Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL says she doesn’t want baby at funeral but DH does

808 replies

KristinaYang · 09/07/2022 14:33

FIL recently peacefully died, after short illness. MIL was very reluctant to have baby (11 months) round to visit during this time but encouraged older child age 11 to visit lots. We went with the flow and visited with one child, no children, both children etc so a real mix and we thought that was ok-no negative comments.

DH and I had previously noticed that in laws were/are not as interested in baby as they were/are with older child but had put it down to their older age this time round, plus then FIL becoming unwell. MIL has also made some negative comments about baby eg comparing them to sibling and saying they are given too much attention etc. I’m making this point as I wonder if that is clouding our thoughts a bit here?

Funeral is tomorrow. MIL has today said baby is not welcome as she doesn’t want them to steal the show. She is shocked we even considered it.
We don’t have any childcare for baby (though I could stay at home) but then older child would be alone at funeral as DH is reading a lot of the service. Older child was close to FIL and will be upset understandably.

DH says to all go as originally planned but I am on the fence, MIL expressly says no. I feel stuck in the middle, and I really don’t want to make MIL’s day worse, but my loyalty is to my DH. WWYD?

YANBU- Stick with DH
YABU- Follow MIL’s wishes

OP posts:
MiniPiccolo · 09/07/2022 23:25

"DD is a precious little gift that will be doted on will ease what is often a tense situation"

Whoever wrote this needs to put the vomit back in my mouth so I can throw up again.

DD is an 11m baby and at a funeral all anyone wants to do is have some peace and mourn, without the stress of a baby around.

For the same reasons babies are banned from a lot of weddings, people feel the same about funerals.

MiniPiccolo · 09/07/2022 23:23

MILs wishes need to be respected. Your baby is 11m old. Babies do not belong at funerals.

Dadschat · 09/07/2022 23:20

saraclara · Today 22:00
Dadschat
Sorry for your loss. In my experience a baby at a funeral is an absolute joy, and a reminder of the wonder of life in times of sadness. There is no show to steal. FIL was loved and will be mourned. DD is a precious little gift that will be doted on will ease what is often a tense situation. When meeting family and friends you don’t often see, it can be awkward. A baby will make it less so. I would follow DHs lead and take both children. I’ve heard of funerals where young children clapped after hymns much to the amusement of everyone around. Nobody loved or mourned the deceased any less because of it.

That's universal is it? Every single person grieving the loss of a spouse, partner, patent or child feels exactly the same? Even this MIL who has said very clearly that she doesn't want this, will feel like you if she is actively defied?

Do you have any concept at all of not everyone having the exact same feelings as you?

I began by saying “In my experience.” In truth our own experiences are all any of us can really speak of with any degree of certainty. I do have concept of people not having the same feelings as me. The only reason I mentioned taking both children is that the OP mentioned that DH was intending to. I just agreed with his decision. @saraclara I’m sorry if I brought out the crazy in you. You seem very angry.

Dyra · 09/07/2022 22:51

IMO widow's wishes take priority. My nan didn't want children at DGDad's funeral, so my DH and DSis' partner stayed outside with the little ones. She loves her great grand kids, but didn't want the possibility of detracting attention away from her husband during the final time that it would be on him. The kids brought lots of joy to the wake afterwards.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 22:25

You'd no problem with the 11 y.o going before the baby got uninvited.

Don't stop her going, let her support her DGM and say goodbye to DGF.

Hellospring22 · 09/07/2022 22:23

I’m so glad you’ve found a solution and have been able to find a way to go along with her wishes. Grief is so all consuming that I wouldn’t take anything that is said at the moment about your baby to heart. I hope the service goes well.

UniversalAunt · 09/07/2022 22:22

@Rosscameasdoody your post at 20:38 is beautifully written, gently poignant & to the very point.

My condolences for your loss even though it was a while ago.
Although time rolls on & we adapt to the changes that close loss brings, the furious storm of those earlier days are not forgotten.

I imagine that OP’s MiL is feeling much the same as you describe.

LuckySantangelo35 · 09/07/2022 22:22

LDN1 · 09/07/2022 22:19

Read my post again. You've just repeated what I said.

@LDN1

no, because I think the 11 year old should go

LDN1 · 09/07/2022 22:19

Read my post again. You've just repeated what I said.

LuckySantangelo35 · 09/07/2022 22:19

UniversalAunt · 09/07/2022 22:16

@KristinaYang ‘ She said she isn’t being mean, she just has no connection with baby, and doesn’t want the limelight to be taken from FIL’s day.‘

I think that your MiL is just being very honest with you. she does not mean to hurt you or DH. In the past few months when she might be bonding with baby, she has been watching he husband die of a serious illness, preparing to accept his death. Likely her feelings have been more of dread, fear, sadness & rage at what has happened - not much scope for bonding with a new baby when her strong visceral bond with her husband is being torn apart. As I mentioned before, her feelings about baby are not personal, the timing is just awful.

I was quite surprised by how indifferent my MiL was towards her 6th & 7th grandchild, particularly in comparison to the first few. I asked, & she said simply that she was that much older & tired, scant maternal hormones, she had passed the thrill of the cuddly baby years & now was enjoying her grandchildren far more now that they were greater individuals & better company. A newborn held little interest for her & facing serious illness brought her mortality closer as she knew that she’d not live long or well enough to enjoy them as they grew up. There was no animus towards the new babies, just a lack of interest. I appreciated her honesty & insight.

So @KristinaYang let’s be optimistic that MiL will come through the worst of her grief to find a connection with your baby as they grow up.

@UniversalAunt

great post

UniversalAunt · 09/07/2022 22:16

@KristinaYang ‘ She said she isn’t being mean, she just has no connection with baby, and doesn’t want the limelight to be taken from FIL’s day.‘

I think that your MiL is just being very honest with you. she does not mean to hurt you or DH. In the past few months when she might be bonding with baby, she has been watching he husband die of a serious illness, preparing to accept his death. Likely her feelings have been more of dread, fear, sadness & rage at what has happened - not much scope for bonding with a new baby when her strong visceral bond with her husband is being torn apart. As I mentioned before, her feelings about baby are not personal, the timing is just awful.

I was quite surprised by how indifferent my MiL was towards her 6th & 7th grandchild, particularly in comparison to the first few. I asked, & she said simply that she was that much older & tired, scant maternal hormones, she had passed the thrill of the cuddly baby years & now was enjoying her grandchildren far more now that they were greater individuals & better company. A newborn held little interest for her & facing serious illness brought her mortality closer as she knew that she’d not live long or well enough to enjoy them as they grew up. There was no animus towards the new babies, just a lack of interest. I appreciated her honesty & insight.

So @KristinaYang let’s be optimistic that MiL will come through the worst of her grief to find a connection with your baby as they grow up.

LuckySantangelo35 · 09/07/2022 22:04

LDN1 · 09/07/2022 21:09

Both children stay at home - away from funeral.

She can't have it all her way, but fair enough on the day of this gravity to respect her wishes.

Just say neither child will attend in this case.

Might be too upsetting for the 11 year old anyway.

@LDN1

why?!

why can’t mother in law have it all her own way on one day? It is the funeral of the most important person in her life. Why can’t people fall in line with what she wants for one day?! It’s one day.

Honestly, it’s not all about kids!! Kids do not have to be present and take precedence in every single situation!!

mother in law and father in law should take precedence on that day

saraclara · 09/07/2022 22:00

Dadschat · 09/07/2022 21:43

Sorry for your loss. In my experience a baby at a funeral is an absolute joy, and a reminder of the wonder of life in times of sadness. There is no show to steal. FIL was loved and will be mourned. DD is a precious little gift that will be doted on will ease what is often a tense situation. When meeting family and friends you don’t often see, it can be awkward. A baby will make it less so. I would follow DHs lead and take both children. I’ve heard of funerals where young children clapped after hymns much to the amusement of everyone around. Nobody loved or mourned the deceased any less because of it.

That's universal is it? Every single person grieving the loss of a spouse, partner, patent or child feels exactly the same? Even this MIL who has said very clearly that she doesn't want this, will feel like you if she is actively defied?

Do you have any concept at all of not everyone having the exact same feelings as you?

Dadschat · 09/07/2022 21:43

Sorry for your loss. In my experience a baby at a funeral is an absolute joy, and a reminder of the wonder of life in times of sadness. There is no show to steal. FIL was loved and will be mourned. DD is a precious little gift that will be doted on will ease what is often a tense situation. When meeting family and friends you don’t often see, it can be awkward. A baby will make it less so. I would follow DHs lead and take both children. I’ve heard of funerals where young children clapped after hymns much to the amusement of everyone around. Nobody loved or mourned the deceased any less because of it.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 21:41

Good update OP even the best babies can cause a disturbance.
Best of luck.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 21:39

We attended a lot of funerals as DC.

Only one had an impact on me when I leaned on my Uncles coffin and tripped.

I was a very clumsy DC.

We really enjoyed the wake that went on for day's with your loved one laid out in the room, it was time for story telling, having a singsong, meeting relatives we hadn't seen since the previous deaths, collecting coins from great Uncles and Aunts.
😀

I didn't bring my youngest to my parents because it was during covid restrictions, Dad's wasn't as strict I brought the DC to the wake.

Not a traditional wake just the meeting of family and friends, a celebration of life.

Both came to the afters.

Death is a normal part of life.

Dasher789 · 09/07/2022 21:38

Hope the day goes well op. Seems like a good solution.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 09/07/2022 21:37

I'm so glad your neighbours are happy to babysit
People are usually happy to help in a situation like this
We didn't know our neighbours particularly well at the time, but it worked well( as possibly could in a sad situation)

Livelovebehappy · 09/07/2022 21:37

This isn’t about your baby, or even you. It’s about someone who has lost their husband and father. Funerals are so hard to organise when you’re dealing with grief too, and so I would just stay home with the baby, and I’m sure if you’re DH isn’t going to be always available to be at the side of your older dc, they’ll be other family members who will watch them. Maybe you can discuss your concerns with mil in the future, but this isn’t really the time to start trying to make a point.

SkeletonFight · 09/07/2022 21:18

Apologies - I missed the update.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/07/2022 21:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Perhaps that's a product of picking up on attitudes like yours to towards funerals? The vast majority of parents are capable of making a decision regarding whether their own children should attend or not.

I've been to loads of funerals as a child, as have my children, my siblings, cousins, friends. None of us were traumatised. Frequently sad and upset but not traumatised.

Are you really this sheltered and obtuse you cannot understand that some things are simply inappropriate for some children

I'm not the one arguing from an absolute position. You are insisting funerals are not appropriate for children. That is an obtuse position. In many cultures it is the norm to have children there. I have very fond memories of some family funerals as a child. It was a way to say goodbye within a supportive environment. That doesn't mean I think everyone should bring their children to every funeral or that all funerals should include children. It just means I think your blanket assertion that funerals are always inappropriate for children is wrong.

Your refusal to recognise that there is more than one way to do things is utterly bizarre.

Anyway, there's no point in talking to you as you are incapable of seeing beyond your own viewpoint.

Scianel · 09/07/2022 21:17

OP I think you've been very kind and accommodating, and she is grieving.
But her attitude to your baby is very odd indeed, if it doesn't resolve itself down the line I can see this causing issues.

SkeletonFight · 09/07/2022 21:17

I know that people say seemingly terrible things at times of immense grief and I would suggest that this is one of them. TBH @KristinaYang you are not giving your DH the time that HE needs for grieving. He needs his own space and not to be worrying about a potentially crying baby. Find someone to even wait outside with the baby.

HaveringWavering · 09/07/2022 21:14

Good update OP, glad your neighbours have agreed to help. Will your DS get to go to the golf club at all? (Presumably he’s also a member due to playing there with FIL and there will be golf friends there who know him and will want to talk to him about his Grandad).

tableanadchairs · 09/07/2022 21:14

why is it MIL that is calling the shots- it may be her DH but it was your DH's dad. I would go with what your DH wants
We took our DD to MIL funeral she was 9 months - certainly did not steal the show but actually was a positive addition to a difficult time