Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my dd is overweight

235 replies

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 06:49

My 15 year old daughter is 6'2 and 220 lbs. I definitely think she is overweight. But, my daughter insists that she is not overweight and she does quite good at basketball. She says that she's athletic. She also claims that she's quite as fast as her teammates(which I think she actually is).

But, the number is too high to believe that she isn't overweight. Also, her basketball coach also thinks she's perfectly healthy.

AIBU to think she is overweight?

OP posts:
Nancydrawn · 09/07/2022 12:54

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 09:30

Well, it's very tough for me. But how can I ignore her problems? I'll have to solve that, right?

Why is it tough for you?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 09/07/2022 12:53
Hmm
PurpleDaisies · 09/07/2022 12:49

Misread as “with endo” rather than “to endo”. Thanks for pointing that out.

Still, I don’t think there would have been any misunderstand that that poster was biologically female without the “cis” adding on. It’s very naive to think that that isn’t a loaded statement to make.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 09/07/2022 12:44

Just leave her alone, she's active and sounds like she is happy with her body.

All the fat phobia and body shaming on this thread is depressing.

If you tell her she's over weight or needs to lose weight op you see are sowing the seeds for poor body image and an eating disorder.

I have a teen with an ED and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy, it's horrific and all it takes is weight loss to let it take hold.

KarmaStar · 09/07/2022 12:43

Leave her alone.You are making barbs that are hitting the target inside even if she's not showing she's hurt by your comments.

justasoul · 09/07/2022 12:41

PurpleDaisies · 09/07/2022 12:30

It was relevant to be clear in this instance

How? A trans woman does not have a uterus so can’t have endo. Woman was entirely sufficient. Gender identity doesn’t come into it.

I’m sure the PP meant endocrinologist - don’t males have hormones too?

SomePosters · 09/07/2022 12:31

Sometimes I think I would love mn a lot more if you could block individual posters instead of just hiding discussion boards and threads to avoid the terf contingent having to stick their big stirring spoons in at every opportunity

it’s like having rats but you can’t just set the dog on them to stop them shitting everywhere

PurpleDaisies · 09/07/2022 12:30

It was relevant to be clear in this instance

How? A trans woman does not have a uterus so can’t have endo. Woman was entirely sufficient. Gender identity doesn’t come into it.

SomePosters · 09/07/2022 12:28

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 09/07/2022 11:58

I would second/third/fourth asking your dr for a refer to endo, I am a cis woman with very high testosterone levels

Woman will suffice, we know what one is without putting cis in front.

It was relevant to be clear in this instance and I used language I chose to describe myself, it’s neither your job not appreciated for you to police the way I talk about myself

5128gap · 09/07/2022 12:27

collieresponder88 · 09/07/2022 12:09

Just leave her be. Have you got enough going on in your own life ?

How much would one need to have going on in their life to lack capacity to care about their daughter?

collieresponder88 · 09/07/2022 12:09

Just leave her be. Have you got enough going on in your own life ?

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 09/07/2022 11:58

I would second/third/fourth asking your dr for a refer to endo, I am a cis woman with very high testosterone levels

Woman will suffice, we know what one is without putting cis in front.

5128gap · 09/07/2022 11:55

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 11:49

the average height for a U.K. female is 5'4. OP is 5'9, that's 5 inches difference, that is NOT near the average at all fgs.

5'4 might be the average height for women in the UK though taking other countries into consideration, average height for a women is 5'7.

UK and Irish women are smaller than average height.

Average daily calories at 2000 for women is based on a fit woman approximately 5'7.

Whereas anyone under 5'4 only needs 1600 calories.

My Dsis 5'2 was convinced a woman's daily calories was 2000 at her height.

Indeed. At 5' 4", so did I for years. I thought i was 'big built' and 'naturally' fatter. Two stone down, fit as a fiddle, and BMI of 21 now I've finally caught on!

BungleandGeorge · 09/07/2022 11:53

@EmeraldShamrock1 do you have a source for that? I think it’s actually about 5’3” worldwide. Yes some countries are taller than UK but there’s many about the same and lower

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 11:49

the average height for a U.K. female is 5'4. OP is 5'9, that's 5 inches difference, that is NOT near the average at all fgs.

5'4 might be the average height for women in the UK though taking other countries into consideration, average height for a women is 5'7.

UK and Irish women are smaller than average height.

Average daily calories at 2000 for women is based on a fit woman approximately 5'7.

Whereas anyone under 5'4 only needs 1600 calories.

My Dsis 5'2 was convinced a woman's daily calories was 2000 at her height.

FancyChips · 09/07/2022 11:48

You’re going to ruin your relationship with her and ruin her relationship with food.
Make healthy high protein meals and snacks and do activities together so she’s not boredom snacking.

5128gap · 09/07/2022 11:48

Its nothing to do with how she looks or how fit she is. Her BMI puts her in the upper range of OW category. It's really not a matter of opinion, its a matter of fact, so I can't see what the debate is really.

ZealAndArdour · 09/07/2022 11:46

I think you need to leave her alone.

And all these 5’2 women on the thread with no lived experience of being in a tall womens body who are convinced she must be grotesque and “very overweight” need to pipe down. I think the person above who said that BMI is less useful at the extremes of height was possibly correct.

I’m 6ft and weigh 204lbs making my BMI 27.7 - very similar to the OP‘s daughter proportionally. At this weight I have visible hip bones, all of the bones and musculature of my shoulders and neck area are totally visible with relaxed posture (clavicles, suprasternal notch, etc), the outline of my ribs are seen and easily felt through the skin of my chest wall, my shoulder blades protrude, as does my spine and I can feel my coccyx and ischium making contact with a hard chair when I sit down. I am told that I look very tall and slim and that “there’s nothing on you” in terms of fat/weight.

thebutcherswife · 09/07/2022 11:42

merryhouse · 09/07/2022 11:14

@thebutcherswife and if you posted saying rocks don't weigh more than feathers you'd be laughed off the internet...

Not sure what you’re trying to say here. A kilo is still a kilo…

trailrunner85 · 09/07/2022 11:41

I am 6'1" and very overweight but always thought it was unfair that BMI did not take into account your frame

Except it does. That's why the BMI range is so huge. For someone of my height I can weigh between approx 8st and 11st and be in the healthy range. If I had huge feet and very broad shoulders, 11st might look about right on me. As it is, I have size 7 feet and hover around 9st. The fact I could put on 2st and still be healthy seems a bit nuts. Particularly because when I was that weight, I was visibly fat - though I can see why people of a different build to me would look great.

Isnt it funny how when people always argue that BMI doesn't take into account build, it's always to argue that they're big boned/ have large feet/ have large shoulders/carry more muscle, so it should go higher. You don't get that many people with small hands and size 2 feet saying BMI should go lower, do you..

GreatStuff67 · 09/07/2022 11:38

NHS BMI calculator says yes.

AIBU to think my dd is overweight
SomePosters · 09/07/2022 11:25

If she’s managing to keep up with team sports and her coach isn’t worried when she asked them then you have your answer. Calm the fuck down.

bmi is a useful but blunt tool especially for those at either end of the height spectrum or those who are very sporty.

I would second/third/fourth asking your dr for a refer to endo, I am a cis woman with very high testosterone levels (I couldn’t compete in some olympic disciplines without taking medication to lower my natural testosterone) I lay down muscle mass very quickly with relatively little effort and have been heavier than my peers since toddlerhood while also fit, active and eating well.

BMI places me as obese and while I could lose a little healthily I will never be in a ‘healthy’ bmi because I lift weights and have unmedicated high testosterone. I work out everyday and could deadlift most people in a healthy weight range without breaking a sweat so I’m not worried and neither is my dr

my cardiovascular health is significantly better than most people in the ‘healthy’ weight range because I get my heart rate up almost every day.

there is more to health than bmi

MushyPeasPrincess · 09/07/2022 11:19

CecilyP · 09/07/2022 09:52

OP will definitely look very thin at her height and at around 10 stoneish

Will she? Her height is not far above average and her weight is also pretty average.

@CecilyP the average height for a U.K. female is 5'4. OP is 5'9, that's 5 inches difference, that is NOT near the average at all fgs.

EarringsandLipstick · 09/07/2022 11:17

GrazingSheep · 09/07/2022 11:10

The Op posted an identical thread a few months ago. She also included a photograph of a girl who she claimed was her daughter
MN deleted the thread.

I remember it.

MadameMinimes · 09/07/2022 11:17

@GrazingSheep I remember that thread very clearly too. A US based mum in the south (I have a hazy memory that they said they were in Texas) with a very tall teenage daughter that the mum thought was overweight but the basketball coach thought was fine. The mother posted a photo of her daughter with other girls the same age who were much shorter and of slighter build. The daughter was tall and solidly built but clearly not fat. Then the thread went poof.