Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stuff AIRBNB hosts.

137 replies

Bangolads · 09/07/2022 16:53

I used to love AIRBNB - it’s felt like the world was your oyster, you could stay in houses rather than sterile hotels and often the price was really reasonable. I loved the quirkiness.
Now the price is often extortionate, the place is run my professional hosts, it’s ruining communities and the rules and lists of things you can and can’t do feel as if hosts think they’re doing you a favour rather than offering a service for which you are paying. For the first time in years we stayed in a hotel on holiday - amazing! Airbnb is dead for me- AIBU?

OP posts:
BlackandBlueBird · 11/07/2022 00:56

We’ve never had a bad experience as guests, no silly rules or crazy cleaning requirements.

I can absolutely understand the gutting out of neighbourhoods resentment though.

ClareBlue · 11/07/2022 00:55

And it should be part of the residence you live in or you should have to get planning permission to change from residential to short letting. The majority of which would be refused.

ClareBlue · 11/07/2022 00:46

We live near the cliffs of Moher and have an Airbnb. Self contained flat attached to house that sleeps a family, bedroom, kitchen, living room and bathroom and all round house parking. We charge 54 É a night plus 10 cleaning per stay. We would never expect any cleaning to be done by guests other than whipe surfaces and washing up. We have one rule of no smoking and that is it. We have had 300 plus bookings from a night to 35 nights and never cancelled anyone and only had minor issues with two guests. Check-in is 3pm onwards and check out 11am. We are 80perc booked March to October and 50 perc rest of year. I thought this was how it worked.
And we always have baby goats about in the summer which you can pet

StrangerYears · 11/07/2022 00:09

We booked an airBnB before Covid. It was cancelled due to Covid becoming rampant. Got no money back and they even kept the 50pct cleaning fee that they took as a deposit.
Apparently it was 'up the host' how much they kept.

So I will not use them again out of principle.

knockyknees · 10/07/2022 23:59

gogohmm · 09/07/2022 20:29

Never used them. Hotel is the way to go - who wouldn't want someone cleaning your room daily!

Same!

I don't even want to clean my own home most of the time (but obviously do), let alone someone else's. I especially wouldn't want to clean someone else's home after I've paid thousands to travel across the world for my holiday!

ChateauMargaux · 10/07/2022 23:26

Haven't used AirBnB much in the UK but have used it a lot in Europe and have never had any problems.

HolidayLetter · 10/07/2022 23:15

Does Air B&B company not help with this sort of scenario?

Not IME. They don't want to know. Even if a guest admits it was true, they still want "proof". Though the proof they want to see (such as a stench of cigarettes in a strictly non-smoking property) is sometimes impossible to provide.

GrowlingManchego · 10/07/2022 23:03

YANBU. I thought airbnb was a good idea when it was about letting out a spare room or main residence whilst away.

Now there’s a direct relationship between numbers of airbnb apartments in my area and numbers of sofa surfers, vehicle dwellers and street homeless. They are contributing to the desperate housing situation for local people.

Sapphirejane · 10/07/2022 22:38

I had the misfortune of having to live next to an Air BnB (we were there first, the flat next door sold to someone who turned it into an Air BnB). We had people coming and going at all hours, parties, doors slamming, strangers constantly outside our front door on their phone, guests parking in peoples spots. We had to move in the end as it was awful. You can be the best host in the world to your guests but unless you are renting out a room in the home you also live in/ an annex etc, I have zero respect for you. Air BnB is destroying communities and also the lives of the people who have to live next to them.

I did have to stay in one recently much to my disgust (a very sedate hen do). The kitchen didn’t even have a baking tray or tea towels, the dishwasher was full on arrival and the host didn’t send us the code for the lock box until 2 hours after check in time. The blinds kept falling down and the advertised Sky TV was then most basic package akin to freeview. £500 for 2 nights. Hotels only for me in future.

woodhill · 10/07/2022 22:14

abbeycafe · 10/07/2022 10:19

I am a host advertising on Airbnb. I provide the whole flat with kitchen, bathroom and 2 bedrooms. It is always cleaned to a high standard, but I am really shocked and upset by the way some guests treat it. Ripped curtains, children drawing on walls and kitchen units. Sick all over beds and carpets, no washing up done, cigarette burns, make up on carpets, food and drink spilled all over soft furnishings. On the good side, people who appreciate the space treat it as they would their own home. I do not charge a cleaning fee. Change over day, mega hard work to clean for new people coming in at 2pm when I have to clean up sick, poo, dirty filthy kitchen area etc, to make it pristine and 5* quality.

That's disgusting, do you have no comeback for this like sending them the bill for cleaning

Does Air B&B company not help with this sort of scenario?

AquaVite · 10/07/2022 12:36

There will be the odd Airbnb host that I'm sure is fine, but I'm not risking anymore holidays and money finding out!

The UK is pretty awful for Airbnb experiences, but I'll continue to use it abroad as we've only had good experiences in France, Italy, Spain and Portugal. I don't why it's like this, but after 10 years of it, no more UK Airbnb for us.

It's not just about cost - I've found smaller booking sites FAR better, with more consumer protections. Airbnb has morphed into something it wasn't at the start. Now it's just the luck of the draw as to whether or not you'll have a great holiday or a stress-filled nightmare, plus the prices in the UK are laughably greedy.

KimWexlersPonyTail · 10/07/2022 10:27

Also, self catering often accepts dogs and cleaning charges often only about £20.00

KimWexlersPonyTail · 10/07/2022 10:25

We prefer now good quality self catering. Cottages, barns etc you can eat in or go out and its a home from home in great locations. Owners available if you need them but we never really need to meet them.

abbeycafe · 10/07/2022 10:19

I am a host advertising on Airbnb. I provide the whole flat with kitchen, bathroom and 2 bedrooms. It is always cleaned to a high standard, but I am really shocked and upset by the way some guests treat it. Ripped curtains, children drawing on walls and kitchen units. Sick all over beds and carpets, no washing up done, cigarette burns, make up on carpets, food and drink spilled all over soft furnishings. On the good side, people who appreciate the space treat it as they would their own home. I do not charge a cleaning fee. Change over day, mega hard work to clean for new people coming in at 2pm when I have to clean up sick, poo, dirty filthy kitchen area etc, to make it pristine and 5* quality.

ginghamstarfish · 10/07/2022 10:09

I have not used Airbnb and would not wish to, and I am amazed that people are willing to pay a 'cleaning fee' and then clean the place themselves! I would not be stripping beds or cleaning toilets etc, would leave it tidy of course, but what a bonkers idea when you're on holiday (nd have paid a lot of money for it). İf you are worried about bad feedback can't you just re-register as a new account if for some reason you want to continue using Airbnb?

Curlyshabtree · 10/07/2022 10:01

I’ve got a few booked this summer. Two in a room in the host’s house and another in a self contained apartment. We’ve booked lots over the years and have had no bad experiences, only good ones!
I did notice that prices have gone up loads this year though and for the family trip it’s been cheaper to book budget hotels.

Fe345fleur · 10/07/2022 09:48

It's more the principle for me. I'm sure there must be places where Airbnb has a positive contribution to the local economy. But there are plenty of places where it's pricing locals out of the housing market and damaging communities. Pubs and hospitality industry can't get staff as property is too expensive to buy or rent. These places need a balance of well run holiday lets and accommodation for locals.

HolidayLetter · 10/07/2022 09:32

Dasher789 · 09/07/2022 21:28

@HolidayLetter who else do you recommend?

VRBO is the best 'big name' by miles (IME - which isn't to say that other owners and/or guests won't have had a bad experience with them). Tripadvisor is ok-ish. Smaller, local agents are good too. If I had a property which were dog friendly, I'd seek out agents who specialise in dog-friendly holidays; if I had one which were (eg) ideal for rock-climbers or hill walkers, I'd advertise on sites which specialise in accommodation for these particular pursuits. What pisses me off is people saying "oh, you've got some Airbnbs, haven't you". No I haven't! I run a business, and Air BnB is just one of many advertising platforms. It was probably a good idea when it was mostly just people letting out their spare rooms to bring in a bit of extra cash. It has now enabled pretty much any amateur with no business plan at all to think they can buy up properties and turn them into "airbnbs"...

Sadza · 10/07/2022 09:18

I have a friend who has an air bnb and I’m often horrified at the state people leave the place…..crayon on the wall, fake tan staining the bedding, food smeared everywhere, curtains torn. When confronted they say that they left the place clean. I’ve always had good air bnb experiences and I don’t mind stripping the bed and putting dishes away, 5 minute job and good manners. I’ve never been asked to wash floors or do the ‘cleaning’. Also to say during the first lockdown air bnb refunded me within a week (unlike Expedia which took two years to get money for cancelled flights).

beastlyslumber · 10/07/2022 09:08

I live in Edinburgh and I'm sick about what airbnb has done to the city. I currently have an airbnb place above me, one below me, and one next door - used to be that I had neighbours and a little community.

So I don't use airbnb on principle! But I do prefer to stay in apartments when I travel abroad. I use booking.com - but not sure if that's part of the same problem. As someone mentioned, the same apartments get advertised on airbnb. With booking.com at least the consumer has some protection though.

Any other sites or companies that are doing this better?

Frannyhy · 10/07/2022 09:02

@OriginalM

i used to allow guests in the kitchen but some of them behaved in such a dangerous way they terrified me. Others were really dirty.

I also don’t like other people in my kitchen.

I am very clear about this and make guests aware and agree to the restriction before I accept their booking. Kitchen use is not a right for Airbnb guests, it’s a concession that some hosts allow. They all charge a lot more than I do!

I’m in a popular seaside town so there are plenty of places to eat.

Ownedbymycats · 10/07/2022 09:00

It depends on the circumstances. My extended family booked one to attend a family funeral.
Being the youngest and most active I realised on the morning we were leaving that I effectively was going to have to clean a 3000 sq foot home and strip 10 beds alongside sorting breakfast and emptying the fridge etc.
A hotel would have been more appropriate for us and by the time a team of very assertive cleaning ladies arrived at precisely 10.30 am I was exhausted.

Sunnysidegold · 10/07/2022 08:49

I've had good experiences with the ones I've used but I suppose it's like everything else where individuals have control over how they run their business.

I don't mind cleaning up when we go, I'd just prefer it if they left a later check out time to accommodate this. And provided cleaning products and plenty of cloths!

Parpophone · 10/07/2022 08:48

AirBnB is an advertising portal for self-catering properties.

Just that. Nothing more, nothing less.

Yes they have their own t&cs but so do all of the other sites which advertise properties.

Owners wanting to maximise their exposure on-line will probably list with more than one portal.

We used to advertise with a number of companies (including AirBnB).

If somebody books a property through booking.com (other sites are available) it is highly likely that the same property will also be advertised on AirBnB.

It is the same property with the same amenities and the same owners.
If we took an AirBnB booking we didn't automatically rush into the property and remove some of the facilities!

The pricing may be slightly different on different sites, but the owner is probably making the same amount of money as they will just adjust their pricing to fit in with the t&cs and to account for whatever commission the particular site takes.

OriginalM · 10/07/2022 08:46

Frannyhy · 10/07/2022 08:31

@PlopPlop

The only rules I have are no smoking on my property, no one in the house except the named guest, and no kitchen use.

I’ve been known to come home roaring drunk at 3 or 4 in the morning, so fairness dictates that guests can too if they want to. All I ask is they are quiet.

Curious why no kitchen use?

Swipe left for the next trending thread