Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Occupational health sending report to my manager that contains really personal things - AIBU

83 replies

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 17:09

I've been off work due to poor mental health, and as part of my return to work I have had a meeting with occupational health. It was a long meeting that was really personal and they have written up a report to send to my manager and HR. I asked to see the report before it gets sent, and it's really upset me to be honest. It's so personal and talks about things I wouldn't even tell my closest friends. AIBU to want to edit it to remove a lot of the details? For example, it mentions things about me struggling to get out of bed, isolating myself from my friends and things I've worried about.

It's made the return to work process even more stressful as I categorically do not want my line manager to know all of this about me.

Does anyone have any experience in this to know if I'm being unreasonable? The report also includes a back to work plan with actionable steps and targets - surely that's the important part rather than hearing all about my personal struggles?

OP posts:
topcat2014 · 08/07/2022 19:52

Not sure how people think you can't be sacked for being off for five weeks. Not everyone is on the public sector etc.

DasGirl · 08/07/2022 19:49

Another HR person here. I didn't realise we were the most hated profession on Mumsnet

Second only to teachers @CleanQueen123 judging by threads this week Hmm

Girliegirl83 · 08/07/2022 19:47

You did not have to consent to them receiving your medical records. I never have.

Edit the document and delete everything you don't want shared. Even if it's a pdf you should be able to open it in word.

DasGirl · 08/07/2022 19:47

edits I want to make are basically removing most of the report and just leaving the actionable steps and maybe some of the more work-related things. I'm not sure if I can do that though,

Yes you absolutely can. I've seen many reports like this. They are paying an occupational health provider for their professional opinion.

So the report can say
" I have assessed thfgre45tyhgfd today and, due to mental health difficulties, she remains unfit for work at present. She continues to receive treatment from her GP and CPN and she will remain unfit for work for a further 2 months"
OR "thfgre45tyhgfd should be able to return to work in X weeks and I would recommend Y adjustments are made to her role during a 4 week phased return"

That's actually all the info HR and your manager need

StrawberriesAndCreamPlease · 08/07/2022 19:39

It’s entirely up to you the information shared with your manager. You have the final say.

EmilyBolton · 08/07/2022 19:36

CleanQueen123 · 08/07/2022 19:34

Another HR person here. I didn't realise we were the most hated profession on Mumsnet. Second HR bashing thread I've seen this week.

You absolutely have the right to remove any information you don't feel comfortable sharing. In my organisation employees have 14 days to review the report and request changes before it's sent.

I would agree though that they do need some level of detail to be able to give proper recommendations and for management to understand the extent of your illness.

I've seen some reports that are so vague it makes it sound like the employee is just a bit sad sometimes when actually they're very unwell.

It's hard for HR to advise and support if we don't know the full picture.

You’re not by people who actually understand what your job is 🤣🤷🏼‍♀️There are just a lot of people who think you should act like a union rep 🤦‍♀️

EmilyBolton · 08/07/2022 19:34

AngeloMysterioso · 08/07/2022 18:31

LOL a few years ago I was signed off work for 5 weeks due to depression and the only thing HR were interested in was getting rid of me. I’ve never worked for a company where HR actually gives a fuck about the employees.

First HR are part of the management team, I don’t know why people think they should act like a union shop steward.

but HR must operate within the law. Private medical information is not allowed to be shared without express permission.
Of course the OP can insist that the report sent to HR and in particular her manager is amended. Occ health wrote an account of what was di#cussed but that doesn’t mean the OP has Given her permission for it to be sent out in an unedited form

Op, act fast. Call occ health asap and say they are NOT to send it out in its current format and that it must be edited first with your review and approval. Send an email too today so you have documented evidence you’ve said it’s not ok.

And with best will in the world, do remember in future that occ health are paid for by company and will want to report back on what you’ve discussed. You can be open and forthright about what’s happening, what you’re struggling with but be judicious about what you say bearing in mind HR would normally want to see the notes. Focus on what you need form company and be honest about what you are doing to help yourself recover and take any advice given seriously.

CleanQueen123 · 08/07/2022 19:34

Another HR person here. I didn't realise we were the most hated profession on Mumsnet. Second HR bashing thread I've seen this week.

You absolutely have the right to remove any information you don't feel comfortable sharing. In my organisation employees have 14 days to review the report and request changes before it's sent.

I would agree though that they do need some level of detail to be able to give proper recommendations and for management to understand the extent of your illness.

I've seen some reports that are so vague it makes it sound like the employee is just a bit sad sometimes when actually they're very unwell.

It's hard for HR to advise and support if we don't know the full picture.

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 19:33

This is also a third party company rather than my employer, not sure if that makes a difference?

I've been told I can make edits, but the edits I want to make are basically removing most of the report and just leaving the actionable steps and maybe some of the more work-related things. I'm not sure if I can do that though, as I guess my employer is paying for them to provide a report and if I cut all of that out is that even allowed?

I had to give permission for them to access my medical records and permission to share the report with my manager and HR. But I would like to write something in the email saying I don't consent to that personal information being shared and want to almost revoke that consent if that makes sense, but I don't know if that will mean I'm not complying with the process and my employer will be annoyed?

I'm not sure whether to mention to HR/my manager that I found the report quite intrusive and overly personal. I know mental health difficulties mean that the issue is personal, but it is so detailed I wouldn't even want friends or family reading it, let alone my employer.

It's so bad that my first thought was to just hand in my notice and not return to work rather than having my manager know all of that about me.

OP posts:
user1471459761 · 08/07/2022 19:32

I'm not in HR so I don't know the norm but I do have a manager I would not share my vulnerabilities with. Just amend up the note as you would like your manager to see it and say you don't consent to share anything else. Hopefully that is the end of it.

Girliegirl83 · 08/07/2022 19:31

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 19:23

No, I understood the purpose of the meeting and I'm usually a very private and guarded person. Even in my GP appointments I'm quite conscious of how much detail I want to divulge. I think the issue is the meeting was so detailed and in-depth that I couldn't really avoid it as the questions themselves were very personal. They asked about every area of my life and my short answers were then followed by lots of follow-up questions.

I guess you didn't defend yourself because you aren't feeling too good? I get that. Next time remember you don't have to answer any question you don't want.

alltheevennumbers · 08/07/2022 19:27

If they don't remove the detail you request you could always revoke your consent to them holding or sharing your sensitive personal data and ask them to delete it? Ask to speak to their data controller?

ThirtyThreeTrees · 08/07/2022 19:26

I'd received a few occupational reports over the years.

I only remember one which was very detailed & that person was recovering after a car crash.

Any of the others which were as a result of stress, depression, anxiety, bereavement or non visible matters were usually very vague in nature.

They usually read as follows:

X attended for their scheduled appointment on day/time.
I am advised their own gp has recommended a further sick cert of x weeks
I concur with this or I expect this to be extended by a further X number of weeks
X is not a position to return to work or I recommend a phased return to work as follows or while X has expressed an interest to return to work, I believe that this would be premature.

As a manager I don't need any additional details, unless the colleague wants me to know them and have never requested them. If a medical professional says someone isn't fit for work, then who am I to challenge it.

Ask them to take out anything personal.

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 19:23

Girliegirl83 · 08/07/2022 18:52

You absolutely can request the personal information be taken out.

Maybe because you are depressed op but did you miss the purpose of the meeting? They are ultimately there on behalf of your company. You obviously chose to tell them a lot of personal stuff which was obviously not ideal. I do feel for you. I'm just wondering why you told them.

No, I understood the purpose of the meeting and I'm usually a very private and guarded person. Even in my GP appointments I'm quite conscious of how much detail I want to divulge. I think the issue is the meeting was so detailed and in-depth that I couldn't really avoid it as the questions themselves were very personal. They asked about every area of my life and my short answers were then followed by lots of follow-up questions.

OP posts:
thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 19:20

The meeting itself was really intense - around an hour long and very specific questions. I'm a very private person so I thought I had been quite vague but because there were so many questions it was hard not to give personal information. For example, I was asked to describe my social life and then how it was when my mental health was at its worst so I said something like 'yeah I have some close friends, but when my mental health was at its worst I guess I just kind of kept it all to myself' and that got turned into '[My name] described how she isolated herself from close ones'.

I did mention in the call I was concerned about the report as a lot of the questions had been personal, and I was told that it would be written in more of a professional way but it hasn't really. I wasn't offered to have it sent to me first, I had to request that as otherwise it would have just gone straight to HR and my manager. It has things like '[My name] described how she had difficulty in keeping up with personal care, although this is now better'. I don't want my manager knowing I struggled with this. I'm so upset by it.

OP posts:
roastedbroccoli · 08/07/2022 19:05

I'm astonished tbh the OH reports I've seen have been exceptionally vague/sensitively worded? Certainly not specific details about e.g. not being able to get out of bed. Some of the reports were almost cryptic.

I thought the point was that they needed to be specific/detailed regarding the recommendations because that is what the employer needs to consider, as opposed to the details of the precipitating illness.

DasGirl · 08/07/2022 19:00

HCP here
Occ health provide a report and advice to your manager on your fitness to return to work and any reasonable adjustments they may need to make.

BUT there is absolutely no need for them to disclose all your medical details in order to provide the advice.
You can absolutely request this is not to be shared with any non- medical person such as your manager

Girliegirl83 · 08/07/2022 18:52

You absolutely can request the personal information be taken out.

Maybe because you are depressed op but did you miss the purpose of the meeting? They are ultimately there on behalf of your company. You obviously chose to tell them a lot of personal stuff which was obviously not ideal. I do feel for you. I'm just wondering why you told them.

devildeepbluesea · 08/07/2022 18:51

DecentPleasant · 08/07/2022 18:48

HR are there to protect the employer, not to care.

HR are there to minimise risk for the employer. Sometimes that means they have to care.

Ivgotasecretcanyoukeepit · 08/07/2022 18:51

To be fair as an employer it is reasonable to understand the triggers for sickness absence particularly if the absence is either continuous or likely to occur again. When looking at absence triggers it does help to have the facts around the absence to ensure the correct and reasonable support is put into place to support good attendance so I don’t see what the issue is really.

DecentPleasant · 08/07/2022 18:48

HR are there to protect the employer, not to care.

Waterfallgirl · 08/07/2022 18:40

You have to give your consent for any information from the meeting to be shared - but of course your personal information could be removed whilst still leaving the ‘what can you do to help @thfgre45tyhgfd return to work/ get better / reasonable adjustments’
I would call occ health and request them to remove the elements which you want to remain confidential. Follow that up with a written copy / email of what you want to be removed .

CatiaR · 08/07/2022 18:36

And 5 weeks is not enough time to dismiss anyone. You would have had grounds for unfair dismissal

SnowyLamb · 08/07/2022 18:35

I think I've understood correctly that they've sent it to you first, as requested? That's why they do it. If there's things you want removing tell them that.

CatiaR · 08/07/2022 18:34

AngeloMysterioso · 08/07/2022 18:31

LOL a few years ago I was signed off work for 5 weeks due to depression and the only thing HR were interested in was getting rid of me. I’ve never worked for a company where HR actually gives a fuck about the employees.

Well I agree that not all HR is the same and some do act that way. Personally in the company I work for that is not the case and we support the employees as much as we can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread