Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why some MNS are so against believing their kids

38 replies

lailamaria · 09/07/2022 01:43

I see this a lot in threads about parents complaining about their childrens teachers or kids complaining about other children, i understand some kids lie but i think i'd rather take an allegation seriously ie a teacher insulting a child than just let my kid be bullied by their teacher. Obviously if they are lying have consequences but sometimes teachers are arseholes (family of teachers here, the stories i've heard) and kids do need to be listened too.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
zingally · 09/07/2022 10:56

I work in a primary school, which has a secondary school backed onto it. The playgrounds are back to back, and the primary children access their site by a footpath that runs up the side of the secondary yard.

Literally this week, a reception child comes running into the classroom, screaming that there's a bomb on the playground. We're all like "what the F?!" She was hysterical, in floods of tears.

Then mum comes hurrying in, (the kid had legged it in ahead of mum). There's no bomb, there's a fake canon in the secondary school playground. The Royal Navy are there, setting up a display for their cadets.

In my experience of little kids at school. There's always 3 versions of a story. Person 1s version of events, person 2s versions of events, and the actual truth.

WhiskersPete · 09/07/2022 10:42

Teenagers have the ability to take something that happens in a classroom and completely change the context of it so when retold to parents it's completely different. Sometimes it's malicious but mostly it's just how teenagers are but many parents seem to think their 15 year olds have a fully rational adult brain.

A lot of the time the truth js embellished in order by the child to try and exonerate themselves from a consequence for poor behaviour.

As a teacher I have found this to be increasing more over the past couple of years. More parents are becoming very defensive over their children's poor behaviour in the classroom.

Autienotnaughtie · 09/07/2022 10:41

I also listen to my children but am open to alternative perspective. But ultimately until my child lies to me (happened a few times in teen years ) I would believe them.

Svara · 09/07/2022 10:15

Maybe some parents who are inclined to believe their children were lied about as children themselves?

AntlerRose · 09/07/2022 10:00

I wouldnt say not to believe your child but I do think they have their own perspective. Its good to listen to their perspective and then consider others before taking action. I do first aid in a school and a child will say 'x punched me' and it is true. That was the child's experience. But when you investigate and get several eye witness accounts and get the child to act it out, it turns out x was putting on their jacket and got in a muddle and their arm pinged out. Its the same with trips and pushing.
I aldo find children say they were shouted at when someone uses a firm/steen tone but with no raised voice. They feel shouted at.

shufflestep · 09/07/2022 09:41

Sometimes leading questions will mean small children will say things that didn't happen, and it's often not possible to be clear about that. (With very rare exceptions - child comes out of reception class with a bumped head sticker on. Mum says "Did x push you again?". "Yes". X had pushed the child the previous week. Mum comes up to me when I have finished handing over child who's just had a nosebleed to his mum. "What are you going to do about x? She's pushed her again." "X is off sick today, your child ran into someone else.")

Children also wind each other up and turn things into stories between them, plus there is a natural urge to pass on the blame if they have done something wrong - siblings do this, so why not classmates too? The tricky bit is working out the most likely scenario!

ClocksGoingBackwards · 09/07/2022 09:23

Because children’s perceptions of the truth aren’t always the real and full truth. You can believe your child is telling the truth to the best of their ability and still know that you aren’t getting the full story.

Children will innocently omit parts of the story that they don’t realise are important and focus on things that aren’t so important.

It’s just common sense to do what you can to check information before relying on it as the whole truth when it’s been told by a child. The parents that unfailingly believe their children no matter what and refuse to open their minds to any other scenario are usually wrong IME.

Babdoc · 09/07/2022 09:18

My DDs were always very honest and logical, being autistic.
I found out the hard way when I told them off for being silly in a large piano/musical instrument showroom.
I was at the till buying a piano when my then 4 and 5 year olds came rushing up saying that a man’s legs were dangling through the ceiling.
I repeatedly ignored them, until they dragged me round the corner - to where a poor salesman had been up to the attic store room and fallen through the joists! His top half was stuck in the attic, so we hadn’t heard him screaming for help.
They never let me forget that I hadn’t believed or trusted them, so I always did thereafter!

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 09/07/2022 09:17

I think it depends on the child

a friend of mine would always ring me if her children told her something infuriating about school because one particularly would always get the wrong end of the stick and she wanted to check with my children before going in all guns blazing. One highlight was what the new head had said at his first school assembly about the children looking like sacks of potatoes (with a sack of potatoes in a blazer as a demonstration model) except thats not what he’d said

it was a particular skill of ds1 to be able to repeat whole conversations while in junior school, he seemed to lose the ability when he was in senior school 🤔

I would tend to believe my children with something relating to school BUT i also would never go in all guns blazing

Triffid1 · 09/07/2022 09:12

Nothing actually makes me eye roll more than the , "I know my child and he would never say something like that if it isn't true" brigade.

Children lie. I truly believe that it's not usually malicious or sly. But they mosremember, want things to be true, get sucked in etx.

That's not to say an allegation shouldn't be investigated but an open mind is needed.

switswoo81 · 09/07/2022 09:10

Teachers can definitely lie to save themselves but children can see things differently.
I taught my own 6 year old last year and it was fascinating to hear her interpretation of classroom events as she would tell my husband. There were a couple of occasions where I could see how she had arrived at a conclusion through what she had seen but was totally wrong.

Curlywurlycazza · 09/07/2022 09:03

I used to work in the courts. Even with adults there are always two sides to a story. And usually the truth is neither of those versions and somewhere in the middle.

You can believe your child, but also want to find out what the school have to say without going in guns blazing and immediately accusing them of wrong doing.

ComDummings · 09/07/2022 08:51

Kids misunderstand. They do sometimes out and out lie but more often they just get things wrong. Or exaggerate.

Svara · 09/07/2022 08:48

The story I've always been told by DS about any incident at school (usually as soon as I see him, before contact from the school) has always lined up with the teacher's version of events. That, along with a few bad experiences of being lied about by teachers myself as a child, means that if the stories ever didn't line up then I'd be inclined to believe my child.

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 09/07/2022 08:47

I've found with my children, especially my eldest, he'll tell me about something happening at school and it'll start off truthful and then he'll start exaggerating and adding more and more until it becomes total lies. I think he just gets caught up in his own imagination.
Sometimes kids do lie, or massively embellish.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 09/07/2022 08:46

I think you'll find that most posts about believing the teachers and not the children come from teachers.

Quackingonthepond · 09/07/2022 08:43

No, I’ve definitely seen threads go like that with no real provocation. There was an awful one a couple of weeks ago.

donquixotedelamancha · 09/07/2022 08:38

there are a significant minority that insist it didn’t happen, the teacher can’t have done it and the kid was probably misbehaving anyway.

When there are a lot of posts like that on a thread it's usually because the OP or others are insisting that an unlikely tale is true and people become equally strident. Nuance is lost quickly on SM.

ChickenOfTheSea · 09/07/2022 08:32

Many are teachers or work with young people or have no children. People tend to be more sceptical and perhaps neutral when it comes to other people's children.

Quackingonthepond · 09/07/2022 07:34

But also, adults do sometimes misremember things.

I remember my mother being adamant that I’d fallen out with some other girls on a sleepover and she’d had to collect me the next day. This didn’t happen. To this day I don’t know if she just made it up in her own mind and started believing it or whether she mixed it with another occasion. But she was wrong.

She did also lie sometimes about what she’d said. She was a teacher, it wouldn’t have surprised me if she lied about her students.

ThisIsNotARealAvo · 09/07/2022 07:29

I have this at work all the time. Kids sometimes outright lie but usually it's because they haven't fully understood what's happened.

One parent came and asked me why her child had only had 'pasta and cabbage' for lunch. They had actually had spaghetti bolognaise with salad. Another parent really angry her child had not had an apple a fruit time. Apparently she was the only one. No, fruit was pear that day and her child hadn't wanted one.

At my school we do a lot of work with the new reception parents about how children can only tell us what they remember and to come and ask if they are not sure what's gone on,

Agree with the pp who said that the 'my kids don't lie' brigade are usually the parents of the biggest liars and troublemakers because what they mean is "I believe everything my kids say and if it's something I don't like I kick off and they like to wind me up and watch me go".

VikingVolva · 09/07/2022 07:05

Experience.

Generally truthful DC can get the wrong end of the stick, or only tell the first half of the story, or exaggerate, or many other permutations of trying things out and sometimes getting it wrong.

It's always worth finding out, of course, but in a genuine spirit of enquiry. Not assuming the worst of others. Because unless and until you actually find a cause for concern, go with the numbers - DC misrepresenting events is extremely common. Abuse in schools is not.

DangerNoodles · 09/07/2022 07:04

We always tell children about the boy who cried wolf, but I think adults need to keep in mind too that kids do lie, sometimes they have misinterpreted the situation or remembered events incorrectly. Despite this we should always give them the benefit of the doubt and investigate just in case.

winniesanderson · 09/07/2022 07:00

Experience with my two, plus many other children over the years (work with children) has taught me that they do sometimes misremember, misread situations, embellish, exaggerate etc.

I had a conversation with my 13 year old last night where she was convinced that I'd pulled one of her loose teeth out when she was 6/7. There is no way this happened - wobbly teeth give me the ick! And actually I remember that particular tooth because she refused to eat or drink for several days due to it and it eventually fell out over night thank god. She will often say I've agreed to things when I haven't, my youngest is always full of stories that may or may not have happened (but she's a lot younger, so kind of standard!)
At work I see it all the time, "X just punched me!" No, they accidentally walked into you. Etc.

I think it's just important to be open minded in situations where we haven't got both sides to a story. If my children came home saying they'd been called names or bullied I would want to have a conversation with their teacher, but I wouldn't go in guns blazing.

Quackingonthepond · 09/07/2022 06:58

There are definitely a lot of posts that encourage checking but there are a significant minority that insist it didn’t happen, the teacher can’t have done it and the kid was probably misbehaving anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread