Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is none of her business and he shouldn't have told her?!

60 replies

User717 · 08/07/2022 16:15

I'm really pissed off. I don't want to be here ranting for ages so I'll just go straight to the issue...

My husband has older kids with his ex. We'd been TTC and had a miscarriage, I was devastated. Had to have surgical removal and it was just horrid.

He's told his ex (WHY he thought this was ok I don't know) and she has now made it about her saying we should have told her we were trying.

Are these people just deluded?!

He says he told her because the kids told her I was upset when they were here the other day. They did see me cry (not in the same room but they walked in whilst I was) and I tried to sort out my.face and smile and tell them it was fine, just work and that was the end of it, they were fine. They don't know about the miscarriage or anything about TTC.

DH and ex aren't friends, they don't get on. So what on earth possessed him to tell her that is beyond me. He knows I wouldn't have wanted her to know.

AIBU to think they are both dicks. Him for telling her and her for not doing the normal human thing of saying sorry to hear that but instead making it a problem.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LilyMarshall · 08/07/2022 21:19

Meraas · 08/07/2022 20:44

It really isn’t. What is it with people thinking everyone has a right to women’s bodies.

Now, that’s not what I said, is it.

but it turns out op’s dh doesn't pay maintenance anyway so it is a non-issue.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 08/07/2022 21:12

I'm sorry for your loss.

My thinking would be the same as yours - I'd be upset at both of them. I do think though, that when things have eased a little, you'll realise he probably didn't mean to say anything. Or maybe he did, but it didn't occur to him that she'd said something so ridiculous, and he also didn't realise it was a secret.

People make mistakes. It's not the be all and end all. Put her out of your mind - you're right, it's got literally not a single thing to do with her. Talk to your husband. Look after yourself.

Meraas · 08/07/2022 20:44

LilyMarshall · 08/07/2022 18:10

id say to an extent it is, depending on the children, as it will impact her maintenance which she will need to prepare for. Unless by older children you meant over 19. Or he will not have the amount reassessed and reduced.

It really isn’t. What is it with people thinking everyone has a right to women’s bodies.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/07/2022 20:31

I’m so sorry you lost your baby x

The only thing that would have made my miscarriages worse for my husband was if his ex knew about them. Like yours, they’re not friends or friendly. We got there in the end and DD is 3. To this day my DSC mum hasn’t acknowledged she exists which is fine with us.

Craftybodger · 08/07/2022 20:25

OP, you said, “He doesn't pay maintenance as we have them 50:50 so no, it's not her business.”

If you have a child it will affect your SC and consequently it will have an impact on his ExW. She does not need to know that you are TTC but your response implies it will not affect her if you have a child, it will.

BoJosRussianHandler · 08/07/2022 20:23

They’re totally unreasonable!

alphapie · 08/07/2022 20:18

@chilledbubble you'd have to ask him. It doesn't matter if you think it's odd, he wanted to tell her, it's his news as much as it's the OPs, she doesn't get to unilaterally decide who he is allowed to tell, or what lie he needs to make up.

Maybe he just didn't feel comfortable lying to her face when asked why his wife was upset.

InFiveMins · 08/07/2022 20:17

I'd be fuming too OP. In fact I'd be raging.

Sorry for your loss Flowers

Cakecakecheese · 08/07/2022 20:13

Of course your husband should talk about it if it helps him but in this case he's not talking about it with a mate for support, he told his ex who instead of being sympathetic made it about her. So yeah I can see why you're upset, it's a tough enough time as it is. Unfortunately he can't unwell her so try not to think about her and focus on making sure you get support. I recommend The Worst Girl Gang Ever.

stuntbubbles · 08/07/2022 19:59

@Burgoo I didn’t say men don’t suffer emotionally. But of course it isn’t their body. It’s not him who has to bleed and cramp, is it? Or who has the hormonal tidal wave? Of course men can suffer the loss of a much-wanted future, no one’s disputing that. But in the same way there’s no such thing as “we’re pregnant”, there’s no such thing as “we miscarried”. The DH didn’t: OP did. It’s her business to decide whether the ex gets to know what’s happening to her body.

Plus, it’s absolutely fundamental that it is ONLY the woman’s body that has the pregnancy and thus the miscarriage: look at how Roe vs Wade has been overturned because men think they have a day over women’s bodies. Now that’s ludicrous and downright offensive.

Burgoo · 08/07/2022 19:44

@stuntbubbles

"yes, together she and her DH were going to have a baby, but only she was pregnant. Only her body is undergoing trauma."

Absolutely nonsensical take here^
It is an archaic belief that the woman suffers and the man doesn't. Is it the same? Hell no. Is it AS painful? Certainly not. But it is different. Men don't know what to do when things like this happen. They are hopeless and powerless; unable to do anything to ease the partner's suffering. They grieve the loss of an imagined future - all the birthdays, christmases, school parents evenings, sports days, proms, taking the child to university, seeing them graduate.

Its an absolute heart-breaker for both involved and to make this nonsensical statement that "only her body" is ludicrous and down-right offensive.

Burgoo · 08/07/2022 19:40

Firstly I think her mentioning it and telling the OP that they should have told her was unreasonable. It really isn't her place to demand she know every detail of their lives.

At the same time, I am also really conscious of the fact male partners get a raw deal when partners miscarry. It is easy to assume the male partner isn't suffering and/or traumatised by the whole process and he may well have needed to get it off his chest. I don't know whether he has friends he can rely on, but talking with someone who isn't you isn't unreasonable. Having had a similar experience, I needed to let out my anger, sadness etc to someone other than my deeply pained partner.

Whilst he may have picked the wrong person to confide in, the fact is people who are grieving make the weirdest decisions.

I would give him a break and tell the woman where to go. Don't allow her to kick you both whilst you are down. You are both likely to be suffering in different ways and he is unlikely to know what to "do" to makes things better. Men are always a second thought in these instances, even though the pain is very much felt. I believe that miscarriage needs to be holistically managed - including BOTH partners - and include a lot of support around the family.

Goodness sake don't turn on each other!
I feel for OP deeply. its a horrific thing for someone to go through, let alone with complications that followed.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 08/07/2022 19:33

I'm sorry for your loss.

I think it's important to distinguish between where he was just a bit stupid & thoughtless or whether there was any bad intent.

I'm sure there wasn't and he probably understands that now. Grieving is hard & everyone does it different, please support each other rather than taking it out on each other.

Try not to hold it against him, if he's not normally a twat. The last thing he wanted to do would be upset you further.

As for her, she can feck off.

chilledbubble · 08/07/2022 19:22

alphapie · 08/07/2022 19:13

@chilledbubble why does it matter if she 'needs' to know?

Would the OPs mother 'need' to know, would he friend 'need' to know.

If you base everything you do and say off who needs to know you mustn't speak to many people about much.

He WANTED to tell her, and that's a pretty simple concept to accept

Ok why does he WANT to tell her? Seems odd.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 08/07/2022 19:16

alphapie · 08/07/2022 19:07

I get the point and disagree entirely.

This loss impacts both, it's not just the OPs decision on who to tell and what lies to concoct. It's everything to do with the ex and the children that's what DH wants.

Just like he would be unreasonable for getting funny if the OP wanted to tell her family, friends or ex.

It's the ops body, she's the one which had the mc not her dh. I'm sure if he wanted to talk he could have picked someone who wasn't his ex who then made it all about her 🙄

alphapie · 08/07/2022 19:13

@chilledbubble why does it matter if she 'needs' to know?

Would the OPs mother 'need' to know, would he friend 'need' to know.

If you base everything you do and say off who needs to know you mustn't speak to many people about much.

He WANTED to tell her, and that's a pretty simple concept to accept

alphapie · 08/07/2022 19:12

@1000yellowdaisies well yes, it's called a conversation, people discuss appointments, why they're off work for x,y or z. It's hardly a new phenomenon. I've discussed my intense period pains, blood clots and fertility treatments, other female co workers have discussed abortions, the menopause and one a very detailed description of her pregnancy induced piles (which tbh I could have done without!) This is across many workplaces over the years.

MN is the only place I have ever seen this weird mentality perpetuated that medical appointments or procedures are secret, same view pops up on here about salaries too.

chilledbubble · 08/07/2022 19:12

alphapie · 08/07/2022 19:07

I get the point and disagree entirely.

This loss impacts both, it's not just the OPs decision on who to tell and what lies to concoct. It's everything to do with the ex and the children that's what DH wants.

Just like he would be unreasonable for getting funny if the OP wanted to tell her family, friends or ex.

It's really not anything to do with the ex? Why does she need to know? There's no benefit to her knowing.

alphapie · 08/07/2022 19:07

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 08/07/2022 19:05

Don't know what happened there but I'm sure you get the point

I get the point and disagree entirely.

This loss impacts both, it's not just the OPs decision on who to tell and what lies to concoct. It's everything to do with the ex and the children that's what DH wants.

Just like he would be unreasonable for getting funny if the OP wanted to tell her family, friends or ex.

beautyisthefaceisee · 08/07/2022 19:05

I'm on the fence. I don't think it's outrageous he would tell his ex, given that they share children....but I'm so sorry for your loss.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 08/07/2022 19:05

Don't know what happened there but I'm sure you get the point

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 08/07/2022 19:04

alphapie · 08/07/2022 17:02

I never get this argument, mainly because I don't know anyone who is so precious about medical treatments.

I know all about my mothers husbands prostate exam, as does DH as he was worried about his soon, my friends husbands are all open and chat honestly about anything medical too. My male co workers discuss regularly their various anal procedures.

Only on MN does this seem to be a taboo thing about not discussing anything medical with anyone, regardless of how close. A miscarriage is nothing to be embarrassed about.

Very outdated thinking, although many on his board are in the older age bracket so makes sense tbh

It's bathing to so with being embarrassed and all to do with the fact it's goy fuck all to do with the ex so why should she be told?

And children don't need to know either

chilledbubble · 08/07/2022 19:01

LilyMarshall · 08/07/2022 18:10

id say to an extent it is, depending on the children, as it will impact her maintenance which she will need to prepare for. Unless by older children you meant over 19. Or he will not have the amount reassessed and reduced.

Nope. It's not her business until he reduces the maintenance. You don't have to give her a heads up about it until say a month before the maintenance drops.

1000yellowdaisies · 08/07/2022 19:01

alphapie · 08/07/2022 17:02

I never get this argument, mainly because I don't know anyone who is so precious about medical treatments.

I know all about my mothers husbands prostate exam, as does DH as he was worried about his soon, my friends husbands are all open and chat honestly about anything medical too. My male co workers discuss regularly their various anal procedures.

Only on MN does this seem to be a taboo thing about not discussing anything medical with anyone, regardless of how close. A miscarriage is nothing to be embarrassed about.

Very outdated thinking, although many on his board are in the older age bracket so makes sense tbh

If your male co workers 'discuss regularly their various anal procedures' and you just sit there listening to it then you sound like an idiot.

This idea that wanting to retain some sort of privacy around miscarriage is to do with shame or embarrassment is wrong and offensive. I didnt tell anyone at work about mine and it wasnt due to embarrassment.

chilledbubble · 08/07/2022 19:00

It is shit all to do with her.