Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher referred me to a tutor

142 replies

ShepherdMoons · 09/07/2022 18:24

dd has been finding the Maths hard at her school. There are a few of the students in her year group (there are 8 of them - small school) who also are finding the homework and Maths difficult. The school don't seem to be able to offer any extra help so I mentioned that maybe a tutor might be needed. The teacher has agreed and given me the number of her friend who is a tutor. I'm going to speak to the tutor but AIBU to think that maybe the school could have offered a bit of help first? It's a lot more expense for us at a time when we are needing to save a bit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Robinsanpaku · 19/07/2022 12:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

underneathleaf · 13/07/2022 20:50

CecilyP · 13/07/2022 06:56

spanishsummers · Yesterday 22:25
I suspect this is about small schools, which are financially disadvantaged by the way that education finances are set up

They’re not. Where I am, maximum class size for a single year class is 30, for a composite class it’s 24. This child’s class has 21 DC and has a teacher and TA. There are only 2 year groups in the class. So, pretty much the same as in a larger school with uneven numbers.

In England there is no class size limit on composite classes (generally known as mixed year classes). I have taught 30 reception/Y1s/Y2s and 34 Y3/4/5/6. It's not fun and massively harder than teaching a single year group.

CecilyP · 13/07/2022 06:56

spanishsummers · Yesterday 22:25
I suspect this is about small schools, which are financially disadvantaged by the way that education finances are set up

They’re not. Where I am, maximum class size for a single year class is 30, for a composite class it’s 24. This child’s class has 21 DC and has a teacher and TA. There are only 2 year groups in the class. So, pretty much the same as in a larger school with uneven numbers.

Testina · 13/07/2022 06:47

Tickledtrout · 12/07/2022 22:29

Make an appointment to see the head OP. Who is the teacher teaching to, if not one of the eight in a year group? Of course the school should be assuring appropriate differentiation and targeted interventions, if need be

The OP already explained that for maths, the teacher is teacher the 12 Y3s in the same composite class.
Though I don’t disagree with speaking to the head!

Tickledtrout · 12/07/2022 22:29

Make an appointment to see the head OP. Who is the teacher teaching to, if not one of the eight in a year group? Of course the school should be assuring appropriate differentiation and targeted interventions, if need be

spanishsummers · 12/07/2022 22:25

I suspect this is about small schools, which are financially disadvantaged by the way that education finances are set up.

Spud90 · 12/07/2022 15:03

YNBU for thinking the school should be doing more, IMO. I think it's strange that y4 are being taught by a TA. My son's school have maths and english booster sessions after school for children that are struggling. Unfortunately, they were cancelled due to covid when my son was doing them in Y4 so I looked into a tutor but it was too expensive. I bought cgp books and did them with him at home. We used khan's academy and bbc bitesize to help him grasp the methods. He just did his sats and was only a few marks off greater depth, which is great to say how behind he was a couple of years ago.

Musmerian · 11/07/2022 13:02

@Littleraindrop15 £15 is very very low. I don’t do it much these days but charge £50 ph when I do. It’s just not worth it otherwise.

Testina · 11/07/2022 12:51

In this case the mixed class should work in this girl’s favour, as she’s Y4 and has the opportunity to join a Y3 group if really necessary.

Testina · 11/07/2022 12:50

No need to imagine @haggisaggis as several of us thought the same as you and asked.
There are around 12 Y3s taught maths by the teacher and 8 Y4s usually taught by the TA.
OP hasn’t come back to really explain where the issues are though, and what she’s already done about it.
I would say that the qualified teacher should be leading both ages on maths, then swapping them over to the TA to practice - so Y4 learns new topic with teacher whilst TA does consolidation with Y3, or catch up work with Y4.
Given thar OP wrote this as 8 in a class and had to be pushed for detail, I’m not sure how the teaching really is split.

haggisaggis · 11/07/2022 12:22

I would imagine it is a mixed year class, so more than 8 dc in total, just 8 in that year group. That can itself cause difficulties if the teacher has to differentiate work over a wide range of abilities. Both my dc went to very small village primaries. Teachers had to teach between 3 and 4 year groups in one class.

surreygirl1987 · 11/07/2022 12:17

OP, next time be clear with the school about the reasonable things you can expect from them. Dropping hints about tutors clearly doesn’t work. You can’t expect the teacher to do do extra teaching outside of lesson time, but you can expect that your child is taught by a qualified teacher at least some of the time, especially in a core subject like maths

Exactly. The expectation for the teacher to essentially tutor for free is ridiculous BUT I would be concerned about the actual quality of the teaching based on what you have said.

Lovetogarden2022 · 11/07/2022 12:07

Just make sure the teacher isn't getting a kickback for any students she refers 😬 However, £40 an hour seems very very reasonable to me for a highly qualified tutor - just make sure they're genuinely good. My cousin had horrendous experiences with rip off merchants before she found a tutor who's worth her weight in gold

holidayelbow · 11/07/2022 09:27

My son's school had intervention groups in school - they should be doing something.

BanjoVio · 11/07/2022 09:21

A decent rule of thumb: If it’s not ok for everyone to do it, it’s not ok for you to do it. It’s certainly not ok for every parent to expect extra help for their darlings. Teachers are leaving the profession in droves as it is due to being overworked. Some days I don’t have a spare five minutes to eat, never mind tutor kids for free.

Testina · 11/07/2022 09:18

I think it’s ridiculous that there are apparently multiple children literally crying over the homework, and none of the parents have just taught the kids themselves.

It’s Y4!

And yes, some parents have dyscalcluia, etc… but I’m willing to bet that all the parents of all of these crying children don’t form an unusual pocket of such.

It just seems really odd to me to jump from multiple kids unable to do homework, to complaining you’ve been given details of a tutor when you asked if you should get a tutor. Where are the interim steps? The discussions on whether homework is consolidation or extension for example?

CecilyP · 11/07/2022 08:20

thanks, she's struggled with maths in particular for a while. there are 2 groups mixed in together y3 and a y4 and the younger class is a bit bigger with thirteen kids in it. The class teacher tends to teach them mostly and the TA teaches dd's class which is v small. a few of the parents in my dds class are in the same situation and have had their dcs also crying that they can't do the homeworks and just worried they aren't keeping up.

the class teacher seems certain no other help can be given so she said if they are upset not to do the homework.

So to sum up, your DD is in a composite class of 21 children, comprising 13 year 3 and 8 year 4. There is also a TA. Yet for Y4 they are setting homework that around half the children can’t do. What is the point of that? If they have to set homework it should be appropriate eg practicing what has been covered in class. Hopefully she will have a different teacher next year. If things don’t improve and it effects a few children, I’d contact the head.

MummaTrinee · 11/07/2022 07:55

Try Khan academy, starts with maths basics all the way up to uni level. It's great

CecilyP · 11/07/2022 07:49

There are only 8 Students in the year and a few of them are finding maths difficult I'd be questioning why.

This! A few out of 8 is at least 37%. I’d try to find out what’s going wrong before forking out £40 an hour for a tutor. As she is only 9, could you try and find where the gaps are and help her yourself? It s nearly the end of year. Will she be getting a new teacher next year? Perhaps things will improve then anyway.

noblegiraffe · 11/07/2022 07:35

A school-recommended list of tutors sounds like an endorsement of those tutors, so probably best avoided.

surreygirl1987 · 11/07/2022 01:15

If you're a HT would you have a problem with one of your teachers sending a parent to a tutor they're friends with? Do you think it's unethical or is it actually acceptable? I would have expected the teacher to say here's a list of people, not here's my friend's contact.

I'm a Head of Faculty, not a HT. I definitely don't recommend tutors at all- either friends or a 'list' as you suggest. Too risky either way. At my school some teachers do tutor pupils who attend the school (paid) but I personally don't like that as I think it blurs boundaries.

Testina · 10/07/2022 22:39

You've posted multiple times about how bad this school is for your daughter, posted that you’ve visited another which she liked and offered you a place, and even posted in April that you’d emailed them to deregister her to homeschool. What’s actually going on here? All that, and yet your complaint is that you were offered details of a tutor, after asking a teacher if you should get a tutor 🤔

spanishsummers · 10/07/2022 22:25

I might feel grateful to have been offered it, depending on where you live. They can be incredibly hard to get.

Alivekicking · 10/07/2022 22:07

@surreygirl1987 If you're a HT would you have a problem with one of your teachers sending a parent to a tutor they're friends with? Do you think it's unethical or is it actually acceptable? I would have expected the teacher to say here's a list of people, not here's my friend's contact.

surreygirl1987 · 10/07/2022 21:01

I cannot believe that schools are sanctioning their staff offering free tuition after school (on the premises???), That sets a massive precedent and an issue for other staff members, who will be "expected" to offer the same.

This is precisely it. It pressures other teachers to do the same, and makes the job unsustainable. People who do this (which in ny opinion is unreasonable), are actually contributing the to recruitment and retention crisis in the profession. I'm a Head of Faculty in my school and as a balance, I offer a 'support drop-in' once a week so my department are not expected to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread