Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate "perfect attendance" awards

209 replies

EllieRosesMammy · 08/07/2022 15:54

Surely after going through a pandemic perfect attendance awards should be scrapped? I refuse to believe any child can go an entire year without being ill atleast once, so essentially schools are rewarding the ones who have been sent in to school to spread their germs around.

And then articles like this:
lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hulldailymail.co.uk%2Fnews%2Feducation%2Fhull-boy-not-missed-day-7300887&h=AT15pbp4zAEVNauE8SDiHV7nuGzjlB9PVwvxfhka2nSCw-fUJHOIxI50ErMwsi96rnXaVdNlk-5HQsPc1agljITptxr5RX-ZjnYAfri6FdNPKn8NIxmThMtnLPlpKaQ1u7hR_L29GLjDoZuRVqbvtw

7 years and he hasn't been ill once? Give over 🙄

OP posts:
incywincywanker · 09/07/2022 08:34

Samcro · 08/07/2022 15:57

hate them discriminate against children who have disabilities/health conditions.

This is my children sadly.... they have to have medical treatment every 2 weeks and that affects attendance

SheepingStandingUp · 09/07/2022 08:34

"The end of my post wasn't quoted, that there would be other awards that would pay to those kids strengths.* because the end bit wasn't the bit you needed picking up in @Florenz . Children with disabilities or acute medical issues aren't one homogenous lump to be dumped into "can't move very fast" category, or frankly ANY such ignorant category.

@Marvellousmadness 'That's like saying some kids can't win first prize in a running race because they're is a kid in a wheelchair in their Class* except a decent school will ensure equality and make sure there's a race that has a chance to compete equally in. Not everything about sports day is using your legs to run at speed. People have such limiting imagination.

SickKid · 09/07/2022 08:33

As a former teacher, the 100% attendance kids were either those with two FT working parents or the 'difficult' kids 😂

Now that I've been blessed with 2 sn kids of my own I have a lot more understanding of the latter!

Navigatingnewwaters · 09/07/2022 08:31

HeadNorth · 09/07/2022 08:29

I am amazed (and amused) that anyone can defend attendance awards when they seem so clearly indefensible. One of my kids would routinely have 100% attendance, the younger wouldn't - she is a sickly child and now a sickly adult, poor wee toot. Their school never did attendance awards, but I certainly would have complained if they did - it is so clearly discriminatory. You might as well give out awards for the nicest legs or best eyesight - absolute pathetic gubbins.

Maybe if more people complained and pointed out the discrimination they’d be removed.

42isthemeaning · 09/07/2022 08:31

I remember in my first teaching job the biggest disruptive bully in the school won a mountain bike in a raffle for those who'd had perfect attendance. Hmm
I don't agree with rewarding perfect attendance. It's a basic expectation that children attend school unless they are ill. Dental appointments are almost impossible to arrange out of school time where we live.
When I think about it that school also used to reward children for have a pen and bringing their books to school...

HeadNorth · 09/07/2022 08:29

I am amazed (and amused) that anyone can defend attendance awards when they seem so clearly indefensible. One of my kids would routinely have 100% attendance, the younger wouldn't - she is a sickly child and now a sickly adult, poor wee toot. Their school never did attendance awards, but I certainly would have complained if they did - it is so clearly discriminatory. You might as well give out awards for the nicest legs or best eyesight - absolute pathetic gubbins.

Midnight0 · 09/07/2022 08:18

Also giving awards for somethings that's out of the children's control is ridiculous...!

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 09/07/2022 08:14

TriptotheBog · 09/07/2022 07:30

Maybe but what kid actually cares about an attendance award? I used to hate standing at the front, hardly an honour. If they shamed low attendance I'd be in full agreement but fact is, only 100% attendees are getting a certificate, hardly discrimination.

Here is my full post @DashOfMilkNoSugar, I think you missed it. Odd thing to only post the last a sentence to wind yourself up.

I’m so so sorry @TriptotheBog i didn’t read it properly.

Navigatingnewwaters · 09/07/2022 08:13

Sirzy · 09/07/2022 08:04

Attendance reseda aren’t going to improve attendance.

to tackle attendance issues then schools, and where needed other agencies, need to work with children and families to get to the bottom of the issues leading to poor attendance.

Well yes obviously 😂

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/07/2022 08:06

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 08/07/2022 16:52

That article. 😬 Seths mum sounds like one to avoid. I bet she’s secretly fuming that her child is ‘only’ deputy head boy. I mean what more does he have to do? He never gets ill, eats his cauliflower, has friends, is sporty and he’s academic. 😂

Attendance awards are a joke but I don’t think they’ll get rid of them so just don’t worry about them. Children get ill, it’s normal.

We don't do them anymore, along with quite a few schools in the area because they've realised it's discriminatory towards students with SEND or whose parent dies, for example.

I think the HT may be on MN

Sirzy · 09/07/2022 08:05

That of course should start attendance awards.

Sirzy · 09/07/2022 08:04

Attendance reseda aren’t going to improve attendance.

to tackle attendance issues then schools, and where needed other agencies, need to work with children and families to get to the bottom of the issues leading to poor attendance.

PinkChaires · 09/07/2022 07:55

Our school is doing a trip where you only get to go if no detention, no lates to class or school and full attendance. It's ridiculous as yes they may need to take some responsibility but as teens they can't change the world around them so they can get to school on time and cannot help getting a stomach bug. Its also ridiculous as the 'naughty' kids also get to go regardless of behaviour and they have gone on multiple other trips but thats for another post!

Navigatingnewwaters · 09/07/2022 07:55

Not everyone can be chronically ill though, tackling poor attendance (especially now) is like fighting a tide of indifference towards education and the tools given are blunt. Maybe they should extend it to say if you have an illness or disability you should get a certificate for the attendance you manage as adversity is actually being faced there (in terms of getting to school) or would that seem patronising 🤔 Ultimately though in my experience is does tend to be the parents who care over the kids, unless you are giving out chocolate then that’s a different matter.

Marvellousmadness · 09/07/2022 07:44

Oh boohoo get over it.
That's like saying some kids can't win first prize in a running race because they're is a kid in a wheelchair in their Class

Let them win a prize. Yay for them. Who cares.

TriptotheBog · 09/07/2022 07:30

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 09/07/2022 07:06

If they shamed low attendance I'd be in full agreement

😳🙄

Maybe but what kid actually cares about an attendance award? I used to hate standing at the front, hardly an honour. If they shamed low attendance I'd be in full agreement but fact is, only 100% attendees are getting a certificate, hardly discrimination.

Here is my full post @DashOfMilkNoSugar, I think you missed it. Odd thing to only post the last a sentence to wind yourself up.

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 09/07/2022 07:06

If they shamed low attendance I'd be in full agreement

😳🙄

caringcarer · 09/07/2022 00:49

My youngest son went through the whole of secondary school without missing a day. He was ill once but over Easter holidays. He was awarded a prize by local mayor as only child in town. He was given a football. My son loves most sports but hates football. He gave it away to a charity.

thing47 · 08/07/2022 23:51

There's already been several posts saying that 100% attendance awards aren't fair on kids with health conditions and disabilities as they wouldn't be able to win

@Florenz, I'm going to assume you just don't have much experience of childhood disabilities rather than trying to be offensive. But FYI there is a whole range of health conditions and disabilities which would mean you were considered disabled but wouldn't prevent you doing some physical activities, or which might mean you could occasionally do such activities but not all the time.

DS for example has a (physical) condition which means he is considered disabled, but he works as a sports coach and PT and his main hobby is doing cross-fit. His students wouldn't know about his disability because on the bad days, he doesn't do them.

thing47 · 08/07/2022 23:35

TriptotheBog · 08/07/2022 21:57

Maybe but what kid actually cares about an attendance award? I used to hate standing at the front, hardly an honour. If they shamed low attendance I'd be in full agreement but fact is, only 100% attendees are getting a certificate, hardly discrimination.

It absolutely can be discrimination.

Equality Act 2010: 'Schools must make reasonable adjustments to ensure that disabled children and young people are not at a substantial disadvantage compared with their peers. This duty is anticipatory: adjustments must be planned and put in place in advance, to prevent that disadvantage.'

So unless absences relating to a medical condition which the school knows about are discounted when assessing absence, a school could very well be in breach of the Act. Adherence to which is a legal requirement.

whataloadabullocks · 08/07/2022 23:33

Arrr but Florenz which child gets the improvement award the one who goes from 68%-90% or the one who goes from 2%-3%.
Likewise with effort, the child who reads 100 books a term or the child who just manages to read 1? Okay I'm being a bit obtuse here, but 'effort' is much more ambiguous than an obvious win in a race or high marks.
And how often do we see on here parents moan about the 'good' behaviour awards, going to the 'naughtiest' child compared to their child who has been good and kind and well behaved?
I just don't think they are needed. If children didn't have them, they wouldn't miss them. What's wrong with a sticker and a well-done each time a child has done something to the best of their ability? Why make a loud sound and dance about achieving something which is unachievable for many?
Why reward something that comes naturally and is generally down to the luck of genetics and or parenting?
As I've already said my kids are polar opposite so I have no real bone to pick, one wins everything, one has never had so much as a sticker.
But I do see the effect it has on my struggling child and it's not okay.
Life will never ever be a level playing field and I accept that, by why not try and level it a bit, at least at primary school?

Florenz · 08/07/2022 23:09

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 08/07/2022 22:37

This. @Florenz that was a fucking shitty comment. To say 'well the kids with health conditions and disabilities wouldn't do well at sport anyway!' Good God. Did you actually think it was acceptable to post that?! Shock

The end of my post wasn't quoted, that there would be other awards that would pay to those kids strengths.

There's already been several posts saying that 100% attendance awards aren't fair on kids with health conditions and disabilities as they wouldn't be able to win.

If you take it to the logical extreme, there shouldn't be any awards in schools because not all kids can win. Which is obviously ridiculous. Achievement should be acknowledged, and there should be awards for effort and improvement too.

whataloadabullocks · 08/07/2022 23:06

I hate all prizes and awards. I have one child who aces everything without having to put in any effort, academically able, sporty, healthy etc. they walk an easy path. My other child the polar opposite, crap health, crap at sport, struggling academically, everything is a challenge and life is so much harder.
I know the child which is far more deserving of the award, and it's not the one who gets all the awards.

Mum233 · 08/07/2022 22:58

I’m a teacher and I dislike these rewards. I’ve seen five year olds sent to school really ill just so they can get 100% attendance reward. Both of my DC have had covid recently and so they won’t get it this year. It annoys me as I know some children who will get rewarded were sent in covid positive. So what is this rewarding in that case?

alphae · 08/07/2022 22:51

redredredredlorry · 08/07/2022 21:34

I went to a rural school. It was accepted as fact that the farm kids were never ill.

Why?

I must ask my mother and grandmother about that one (my grandfather has passed away) as my mother suffered with asthma badly as a 'farm child' as did her father.

Swipe left for the next trending thread