated about the financial loss, the disgusting clean up job etc, but he is probably also upset about the manner of death. Death in the abattoir is a lot quicker, cleaner, and less painful than being disembowelled by dogs. Not pleasant, but less awful. OP, yabu. Rural life means getting up close and personal with death (and farming), and FB "community standards " are bollocks anyway. You shouldn't have reported, that wasn't helpful, and you will get a reputation now, "school mum friends" or no.

SolasAnla · 10/07/2022 08:25

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:08

And that has and impact on them sharing graphic images?

Nope.

And suicide rates, you mean the ones that are in line with wider male suicide rates in the UK? And since the majority of farmers in the UK are male this means they are no more likely to commit suicide than the average male.

That is a vile post.

You are looking for sympathy posts while clearly showing your ignorance, and lack of empathy.

Plantstrees · 10/07/2022 08:24

YABVU You had to witness a photograph on Facebook. I have much more sympathy for the poor farmer that had to see those dead lambs in the flesh. Go back to the city if you can't cope with rural life. I hope they find out who is responsible for this.

Icecreamsodaloda · 10/07/2022 08:22

Couldn't you have sent a private message to the farmer instead of publicly trying to shame them at a time they have lost their livestock and a chunk of the livelihood. The reaction by him and others sounds like you might well have precedent for being a busy body who likes to have her say on things, as does your moaning about country smells and cows waking you up!

Maisa45 · 10/07/2022 08:17

mizzo · 09/07/2022 21:47

YABU you can see bits of dead lamb in the supermarket.

This. The only difference then is that people can convince themselves it was wasn't once a sentient being cause it no longer has a face.

thedancingbear · 10/07/2022 08:14

It’s not weird at all. You’re happy to have people kill and dismember animals for your tea, but can’t cope with the reality of what that looks like.

meat eaters complaining about the sight of a slaughtered animal are massive hypocrites

orangeisthenewpuce · 10/07/2022 08:09

I'm with the farmer on this. Given that no children under 13 should be on fb that's old enough to see the carnage dogs can do to sheep. He was quite right to show it to locals.

EdithStourton · 10/07/2022 07:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

He's probably very upset at how they died. A well-run kill line is quick and efficient and designed to cause the animals minimal stress and pain. A dog attack is usually protracted (the last local one I heard of lasted half an hour) and terrifying for the sheep, who are often ripped to shreds before they die.

It's a shame your empathy for the animals doesn't extend to the person at the sharp end of this one.

Mangogogogo · 10/07/2022 00:45

To be clear. I don’t think the dog attack is bs.

i think most of the other shit you’re banging out is bs though

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 00:43

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 09/07/2022 23:28

Do you know this case? Are you local? It is relevant when it makes no sense.

I don't need to be local to answer the OP's question:

Was I being unreasonable or overly sensitive to find this shocking

The OP didn't ask if we all think the farmer's invented a dog attack for some unfathomable reason of his own. The OP asked if they were unreasonable to report the farmer's post because they didn't like seeing it.

Do you understand the difference? You seem to be struggling with the basics here...

Pieceofpurplesky · 10/07/2022 00:26

You're right OP. It can't possibly have been a dog that did that.

It will be those weird country folk and their mysterious secrets ...

ladydimitrescu · 10/07/2022 00:19

Yeah, you should have just scrolled past. The farmer will be massively out of pocket and rightly upset. There was no need for you to comment on it tbh.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 00:12

TrainspottingWelsh · 10/07/2022 00:05

@LivingLifeOnTheVeg If I exclude dodgy diy yards and townie wannabe smallholders, then I’d say 90% of the animal strayings I’ve ever experienced or heard of are down to members of the public, either wrecking perimeters, leaving gates or scaring animals to the point they are willing to injure themselves escaping. And the remaining 10% include weird and wonderful unpredictable escapes and natural events as well as human failings.

Human failings could be one way of putting it I suppose. Sometimes it’s a step further than a failing though. You have to know the circumstances and history sometimes. My family have some very interesting stories of whats happening on farms and times are getting tougher for farmers. Desperation results in all sorts of things so I’m told.

mycatisannoying · 10/07/2022 00:11

YABU, sorry. The farmer must have been furious and rightfully so. You're definitely entitled to your opinion though OP, and I'm not saying it's wrong. But I think the horror of the situation trumps your sensitivity on the matter.

gezelligheid · 10/07/2022 00:11

TrainspottingWelsh · 09/07/2022 23:54

@gezelligheid but that’s the result of it happening. The farmer had to see it.

Every time some scum member of the public has made one of my horses ill, or caused an injury, I’m really tempted to laminate graphic images and stick them on the fence next to the do not feed signs. I very nearly did the morning after my then young dc had to watch their pony rolling round the floor in agony and I had to leave them sobbing because I was trying to stop the pony breaking limbs before the vet got there. Kind of fits with one of my early memories too, mutilated livestock is far more distressing in reality.

Just because it is distressing in reality it doesn't mean it is okay to post the graphic images. If I'd witnessed something distressing the last thing I would want to do is make other people see a picture of it. Witnessing it in person OR online is sad and horrific.

The farmer could have put his post up with a content warning and posted the pictures in the comments. That's what any sane person would do. Subjecting people to graphic horrifying images to prove a point is weird.

Hearing your anecdotal stories won't change my mind. I agree with the OP.

TrainspottingWelsh · 10/07/2022 00:05

@LivingLifeOnTheVeg If I exclude dodgy diy yards and townie wannabe smallholders, then I’d say 90% of the animal strayings I’ve ever experienced or heard of are down to members of the public, either wrecking perimeters, leaving gates or scaring animals to the point they are willing to injure themselves escaping. And the remaining 10% include weird and wonderful unpredictable escapes and natural events as well as human failings.

TeresaBlue · 10/07/2022 00:04

So many posts on here scoffing at the op being a 'townie' and having no understanding and insisting that of course anyone local would be fine with the images.

Bollocks.

I live fairly rurally. I'm well used to seeing dead animals (mainly singular) in the lanes and have put a few that were clearly beyond help out of their misery in my time. I'm not particularly squeamish or sensitive.

I have to chase sheep out of my front garden regularly and I live within sight of a working farm...so definitely wouldn't come under the 'townie' bracket.

I've still never seen a pile of dead lambs with innards spilling out in RL or online and I think I'd probably find it a bit much. I can imagine some people would be incredibly upset to be faced, with no warning, with such graphic images when scrolling Facebook.

It's awful for the farmer but 20 graphic images is not necessary.

The repeated posts on here suggesting that all rural dwellers are so frequently faced with dead animals that they're 'used' to this are ludicrous and I suspect are mainly troll types only trying to poke at the op.

People are people. Living rurally doesn't mean you're immune to being upset by horrific images of dead animals 🙄
And whilst I feel for the farmer, fb has community standards - not very well Enforced but still - that these images probably breached.

SirVixofVixHall · 09/07/2022 23:58

alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:39

@RunningFromInsanity I think this is my biggest issue with it, what difference would these images make, no one is going to say 'oh yeah shit it was me and Fido, soz'

And on the flip side, who would see anything in the middle of a 10 acre farm past midnight.

As I said I have huge doubts it was a dog at all, as who would be walking a dog that late and not stop it after one or two dead sheep, how can one dog do so much damage, and there are careless owners but letting your dog rip apart 40 animals over what must have been a longish period is on another level. Surely Confused

Dogs can and do kill sheep like this. It really is not uncommon, sometimes there may be two dogs together that have got loose and into a field. There really isn’t much else that will cause this sort of damage to a field of sheep, beside a dog.
I mean, possibly a particularly disturbed human but a dog is far and away the likely culprit, we get attacks like this happening locally all too frequently.

I imagine the farmer is hoping that someone might have an idea whose dog it was and be shocked enough by the images to tell.

TrainspottingWelsh · 09/07/2022 23:54

@gezelligheid but that’s the result of it happening. The farmer had to see it.

Every time some scum member of the public has made one of my horses ill, or caused an injury, I’m really tempted to laminate graphic images and stick them on the fence next to the do not feed signs. I very nearly did the morning after my then young dc had to watch their pony rolling round the floor in agony and I had to leave them sobbing because I was trying to stop the pony breaking limbs before the vet got there. Kind of fits with one of my early memories too, mutilated livestock is far more distressing in reality.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 09/07/2022 23:53

coffeecupsandfairylights · 09/07/2022 23:47

@LivingLifeOnTheVeg yes, but my point is that nobody else is going to know unless they're also local to OP and recognise the details.

Dog attacks on sheep happen all the time - people are just responding with their experiences.

If OP thinks the situation is weird or dodgy then she should give more information to support her case 🤷🏻‍♀️

When farmers have guns, there’s no harm in being careful what you say, even on here. 😉

Swipe left for the next trending thread