Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I being overly sensitive? *TW animal death

213 replies

alphapie · 09/07/2022 21:29

So I live in a small Villiage, as a previous city dweller some of the downsides of living in the countryside have taken a while to get used to, such as cows waking us up at 5am, free roaming peacocks destroying our cars paint on the roof and general manure smells every now and again. But after 4 years we are getting there.

Last night a local farmer had 40 lambs killed, he thinks it was a dog attack, instead of just putting a normal post about it on the local FB group (like he and other farmers have before) his son instead decided to share 20 graphic photos of the dead lambs along with the post asking for information or if anyone saw anything.

Now I was pretty upset to be scrolling through FB and to then see images of lambs ripped apart, insides everywhere, pilled on top of each other and commented this on the post. Reminding him that there are teens and young people in the group and it's maybe not the best thing to put on here, to be fair I'd expect many people, adults included would feel upset seeing these images on their FB feed.

I was jumped on by the farmer, other farmers in the village, the 'we've been here for 30 years, go back to the local city if you don't like it' lot and even accused of being the attacker, despite not owning a bloody dog.

I personally also think 40 lambs in one go is unlikely to be a dog attack, but didn't comment that of course.

Was I being unreasonable or overly sensitive to find this shocking and to maybe suggest it's a bit too much to post in a FB group where local children often post looking for summer work or weekend car washing for pocket money? Am I turning into one of those 'think of the children' people!

OP posts:
alphapie · 10/07/2022 16:55

FrangipaniBlue · 10/07/2022 16:37

*The villiage is small and mostly old people, so I just highly doubt someone is off in the fields with a dog past midnight tbh.

It doesn't make much sense, why walk a dog in the pitch dark with no lighting in the middle of a 10 acre field. The part of the field they're kept in after giving birth is quite far from the road too. So the dogs would have to be off lead and ran pretty far*

You live in the countryside and genuinely have no idea who could be out in the dark with rogue dogs nor why they were there?

@coffeecupsandfairylights has given you the answer at 9:37 this morning....

My issue is are images necessary, most know it's not ideal to let dogs lose in fields, there are posts upon posts about it, police notices, signs, yet some twats still do.

By your own admission, none of that has worked!

But this won't work either, that's the point

The only people with lose dogs round here are the farmers anyway, it's a bit of a moot point.

OP posts:
FrangipaniBlue · 10/07/2022 16:37

*The villiage is small and mostly old people, so I just highly doubt someone is off in the fields with a dog past midnight tbh.

It doesn't make much sense, why walk a dog in the pitch dark with no lighting in the middle of a 10 acre field. The part of the field they're kept in after giving birth is quite far from the road too. So the dogs would have to be off lead and ran pretty far*

You live in the countryside and genuinely have no idea who could be out in the dark with rogue dogs nor why they were there?

@coffeecupsandfairylights has given you the answer at 9:37 this morning....

My issue is are images necessary, most know it's not ideal to let dogs lose in fields, there are posts upon posts about it, police notices, signs, yet some twats still do.

By your own admission, none of that has worked!

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 16:13

And you don’t have to be ‘educated’ by us. We politely ask if you have a few minutes to talk to us. If you haven’t or don’t want to, that’s ok. We’re just people that love animals and want to raise awareness of what we believe. We know not everyone will agree, that’s ok too.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 16:04

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 15:50

Yep, particularly when vegans are judging from video footage, sometimes decades out of date or not from the UK (and, sometimes, appalling recent footage from the UK, to be entirely fair). I've been in abattoirs, I've seen animals slaughtered, in the UK, first hand. I don't need to be educated by someone who's watched a video on youtube 😂

My family are farmers and I’ve seen the slaughter first hand too. The ‘good’ and the bad. Just because you have seen the ‘good’ doesn’t mean it’s all like that.

The footage we use when campaigning is always from here and we use as up to date as we have, it’s never older than a few years. Footage from abroad does matter though as not everyone eats British. There’s plenty of people working undercover on farms and slaughterhouses filming daily and some real workers that have been whistleblowers either because they’ve been disgusted or for cash. Unfortunately not all workers adhere to the rules and animals do suffer more than what the rules say they should.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 15:50

Scianel · 10/07/2022 15:00

I find it so patronising when vegans think if we just "saw the reality" of an abattoir we'd all stop eating meat.

Just got a happy text from my SIL, she's been given a large bag of mutton by her boss who slaughtered this weekend.
That's how I grew up, seeing home slaughtering. It hasn't put me off eating meat and its nothing like an animal getting killed in a dog attack.

Yep, particularly when vegans are judging from video footage, sometimes decades out of date or not from the UK (and, sometimes, appalling recent footage from the UK, to be entirely fair). I've been in abattoirs, I've seen animals slaughtered, in the UK, first hand. I don't need to be educated by someone who's watched a video on youtube 😂

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 15:47

There is no right or wrong as to whether OP is overly sensitive, people will be different. It’s opinion, not fact to say OP is or isn’t too sensitive. But the conversation moves on from the original question. And peoples opinions may differ if they for example knew that it wasn’t a dog attack, or that it was lampers gone wrong or the lambs were killed by something else or the lambs were killed by the farmers own dogs or many other possibilities.

I didn't say there was an absolute right or wrong - although in my opinion there is a very clear answer. But since I never claimed it to be fact, I'm not sure why you're pointing out the obvious there.

I also never claimed that the debate shouldn't move on - although as you and the OP are the only ones who claim to know the specifics of this situation, it's not a conversation - it's just you speculating by yourself. Your speculations on the rights and wrongs of what happened to the sheep don't undermine other posters' views on how sensitive and unempathetic the OP is being.

I have no idea why you think the provenance of the dogs would affect the opinions of posters about how sensitive the OP is - the two concepts are completely independent.

But since we're clearly not going to agree on this one - do please feel free to carry on by yourself.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 15:40

Zigzagzoozoo · 10/07/2022 15:32

If there were 40 lambs killed, the only thing it could possibly be is a dog attack.

I’m a farmer and I have done exactly the same and shared images on my local Facebook groups of 5 of my lambs that were killed in a dog attack last year. I did that because I wanted the images to stick in the dog owner’s mind. The dog that attacked my sheep habitually roamed the local village and the owner just thought it made them a bit quirky. The only was to get the message across, short of dumping the lambs on her driveway, was to show her just how brutal and distressing a dog attack on sheep actually is. The dog has never been allowed out since.

I’m sorry for the poor lambs. You’ve been ‘lucky’ that the dog owner has changed though. The bad owners here won’t be told, even the threat of their dog being shot hasn’t stopped them. A mix of naivety and arrogance from both born and bred country folk and newer people moving in. My dogs are too precious to me to risk and I love all animals, I’d be devastated if they hurt sheep so they don’t get to go off lead on walks. Good recall isn’t so good for many dogs if they see sheep.

Zigzagzoozoo · 10/07/2022 15:32

If there were 40 lambs killed, the only thing it could possibly be is a dog attack.

I’m a farmer and I have done exactly the same and shared images on my local Facebook groups of 5 of my lambs that were killed in a dog attack last year. I did that because I wanted the images to stick in the dog owner’s mind. The dog that attacked my sheep habitually roamed the local village and the owner just thought it made them a bit quirky. The only was to get the message across, short of dumping the lambs on her driveway, was to show her just how brutal and distressing a dog attack on sheep actually is. The dog has never been allowed out since.

Saucery · 10/07/2022 15:18

didn’t blame him

Saucery · 10/07/2022 15:17

A farmer near us put a dead ram by the footpath for a couple of days. It had been killed by a dog. With a big hand painted sign saying “A dog did this. KEEP YOUR DOGS ON LEADS”.
I did blame him one bit. Some dog owners are absolute twats. DH had to speak to a woman who was letting her collie chase sheep on the moors the other day. She told him and another woman who challenged her to fuck off. There really is no reasoning with some people and the reality of dog attacks needs to be seen. Irl or on social media.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 15:13

I find it so patronising when vegans think if we just "saw the reality" of an abattoir we'd all stop eating meat.

For some people, that’s what happens, awareness changes their views. For others, they’re ok with it. Most aren’t ok with the practices agreed not bring adhered to, which certainly happens. Plenty of people choose not to view footage. My son is one of them, he doesn’t want to view it because he says he knows he wouldn’t eat meat again and he wants to, which of course is his choice. There’s also a lack of knowledge of how animals are killed. A huge number of people are unaware of how animals are actually slaughtered. When we do campaigning, a lot of people don’t even consider the slaughterhouse, they think they’re shot by a farmer or even injected, like putting your dog to sleep. We get new people support us all the time because they simply become aware of reality, so it may not apply to you and your SIL, it does to others.

Theluggage15 · 10/07/2022 15:12

You seem completely unaware of how devastating dog attacks can be, it doesn’t take long for a large dog to absolutely devastate a flock. You sound like you’re not cut out for living in the country if the first thing you do one seeing an upset farmer post on Facebook is moan about how the photos make you feel.

manlyago · 10/07/2022 15:04

I think it’s a shame you commented on the
post. I think that was misjudged. Maybe think
about how the farmer must be feeling? You’ve now soured neighbourly relations and people think you’re a knob. If it were me I would message the farmer and apologise. Telling
people off on Facebook never ends well.

I get what you’re saying about the images but really what were you hoping to achieve? Maybe country life isn’t for you?

Scianel · 10/07/2022 15:00

I find it so patronising when vegans think if we just "saw the reality" of an abattoir we'd all stop eating meat.

Just got a happy text from my SIL, she's been given a large bag of mutton by her boss who slaughtered this weekend.
That's how I grew up, seeing home slaughtering. It hasn't put me off eating meat and its nothing like an animal getting killed in a dog attack.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 14:59

nocoolnamesleft · 10/07/2022 14:27

It's meant to be shocking. It's trying to shock ignorant townies into controlling their dogs.

And townies is being used as a derogatory term. I’ve lived in the countryside, then city, now I have homes in both. There are plenty of country folk that do not control their dogs. There are plenty of psycho farmers who threaten any owners of any dog.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 14:56

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 14:13

My other responses are not irrelevant if you are aware of this farm. If you don’t want them to be relevant to you, feel free to ignore them. They are however related to this case.

I'll say it again - your opinions on this farm are not relevant to whether the OP is being over-sensitive or not. I've not told you not to share your opinions - I really couldn't care less, but I did respond to a post of yours which implied that people's opinions would differ if they knew what you claim to know about this farm.

There is no right or wrong as to whether OP is overly sensitive, people will be different. It’s opinion, not fact to say OP is or isn’t too sensitive. But the conversation moves on from the original question. And peoples opinions may differ if they for example knew that it wasn’t a dog attack, or that it was lampers gone wrong or the lambs were killed by something else or the lambs were killed by the farmers own dogs or many other possibilities.

nocoolnamesleft · 10/07/2022 14:27

It's meant to be shocking. It's trying to shock ignorant townies into controlling their dogs.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 14:13

My other responses are not irrelevant if you are aware of this farm. If you don’t want them to be relevant to you, feel free to ignore them. They are however related to this case.

I'll say it again - your opinions on this farm are not relevant to whether the OP is being over-sensitive or not. I've not told you not to share your opinions - I really couldn't care less, but I did respond to a post of yours which implied that people's opinions would differ if they knew what you claim to know about this farm.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 13:48

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 13:11

Actually, it's still you struggling with the basics: facebook are not the arbiters of moral conduct. Nobody is stopping you making unrelated points, but they remain simply irrelevant to the responses given to the original question of the OP.

OP asked if she being overly sensitive to find it shocking. That’s a matter of opinion. She also asked was she unreasonable to suggest it’s a bit too much for Facebook. Again, individuals would have different opinions. But it’s now been taken down so presumably whoever did that thought it shouldn’t be allowed. She’s allowed to report it or bring whatever she wants to the farmers attention. it’s not unreasonable. It wouldn’t bother me, it does bother others. My other responses are not irrelevant if you are aware of this farm. If you don’t want them to be relevant to you, feel free to ignore them. They are however related to this case.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 10/07/2022 13:11

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 10/07/2022 08:38

I’ve already said the images themselves don’t bother me but discussion moves on and we’re allowed to make other points. That’s what happens on forums so it seems that you are the one struggling with the basics here. But he was actually unreasonable to post them it seems as that sort of thing isn’t allowed on Facebook. Facebook agree as they removed the images.

Actually, it's still you struggling with the basics: facebook are not the arbiters of moral conduct. Nobody is stopping you making unrelated points, but they remain simply irrelevant to the responses given to the original question of the OP.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 10/07/2022 12:38

alphapie · 09/07/2022 22:17

Well clearly it is deemed inappropriate to post those images on FB, since it's broke the rules.

As expected no one has come forwards, the police have no leads and nothing will have been gained from this FB post

It might have, you can't possibly know who has read it and taken something in from it. Given you started your post along the lines of being an outsider and learning to fit in and not knowing everything your posts are arrogant as fuck, but as long as you aren't upset any more all is well I guess.

LifeInTheLakes · 10/07/2022 12:37

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/07/2022 12:02

For the sheep themselves, yes. But for the farmers (who as has already been mentioned, have an extremely high rate of ending their own lives), one of the worst things can be people refusing to acknowledge the enormity of what has happened to the animals because 'Oh, no, it's distressing, I don't want to see it, why are you confronting people with the true reality of what loose dogs do?'. Or saying 'what's your problem? They'd be in an abattoir in six months anyhow'.

Show people what dogs do if they’re not on leads, absolutely. Its reality.

But lets show them the other true realities of farming and slaughterhouses. I’m all for it. I think there would be far more vegans or at vastly improved methods. The reality of our ‘food’ is hidden behind words like free range, rspca approved, red tractor and ethical. Bring it on I say, show everyone what this actually means. Unfortunately, the realities are often only seen in undercover footage which often gets taken down if posted. People are threatened both with formal legal action and trouble/violent acts. And the farming propaganda is allowed but the vegan society can’t get their adverts approved. Tell people the real truth about all of it, because if they’re horrified by a few dead lambs, they wouldn’t cope at all with the things really happening on U.K. farms and slaughterhouses. For every farmer and slaughterhouses that does things right (not that it’s good enough imo) there’s plenty that don’t.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/07/2022 12:28

Fucks sake.

A farmer has seen his livestock shredded and you are complaining that your sensibilities have been offended.

That's why this shit happens. See the reality of dog attacks on sheep and oh, woe is me, horrible farmer assaulting my senses like that. Tough. Instead of bemoaning the insensitivity of making you see the carnage join with the farmer and be vigilant for off lead dogs.

picklemewalnuts · 10/07/2022 12:26

YABVVU.

The farmer has to deal with it face to face, not just photos.

If he'd posted 'my sheep were worried last night', you'd never have imagined what you saw today.

Someone now knows their dog didn't just run down a rabbit when out last night, but tore apart a flock of sheep.

Someone now knows their neighbour's dog that sometimes slips out at bedtime is actually doing serious damage.

He gets to post.
You should be horrified by what happened, not grumbling about having to see it.
The reality of rural living is 'sometimes smelly, annoying, distressing things happen'.

Soubriquet · 10/07/2022 12:17

Just to add, if it was the dead of night, could it possibly have been hare coursers, and the dogs found the lambs instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread