Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cloth nappies are hard work

58 replies

Mummyof287 · 09/07/2022 21:03

So I'm privileged to be benefiting from a months free cloth nappy trial from a local organisation.
It's only day one, so early days and would like to give them a good go.

All started well this morning, the nice lady dropped them off, then i spent awhile getting to grips with them and watched the video about how to use them.
Felt the pocket ones would be preferable, so popped one on DD and was pleasantly surprised by how much comfier they looked than disposables, and loved the colourful designs too.

Went out to the shops though, and part way through took 8mo baby out of her carseat to find that poo had leaked all out the top at the front and was all over her dress, in her tummy button etc (which i get can happen with diposables at times also) but the nappy itself was absolutely covered too (the thin disposable liner I had put in was all crumpled up inside the pooey nappy!)

I spent some time with her on the grass area in the retail park carpark trying to sort it all out, and now am panicking I won't be able to remove the poo stains from the blooming nappy (it's currently in a cold water soak in an old bowl ready to go in the washing machine....obviously don't want to use chemicals on it.

I thought I had fitted it right, and that the liners would catch most of the poo so it didn't end up in the washing machine, but maybe I used them wrong? I also thought that the padded removable parts would just need to be washed after being weed on, meaning I wouldn't have to wash the whole nappy, but doesn't seem to be the case? If so it would never be affordable for me as I'd get through loads before wash day.She has only just started eating a fair bit of solid food, and is still breastfed alot, so her poos aren't particularly well formed yet.

Am I missing something/not using them correctly, or are they actually rather a faff and that's the price to pay for a healthier, environmentally friendly product?

OP posts:
PlanBea · 09/07/2022 22:41

We used disposables in the hospital and then it's been cloth ever since then and DS I is 14 months, though the nursery use disposables. We're having a bit of a time as he gets nappy rash from the disposables, and by the time we've got it sorted it's time for him to go back to nursery. Though we've never had a poonami yet!

Not every brand suits every baby, some are better for babies with longer bodies or chunkier legs etc. We use TotsBots mostly as they're easy to get a good fit on, and we can reuse the wraps when we swap the pad out. They're having a sale at the moment too so if you don't mind what designs you get you can get stocked up for a good price.

LifeInsideMyhead · 09/07/2022 22:38

I moved in quite crunchy circles as lean that way myself usually - so many of the "potty trained at x months" kids still had "accidents" more days than not... it just became easier to change joggers and pants occasionally than nappies. Often put on the potty every hour too!

Mwnci123 · 09/07/2022 22:38

I found them ok once I got in to a laundry routine and got to know which nappies I liked. I found the pocket nappies much more likely to leak than the two part ones, which could hold more or less anything. It sounds like those would be a better choice for you as you can get away with not changing the waterproof bit every time.

Don't worry about staining. I am rubbish at laundry but the nappies always seemed to come out looking ok.

UndertheCedartree · 09/07/2022 22:31

They're a bit more work but you get into the swing of it. I felt really gullible that I'd been sucked into using disposable nappies - such a waste of money if nothing else!

Avarua1 · 09/07/2022 22:29

Yes my kids potty trained WAY earlier than their peers. DD was 15 months.

Avarua1 · 09/07/2022 22:28

It depends on the nappies you use. Old inserts will have lost their absorption and some designs are much better than others. Sometimes user error wrecks absorbancy (eg using too harsh chemicals for soaking or soaking too long).

I would buy new or a set that you are certain have been used on one Baby only.

My bet is that the trial ones have been stuffed by over-use and bad washing technique.

I used one new set of 18 nappies for three kids. But they were at the end of their usefulness by the time DS was potty trained, that's for sure!

Rocketpants50 · 09/07/2022 22:27

They are harder, we used in the day but not at night just because we had lots of leaks and a bad sleeper. Once we got I to swing of it, it got easier.

My brother and I were vert close in age, my mum had has both in Terry toweling nappies with the high pins - this was before disposables were invented. She kept all our nappies separate to avoid cross contamination, she has absolutely no idea why. But just thinking of all those nappy buckets and separate washing makes me realise how much easier everything is now.

Don't give up, maybe a bit of both. Think everytime you don't use one that's 1 less 1 in the landfill.

millymae · 09/07/2022 22:25

I would say you are not being unreasonable but my mum would say you are as she used terry nappies for all of us and is adamant that it caused her no problems. That said she didn’t have much to compare them with as disposable nappies weren’t as readily available as they are now.
When I was a baby reuseable nappies were a square of terry towelling that you folded with a liner inside, fastened with a nappy pin and wore with plastic pants over.
Mum kept two buckets in the bathroom one for wet nappies and one for dirty and they were all soaked in a solution of Napisan then rinsed in the washing machine the next day. She is adamant that she never used washing powder of any description and that she only ever used the rinse programme.
The nappies were hung on the washing line whatever the weather and mostly ended up stain free. All this seems very unhygienic to me but we apparently never had nappy rash and none of the family suffered with tummy upsets.
I did vaguely consider reuseable nappies when I had my last baby but that’s as far as it went. The initial outlay and extra washing put me off
Derekthehampsters point about potty training is an interesting one - mum is firmly of the view that babies were out of nappies far earlier when I was little than they are nowadays

orbitalcrisis · 09/07/2022 22:21

I used the old fashioned Terry toweling nappies for all three of my babies 15-20 years ago. I don't see what all the fuss is about!

MuddlingMackem · 09/07/2022 22:18

YABU to write them off after one poonami.

We used terries and plastic pants for eldest, but youngest was slimmer and pocket nappies stuffed with the terries worked better for her. We also had the pocket nappy inserts, Bummis wraps and even a couple of wool soakers. Oh, and for both of them we used cheap flannels as boosters to catch the wee and distribute it to the nappy.

The great thing about pocket nappies rather than all in ones is the way you can add layers to increase absorbency as the baby gets older, or for overnight. They are so versatile.

I second dry pailing. We had two nappy buckets as once they were both full it was a full washer load. I also always did a quick cold rinse in the washer before a 60 degree wash. Line dried when weather permitted, radiator airers when it didn't. And the pocket nappies themselves were so quick to dry hung over the shower rail.

RosesAndHellebores · 09/07/2022 22:18

I thought they were a marvellous idea but they didn't come with a free aya.

Mythril · 09/07/2022 22:10

They are more work, but you do send so much less to landfill.

I would say it doesn't have to be all or nothing - we would use disposables when going out all day, or when staying at someone else's house, or when really behind on laundry.

The nappies themselves do take getting used to. You'll get a feel for how to put them on.

CucumberCool · 09/07/2022 22:07

I have been having the same dilemma OP!

My little is 4 mo and I have been lent a load from a friend who will be needing them back soon and I'm deciding whether to invest in some myself.

For me, my two minds look like:

Pros : environment
Financial (although expensive initially)
Supposed easier to potty train after

Cons: bulky, like cardboard (not sure if all like this or because they are third (?) hand)
Get throigh many more in a day
Not absorbent
More washes
More to lug about when out (inc pooy ones n cloth wipes)
Makes her very sore when she hasn't been before
Would need a wet bag also

I have only used for the odd day when I'm not going out. I'm too worried to use them out!

Which are the best brands?

prescribingmum · 09/07/2022 22:04

Definitely a learning curve to see what works for you but I did 3 consecutive years of cloth nappies for 2 children (with overlap where both were in cloth) and not a single poo leak from either. Rare time we used disposables, poo always went up the back

nomeslice · 09/07/2022 22:00

I'm on my 2nd baby using cloth. I much, much prefer cloth.
Disposables are more convenient to some extent but I really resented buying them over and over and over again. I would rather put a wash on than lug out a bag of rubbish filled with pooey nappies any day. My first baby was toilet trained by 2.
www.cleanclothnappies.com has loads of very good information.on cloth and washing properly. There are lots of different styles of nappies and it takes some trial and error to figure out what works best for you and baby. Also a dehumidifier is a game changer with getting stuff dry.

LifeInsideMyhead · 09/07/2022 21:58

We did 4-6 weeks and realised how amazing disposables were....

I SO wanted to stick with them for environmental reasons but it really was too much work for us. Also I saw the worst nappy rash in several nappy evangelists who wouldnt even use disposables until it cleared up because it becomes very tribal/part of identity. You really do have to be on it with every wee with real nappies.

Hankunamatata · 09/07/2022 21:57

Pocket nappies you need to wash whole thing as they are all in one. So need enough nappies for whole day until you wash and some brands you can't tumble dry.

Two part which is cloth nappy with waterproof cover - you only usually need one cover a day as only the cloth gets dirty. I preffered as I could wash and tumble the cloth part and just dry the covers on on airer. I used mother ease one size meos with airflow covers. Even better if you can get used as they are more absorbent.

elepants · 09/07/2022 21:55

Well done for trying them out! It's worth sticking with them a little longer before deciding, most people I know (us included) really love them once you get the hang of it but it is a learning curve and not for everyone.

Don't worry about staining. In 18 months of cloth nappies I've never had a stain that wouldn't shift. If it doesn't come out in the wash, hang the nappy to dry outside in the sun and the stain will vanish, I promise.

I'm not sure what washing instructions you've been given, if any. People's approaches seem to vary massively. If you check out Clean Cloth Nappies on Facebook, their advice is pretty much the gold standard of nappy washing. Even if you don't follow all of it, it's a good crash course in laundry science.

Pocket nappies do need washing after every use. The advantage is that the inner can be hung to dry separately and the whole lot dries a lot faster than an all-in-one. So in that sense it's cheaper as you'll need fewer to see you between washes. If you want a more affordable system, terries and wraps are the way to go. The wraps can be reused between changes and terries dry fast.

If you decide it's not for you, there's no shame at all. Parenting is hard enough without adding to the load. But there's loads to love about cloth nappies so do consider giving it another couple of days if you fancy it. Good luck!

Hankunamatata · 09/07/2022 21:49

Disposable liners are rubbish. I found fleece blanket cut up to shape of the nappy was better liner (I used VITMOSSA throw from ikea).

Then with fleece liner you can flick off any solid then either wrap up or at home I rinsed it off in toilet with jug water then chucked it in nappy bucket next to toilet.

I used an old 2 part system with cloth nappy with snaps then mother ease airflow cover. Those covers could contain 99% of explosions.

Hanging nappies in sun reduces staining.

goldopals · 09/07/2022 21:48

Once you get used to them, it’s so much better. I would suggest joining clean cloth nappies on Facebook for advice

Simonjt · 09/07/2022 21:46

We stuck them out for four weeks, a nightmare the entire time, so pleased we got rid of them, no more carrying poo covered nappies in the nappy bag.

ThettaReddast · 09/07/2022 21:45

Persevere, they can take a little while to get used to but I found them great and really not a big faff compared to when I used disposables with my first.
The fluffy washable liners I found to be so much better than the ‘disposable’ ones. Once their pop is solid it’s easy to tip down the loo, but before then just hold in the loo and a flush tends to sort it. Also worth following a few nappy on Facebook etc for tips.

Fulbe · 09/07/2022 21:40

Oh and don't soak them, that's bad for the nappies. You can 'dry pail' which is just putting them in a bucket/bin without water and rinse within a day or 2. We used a mesh bag in a small ikea bin, so you can pick them up and dump them all in the washing machine at once.

Fulbe · 09/07/2022 21:37

oh and get a dehumidifier, some use it in combination with a heated drying rack. And don't be intimidated by photos people post of beautifully arranged nappy areas!

Fulbe · 09/07/2022 21:35

In some ways, but if you use disposables you throw an average of 4500 in landfill which is pretty horrendous. Also, as a PP said, they potty train earlier - I think our girl was ready at 18 months. In my experience (and this is well known in the cloth nappy world) poo explosions are MUCH rarer in cloth. Maybe it wasn't fitting right or you were just unlucky. with all the poo explosions you get in disposables you have a fair amount of extra washing anyway!

My advice is - for washing instructions, the Nappy Lady blog gives clear and simple instructions. Use paper liners (we used bambinex) if you don't want to deal with poo. Yes drying in sunshine does work to bleach them again. We rinsed with sanitiser before washing in with all our other clothes/bibs etc. Boosters are your friend (we didn't change after EVERY wee, only every few hours or when it was noticeably wet).

Next time I'm going to try muslins/ terry nappies. Last time we loved our Motherease.

It gets easier with time, as you get more used to it and the baby gets older too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread