Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL says she doesn’t want baby at funeral but DH does

808 replies

KristinaYang · 09/07/2022 14:33

FIL recently peacefully died, after short illness. MIL was very reluctant to have baby (11 months) round to visit during this time but encouraged older child age 11 to visit lots. We went with the flow and visited with one child, no children, both children etc so a real mix and we thought that was ok-no negative comments.

DH and I had previously noticed that in laws were/are not as interested in baby as they were/are with older child but had put it down to their older age this time round, plus then FIL becoming unwell. MIL has also made some negative comments about baby eg comparing them to sibling and saying they are given too much attention etc. I’m making this point as I wonder if that is clouding our thoughts a bit here?

Funeral is tomorrow. MIL has today said baby is not welcome as she doesn’t want them to steal the show. She is shocked we even considered it.
We don’t have any childcare for baby (though I could stay at home) but then older child would be alone at funeral as DH is reading a lot of the service. Older child was close to FIL and will be upset understandably.

DH says to all go as originally planned but I am on the fence, MIL expressly says no. I feel stuck in the middle, and I really don’t want to make MIL’s day worse, but my loyalty is to my DH. WWYD?

YANBU- Stick with DH
YABU- Follow MIL’s wishes

OP posts:
MissusPongo · 11/07/2022 15:09

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 14:46

You can organise a celebratory funeral. You can't say it will be fun.
People attending will decide if the funeral is fun or if they are grief-stricken.
I think celebrating someone's life is fine. You can recognise their achievements and what was important to them. But I have never been to any funeral, even the most celebratory, where at least one person was not grief-stricken.

I think our culture struggles with the idea of people grieving and wants to erase or smooth over that unpleasant fact. As if grief can be banished by a baby cooing or clapping at a hymn, or by wearing bright colours. I have nothing against wearing bright colours at a funeral, but it does not stop the grief.

Yes, that's my point- as I said, "ultimately it shouldn't be up to me- it should be up to the people mourning me".

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 14:46

MissusPongo · 11/07/2022 14:40

I think people often substitute their own idea of what a good funeral is like for what other people might wish a funeral to be like.

I love the idea of mine being celebratory and fun (assuming I die in my sleep at 90 rather than being horribly murdered tomorrow or something), clapping children welcome. But ultimately it shouldn't be up to me- it should be up to the people mourning me. Likewise my mum has made me swear that when she dies we won't get people to wear bright colours to celebrate her life- she wants everyone in black and being very correct. There isn't a single right way to do it.

You can organise a celebratory funeral. You can't say it will be fun.
People attending will decide if the funeral is fun or if they are grief-stricken.
I think celebrating someone's life is fine. You can recognise their achievements and what was important to them. But I have never been to any funeral, even the most celebratory, where at least one person was not grief-stricken.

I think our culture struggles with the idea of people grieving and wants to erase or smooth over that unpleasant fact. As if grief can be banished by a baby cooing or clapping at a hymn, or by wearing bright colours. I have nothing against wearing bright colours at a funeral, but it does not stop the grief.

MissusPongo · 11/07/2022 14:40

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 13:34

There are multiple people on this thread who think it is appropriate to think babies and children can cheer people up at funerals, to describe a funeral as pleasant, and to think it is fine if people can not hear the eulogy.
At most funerals there is one person at least who is grief stricken. Some people here talk about funerals as purely social occasions.

I think people often substitute their own idea of what a good funeral is like for what other people might wish a funeral to be like.

I love the idea of mine being celebratory and fun (assuming I die in my sleep at 90 rather than being horribly murdered tomorrow or something), clapping children welcome. But ultimately it shouldn't be up to me- it should be up to the people mourning me. Likewise my mum has made me swear that when she dies we won't get people to wear bright colours to celebrate her life- she wants everyone in black and being very correct. There isn't a single right way to do it.

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 14:23

@ancientgran The phrase used was not a comfort, but that it would cheer her up.
And any funerals I have been to of people I am very close to, I could not tell you who was at the funeral. My grief was too raw to take comfort from anything and to really notice a baby. Comfort of this type is I think for funerals of people you care about, but are not devastated by their death.

ancientgran · 11/07/2022 14:19

I think babies and children can be a comfort, MIL could have looked at her two GC and thought her husband's genes were going on. People can feel differently about these things and some would find that comforting. I'm used to babies and children at funerals, seems normal to me but then again they go to Mass every Sunday from being babies so even very little ones tend to be well behaved in a church and family are used to them at services. Same at weddings. I've never actually experienced children playing up at a wedding or funeral.

None of that applies to the reception at the golf club though where people will be chatting/eating/drinking and it isn't like the service.

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 13:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

There are multiple people on this thread who think it is appropriate to think babies and children can cheer people up at funerals, to describe a funeral as pleasant, and to think it is fine if people can not hear the eulogy.
At most funerals there is one person at least who is grief stricken. Some people here talk about funerals as purely social occasions.

iRun2eatCake · 11/07/2022 13:27

Good grief!! How did your DH react to the other child being there and what was said?

Lola4321 · 11/07/2022 12:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lola4321 · 11/07/2022 12:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 12:41

I read there was history. But nothing was said about the MIL being misogynistic.

whynotwhatknot · 11/07/2022 12:40

there is history the op said so ffs why cant people read

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 12:10

I wouldn't take what a third party says as gospel. A woman who would not accept a grandchild as they are a girl is a woman with a lot of misogyny. Her misogyny would have been pretty clear early on and not just now been revealed.

Anonymouseposter · 11/07/2022 10:51

I wasn't excusing the MIL or calling OP a liar above.
I said earlier that I thought the MIL sounded nasty just from what OP had heard her say directly.
I was just cautioning against uncritically accepting what a third party had said in case they were stirring.
I think Op has handled everything very well for now.
I would bear in mind what has been said about MIL. and see if she continues to act this way.
If she does I would certainly tackle her about it (probably best coming from her son) and I would restrict contact if it continues.

Laiste · 11/07/2022 10:37

@wishingitwasfriday

Your post reminded me of my XMIL. She didn't ''like'' girls.

She had 3 sons herself (XH was the eldest) and long before her son and i had our DCs i remember her telling me how she ''always longed only for boys'', and how boys were better than girls and bla bla. It was weird.

When i fell preg with DC1 she kept on about how she was hoping for another grand son (She had one already). She suggested we went for blue for the nursery as ''It's boys in our family you know!''.

Well, i had a girl 😃It didn't go down well.

And then within three years we'd had 2 more! 😂

I clearly remember her saying, at some point while i was pregnant with DD3, that she was SO GLAD she didn't have daughters. And that this time i will probably finaly have a boy and was i prepared for all the boy'ish ness and mess and wonderfully amusing chaos?

When XH announced DD3's birth she actually said ''Oh'' and then ''Never mind'' !! 😳

This is all years ago and it's all ancient history. (In fact I've remarried and had a 4th girl!) But looking back, older and wiser, i think she protested too much, as they say. I recon it was all bluster and she would have loved a DD of her own. There i said it!

derxa · 11/07/2022 10:26

Cameronnorrieisabitofalright · 10/07/2022 17:59

Missing sibling? Mil was adamant she was to be chief mourner wasn't she?

Goodness me

Rhaenys · 11/07/2022 10:12

Sorry I didn’t RTFT! Glad you sorted it.

Rhaenys · 11/07/2022 10:09

I was once asked to take care of a neighbour’s baby in a similar situation. Is this something that’s possible for you?

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 11/07/2022 10:06

I have to be honest, I wouldn’t take a baby or young child to a funeral anyway.

sounds like your Mil is being odd though, give her time and space to grieve and see if she comes around. Don’t take the baby to the funeral and damage your relationship though.

wishingitwasfriday · 11/07/2022 10:03

Having had a grandmother who hated girls I can completely believe the OP. My grandmother repeatedly told me and my sisters that girls were worthless and always treated my brother and me cousins differently. They were allowed in the new car (we weren't), they got taken on holiday (we weren't) etc etc.
Weirdly her attitude changed towards me when I went to uni, but the damage was done years ago. I was never close to her and didn't mourn her when she died a few years ago.

ancientgran · 11/07/2022 10:02

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 09:40

Maybe her partner was an abusive arse? Some people are relieved for good reasons when their partner dies.
Or maybe she has a black sense of humour?
You do not know this woman yet are judging her based on a 2 minute over heard conversation.

I'm not judging her but I was quite impressed with how she stopped the misery fest however she actually felt about being a widow. The fact remains that people will experience grief in their own way, some widows will be delighted, some will be neutral and some will be devastated. Considering how many women post on here about how unhappy they are in their relationship/marriage it seems odd that so many people seem to think it is a given that this woman is so distraught she isn't responsible for what comes out of her mouth.

ancientgran · 11/07/2022 09:58

saraclara · 11/07/2022 09:41

She was probably weary of misery talk, however well intentioned the group. Maybe she just wanted to let a little light in to what she had hoped would be a nice, distracting meetup with friends.

I'm pretty sure that there were times when I was that woman, after the loss of the husband I adored.

You overheard a few seconds of a conversation among people you don't know. You have absolutely no context from which to decide that this woman wasn't grief stricken by her loss. I doubt that 'upside' made up for anything at all. She was just trying to lift the atmosphere I imagine.

Well obviously you can imagine all sorts. As an example that I heard a few seconds of conversation when in fact it all went on for half an hour.

Why is it hard to accept that she might actually be quite relieved to be on her own? Not everyone has happy marriages, I've known a couple of women who had unhappy marriages and stayed because they couldn't face the financial hardship of divorce. They were both perfectly happy when left as widows with a nice house and half his pension.

Of course she might be heartbroken and a brilliant actress but all the stuff on here about lifepartners and people being heartbroken as if that applies to everyone is just silly.

ladydoris · 11/07/2022 09:45

Well, well well. Lost sympathy for the MIL for sure. Your husband saw through her and was right. Mirror mirror on the wall...

Laiste · 11/07/2022 09:42

A few posters are scrambling about now hinting that some of what the OP is saying is lies, because it doesn't fit their own narrative about the MIL.

Honestly if you're going to openly not believe half the OPs posts it makes a mockery of you commenting at all.

saraclara · 11/07/2022 09:41

ancientgran · 11/07/2022 09:25

Well I was there and I heard her and she was clearly fed up off all the tragedy stuff and let them know that actually she felt there was an upside to her new situation.

She was probably weary of misery talk, however well intentioned the group. Maybe she just wanted to let a little light in to what she had hoped would be a nice, distracting meetup with friends.

I'm pretty sure that there were times when I was that woman, after the loss of the husband I adored.

You overheard a few seconds of a conversation among people you don't know. You have absolutely no context from which to decide that this woman wasn't grief stricken by her loss. I doubt that 'upside' made up for anything at all. She was just trying to lift the atmosphere I imagine.

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 09:40

ancientgran · 11/07/2022 09:25

Well I was there and I heard her and she was clearly fed up off all the tragedy stuff and let them know that actually she felt there was an upside to her new situation.

Maybe her partner was an abusive arse? Some people are relieved for good reasons when their partner dies.
Or maybe she has a black sense of humour?
You do not know this woman yet are judging her based on a 2 minute over heard conversation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread