Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

getting a gastric band at 20?

89 replies

amykg · 08/07/2022 16:15

hey all x

so I’ve never been a slim girl but I had my dd really young (i was 17). i’ve struggled really badly with my size since then and i’ve got really overweight.

i’ve tried all the usual stuff, slimming world, slim fast, calorie counting, but haven’t found anything where i can get the weight off and keep it off.

my parents sat me down last week and told me that for my 21st birthday present that they would give me the money to have the gastric band operation if i want to do it.

I’m obviously super grateful to them for the offer and i said yes because i want to be healthy and a good role model for my dd. but now i’ve had time to think i’m wondering whether its the right decision at my age because its such a massive life choice and whether i just need to try harder losing weight myself

am i being unreasonable having second thoughts about such an amazing offer?

OP posts:
QOD · 09/07/2022 05:29

Don’t have the band. Nhs don’t do them generally now as they have so many issues
also super easy to cheat (Ice cream, chocolate, high calorie drinks etc).
i had a bypass but I think the sleeve is more appropriate for youngsters. It’s more like the old stomach stapling
20/21 is very very young. It’s definitely not been easy and a huge % of post by passers end up with alcohol issues. I did but have sorted that 2 yrs ago

Marvellousmadness · 09/07/2022 04:53

Not an amazing "gift"
It is a life time of not being able to eat normal food or portions anymore

It is a quick 'fix ' for people who think it is a whole grail.

You were never fat
So it is not genetic
You need to change your life style. And you lack willpower thats it.

Carpy88999 · 09/07/2022 04:09

topdot · 08/07/2022 17:06

Yeah it's definitely that easy. Thank goodness someone's come along to explain it.

It is for the vast majority of people. They just lack willpower...

sashh · 09/07/2022 04:05

My GP asked me if I wanted a referral.

I looked into it, and to be honest when I looked into what you have to do before and after, well I thought, "If I could do that I wouldn't need the op".

I was always big, I was 10lb at birth.

After developing arthritis (not linked to my weight) and not being able to work my weight has gone up.

I managed to lose 5stone using Orlistat, but then I got ill and had to stop, the weight came back on.

I've now got T2 diabetes. I'm shorter than you and not quite as heavy so I know how miserable it can be.

Because of the diabetes I'm following 2rules.

Low carb diet (not no carb)
Eat protein for breakfast

The weight is coming off at about 0.5kg a week

I think you should talk to your GP about this, it may be possible to get a referral to a dietician to go through issues with eating, and one thing I have had to learn is what to eat. What is good? How does it affect my blood glucose?

You are still young. Do you want more children? Bariatric surgery won't stop you from having more but you would need to be monitored more closely.

Another thing I have done is to get a 'Freestyle libre' glucose monitor. It is a disc about the size of a £1 coin that monitors interstitial glucose every 15 mins. You scan it with a phone and it tells you your glucose reading, I have found it really useful because it tells me what my blood sugar is doing in response to what I have eaten.

So I now know a banana on its own causes a spike for me, so I don't eat bananas unless they are with something else. For others there might not be a spike.

I do not know if it is something that would help you, I have no idea if you could even get one (you can get a free sample if you are diabetic and on the NHS if you have Type 1).

I'm learning a lot about how the body processes different food and how different sugars are processed so a piece of fruit can contain a lot of sugar, but the sugar is fructose and the rest of the fruit contains things like fibre.

The body processes fructose differently to other sugars, ie in the liver.

www.bbcgoodfood.com/howto/guide/sugar-explained

In short there are people on here who have been through the experience of bariatric surgery and have found it a positive. I decided against it but I'm having to change my lifestyle now, for good.

Talk to your GP, make contact with people who have had the surgery and ask about the downsides.

Make sure your decision is informed, not just about the surgery but about the lifestyle changes.

And good luck with whatever you choose.

Ylvamoon · 09/07/2022 01:45

@amykg This thread below may be of interest to you.... I have cut out UPF, and the health benefits are fantastic!
If you go for it, you'll need to give it at least 6 months before you are used to it.

mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4583619-to-be-totally-on-the-anti-upf-bandwagon-and-think-this-may-finally-be-how-i-crack-my-food-addiction

Personally I wouldn't rush into this type of surgery, I understand that for many people it looks like an easy fix. But I always think, exploring the underlying reasons and sustainable lifestyle / diet changes should come before any weight loss surgery.

AnaïsM · 09/07/2022 01:13

amykg · 08/07/2022 17:05

i’m 5ft 2 and about 20 stone

That’s a BMI of over 50; are you already working with your GP for help with this?

MoonShadowMoonShadow · 09/07/2022 00:37

I've had it at 36 and I wish I would have done it younger.

I'm not sure about 20 but it would have saved me years of upset.

bloodyplanes · 09/07/2022 00:32

Go for it, i had a bypass at 40. I wish i had done it much younger, it would have saved me all those years of self loathing.

ISeeTheLight · 08/07/2022 22:08

Oh and when i say I tried everything- I found that I do lose weight on 800kcal a day but I get headaches and feel faint and can't do my job so that's not sustainable. At 1200kcal I lost 2kg in 2 weeks and then nothing for the following 6 weeks. At 1500kcal I don't gain weight. Over 1500kcal I gain weight.
I did slimming world for months, stuck strictly to plan and almost never used all my sins and lost about 3kg in 6 months.

I also have an underactive thyroid which doesn't help.

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 08/07/2022 22:08

The NHS often give you more psychological support than private health care providers. However, it can take years to complete the program and then wait for surgery and some people find it a bit like jumping though hoops for no clear reason.

ThinWomansBrain · 08/07/2022 22:06

spend the money on therapy to look at why you overeat?
also, a few years ago, I had a short spell of seeing a nutritionist - seeing her once a month was comparable to the cost of slimming world type stuff - and more beneficial.

ISeeTheLight · 08/07/2022 22:06

I'm a bit older than you OP (mid 30s), have struggled with my weight for about 7 or so years now. Also tried everything. I'm tall but BMI of 37. It's affecting me now and I'm fed up; I struggle to exercise, I've got back problems, I can't kneel on my knees etc.

I booked an appointment with my GP and saw him this morning. He was actually lovely about it and totally non-judgemental. Was saying the same as what others have said; that it's basically metabolism and very hard to lose weight (and crucially, keep it off after!). He has referred me to the weight management team - I asked what they would do and he said probably surgery or maybe semaglutide.
Go see your GP, they may be helpful!

Darbs76 · 08/07/2022 22:00

How hard have you tried with things like slimming world and calorie counting / increasing your steps. I’d give them a proper go first

MsOllie · 08/07/2022 21:56

@Glitterspy but that doesn't always work! It's like when the doctor suggested to me to try some gentle walking as if I don't exercise just because I'm fat

Today I had
A tuna, sweetcorn and salad sandwich for lunch, banana and some Greek yoghurt
Cottage pie (400g portion homemade with lots of veg in) for tea, and some steamed veg on the side
Grapes (handful)
Mugs of tea (no sugar) and about 2.5l water

I do 30-90 min spin classes almost daily, plus stretching and weights and some barre/yoga. I started doing that in feb, didn't change my diet and have lost zero despite going from doing nothing to doing loads

What part of that food should I cut out because I'm already not eating breakfast. I don't move during the day because of my job hence why i exercise at night

Chilldonaldchill · 08/07/2022 21:54

But also....
If you're really 5ft 2in and 20 stone then your BMI is 51.5.
There is no part of the UK (England/Wales - I don't know about Scotland or NI to be fair) where you wouldn't be eligible for NHS surgery.
Your parents obviously love and care for you but their money might be best kept for something else.
It's definitely worth exploring the NHS route...

Chilldonaldchill · 08/07/2022 21:50

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 08/07/2022 21:32

Why is it ridiculous? Look up the stats. All studies show that once you are morbidly obese the chances of maintaining a healthy weight are almost zero. You might prefer to keep telling overweight people that they just need to ‘eat less and move more’ but it isn’t realistic. The surgery is much safer than being obese.

This. Evidence is that if you are obese at or after puberty it's very very difficult (and almost impossible) to successfully lose weight permanently without surgery.
Go and see your GP op but they'll almost certainly tell you to explore surgical options.
Good luck.

CactusBlossom · 08/07/2022 21:42

Have you seen your GP? I think surgery should be a last resort. Your GP may have (or be able to recommend) a scheme where you are monitored for your progress in losing weight as well as keeping healthy. Sudden weight loss is not good for your body. I'm not sure how long you have tried other methods, but as you are 20, it won't have been for many years. Do you think perhaps you have problems sticking to a scheme? Some days you will follow a programme, but others you will not be so successful. Don't give up! You need to consider a lifestyle change; having surgery in itself will not deal with the root cause of the problem. Are you perhaps not as overweight as you think? Please see you GP for advice; surgery is a drastic option for one so young.

Wishing you well.

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 08/07/2022 21:32

TeapotTitties · 08/07/2022 19:14

The chances of you losing the amount of weight you need to to be healthy and keeping it off are virtually non existent without surgery.

That's a ridiculous (and arguably dangerous) thing to tell a 20 year old!

OP, this really isn't the right place (no matter which MN topic you choose).

Please seek medical advice and not the advice of internet randoms.

Why is it ridiculous? Look up the stats. All studies show that once you are morbidly obese the chances of maintaining a healthy weight are almost zero. You might prefer to keep telling overweight people that they just need to ‘eat less and move more’ but it isn’t realistic. The surgery is much safer than being obese.

amykg · 08/07/2022 20:01

of course i’m going to get actual medical advice. i was asking for opinions and views on here, that doesn’t mean I’m then suddenly going to have an operation without getting full advice from a doctor.

i honestly don’t know why some people bother with the ‘eat less exercise more’ advice. if it were that simple then nobody would be overweight. what do you get out of it other than making yourself feel clever?

OP posts:
TeapotTitties · 08/07/2022 19:14

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 08/07/2022 18:11

You will get a lot of rubbish from people who don’t have weight issues on this thread. Some of the responses are disgusting.
The chances of you losing the amount of weight you need to to be healthy and keeping it off are virtually non existent without surgery. Come and read the bariatric surgery threads we are are lot less judgmental over there.

The chances of you losing the amount of weight you need to to be healthy and keeping it off are virtually non existent without surgery.

That's a ridiculous (and arguably dangerous) thing to tell a 20 year old!

OP, this really isn't the right place (no matter which MN topic you choose).

Please seek medical advice and not the advice of internet randoms.

Jenasaurus · 08/07/2022 18:41

haggan · 08/07/2022 17:13

If you can ignore the cancer risk warnings Sad

As a recently diagnosed (a week ago) type 2 diabetic I have read about this with interest, sadly there is thyroid cancer in my family and the risks listed about it have put me off. I am just basically eating fruit, veg and protein which is so boring, so I feel your pain, (I also have very high chloesterol and non-alcoholic fatty liver) so have to eat, low car, low far and low sugar which feels very hard but I have lost 5 pounds since last week ( started at 14 stone 4 and BMI of 35)

I have set myself a challenge to lose 10 pounds a month, if you want a diet buddy I would be up for it :)

Focalpoint · 08/07/2022 18:34

As others have said, Ozempic / Wegovy is now approved as a treatment of obesity and there are other newer GLP1 agonist medications (such as mounjaro) that are even more effective for weight loss. It is likely there will be more innovation in medical obesity treatments in the next few years and give the same results as surgery.

TheBikiniExpert · 08/07/2022 18:31

The chances of you losing the amount of weight you need to to be healthy and keeping it off are virtually non existent without surgery.
I don't think that's true unless you have been obese for many years. From what the OP says, it sounds more like it dates back to her pregnancy in which case it is more likely to be due to lifestyle and could be reversed. I'm not against surgery per se but surely it is better to consider other options?

WeeOrcadian · 08/07/2022 18:13

kewgirl · 08/07/2022 16:39

Just eat sensibly and do exercise for god's sake

Absolutely unnecessary and utterly unhelpful

OP - do some research around types of surgery, I had a sleeve in December and I'm 5 stone down, I wish I'd done it years ago. That said, it isn't the right choice for everyone.
The band has awful, potentially horrific outcomes, most health authorities won't even offer a band any more - with good reasons.

Good luck!

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 08/07/2022 18:11

You will get a lot of rubbish from people who don’t have weight issues on this thread. Some of the responses are disgusting.
The chances of you losing the amount of weight you need to to be healthy and keeping it off are virtually non existent without surgery. Come and read the bariatric surgery threads we are are lot less judgmental over there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread