Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Occupational health sending report to my manager that contains really personal things - AIBU

83 replies

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 17:09

I've been off work due to poor mental health, and as part of my return to work I have had a meeting with occupational health. It was a long meeting that was really personal and they have written up a report to send to my manager and HR. I asked to see the report before it gets sent, and it's really upset me to be honest. It's so personal and talks about things I wouldn't even tell my closest friends. AIBU to want to edit it to remove a lot of the details? For example, it mentions things about me struggling to get out of bed, isolating myself from my friends and things I've worried about.

It's made the return to work process even more stressful as I categorically do not want my line manager to know all of this about me.

Does anyone have any experience in this to know if I'm being unreasonable? The report also includes a back to work plan with actionable steps and targets - surely that's the important part rather than hearing all about my personal struggles?

OP posts:
timbee2b · 08/07/2022 20:35

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:30

They were not a medical professional at all, so not a doctor, nurse, therapist, etc.

This makes no sense. How did they introduce themself to you?

hedwigismyowl · 08/07/2022 20:35

user976577 · 08/07/2022 20:27

Can I hijack this thread and ask someone with knowledge if you have a OH report does it go into your employment file for future managers to look at or is it just relevant to the manager at the time of the illness?

Think the answer will depend on the organisation and the rules it operates in.

I'm a manager and where I work, the OH report goes into the personnel file and stays there until the end of employment. On a practical level, I wouldn't go looking for one unless it would be relevant to the current issue or sickness absence. The other reason would be for me to find out when the last time you were referrred to OH if you had recurrent sicknesses, just so I could get an up to picture of what support you may need.

I don't go rummaging around in staff files for 2 reasons:
1- I have no reason to most of the time, only done if I'm looking for something specific, ie on a need to know basis.
2- I have no time or inclination to sit and read everyone's file, I've got a day job to do.

Everyone thinks personnel files are interesting to read, newsflash- they're not!

Snoopymcsnoopface · 08/07/2022 20:35

OP please don't get yourself upset snd stressed about this. Occupation health must get your sign off and permission to share anything that has been discussed, with your manager/HR dept/work

One of my direct reports is under OH, we use BUPA, although BUPA are the umbrella for the majority of OH companies, and they will not share anything that you ask them not to.
They have a duty to record everything you discuss with them, but you still do get final sign off before its submitted .

However do remember that your work cannot help you and make reasonable adjustments to help you through your difficult time if they don't know what's affecting you.
Maybe ask OH to reword the report so it's less personal but don't remove everything entirely.

Watapalava · 08/07/2022 20:33

I’m a manager and OH reports come to me first and then I pass to the colleague for their approvql

it is me who gives them the copy not the other way round

CleanQueen123 · 08/07/2022 20:32

user976577 · 08/07/2022 20:27

Can I hijack this thread and ask someone with knowledge if you have a OH report does it go into your employment file for future managers to look at or is it just relevant to the manager at the time of the illness?

I can only speak for my company but we have a portal that HR access and the current manager of the individual would be able to see the report but not all managers or any future manager. The reports stay there. We don't put them on the employee's general personnel file.

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:30

They were not a medical professional at all, so not a doctor, nurse, therapist, etc.

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 08/07/2022 20:30

Take out as much as you want and say that you do not consent to the answers you gave being shared with your manager. You can also state that you were not aware of the details that would be asked when you gave your original consent therefore as you were not adequately informed, that consent is not valid.

midairchallenger · 08/07/2022 20:29

When I saw OH they actually made a point of saying some of the details my employer had requested were none of the employer's business and irrelevant to them as an employer - and therefore OH would not be providing that information and I should not feel I had to disclose it either. (And they suggested it would be in my interest NOT to disclose.)

For instance, employer had requested details of medications and doses. OH's view was that all they needed to know was that I was on an appropriate treatment regime and any impact on work (e.g. common examples re medication and work are people who need a slightly later work start time as medication makes them groggy in the morning; not being able to operate machinery; needing to self-inject at work, etc).

On that example, OH also observed that HR were not doctors so telling them details of medication wouldn't be useful to them anyway - because they weren't qualified to know if that was appropriate medication or what the side effects were so what were they going to do with the info except hit Google and come up with ignorant conclusions. OH considered it an entirely inappropriate and intrusive question.

My OH were very clear on what information was appropriate and relevant to employer, they were not prepared to go on a fishing expedition. It is a shame the person you're dealing with lacks that experience and expertise, but you are right to assert your boundaries. It is necessary and better over the long term.

Your employer isn't entitled to know "context" of how you are affected in your personal life - the section on how work is affected and how they can support you is perfectly sufficient and constructive. That is all they should have requested in the first place.

user976577 · 08/07/2022 20:27

Can I hijack this thread and ask someone with knowledge if you have a OH report does it go into your employment file for future managers to look at or is it just relevant to the manager at the time of the illness?

100problems · 08/07/2022 20:21

Another HR here, loved and hated in equal measure. Our job is to advise management how to operate within employment law, we are not all arseholes and I've successfully supported colleagues back into work with OH guidance more times than I've ever used an OH report as a tool to terminate (although in certain cases where OH cannot see a return in the foreseeable future that may eventually be an outcome).

I assume you spoke to a clinician given the timeframes. Your consent form should have given you the choice to review the report or send it to your employer simultaneously. Also whether you give consent for OH to obtain reports from your GP.

Your employers side of the referral will have asked the Clinician to ask for information such as the nature of your absence, a foreseeable return to work date and salient information that would enable HR and your manager to support you eg with reasonable adjustments, phased return etc.

My guidance would be to seriously consider, embarrassment to one side, whether the information you've given enables that. Could be that your withdrawal is actually relevant as it may point to heightened levels of anxiety which would support a phased return. No point coming back full time and having to go sick again because you're not ready.

Ask for reasonable edits, but try and leave in information that actually helps your Employer to help you.

MarshaMelrose · 08/07/2022 20:12

I’ve never worked for a company where HR actually gives a fuck about the employees.

😂Quite.
I remember the days when it was called Personnel and their job was to help the staff. Then one day it all became Human Resources and their job was to screw the staff.

Manuuuu32 · 08/07/2022 20:12

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:00

Thank you all, I've been given the weekend to make any edits to it so I'll do that and get it sent by Sunday night. I didn't feel like I could make any drastic changes but you've all given me the confidence to be more assertive about what information I do not want shared, so thank you.

Like I've mentioned, I'm a very private person so on the call I was really conscious of what I was saying and trying to be as evasive as possible, but it was the way the questions were asked. There were lots of yes or no follow-up questions

Good for you op. Stand your ground. You can't take back something once it's out there. I'm sorry you are in such a vulnerable position. Good luck

EarringsandLipstick · 08/07/2022 20:11

They are ultimately there on behalf of your company. You obviously chose to tell them a lot of personal stuff which was obviously not ideal. I do feel for you. I'm just wondering why you told them

That's absolutely not how our OH works.

They are as much there for the employee, if not more.

The review is carried out by an experienced doctor and all the usual rules of patient confidentiality apply.

OP has done nothing wrong or inadvisable here

Manuuuu32 · 08/07/2022 20:10

CleanQueen123 · 08/07/2022 19:34

Another HR person here. I didn't realise we were the most hated profession on Mumsnet. Second HR bashing thread I've seen this week.

You absolutely have the right to remove any information you don't feel comfortable sharing. In my organisation employees have 14 days to review the report and request changes before it's sent.

I would agree though that they do need some level of detail to be able to give proper recommendations and for management to understand the extent of your illness.

I've seen some reports that are so vague it makes it sound like the employee is just a bit sad sometimes when actually they're very unwell.

It's hard for HR to advise and support if we don't know the full picture.

Like most things in life having a bad experience with a few people in a role tends to put people off for life.

And if the gutless wit in my previous company happens to be on here, I hope you've learned from being a sheep and your new linked in profile has really amused me.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/07/2022 20:09

DasGirl · 08/07/2022 19:00

HCP here
Occ health provide a report and advice to your manager on your fitness to return to work and any reasonable adjustments they may need to make.

BUT there is absolutely no need for them to disclose all your medical details in order to provide the advice.
You can absolutely request this is not to be shared with any non- medical person such as your manager

Exactly.

I'm a manager (in Ireland so maybe it's different) but this is what I'm used to.

I receive advice re the individual's fitness to work, and reasonable adjustments needed. That's it.

I don't know any details regarding their medical condition unless it's pertinent to helping them eg I was made aware that a particular accommodation was needed for a team member because of their hearing loss.

I think you absolutely can make sure that your personal medical information is protected.

DasGirl · 08/07/2022 20:08

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:04

They weren't a medical professional, maybe occupational health was the wrong term but they are within that kind of field.

They were probably a qualified occupational health nurse

CleanQueen123 · 08/07/2022 20:04

EmilyBolton · 08/07/2022 19:36

You’re not by people who actually understand what your job is 🤣🤷🏼‍♀️There are just a lot of people who think you should act like a union rep 🤦‍♀️

I think I spend half my life explaining that to people. I don't think we can win. We're either fluffy bunny and don't bring any value or people think we're uncaring monsters looking to sack people at the earliest opportunity 🙄

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:04

They weren't a medical professional, maybe occupational health was the wrong term but they are within that kind of field.

OP posts:
LemonGelato · 08/07/2022 20:01

Another HR person here and I agree with previous posters that you CAN edit the report but also that vague, waffly OH reports don't help anyone. There has to be some detail in it to be of use.

Think about it from the perspective of what HR/line manager need to know in order to help you in the workplace. Then take out or rewrite the really personal bits that you don't feel comfortable with.

For example, it's helpful if I know someone has a diagnosis of bipolar or severe clinical depression or cancer or whatever, but if it's not in the report then I can still assist so long as there is a good desciption of the issues. A diagnosis doesn't tell me how it is affecting that individual so it's important the symptoms and treatments and ideas for reasonable adjustments are in the report.

I wouldn't see it as you not co-operating if you edit the report or ask for changes to be made, so long as there is enough left in it to give a clear picture of the problems you are facing and the help you need to return to work and maintain that over time. If you take so much out you make it really bland that won't help you at all. I know having personal stuff in an OH report can feel very vulnerable and scary but you do have to let some of that fear (and possibly embarrassment) go.

Oh and not all HR people - or line managers - are arseholes, incompetent or out to get staff, such as some posters seem to think. But we also aren't the trade union rep and nor are we counsellors, that's unrealistic. You should however expect a professional approach that follows your organisational policies whilst treating you respectfully.

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:00

Thank you all, I've been given the weekend to make any edits to it so I'll do that and get it sent by Sunday night. I didn't feel like I could make any drastic changes but you've all given me the confidence to be more assertive about what information I do not want shared, so thank you.

Like I've mentioned, I'm a very private person so on the call I was really conscious of what I was saying and trying to be as evasive as possible, but it was the way the questions were asked. There were lots of yes or no follow-up questions

OP posts:
Heroicallyl0st · 08/07/2022 19:58

Really surprised they asked to access your medical records. Can you ask to retract your permission? Presuming you’re not in a job where physical health/fitness has to be assessed like the army etc?

EmilyBolton · 08/07/2022 19:58

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 19:20

The meeting itself was really intense - around an hour long and very specific questions. I'm a very private person so I thought I had been quite vague but because there were so many questions it was hard not to give personal information. For example, I was asked to describe my social life and then how it was when my mental health was at its worst so I said something like 'yeah I have some close friends, but when my mental health was at its worst I guess I just kind of kept it all to myself' and that got turned into '[My name] described how she isolated herself from close ones'.

I did mention in the call I was concerned about the report as a lot of the questions had been personal, and I was told that it would be written in more of a professional way but it hasn't really. I wasn't offered to have it sent to me first, I had to request that as otherwise it would have just gone straight to HR and my manager. It has things like '[My name] described how she had difficulty in keeping up with personal care, although this is now better'. I don't want my manager knowing I struggled with this. I'm so upset by it.

It does sound quite intrusive OP.
I’ve been off twice with during my 30 year career depression/anxiety/stress. And for a couple f other reasons that occ health needed to review. In all cases occ health asked questions in a very open style. The focus was on what had triggered/ caused it (they want to know if it is work related or a personal issue such as bereavement, divorce etc so thy can assess what they need/ can do to eliminate triggers). Then they wanted to know what support and treatment I was having..stuff like how often I was seeing Gp, was I lined up to see a therapist, was I being prescribed meds etc. They would be trying to assess how long I was likely to Be off for but even then they need to be careful not to put pressure on sick person . They would offer advise and reinforce what GP would say like ensuring I got out for a walk everyday, asking if I had people to support me, but just standard stuff that is part of treatment plan for any mental health condition.
Never once was I asked to describe my symptoms- that sounds like they were trying to diagnose you. If you have a sick note form GP that states the nature of your illness they really shouldn’t be doing that- it is massively overstepping and is coming from a position of not trusting your GP to have diagnosed you properly.
was the person a qualified doctor- if so yep, definitely over reaching but probably no harm done based on you being able to editing report that goes out to company . If it was not a qualified doctor you need to desk to HR. Tell them or perhaps better write it n an email, that you are really distressed by the intrusiveness of that interview, that it is now causing you more stress and distress becuase of the report documenting some really personal stuff that you felt you were obliged to disclose despite your discomfort, and that they need to feed that back to whoever provided the occ health specialist. Say you do not want to speak to that person agian but will speak to someone else.

HR have a duty of care. If the occ health interview has made you more anxious or stressed they need to know and they will want to cover themselves to ensure it doesn’t happen again.

To be honest I’d send an email anyway to Hr to tell them how distressing you found the whole thing and how you are stressing about it. No one should feel like that.

Fenella123 · 08/07/2022 19:57

Was the person preparing the report quite junior, OP? It's just I can imagine many decent managers really not wanting to know that level of detail either, it puts them in a bit of an awkward position. My line managers would just want to have a broad idea of what was wrong but mainly need to know what the recommendations were for moving forward.

Think about it - if someone broke a leg, the manager doesn't want.a picture of the bones sticking out or details of the infection you got during traction! Just details about how to deal with the return to work safely.

Girliegirl83 · 08/07/2022 19:56

Waterfallgirl · 08/07/2022 19:53

Occupational health are independent medical professionals they are absolutely not there on behalf of the company. They have professional codes of ethics and standards to uphold.

Apologies then

Waterfallgirl · 08/07/2022 19:53

Girliegirl83 · 08/07/2022 18:52

You absolutely can request the personal information be taken out.

Maybe because you are depressed op but did you miss the purpose of the meeting? They are ultimately there on behalf of your company. You obviously chose to tell them a lot of personal stuff which was obviously not ideal. I do feel for you. I'm just wondering why you told them.

Occupational health are independent medical professionals they are absolutely not there on behalf of the company. They have professional codes of ethics and standards to uphold.