Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Occupational health sending report to my manager that contains really personal things - AIBU

83 replies

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 17:09

I've been off work due to poor mental health, and as part of my return to work I have had a meeting with occupational health. It was a long meeting that was really personal and they have written up a report to send to my manager and HR. I asked to see the report before it gets sent, and it's really upset me to be honest. It's so personal and talks about things I wouldn't even tell my closest friends. AIBU to want to edit it to remove a lot of the details? For example, it mentions things about me struggling to get out of bed, isolating myself from my friends and things I've worried about.

It's made the return to work process even more stressful as I categorically do not want my line manager to know all of this about me.

Does anyone have any experience in this to know if I'm being unreasonable? The report also includes a back to work plan with actionable steps and targets - surely that's the important part rather than hearing all about my personal struggles?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Waterfallgirl · 12/07/2022 21:14

alltheevennumbers · 10/07/2022 18:42

So Movers, do explain how that works in respect of a) the common law duty of confidentiality and b) the GDPR?

I’m quite shocked that @Moversnotshakers works in OH as they should know that you can consent (or not) to information being disclosed . Plus any professional OH team will not disclose information about the persons medical history to their manager ( following their own duty of confidentiality as a clinician ) so, only the information the employer needs to be able to make a decision on next steps is disclosed. Enough to help the manager make a decision on reasonable adjustments for example or at times when the person cannot return to work for redeployment or ill health retirement etc.
Wishing you good luck op.

thfgre45tyhgfd · 11/07/2022 00:51

I've gone through the report and removed a few things but left most of it in so that there is enough context. I'm never going to be strong/open enough to verbally say those things to my manager so I might as well let the report explain what I've been going through. I went through it with a close friend which helped to get a second opinion

OP posts:
alltheevennumbers · 10/07/2022 18:42

Moversnotshakers · 09/07/2022 13:44

I work in OH . If u request to see the report before your employer, its normally 48 hours only then.it would sent off to your HR. The referral document HR send to OH has lots of questions,( tick boxes) so the OH nurse would probably just be respnding to the HR questions and maybe elaborating but if you didnt want things shared you maybe shouldnt have disclosed those things.

So Movers, do explain how that works in respect of a) the common law duty of confidentiality and b) the GDPR?

ChateauMargaux · 09/07/2022 17:23

@Moversnotshakers .. your final sentence concerns me but perhaps its an issue of brevity and lack of tone.

The OP is a vulnerable person who was 'ordered' to attend this meeting as part of her employment obligations. At the time that she gave her consent to sharing information she was not aware of the depth of information that would be required. This makes the original consent invalid and she should retain the right to revoke consent at any time.

It is also disengenious to say she shouldn't have given details of her treatment ifnshe didn't want to have them shared... she has repeatedly said she felt she had to give more details and justify her illness.

The details may have been required for the OH consultant to make their assessment but she should be able to request that the details which are not relevant to any decisions relating to returning to work and adjustments remain confidential.

Moversnotshakers · 09/07/2022 13:44

I work in OH . If u request to see the report before your employer, its normally 48 hours only then.it would sent off to your HR. The referral document HR send to OH has lots of questions,( tick boxes) so the OH nurse would probably just be respnding to the HR questions and maybe elaborating but if you didnt want things shared you maybe shouldnt have disclosed those things.

midairchallenger · 09/07/2022 13:19

Your medication details should not be in an OH report.

All an employer needs to know is that you are receiving appropriate treatment and any side effects relevant to your work.

In fact, providing medication specifics does not actually provide them with the information they need as an employer, because they do not have the medical expertise to interpret that data (something they have in common with the OH person it seems).

VerveClique · 09/07/2022 11:50

Thank you OP.

Having been in that terrible brain fog position myself at time, just decide what you’re going to do now (request to edit the report) then do it (but not too much) and decide to leave it at that for now.

Your employer should then want to have a conversation with you about whether you see yourself returning to work in the foreseeable future, and what they might be able to do to support you in that. Just be honest but understand that even if they are compelled to make adjustments, they aren’t obliged to keep you in your role indefinitely, so you have nothing to lose.

look at the Acas code on discipline and grievance… even though they’re dealing with your ill health they have to follow this in terms of meetings, escalation, putting things in writing etc.

then…. easy for me to say but after you’ve taken each step just wait for your employer to take the text step, and try to rest and avoid ruminating on it.

I wish you well x

thfgre45tyhgfd · 09/07/2022 11:32

The report also includes the medication I'm on and the dosages, I don't see how that's relevant either. My manager and HR aren't medical professionals, why do they need to know what medication I'm on. Fair enough for it to say 'X started taking antidepressants X months ago' but the exact medication and dosages - they have no need for that information.

The more I think about it all the more upset I get to be honest. I'm fine with leaving in some information as I get that my manager and HR need to know some of the context, but this is way too much information. I think, on my end, I almost felt like I needed to prove how unwell I had been, as if I would be accused that I hadn't been ill enough to not be at work.

@VerveClique Yes thank you, I found your post really helpful.

OP posts:
Windywuss · 09/07/2022 09:53

@latetothefisting is right. Mine did comment in whether I'd engaged with the process fully or not..

Hope you are ok @thfgre45tyhgfd . I found it very difficult.

latetothefisting · 08/07/2022 22:41

Op I've also had a weird occ health report. Some of the comments above are very victim blaming. If people are asking you very direct questions it can be hard to repeatedly say, "I don't want to answer that," particularly if you're not sure how that will be interpreted (e.g. if you're being defensive or not engaging with the process), and if it's a mental health issue you're struggling with, you're usually not going to be at your most resilient anyway!

I would go in asking the report to remove as much non-essential information as possible, and say if your manager comes back to OH and says they require more detail you'll consider then what you're happy to disclose. If you feel up to it I would 100% raise your concerns generally about the report with HR too - you can say you've spoken to 'friends' working in the sector and they were surprised at the level of unnecessary detail the report included. I would expect the OH person to make it very clear at the start that everything you said would be fed back, and also make sure you are sent a version to check. I raised this as an issue when I did mine, I wasn't sent a copy at all, let alone before it was sent to my manager! My manager started to discuss sections of it with me and I had to say I had no idea what he was talking about, so he sent it to me, and, like you, I was surprised at the level of detail. I think it's important you make clear that reading it has actually made you feel worse. You could also query the exact qualifications of the person doing it and if they are sufficient.

OH people can be useless. Mine asked me how many units of alcohol I drank per week and I couldn't remember off the top of my head what a unit would roughly be equivalent to so asked her, and she said in a really judgy voice "I wouldn't know, I don't drink." So I said "Well, I suppose roughly estimating, perhaps the equivalent of whatever a bottle of wine is, so what's that, 8-10 units, but obviously not all in one go," and from that she wrote "X drinks wine every night!"

Magnolia08 · 08/07/2022 21:40

They have a masters in sports medicine yet it sounds like they were carrying out a psychological assessment on you? Doesn't sound like that would be in their remit, I'd be questioning this too op

VerveClique · 08/07/2022 21:32

Did my post help at all OP?

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 21:26

They have a master's in sports medicine

OP posts:
DasGirl · 08/07/2022 21:17

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 21:07

They are a work place rehabilitation consultant or something like that

They will have to be a qualified HCP to get a role like this.
They often put their qualifications after their name st bottom of the letter.

VerveClique · 08/07/2022 21:14

The role of HR in all cases is to ensure employment compliance, but within that, to help the employer to help its employees to perform well, especially if they’re struggling with issues of discipline, capability, or fitness for work.

The role of occupational health is to look at the impact of work on the individual’s condition, and the impact of the condition on their ability to work, so it’sa balancing act. Occupational health in this sense should never diagnose or treat a condition.

I beg to differ to lots of PPs and say that sometimes that detail is really needed. The threshold for reasonable adjustments under the equality act is of the condition causes an impairment to everyday life for 12 months or more or is likely to, along with just three diagnoses that are automatically considered to be a disability.

So your employer knowing that you’re struggling to get up and about is very demonstrative to them that you’re nowhere near ready to face the rigours of work. It’s not in anyone’s interests for there to be a failed attempt to return to work.

Like another PP has said, the causes of your condition can also be very helpful to know. If someone’s depression stems from working with an awful college, the employer can address this. Sometimes people who become depressed due to work have completely unreasonable expectations about what the employer can actually do. And if the cause of any illness is actually something outside of work, then it’s imperative that the employer knows this too

vague, waffley OH reports don’t help anyone.

like PPs have said, you may have to trust the employer with a little information here. Good managers and HR people will likely have seen it all before.

Yes you should be able to edit/consent before the report is released to your employer.

No it shouldn’t be available to all and sundry in your personal file. However I very much like to ensure that OH reports are indeed Leo appropriately over time so that patterns and the ‘story’ of what’s happened can be ascertained, especially if certain individuals leave the business.

I’m sorry you feel this way OP. By all means give cautious content. Whilst I’m not sure of the qualifications of the OH assessor, and the assessment itself seems overly long, as a HR professional this all sounds fairly normal practice to me.

sleezeandwineparty · 08/07/2022 21:10

Ps if they have written about anything really personal they can take it out I often have people tell me awful things that have happened and I just write they have depression due to personal issues... for work it's not important for them to know what the issue is, just how it affects you.
Rarely I do have something personal which I do feel is relevant and I ask if I can include it and why.

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 21:07

They are a work place rehabilitation consultant or something like that

OP posts:
sleezeandwineparty · 08/07/2022 21:03

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 17:09

I've been off work due to poor mental health, and as part of my return to work I have had a meeting with occupational health. It was a long meeting that was really personal and they have written up a report to send to my manager and HR. I asked to see the report before it gets sent, and it's really upset me to be honest. It's so personal and talks about things I wouldn't even tell my closest friends. AIBU to want to edit it to remove a lot of the details? For example, it mentions things about me struggling to get out of bed, isolating myself from my friends and things I've worried about.

It's made the return to work process even more stressful as I categorically do not want my line manager to know all of this about me.

Does anyone have any experience in this to know if I'm being unreasonable? The report also includes a back to work plan with actionable steps and targets - surely that's the important part rather than hearing all about my personal struggles?

First of all if you asked for it to be sent first it should have been. So I would suggest you complain about that.

All the rest about struggling to get out of bed and not seeing friends. They are a description of your symptoms and should be in the report in order for your manager to understand why you are not at work. If you are returning to work and are fit and no longer experiencing these symptoms I tend to gloss over them as they are not relevant but if you are still avoiding social interactions and getting out of bed then they very much are.
not wanting this information shared is also a symptom as you see it as a failure therefore "personal information" rather than as a symptom and is due to the stigma of mental health issues even when the individual ironically has them. I have never had someone complain when I write they are unable to get out of bed and can't manage washing and dressing due to their fractured arm and ankle but if I write it about mental illness people get angry and that is also a symptom.

Personal information would be why you have depression/anxiety and I leave it very bland work or personal and really one or two words to describe it, such as workload, bereavement, change, moving house, several personal issues, poor working relationship with manager/colleagues/report.

I would be pretty surprised if the OHA/P didn't discuss this with you and if you did say you wanted to see it first it is almost always an admin error.
Managers rarely look at reports straight away so contact the company and ask them to withdraw it, whilst you decide if you want to give consent or not

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/07/2022 20:48

I'm glad you are getting a chance to edit certain information.

When in this situation always remember the person assessing you is working on behalf of your employer, they're not overly concerned about you personally or your future health needs.

Windywuss · 08/07/2022 20:47

I had an awful experience with OCC health. They were also intrusive and I ended up saying things because I was being pushed to explain. They then sent it to me, my manager and our HR without letting me see it first.

I was v upset and made a complaints. It really set back my recovery. If you have a good relationship with your manager, I'd encourage you to complain. Our OCC health used to be good. Then they cut costs and bought a dreadful third party off the shelf product with OCC health people who are so pushed for time, they actively told me not to interrupt and were irritated by me asking them to repeat questions when my condition has bluddy brain fog.

Hugs. I totally get how you feel. Flowers

Moonshine5 · 08/07/2022 20:45

OP if it's the NHS I remember a colleague telling me they had the option to request amendments, can you do that?

chopc · 08/07/2022 20:43

I don't think your line manager needs to know the nitty gritty personal details. They need to know from
Occ health if you are fit to work or not and if you need any adaptations etc. They don't need to know the details. You can talk to Occ Health and state clearly what you are happy and unhappy to disclose

midairchallenger · 08/07/2022 20:40

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:30

They were not a medical professional at all, so not a doctor, nurse, therapist, etc.

So about the same quality of a PIP assessor where the DWP have wholly unqualified people "assessing" disabilities in which they hold zero expertise?

They don't sound appropriately qualified to be writing such a report, which may explain their inability to write a professional appropriate report.

midairchallenger · 08/07/2022 20:36

user976577 · 08/07/2022 20:27

Can I hijack this thread and ask someone with knowledge if you have a OH report does it go into your employment file for future managers to look at or is it just relevant to the manager at the time of the illness?

Your employer should have a policy explaining that. If they don't the only way to know what they do is to ask for their policy. Our managers don't even see OH reports in the first place, much less years down the line - HR only pass on any adjustments or practical measures they need to be aware of.

Health information is "sensitive data" under GDPR so your employer is legally required to safeguard it and ensure it is not leaked to whoever fancies a dig.

DasGirl · 08/07/2022 20:36

thfgre45tyhgfd · 08/07/2022 20:30

They were not a medical professional at all, so not a doctor, nurse, therapist, etc.

What on earth were they then???
I'm not aware of any other kind of occupational health practitioner