Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my dd is overweight

235 replies

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 06:49

My 15 year old daughter is 6'2 and 220 lbs. I definitely think she is overweight. But, my daughter insists that she is not overweight and she does quite good at basketball. She says that she's athletic. She also claims that she's quite as fast as her teammates(which I think she actually is).

But, the number is too high to believe that she isn't overweight. Also, her basketball coach also thinks she's perfectly healthy.

AIBU to think she is overweight?

OP posts:
fUNNYfACE36 · 10/07/2022 02:08

thebutcherswife · 09/07/2022 07:31

Muscle does not weigh more than fat, it takes up less space as it is more dense but a kg is still a kg whether it’s a kg of feathers or a kilo of rocks.

Oh for gods sake, more dense ( or weighs more fir her size) is what people mean by 'weighs more' , cut the patronising physics lecture
Kg is not a unit if weight anyway if you want to beva smart alec

wellhelloitsme · 10/07/2022 02:04

@XelaM

Of course we may be wrong but there was a thread with a picture that had a very similar background sport wise etc.

I think that's that's what people are remembering and assuming is the same person. Including me.

XelaM · 10/07/2022 01:54

EarringsandLipstick · 09/07/2022 17:45

Oh stop OP. We all remember!

Except if you search by OP's username you will see that she didn't post any pictures of her daughter and only posted one thread about finding her clothes that fit.

XelaM · 10/07/2022 01:45

Muscles weigh more than fat, so if she looks very athletic and is very fast, it's possible that it's muscle rather than fat.

Beanomatica · 10/07/2022 01:37

I'm not desperate to prove anything, and my apologies if Liz Cambage wasn't the perfect example.

I was trying to point out (evidently not very well) that there can be significant differences in stature which mean BMI isn't a clear marker, and we don't know if any of those apply here.

A very petite framed person can be carrying a lot of excess fat even if they are in the middle of the BMI range. Conversely a very broad statured person can be carrying very little body fat at all, but still be classified as overweight according to BMI.

We have both of those body types in my family; I wasn't trying to be hyperbolic. I just think that a bunch of randoms like ourselves cannot possibly advise on whether the OP's daughter is relevantly overweight.

We haven't seen her (and the OP definitely should not post a photo), we don't know her body type, her skin fold measurements, her waist to hip ratio, her arm span or ANYTHING about her. The daughter's basketball coach is likely to be a far better source of advice than us.

The OP clearly has concerns. She does not appear to be a position where she can take an educated, objective, nuanced view about the issue. Neither are we. So trying to do so is unlikely to be helpful for her or her DD.

trailrunner85 · 09/07/2022 20:05

Does she look like Liz Cambage in proportion? Because her measurements are very similar to what the OP describes, and her weight is clearly not an issue

What, professional basketballer Liz Cambage who is seven inches taller than the OP's daughter, yet half a stone lighter?

The Liz Cambage who has a BMI of 23 so is well within the healthy range?

I know there are people on this thread absolutely desperate to prove that being an athlete or being tall means BMI doesn't apply, but you'll have to do better than Liz Cambage.

Snowpatrolling · 09/07/2022 19:05

Careful op,
my mum spent years telling me I was fat and that I eat to much (I wasn’t fat)
I now have serious issues around food because of it which has resulted in me being overweight.
every time I diet/eat healthy exercise, I have my mums nagging voice in the back of my head and I go and eat.
therapy did t help either. You may be causing more damage than you think.

LargeLegoHaul · 09/07/2022 18:50

Liz Cambage is several inches taller, and an adult.

AliceS1994 · 09/07/2022 18:12

She is the exact same height and weight as my husband, a 32 year old bloke

BritWifeInUSA · 09/07/2022 18:05

When did you last speak to the coach? Schools have already been closed for at least a month (in some states two months) for summer now.

Beanomatica · 09/07/2022 17:57

Does she look like Liz Cambage in proportion? Because her measurements are very similar to what the OP describes, and her weight is clearly not an issue. Other basketballers would be similar- it's that they are broad as well as tall, and carry lots of muscle.

If on the other hand she is a very slender frame and not muscular then the weight probably is an issue.

There really is no 1 size fits all. If her coach doesn't think it's a problem, it probably isn't.

Friarclose · 09/07/2022 17:48

My sister is 6'2 and 364lbs. She is obese. Based on that I think 220lbs is fine.

EarringsandLipstick · 09/07/2022 17:45

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 17:35

I dont know where yall getting this info that I posted pictures of my daughter here. Nope, I didn't. Never. Stop.

Oh stop OP. We all remember!

JorisBonson · 09/07/2022 17:42

6'2 and 15 stone isn't huge, especially if she's playing something like basketball.

My DB is 6'4 and 19 stone, he plays rugby and is literally a brick shithouse. Totally solid.

I grew up with a mother who put pressure on me to constantly lose weight and have struggled through body dysmorphia all of my adult life. Please don't do this to her.

Hopeislost · 09/07/2022 17:40

I am a similar height and weight to your daughter. BMI is flawed, and worse for tall people. I am not overweight - I am a size 12 and my waist is 32" which is under half my height. I am naturally broad and muscular and would find it impossible to get into the 'normal' BMI range.

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 17:35

I dont know where yall getting this info that I posted pictures of my daughter here. Nope, I didn't. Never. Stop.

OP posts:
HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 17:33

CheeseandWhine22 · 09/07/2022 17:20

Why on earth would you post pics of your daughter, you massive creep? Does she know you posted the pics? MumsnetHQ, we need a safeguarding button..

Except I didn't post pics of my daughter. Idk how people are saying this trash.

OP posts:
NoWordForFluffy · 09/07/2022 17:32

ZealAndArdour · 09/07/2022 11:46

I think you need to leave her alone.

And all these 5’2 women on the thread with no lived experience of being in a tall womens body who are convinced she must be grotesque and “very overweight” need to pipe down. I think the person above who said that BMI is less useful at the extremes of height was possibly correct.

I’m 6ft and weigh 204lbs making my BMI 27.7 - very similar to the OP‘s daughter proportionally. At this weight I have visible hip bones, all of the bones and musculature of my shoulders and neck area are totally visible with relaxed posture (clavicles, suprasternal notch, etc), the outline of my ribs are seen and easily felt through the skin of my chest wall, my shoulder blades protrude, as does my spine and I can feel my coccyx and ischium making contact with a hard chair when I sit down. I am told that I look very tall and slim and that “there’s nothing on you” in terms of fat/weight.

Well, I'm 5'11" and I'd be / look fat at your weight. We're all different.

CheeseandWhine22 · 09/07/2022 17:20

Why on earth would you post pics of your daughter, you massive creep? Does she know you posted the pics? MumsnetHQ, we need a safeguarding button..

strawberrylacey · 09/07/2022 16:47

What/how much does she eat?

MushyPeasPrincess · 09/07/2022 16:41

In fact, a 2 second google gave an average global height of 5'3. So where did you get 5'7 from please?

MushyPeasPrincess · 09/07/2022 16:30

@EmeraldShamrock1
5'4 might be the average height for women in the UK though taking other countries into consideration, average height for a women is 5'7.

Link for this stat please? I highly doubt it considering the overall global population weighted towards Asia.

MushyPeasPrincess · 09/07/2022 16:23

So HappyMom363 posted in 2019 about her super tall, overweight basketball playing daughter and now you OP @HappyMom1122 are posting about your super tall, overweight basketball playing daughter but that's not you?

Riiiiiiiiigggghhhhhtttt. HmmHmmHmm

Someone has ishooooooos. Mom.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 09/07/2022 15:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HappyMom1122 · 09/07/2022 15:47

Ray92 · 09/07/2022 14:14

BMI is an outdated method, especially for anyone who isn't a white male (original study).
It is also proven to be completely inaccurate for many athletes.

Height to waist ratio is thought to be a better indicator of health.
Also, where she carries her weight. I highly doubt she has a large middle, being a basketball player.

Oh, yeah. She doesn't have a big belly at all.

OP posts: