Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate "perfect attendance" awards

209 replies

EllieRosesMammy · 08/07/2022 15:54

Surely after going through a pandemic perfect attendance awards should be scrapped? I refuse to believe any child can go an entire year without being ill atleast once, so essentially schools are rewarding the ones who have been sent in to school to spread their germs around.

And then articles like this:
lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hulldailymail.co.uk%2Fnews%2Feducation%2Fhull-boy-not-missed-day-7300887&h=AT15pbp4zAEVNauE8SDiHV7nuGzjlB9PVwvxfhka2nSCw-fUJHOIxI50ErMwsi96rnXaVdNlk-5HQsPc1agljITptxr5RX-ZjnYAfri6FdNPKn8NIxmThMtnLPlpKaQ1u7hR_L29GLjDoZuRVqbvtw

7 years and he hasn't been ill once? Give over 🙄

OP posts:
Penfelyn · 11/07/2022 01:55

I'm not in the UK so never heard of attendance awards. Sounds a bit dumb as this kind of empty gesture is unlikely to entice the children who skip school for no good reason. They're not gonna care.

If they absolutely must have attendance awards then I'd suggest they limit it to unjustified absences and not sanction Keith who was off two weeks with appendicitis or Joan who had covid and missed ten days straight. Or else I'd be tempted to send in sick DC and if the school calls me I'd tell them I want the award ! Just to make them understand how ridiculous it is.

(obviously I wouldn't as I wouldn't want DC to be miserably sick in school just to make a point).

That said I don't think you're gonna make these awards disappear OP so next best thing is to not give a shit and not attend the awards ceremony. (I'm pretty like that).

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/07/2022 01:34

Its ableist crap and ripe for a challenge under equalities legislation.

Given the pandemic they are also beyond stupid.

I'd judge any teacher or indeed parent who supported them.

Nat6999 · 11/07/2022 01:26

There was a boy in ds class in primary who had 100% attendance right through primary. In reality his mum sent him to school when he was practically dying, she sent him to school with chicken pox & denied he had it, all because she had a very important job as a bank manager & refused to take time off. She went back to work practically the minute she gave birth & the day after he started school she went back full time putting him in wraparound care from 7.30am - 6 30pm.

HappydaysArehere · 11/07/2022 01:22

Many years ago I used to get prizes for good attendance at Sunday School. I was so pleased I can remember the titles of the books - King Purple’s Jester and Teddy’s Button.

Madwife123 · 11/07/2022 01:21

I agree!

my foster son didn’t get one this year as despite not missing a single day at school he joined late in the year, you know because he was undergoing the trauma of being removed from the only family he’s ever known and being sent to live with strangers miles away. Totally outside of control and was traumatic for him but the school is happily punishing him for this.

ClareBlue · 11/07/2022 01:04

Quia · 11/07/2022 00:32

What makes it worse is that attendance prizes are often in the form of treats or attendance at special parties or outings. It's miserable enough for a child having a condition like rheumatic arthritis, imagine how they feel seeing their friends going off for a special treat from which they are excluded for the crime of having an incurable medical condition.

And my daughter with dyspraxia seeing sports awards when she practiced for years to catch a ball and never managed it. But got her 100 perc attendance award and was proud to get it.

ClareBlue · 11/07/2022 01:02

IcedOatLatte · 08/07/2022 16:33

Exactly, I don't have strong feelings about attendance awards but my DC are never off school and I'm sure they aren't the only ones, it's not unusual

I know it's been about 7 years since I was off work and only then because I couldn't drive to get there

Yes, we had two who never missed a single day of their schooling. Another only 4 days and it wasn't that uncommon

Quia · 11/07/2022 00:32

What makes it worse is that attendance prizes are often in the form of treats or attendance at special parties or outings. It's miserable enough for a child having a condition like rheumatic arthritis, imagine how they feel seeing their friends going off for a special treat from which they are excluded for the crime of having an incurable medical condition.

Quia · 11/07/2022 00:29

attendance awards are really no different to many of these awards given out and it’s very sad that some parents just have to find a way to take something away from a child just because their child might not win it.

Yes, they are different. In a properly run school that operates properly and gives prizes for effort as well as achievement, it is reasonably possible for every single child in that school, including the disabled, to win a prize. But it is never going to be possible for the disabled child who has to attend regular termtime medical appointments, or who gets regular seizures or flare-ups of conditions like diabetes, psoriasis, asthma or arthritis to win that attendance award. I can't see why it's so difficult for people to understand that.

Johnnysgirl · 10/07/2022 21:43

SmellyWellyWoo · 10/07/2022 21:19

But why do non sporty kids need to be given nonsense awards? Why can't the sporty kids just win them, as long as the non sporty kids don't feel bad about themselves? Same with attendance awards. Otherwise just get rid of all awards.

Agree.

SmellyWellyWoo · 10/07/2022 21:19

But why do non sporty kids need to be given nonsense awards? Why can't the sporty kids just win them, as long as the non sporty kids don't feel bad about themselves? Same with attendance awards. Otherwise just get rid of all awards.

blubberyboo · 10/07/2022 19:02

@thing47

creating sports day awards for the sake of creating them does nobody any favours. And events that “nobody wins” is a non competitive event. It just detracts from the sports achievements that are taking place. There will always be a child in every class that never has the “opportunity to win” just because they simply are not sporty and will always come last no matter what opportunities are placed in front of them.

if that’s the case it is very easy to create an attendance award that discounts periods of absence on the grounds of chronic illness and reward the kids who make effort. If you are going to make adjustments for sports day which is essentially what you have described, the same adjustments can be made for attendance awards. If you can’t create a sports day without having to create non competitive events like you have described to make it non discriminatory then sports day is just as discriminatory.

every child cannot win every award and there will always be awards that some kids will win that others won’t.
other kids get awards for personality, bravery, reaching an individual target, kindness and various other versions related to personality, resilience and capability.

attendance awards are really no different to many of these awards given out and it’s very sad that some parents just have to find a way to take something away from a child just because their child might not win it.

JustLyra · 10/07/2022 18:07

blubberyboo · 10/07/2022 15:36

@thing47

what a load of tosh.
I have never in all my years of being a parent seen any sort of silly game at sports days that the least sporty child in the class can win.
it just doesn’t happen.
by its very definition sports day is for the able and sporty kids.
don’t try and dress it up to be something inclusive because it isn’t

It absolutely does happen.

In lots of schools with decent SLT’s. They make sure that it does.

same with other awards.

JustLyra · 10/07/2022 18:05

SmellyWellyWoo · 10/07/2022 15:42

I have never seen a sports day where the least sporty child wins anything.

You might as well do away with all awards on the ground that not everyone has an equal chance of being awarded them.

Surely they all favour high achieving sporty NT children with no mental or physical health conditions?

Then you’ve never been involved with a decent school leadership team.

Attendance awards directly discriminate against some children and there is no way to balance that out.

whereas there is with sports day and other awards.

thing47 · 10/07/2022 17:55

blubberyboo · 10/07/2022 15:36

@thing47

what a load of tosh.
I have never in all my years of being a parent seen any sort of silly game at sports days that the least sporty child in the class can win.
it just doesn’t happen.
by its very definition sports day is for the able and sporty kids.
don’t try and dress it up to be something inclusive because it isn’t

The fact that you haven't seen it doesn't make it 'tosh', @blubberyboo, as it is quite clear some us HAVE seen it. And if you're going to be rude, at least be accurate – I didn't claim 'the least sporty kids could win', I said you could give 'less sporty kids opportunities'. You can do this by holding events that nobody 'wins'.

And as lots of pp have pointed out, you can give out awards for attitude, behaviour, helpfulness, kindness, improvement, effort and so on. It's not terribly difficult. Attendance awards are discriminatory. I bet you would struggle to find a parent of a chronically ill or disabled child who is in favour of them.

Quia · 10/07/2022 17:38

The use of attendance awards should earn an automatic black mark from Ofsted. It is so obvious that it potentially penalises disabled children for being disabled and is therefore unlawful.

It isn't excusable on the basis that it might be the only award some children get. It's not as if the school can do anything to direct the awards to those children, so it may well be that the sporty academically able child is also picking up the attendance prizes along with all the others they win. If the school wants to direct awards to children who struggle in academics and sports, it surely can't be beyond them to give awards for effort, kindness, helpfulness etc.

My DS used to get these, plus punctuality awards, in secondary school. They meant nothing to him, not least because he knew full well that the only reason he got them was that we hounded him out of bed and into the car and made sure he got there on time every day. Left to himself, it just wouldn't have happened.

Harridance · 10/07/2022 17:29

I've been to loads of sports days, prizes have always gone to the fastest/strongest/best

Johnnysgirl · 10/07/2022 17:27

No, because at least on sports day you can have all sorts of fun/silly events which give opportunities to the less sporty kids
Mmm... You can do just about anything; in practice this simply doesn't happen. Sports Day is a series of competitive events, best man (or woman) wins.

Rocky2022 · 10/07/2022 16:53

O and my ADHD child is very able and put up a good performance during Sports Day. However if he has a bad night and is more than 15 minutes late it impacts on class attendance. He could very easily be bullied for this.

Rocky2022 · 10/07/2022 16:49

what a load of tosh.
I have never in all my years of being a parent seen any sort of silly game at sports days that the least sporty child in the class can win.
it just doesn’t happen.

by its very definition sports day is for the able and sporty kids.
@blubberyboo
Err our Primary Sports Days are based on Houses competing against each other in time trial type events. No pressure on individual kids for example.
Whereas attendance Awards even class based put undue pressure on the child who is late or off becsuse of Medical Appointments or illness etc.

SheepingStandingUp · 10/07/2022 16:07

SmellyWellyWoo · 10/07/2022 15:42

I have never seen a sports day where the least sporty child wins anything.

You might as well do away with all awards on the ground that not everyone has an equal chance of being awarded them.

Surely they all favour high achieving sporty NT children with no mental or physical health conditions?

There is a difference between talents where you can practise, have other strengths, reward effort etc and disability / acute illness where you can't do a thing about the absences.

Sirzy · 10/07/2022 16:03

I have never seen a sports day where the least sporty child wins anything

I have. I went to watch Dn in sports day last week. He was in a group that was obviously well picked for the abilities because dn managed to win and every race was close enough that nobody was left miles behind it’s not hard for an inclusive school to do that

SmellyWellyWoo · 10/07/2022 15:42

I have never seen a sports day where the least sporty child wins anything.

You might as well do away with all awards on the ground that not everyone has an equal chance of being awarded them.

Surely they all favour high achieving sporty NT children with no mental or physical health conditions?

blubberyboo · 10/07/2022 15:36

@thing47

what a load of tosh.
I have never in all my years of being a parent seen any sort of silly game at sports days that the least sporty child in the class can win.
it just doesn’t happen.
by its very definition sports day is for the able and sporty kids.
don’t try and dress it up to be something inclusive because it isn’t

thing47 · 09/07/2022 23:02

I'm not a fan of attendance awards; but doesn't sports day (or sports week as some primaries are doing now) discriminate just as much?

No, because at least on sports day you can have all sorts of fun/silly events which give opportunities to the less sporty kids. There is nothing you can do to give an attendance award to someone who has been off school because of chronic illness or disability – unless maybe you discount all time off for that illness or disability.

My DCs are way beyond school age now, but I'd love to see someone challenge attendance awards via anti-discrimination laws.

Swipe left for the next trending thread