Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my dd is overweight

235 replies

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 06:49

My 15 year old daughter is 6'2 and 220 lbs. I definitely think she is overweight. But, my daughter insists that she is not overweight and she does quite good at basketball. She says that she's athletic. She also claims that she's quite as fast as her teammates(which I think she actually is).

But, the number is too high to believe that she isn't overweight. Also, her basketball coach also thinks she's perfectly healthy.

AIBU to think she is overweight?

OP posts:
SomePosters · 09/07/2022 14:56

Her sports coach thinks she’s fine

why would a bunch of bored people on the internet using outdated, blunt biometrics based on white men to make sweeping statements about a child who they’ve never seen know better than the person who sees her play basketball on the regular?

LargeLegoHaul · 09/07/2022 14:47

Obesity related disease processes are not likely to manifest themselves in a child, things like T2DM, NAFLD, Hypertension, Heart Disease, etc. So from that point of view, although she may be overweight, she’s not at all likely to have any underlying health issues going on, especially so as a sporty, active girl.

a) there is more to health than your list, for a start how do you know that there isn’t an underlying reason for the high height and weight, you don’t without specialist review, and b) T2D at least is increasing in incidence in children so not so without specialist review no you can’t be certain OP’s DD is healthy.

What is far more likely and prevalent in teen girls is Eating Disorders, Mental Health problems, problematic use of drugs and alcohol, etc - all of which the OP will contribute to if she continues to make moves to undermine her daughters self confidence and body image.

Which is why I said OP isn’t going about things in the right way.


The tiny sylph-like little tinkerbells on the thread really need to stay in their lane and stop fuelling the fire that the OP has managed to dream up out of nowhere.

I post as an overweight woman. But thanks for thanks for that. Hmm

Hankunamatata · 09/07/2022 14:37

So max for her height is 188lb so yes she is overweight BUT I'm a stone and half over my max healthy weight and feel ok about it. I'm fit and I'm try to eat better. Iv always been about a stone over my max healthy weight from age 13

ADHDgirls · 09/07/2022 14:36

With all due respect OP you, are a massive arsehole.

Get over yourself and your obsession with her weight it’s unhealthy and you will end up with her cutting you off.

ZealAndArdour · 09/07/2022 14:33

LargeLegoHaul · 09/07/2022 14:11

Again, how can you be certain OP’s DD is healthy when her height and weight centiles are above +4SD and +3SD (which are the highest line) respectively? The charts account for completing puberty.

Obesity related disease processes are not likely to manifest themselves in a child, things like T2DM, NAFLD, Hypertension, Heart Disease, etc. So from that point of view, although she may be overweight, she’s not at all likely to have any underlying health issues going on, especially so as a sporty, active girl.

What is far more likely and prevalent in teen girls is Eating Disorders, Mental Health problems, problematic use of drugs and alcohol, etc - all of which the OP will contribute to if she continues to make moves to undermine her daughters self confidence and body image.

The tiny sylph-like little tinkerbells on the thread really need to stay in their lane and stop fuelling the fire that the OP has managed to dream up out of nowhere. She’s active and comfortable with herself, and OP has given no indication that she’s at all unwell or unhealthy or troubled in her eating habits. A balanced person would be able to see that there is currently no issue at all. It might be appropriate to reassess after puberty and see how things are but at the minute, I think it’s a very, very bad idea to interfere with anything or start her down a path of dieting and weight/body related neurosis.

Ray92 · 09/07/2022 14:14

BMI is an outdated method, especially for anyone who isn't a white male (original study).
It is also proven to be completely inaccurate for many athletes.

Height to waist ratio is thought to be a better indicator of health.
Also, where she carries her weight. I highly doubt she has a large middle, being a basketball player.

Luredbyapomegranate · 09/07/2022 14:12

🤷‍♀️ There’s not a lot you can do if she is happy with her weight. She’s active and feels good both of which count for a lot.

Have healthy meals at home, no junk.

That’s all you can do, end of.

LargeLegoHaul · 09/07/2022 14:11

ZealAndArdour · 09/07/2022 14:02

I mean that reads like the blurb from a child growth chart in the red book alluding to referring for a Failure to Thrive or for a Prader-Willi or Marfans type picture.

At 15 OP’s DD is likely some considerable way through puberty and is also clearly incredibly tall, I’m not sure she’d need referring to paeds at her age or height.

She just needs to be left to get on with her healthy, happy life of sport and being comfortable in herself.

Again, how can you be certain OP’s DD is healthy when her height and weight centiles are above +4SD and +3SD (which are the highest line) respectively? The charts account for completing puberty.

BruceWaynettaSlob · 09/07/2022 14:10

MadameMinimes · 09/07/2022 07:23

The OP posted a picture before. The daughter looked very tall and athletic, not fat.

Gross. Why would you post pictures of your daughter so all the world can gawp at her and judge her? Dick move, op.

Meadowbreeze · 09/07/2022 14:06

Please get therapy for yourself.

ZealAndArdour · 09/07/2022 14:04

GreenWasTheColour · 09/07/2022 13:34

It's absolutely not the case that someone overweight will put on a stone per year.

The best predictor of long-term weight gain is dieting.

So many women have been locked into destructive and painful cycles of dieting from teen or even pre-teen age all the way through their adult lives and have paid for it with ruined health (mental and physical) usually ending up heavier.

A teenage girl who is sporty and active and has a positive body image while also overweight is probably far better off than one who isn't overweight but feels negatively about her body and hears from her mother that being overweight is terrible or a failure.

There are worse things than being overweight in life. Attaching so much shame and panic and weird obsessive projections of future weight gain will damage a child more than them being overweight.

Someone who feels loved and accepted, who loves and accepts themselves and enjoys exercise is much more likely to be happy and healthy than someone who feels judged and ashamed of their weight.

I completely, completely agree with you.

A happy, sporty teenager who is comfortable with her body and appearance is a precious, precious thing and should not be messed with. Her mother needs to stop looking for problems where there are none, or she will create them for her daughter herself.

ZealAndArdour · 09/07/2022 14:02

LargeLegoHaul · 09/07/2022 13:49

If this is true I don’t know how those posters saying OP’s DD is healthy can post that with such certainty when the growth charts say "Children whose growth lies on these outer lines are likely to have additional clinical problems, and if not already receiving medical attention should be referred" and “Children plotting above this line should usually be under specialist review”. Although the OP isn’t going about things in the right way.

I mean that reads like the blurb from a child growth chart in the red book alluding to referring for a Failure to Thrive or for a Prader-Willi or Marfans type picture.

At 15 OP’s DD is likely some considerable way through puberty and is also clearly incredibly tall, I’m not sure she’d need referring to paeds at her age or height.

She just needs to be left to get on with her healthy, happy life of sport and being comfortable in herself.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/07/2022 13:51

MolliciousIntent · 09/07/2022 07:20

BMI is a completely pointless measurement for athletes, because it's not designed for people with a higher than average degree of muscle mass.

How does she look, OP? If she's overweight she'll look it.

For professional athletes maybe, for the rest of us it’s still a good starting point.

LargeLegoHaul · 09/07/2022 13:49

If this is true I don’t know how those posters saying OP’s DD is healthy can post that with such certainty when the growth charts say "Children whose growth lies on these outer lines are likely to have additional clinical problems, and if not already receiving medical attention should be referred" and “Children plotting above this line should usually be under specialist review”. Although the OP isn’t going about things in the right way.

ActualMadness · 09/07/2022 13:44

@LetHimHaveIt you are right it is 15st 10lb

LetHimHaveIt · 09/07/2022 13:42

ActualMadness · 09/07/2022 13:28

220lbs is 15st 7lbs

15 stone 10 lbs, isn't it? If 14 lbs is a stone, then 140 lbs is ten stone. So 210 lbs is fifteen stone. So 220 lbs is fifteen stone and ten pounds.

GreenWasTheColour · 09/07/2022 13:34

It's absolutely not the case that someone overweight will put on a stone per year.

The best predictor of long-term weight gain is dieting.

So many women have been locked into destructive and painful cycles of dieting from teen or even pre-teen age all the way through their adult lives and have paid for it with ruined health (mental and physical) usually ending up heavier.

A teenage girl who is sporty and active and has a positive body image while also overweight is probably far better off than one who isn't overweight but feels negatively about her body and hears from her mother that being overweight is terrible or a failure.

There are worse things than being overweight in life. Attaching so much shame and panic and weird obsessive projections of future weight gain will damage a child more than them being overweight.

Someone who feels loved and accepted, who loves and accepts themselves and enjoys exercise is much more likely to be happy and healthy than someone who feels judged and ashamed of their weight.

ActualMadness · 09/07/2022 13:28

220lbs is 15st 7lbs

RJnomore1 · 09/07/2022 13:21

misskatamari · 09/07/2022 13:07

Ahh nothing like a bit of fat shaming from your own mother to set you up for a life time of self esteem issues, and things that may actually lead to weight gain and an unhealthy relationship with food (eg bingeing, restriction and a big heap of shame). Leave her alone. She's fit and healthy, and your attitude is way more damaging than any excess weight she may or may not be carrying

You called?

CheeseandWhine22 · 09/07/2022 13:11

What is your desired outcome from telling her she is overweight?!

misskatamari · 09/07/2022 13:07

Ahh nothing like a bit of fat shaming from your own mother to set you up for a life time of self esteem issues, and things that may actually lead to weight gain and an unhealthy relationship with food (eg bingeing, restriction and a big heap of shame). Leave her alone. She's fit and healthy, and your attitude is way more damaging than any excess weight she may or may not be carrying

CheeseandWhine22 · 09/07/2022 13:06

You are not unreasonable for thinking she is overweight, but you are unreasonable to tell her so..

I worried that my DD was overweight, but rather than telling her, and giving her a complex, we got into healthy eating, a lot of walking, and drinking tons of water. In the last three months, we have lost quite a few pounds between us. I wasn't overweight before we started this but I didn't want her to go through it alone.

Instead of focusing on her weight, why not focus on ways that she could eat healthy? Because that was the angle I came from as I did not want my child to have a complex.

Please stop arguing with your daughter about her body, not only is this strange, it will not help her self esteem, in the long run.

Nancydrawn · 09/07/2022 13:03

5128gap · 09/07/2022 12:57

It can be very tough for a parent to worry their child may be unhealthy and we are constantly advised being OW is unhealthy. Would you question why it was tough if she was worried her daughter was significantly underweight, as all that matters is that the daughter is happy with her body?

Her daughter is highly active, slightly overweight but confident and athletic, and has an athletic trainer telling her she's in great shape. I don't think that would be the cause for significant worry, no.

It certainly wouldn't lead me to bringing up with her constantly (at an age when women often develop serious eating disorders) or posting repeatedly about it on mums net.

If she were 5'2" and 220 lbs and inactive, you might have a point. As it stands, this seems much more about the OP and her body hangups than about her daughter's health.

5128gap · 09/07/2022 12:57

Nancydrawn · 09/07/2022 12:54

Why is it tough for you?

It can be very tough for a parent to worry their child may be unhealthy and we are constantly advised being OW is unhealthy. Would you question why it was tough if she was worried her daughter was significantly underweight, as all that matters is that the daughter is happy with her body?

SomePosters · 09/07/2022 12:55

It’s myself I am describing. If you want to have a temper about it being used to describe you then be my guest but I am a cis woman and choose to describe myself as such when I think it’s relevant.

you don’t have to like it but maybe stop derailing this thread and go and make one moaning about me on the board I’ve had to hide so that I can enjoy mn without it being spoiled by people like you.