Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cloth nappies are hard work

58 replies

Mummyof287 · 09/07/2022 21:03

So I'm privileged to be benefiting from a months free cloth nappy trial from a local organisation.
It's only day one, so early days and would like to give them a good go.

All started well this morning, the nice lady dropped them off, then i spent awhile getting to grips with them and watched the video about how to use them.
Felt the pocket ones would be preferable, so popped one on DD and was pleasantly surprised by how much comfier they looked than disposables, and loved the colourful designs too.

Went out to the shops though, and part way through took 8mo baby out of her carseat to find that poo had leaked all out the top at the front and was all over her dress, in her tummy button etc (which i get can happen with diposables at times also) but the nappy itself was absolutely covered too (the thin disposable liner I had put in was all crumpled up inside the pooey nappy!)

I spent some time with her on the grass area in the retail park carpark trying to sort it all out, and now am panicking I won't be able to remove the poo stains from the blooming nappy (it's currently in a cold water soak in an old bowl ready to go in the washing machine....obviously don't want to use chemicals on it.

I thought I had fitted it right, and that the liners would catch most of the poo so it didn't end up in the washing machine, but maybe I used them wrong? I also thought that the padded removable parts would just need to be washed after being weed on, meaning I wouldn't have to wash the whole nappy, but doesn't seem to be the case? If so it would never be affordable for me as I'd get through loads before wash day.She has only just started eating a fair bit of solid food, and is still breastfed alot, so her poos aren't particularly well formed yet.

Am I missing something/not using them correctly, or are they actually rather a faff and that's the price to pay for a healthier, environmentally friendly product?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BudgetTarzan · 10/07/2022 08:57

Used cloth for all 4 of mine - had 3 in them at one time! Once you find the ones that work for you and you're in a routine it's easy. Pockets were not for me. Bright coloured popper (not velcro) wraps, mother ease popper (again no velcro) with paper inserts. Dry nappy pail with mesh insert in the house and waterproof bag for out and about. Line drying whenever possible or on a clothes horse in the window to bleach.

The only thing I regret is the cloth baby wipes as they broke two washing machines. One by getting stuck on the element - no idea how it got there - and the other was constantly getting them in the drain despite the use of mesh bags, it was a monthly session of tipping the damn thing up and playing search for the lost wipe.

miltonj · 10/07/2022 08:47

Yeah it took me a while to get into the grove but now I don't even think about it. Using pad folds and wraps with DD but just bought a load of Terry's for DD due soon so we'll see how we get used to that.

Ionacat · 10/07/2022 08:28

We didn’t find them much faff, flick poo off into bucket with mesh bag and then into the machine. Very few leaks compared to disposables. We tended to use disposables on holiday though. (And that was the worst poonami ever!)

However some of the cloth nappy groups can be a bit cult like and the competition over certain prints - they were going for ridiculous prices a few years ago. Ignore all of that and any that you use are going to be better than a disposable sitting in landfill, it doesn’t have to be all or nothing. Once you’ve worked out the ones that suit you then you can get some second hand or new.

Strip washing can help with the cardboard feel - you need to get rid of all traces of detergent. And even in November putting them on a window sill on a sunny day can help get rid of the stains.

You can get nappy rash with disposables as well as cloth.

Fluffyowl00 · 10/07/2022 07:58

i recommend the flushing dirty nappies in the toilet and then dry pailing method (wet ones go in wet bag, turn it out in the washer). I thought the soaking would be a real faff, didn’t realise that’s not necessary.

Then I just do one short cold wash to rinse out the baddies and a long 50 or 60 wash, sometimes with an extra rinse, every 3 days. When you’re doing so much washing anyway it’s not much more and they are just SO cute

Dogtooth · 10/07/2022 02:03

They're definitely more with than disposable, but it's ok once you have a system.

They leak less once you've worked out the fitting. You never run out (definitely a bonus when nappies were scarce in crazy 2020 times). You don't have a bin full of stinking plastic.

It takes a while to get into your stride with them. I agree that fleece liners are better than disposable ones. You should be able to just hold liner in the loo and blast poo off with the flush. There's a knack to it! We used to dry pail and do a nappy wash maybe twice a week. No soaking. Fleece liner prevented poo stains and drying in the sun helped too.

People get a bit weird about them, as if there weren't plenty of other sources of plastic waste to worry about. But it's easy enough once you get going.

Somuchgoo · 10/07/2022 01:49

I tried them in a nappy trial. Hated then with an absolute passion. I'd rather hug Boris Johnson with Covid than try then again if I have another child.

I use reusable swimming nappies, but that's as far as I'll go. They aren't for everyone.

JaceLancs · 10/07/2022 01:42

It’s 30 years plus since I had DC in nappies but disposables were too expensive
I thought cloth was more eco friendly too
it was best to get into a routine and then wasn’t a huge issue

Twillow · 10/07/2022 00:45

Don't give up, they are fantastic. You will soon find out what works and get in a routine. I never looked back. The bamboozles were my favourite, it was a while ago though -soft, lovely creamy colour, always came up spotless. With Motherease covers. (That way you get two lines of defense against poonamis, compared to the all in ones, and they dry quicker.)

Boysgrownbutstillathome · 10/07/2022 00:02

When my first child was born we used a local nappy service who would provide the nappies, liners and covers, a bin and bin-liners. They would collect the dirty nappies and get them industrially laundered. They were mostly very good but tended to leak after poonami's. By the time my second son was born the company had stopped collecting and laundering the dirty nappies and I didn't want the costs of 90 degree hot washes, so used disposables!

solarbirdscalm · 09/07/2022 23:33

My experience was rubbish to start with as I was given damaged nappies by the local nappy library. Reusables did not work for me for DS1. He was huge and just an odd shape. DS2 they worked great, I used them for daytime, but could not get any to suit for overnight, so used one disposable a day.

Lucinda7 · 09/07/2022 23:32

I used Terry nappies back in the 80's. I used a papery liner. Wet liners went in the bin, soiled ones went down the toilet. Nappies put in a lidded bucket and soaked in Napisan as mentioned by PP. Then rinsed and washed in washing machine with normal detergent. Dried in front of gas fire when necessary! Outside when possible. Used for both DC.

Barrawarra · 09/07/2022 23:22

I couldn’t get the hang of them, so many leaks for me, especially at night which was disrupting sleep even more than it already was. I so wanted it to work but tried at a time when baby life was overwhelming in so many ways, I couldn’t take additional stress that was unnecessary. Still got them all in a box in the attic to try again 3rd time round. Worth persevering I think but I have to agree faff from my experience.

PickAChew · 09/07/2022 23:21

I never get how people get stains out in the sunshine between, oooh, October and March.

And I say this as the mother of an incontinent young man whose clothes and bedding do not smell great for 8 months of the year and the odd week in between. Maybe it's because I live further north.

Imknackeredzzz · 09/07/2022 23:16

sorry but just not worth the faff

AliceW89 · 09/07/2022 23:09

They are a bit more hard work, but so worth it. I hate thinking about DS wearing a disposable nappy for a couple of hours, that will then hang around earth likely longer than he does. DH and I both work long hours and we manage washing them fine. You fall into a routine, it takes a bit of time but washing them and hanging them out just become part of your day. Poo explosions are rare due to the tightness from the elastics - you likely just need a bit more practice fitting them. Pee leaks are more likely than disposables as they do need changing more often. The odd time DS has been in a disposable they have held pee longer. Second the recommendation of clean cloth nappies for washing advice. Good luck!

KarmaStar · 09/07/2022 23:02

Practice op,it is hard work but really worth it and you will save so much money.If you can afford to do so,work out the saved money each week on not buying disposable ones and watch it grow,you'll be pleased how fast it grows.
So much better for the environment too.
good luck.🌈😀

bakewellbride · 09/07/2022 22:59

I love cloth nappies and haven't had any issues or problems. I've used them for nearly 2 years.

DockOTheBay · 09/07/2022 22:59

It sounds like the fit wasnt correct as they very very rarely leak when fitted properly - maybe ask the library to check them or there are many dedicated Facebook groups.

I loved using cloth for my second and didn't find them hard work, and they don't smell of chemicals like the disposables. But it's not for everyone and that's OK.

ChagSameachDoreen · 09/07/2022 22:54

Not worth the faff.

MassiveSalad22 · 09/07/2022 22:52

I’ve never had that happen OP, bad luck!

How old’s your baby? With all of mine I didn’t bother before 3 months. DD has just gone into them. I’m not bothering with night nappies this time around. It’s not all or nothing - every cloth nappy you use is a disposable saved from landfill. We’ll use disposables, most likely Naty, when we go on holiday.

Different nappies work for different babies too. For example DD is my 3rd baby in cloth, totsbots are really working for her where little lamb pockets and baba and boo (on the large side) worked better for my boys. Also boys wee up/to the front where girls were downwards(/up the back I am finding! Still not used to that!!!) so how you stuff the nappy makes a difference.

Flittingaboutagain · 09/07/2022 22:52

We took our set away on holiday too. Never regretted not using disposables once we started.

Flittingaboutagain · 09/07/2022 22:51

Once I found the brand that best fitted (second ones I tried from eBay bundle) I never had a single leak ever with cloth nappies so personally way less hard work than disposable poonamis! Pocket nappies, dry paling and cheeky wipes all the way here.

Harpydragon · 09/07/2022 22:48

I hated the thought of soiled disposable nappies being in landfill for hundreds of years!.

My DS is 18 now but when he was a baby I used Terry nappies with fleece lingers and mother ease wraps, Dry pailed and washed every couple of days. The fleece liners were a game changer, they wicked all wetness away from his skin and solid just fell off into the loo. Once he went to nursery we used a pocket nappy because it s just like putting a disposable nappy on for the nursery staff, we just used the Terry nappy as the insert. He was out of nappies just after he turned 2.

One thing with cloth nappies is that you have to be a bit more organised. I had enough that I could have half in the wash, half ready to be used. Once they were washed and dried I took 10 minutes to fold them so that they were ready to use, that way I wasn't faffing with them at the point I need to use them. Once he was done, I was able to sell on everything for use by another family.

We weren't evangelical about cloth and used disposable for days out and weekends away, but other than that cloth all the way!

Hardbackwriter · 09/07/2022 22:44

I still feel a bit guilty about giving up on them with DS1 (and never trying for DS2). We did and do use reusable nappy wipes so it wasn't any issue with laundry squeamishness etc, but the nappies didn't work at all for us, with constant, constant leaking. Apparently the ones we had been given for free were the wrong shape for long and skinny DS1 and we should have tried out a few different brands, according to some slightly cult-like Facebook groups I perused, at which point both the potential cost and the hassle felt like something I didn't much want to take on with a small baby.

He toilet-trained at just turned two so I don't think the disposables held him back too much!

Avarua1 · 09/07/2022 22:42

Oh yes, disposable at night and for newborns is a sensible compromise. Still doing a massive favour for the environment.