Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish it was the cultural norm not to comment on things you don’t have experience in

37 replies

Peaplant20 · 09/07/2022 12:27

I think about this quite frequently. So many times I’ve had one opinion on something, then when I’ve experience it first hand, I’ve completely changed my mind. But yet as a culture we constantly comment our opinions on things we don’t have experience in (including myself)). Some examples:

  • I met someone today who had a friend who’d had a baby arrive 4 weeks early. My baby was also early. The other person said “it’s quite nice when they’re like that isn’t it, because they don’t really cry.” For me personally, there was nothing nice about having a baby arrive prematurely. It was scary and traumatic.
  • commenting on people’s pregnancy bodies. I’ve definitely said things like “wow your bump is so big!” to other pregnant women before. It wasn’t until I was pregnant and I became part of a Facebook group with lots of pregnant women that I realised people don’t usually like being told this! My own bump was small and people used to comment on that all the time and I didn’t like that either. I made a vow only to ever say “you look well/ healthy” etc to pregnant women in future.
  • as a teacher I find people comment ALOT about how much “holiday” teachers get without any real understanding of teacher workload today (very different to when most adults attended school themselves).
just a rant really 😂 not meant to be a debate about those specific examples but more of why we do this. Any other examples? Times when you’ve had one opinion on something and then changed your mind when you experienced it yourself?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WalkingOnTheCracks · 09/07/2022 18:03

I was going to contribute to this discussion but - on reflection - I don't think I'm qualified.

MamaFoxToBe · 09/07/2022 17:55

Phrenologistsfinger · 09/07/2022 13:01

anything related to pregnancy loss, infertility, IVF, childlessness etc - if you haven’t been through it, you’ve no idea. The amount of insensitive sh*te people say. Best just to say I am sorry things are hard, not ‘at least you can get pregnant’ (yeah, I’ve been pregnant ten times but they are still all dead), ‘you can have my kids’ (that’s not the point), ‘you’ll get your baby one day, I just know it’ (my high experienced doctor doesn’t even know that).

Agreed! Had some really insensitive comments said to me after my miscarriage, including one from a Mind counsellor!! Sorry for your losses x

lovelyweathertoday · 09/07/2022 17:37

FriendlyPineapple · 09/07/2022 12:32

It's just people making chit chat 🤷🏻‍♀️

It's what people do. Best not to take random comments too seriously.

Harridance · 09/07/2022 17:28

Would that mean we can't comment on how the country is run?

Pruella · 09/07/2022 17:14

What culture is it where people don’t make comments? I’m from one culture, DH from another and we live in a third one (UK) all three enjoy commenting on things and my native culture in particular I find have a lot to say about pregnancy/ babies etc.

waterfly · 09/07/2022 17:10

It never really bothered me when people commented on the size of my pregnancy bump, but that's just me.

5128gap · 09/07/2022 13:58

No, I think people should be able to comment on things they know nothing about in principle, because if they couldn't how would anyone ever learn anything? So if someone says 'teachers have too many holidays' you can reply with whatever your counter argument to that is, and then they know.
I think commenting on someone's appearance, whether pregnant or not, is best avoided though.

TitInATrance · 09/07/2022 13:45

I was widowed young too, after 5 years together. I hate it when people bleat on looking for extra sympathy because they had 40 years together and aren’t used to being alone. Would never say so, and I make the appropriate noises.

Everyone’s experience is unique and playing top trumps with tragedy (or anything really) is infuriating.

Hawkins001 · 09/07/2022 13:38

Wombat100 · 09/07/2022 13:13

I get the basis of what you’re saying but ultimately you ABU. If we could only speak on or express an opinion about the things we have actual experience about then we’d all be pretty boring.

But then it would help if people lead the conversation with e.g. I don't know much about x but what do you think or know about x,

Hawkins001 · 09/07/2022 13:37

Leoismybae · 09/07/2022 12:51

People are allowed talk about anything they want to talk about, even if it's annoying to others.

I think sometimes it's when people offer x perspectives without actual knowledge to back up the perspectives,

godmum56 · 09/07/2022 13:28

I think its the human condition to sometimes not say the right thing even if its about something which you have experienced yourself. When I was widowed, other women who had lost their husbands said things to me that were meant kindly but made me want to kill them. Baseline Op I think you are overthinking.

WoundTheBobbinUp · 09/07/2022 13:20

I'm a very quiet person and this is why! You never know what will upset people. I just don't bother anymore Blush

Bagzzz · 09/07/2022 13:19

one issue for sensitive issues such as serious illness or bereavement is not knowing what to say so not saying anything at all. I haven’t experienced my child dying. Whatever I say seems inadequate. Then I say nothing as if I don’t care at all.

For other things I think we may be more likely to know what does not help from the person with lived experience of being a nurse, teacher, lawyer.
An example may be being woken very early when a patient. I felt that didn’t help my recover my and feel like complaining about nurses doing that. However nurses themselves have a different perspective and can discuss the reasons. Or we can talk about very bland topics instead.

Wombat100 · 09/07/2022 13:13

I get the basis of what you’re saying but ultimately you ABU. If we could only speak on or express an opinion about the things we have actual experience about then we’d all be pretty boring.

Sapphire387 · 09/07/2022 13:10

Oh yes, I feel this.

Within my experience (sadly) was being widowed at a young age.

The amount of people who thought they 'understood' when they really, really didn't.

I'm now remarried and they don't understand why I worry about my husband and can't simply draw a line and leave all my life experience behind.

TulipCat · 09/07/2022 13:06

I think it's useful sometimes to have outside perspectives from people not emotionally involved in things. Also I think calling people out on things should not be limited to those with direct experience. For example, I have never owned a dog but I have opinions on irresponsible owners.

TulipsTwoLips · 09/07/2022 13:02

The thing is, people experience the same situation in totally different ways. So although you might have been through something, the comments of someone who'd been through it differently would annoy you.

Phrenologistsfinger · 09/07/2022 13:01

anything related to pregnancy loss, infertility, IVF, childlessness etc - if you haven’t been through it, you’ve no idea. The amount of insensitive sh*te people say. Best just to say I am sorry things are hard, not ‘at least you can get pregnant’ (yeah, I’ve been pregnant ten times but they are still all dead), ‘you can have my kids’ (that’s not the point), ‘you’ll get your baby one day, I just know it’ (my high experienced doctor doesn’t even know that).

Georgeskitchen · 09/07/2022 12:58

People have always had conflicting opinions, but since the advent of social media its in yer face 24/7. Someone will make a comment, however innocuous, then someone else will decide they are an idiot and start a barney. I rarely comment on anything public but it has some great entertainment value when your feeling a bit bored!!

poetryandwine · 09/07/2022 12:57

I’m with you, OP. TBF I am also tired of teachers who think academics have it easy because there are fewer teaching hours. They never see the myriad other job duties. And yes, I am well aware of the invisible work of teaching and have great respect for that.

But what gives me the rage is when people change a recipe beyond recognition before attempting it, and then give it a bad review because their version didn’t work.

EthicalNonMahogany · 09/07/2022 12:57

@chilledbubble to be fair since posting I've gone on a million threads and said judgement opinionated stuff 😂

Leoismybae · 09/07/2022 12:51

People are allowed talk about anything they want to talk about, even if it's annoying to others.

Somanymistakes · 09/07/2022 12:51

Itisasecret · 09/07/2022 12:40

Everyone on MN knows how to teach better than teachers. That’s why they are here 24/7 bad mouthing them and not signing up to teach. Maybe they should charge consultancy fees for their expertise.

I do not.
I cannot even teach basic things to a relatively intelligent child. If they don't understand the first time, I'm completely befuddled how I can help.

Although I'd long had a feeling I'd be a terrible teacher, lockdown homeschooling confirmed it for me. The weird thing is that everyone else in my family is a teacher!

lljkk · 09/07/2022 12:50

Not a lot of room for anything but the most banal chitchat in your world, OP.

i could flip this & say "Why do people take chitchat so seriously!?"

GirlDownUnder22 · 09/07/2022 12:45

If armchair experts were forbidden twitter would collapse overnight.