Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate "perfect attendance" awards

209 replies

EllieRosesMammy · 08/07/2022 15:54

Surely after going through a pandemic perfect attendance awards should be scrapped? I refuse to believe any child can go an entire year without being ill atleast once, so essentially schools are rewarding the ones who have been sent in to school to spread their germs around.

And then articles like this:
lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hulldailymail.co.uk%2Fnews%2Feducation%2Fhull-boy-not-missed-day-7300887&h=AT15pbp4zAEVNauE8SDiHV7nuGzjlB9PVwvxfhka2nSCw-fUJHOIxI50ErMwsi96rnXaVdNlk-5HQsPc1agljITptxr5RX-ZjnYAfri6FdNPKn8NIxmThMtnLPlpKaQ1u7hR_L29GLjDoZuRVqbvtw

7 years and he hasn't been ill once? Give over 🙄

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustLyra · 14/07/2022 13:39

TheBitterBoy · 12/07/2022 16:48

I don't understand the attitude that not getting an award is somehow 'punishing' a child for less than 100% attendance. Is the child who didn't get a medal for coming 4th in the sprint at sports day being punished? Or the kid who came last? I totally disagree with sanctions for genuine illness in situations like prom, but a primary school attendance certificate? Most primary schools seek opportunities to reward every child, sometimes attendance is the only thing a child has managed.

If every school just did certificates then it wouldn’t be the same size of issue.

the problem is that some (clueless) schools have bugger awards for attendance - extra golden time, days out and the likes.

They also often have class awards. So when they are discriminatory enough that little Mary misses out on the trip to the cinema or video afternoon because of her attendance, they also make Mary the most hated kid in the class because the whole class miss out

Harridance · 14/07/2022 13:30

If it encourages reliability in any form its a good thing

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 13:13

blubberyboo · 13/07/2022 23:17

@Fairislefandango

Not being ill isn't a question of reliability or being good at something though, is it? It's pure luck

I disagree , reliability is a characteristic of personality, that demonstrates being persistent and consistent and someone you can depend on. People regularly put “reliable” on job CVs and application forms , and part of building that character starts in school by getting out of bed, not when ill but oftentimes when someone has that momentary thought where they can’t be arsed and decide either to go or not to go.
employers value reliability. Reliability is important in relationships. Society needs people who are dependable , reliable and committed and there are many many people who just aren’t that way inclined.
not luck… a characteristic.

the same way other personality characteristics are rewarded in school and in later adult life.
like bravery
kindness
honesty
carefulness

Disability is something separate to this and all of those characteristics can be shaped both with or without a disability it’s just strange that mumsnetters seem to want to hang on to one particular award and criticise it when literally every other award in school could equally be affected by disability.
all other achievements have adjustments made for disability :
sports day
reading targets
literacy targets
music and art
dance
numeracy targets

No child is equal at everything and every child won’t win every award and there is no reason why an attendance or commitment award couldn’t be adjusted similarly with imagination.
much better than bitter adults just angrily dismissing children who have earned these awards.

But they aren't reliability awards.

Whenever he's in school, Bob can be relied upon to be helpful in class, mentor his peers and work hard
Is not the same as
Bob turns up to school every day.

If yo u want to do a reliability award, fine but it's seperate to attendance. It comes under the good behaviour stuff.

Perhaps in secondary in a school with an issue around kids bunking off but certainly in primary where it's on the PARENTS to arrange their delivery to school every day. Not on the kid. If DS says "golly, I feel like watching TV today and doing a spot of gardening" it's tough, he's going to school. Because that's MY job.

Rocky2022 · 14/07/2022 12:53

I was just reading a terrible story about a teen denied a ticket to her prom because she failed to meet attendance targets. She has chrohns disease ffs. This was a Church school. They should be ashamed of themselves.
She got her Prom in the end through the kindness of local people but that is the type if shit some people are defending.

blubberyboo · 13/07/2022 23:17

@Fairislefandango

Not being ill isn't a question of reliability or being good at something though, is it? It's pure luck

I disagree , reliability is a characteristic of personality, that demonstrates being persistent and consistent and someone you can depend on. People regularly put “reliable” on job CVs and application forms , and part of building that character starts in school by getting out of bed, not when ill but oftentimes when someone has that momentary thought where they can’t be arsed and decide either to go or not to go.
employers value reliability. Reliability is important in relationships. Society needs people who are dependable , reliable and committed and there are many many people who just aren’t that way inclined.
not luck… a characteristic.

the same way other personality characteristics are rewarded in school and in later adult life.
like bravery
kindness
honesty
carefulness

Disability is something separate to this and all of those characteristics can be shaped both with or without a disability it’s just strange that mumsnetters seem to want to hang on to one particular award and criticise it when literally every other award in school could equally be affected by disability.
all other achievements have adjustments made for disability :
sports day
reading targets
literacy targets
music and art
dance
numeracy targets

No child is equal at everything and every child won’t win every award and there is no reason why an attendance or commitment award couldn’t be adjusted similarly with imagination.
much better than bitter adults just angrily dismissing children who have earned these awards.

Rocky2022 · 13/07/2022 08:20

Yeah out school have Head Teachers Awards. One child per class get one most weeks. Child with undisclosed SEN probably got one once in 3 school years. Also had online learner of week during the lockdown. Could never win that as couldn't engage properly in online learning.
Finally got s diagnosis and a change of Leadership at the school meant that suddenly they started rewarding effort and they introduced an Awards for the SEND children.
Child now much happier as finally is getting some recognition.

Quia · 12/07/2022 17:17

TheBitterBoy · 12/07/2022 16:48

I don't understand the attitude that not getting an award is somehow 'punishing' a child for less than 100% attendance. Is the child who didn't get a medal for coming 4th in the sprint at sports day being punished? Or the kid who came last? I totally disagree with sanctions for genuine illness in situations like prom, but a primary school attendance certificate? Most primary schools seek opportunities to reward every child, sometimes attendance is the only thing a child has managed.

Yet again, there's a difference. I'm not talking about attendance certificates, but the schools where the 100% attenders get vouchers or invitations to a party or similar. If that was on offer for, say, effort with school work, every child in the class would be eligible and would have a decent chance at getting it. But when it's on offer for attendance, some children are in the position where they stand absolutely no chance through no fault of their own. And that's basically unfair.

And what if the child with a disability hasn't managed to win any other prize or certificate either? How does it help them to know they can't even become eligible for this one because of those essential medical appointments or unavoidable relapses?

TheBitterBoy · 12/07/2022 16:48

I don't understand the attitude that not getting an award is somehow 'punishing' a child for less than 100% attendance. Is the child who didn't get a medal for coming 4th in the sprint at sports day being punished? Or the kid who came last? I totally disagree with sanctions for genuine illness in situations like prom, but a primary school attendance certificate? Most primary schools seek opportunities to reward every child, sometimes attendance is the only thing a child has managed.

Fairislefandango · 12/07/2022 16:40

one thing he was good at was showing up every day and being reliable

Not being ill isn't a question of reliability or being good at something though, is it? It's pure luck.

I'm all in favour of giving awards for things other than academic achievement. Awards for a clean behaviour sheet - definitely. Awards for a marked improvement in behaviour or attitude - yes.

And I'm hugely in favour of excluding kids from prom (and anything else fun) for persistent, serious poor behaviour.

Harridance · 12/07/2022 16:38

That's great bitterboy

TheBitterBoy · 12/07/2022 16:36

DS had three (non consecutive) years of 100% attendance in primary school. He genuinely was not ill on a school day in those years. As a not particularly high achieving, middling sporty child they were the only awards he got in primary school.

Lunificent · 12/07/2022 16:35

I don’t like them. I also don’t like children being excluded from prom. It shows a lack,of understanding and empathy for the different home situations, physical and mental health, children are facing.

IForgiveYouPaula · 12/07/2022 16:29

Well it’s not 100%

Pure luck she wasn’t a poorly child. And I never took her out of school just because the sun was shining. I was chuffed that she got it, DD not so much.

To hate "perfect attendance" awards
SheepingStandingUp · 12/07/2022 13:53

one thing he was good at was showing up every day and being reliable, so some kids do deserve these fucking awards and the other kids get something else.
No one is "GOOD" at having a good immune system, they just do, it isn't something he works hard toward, it isn't an achievement. Going to school when you're well is the basic requirement, it isn't something special he goes out of his way to achieve. If he's reliable and the teachers can depend upon him to be a good team player, then that should be acknowledged through behaviour certificates as that's a different issue because that isn't to do with attendance or immune system. He won't be less reliable tomorrow if he gets D&V tonight.

SheepingStandingUp · 12/07/2022 13:44

Johnnysgirl · 11/07/2022 11:50

If you've got a child who school refuses who does a whole term, by all means reward. That's an achievement.
Not sure I'm on board with school refusers being rewarded for showing up, tbh.

i was thinking the only time attendance might actually be an achievement. If you've got a 7 year old who hates school and is chronically late and they manage a term of on time, or constantly playing up so much parents struggle to get them in and then they work through a whole term with no missed days, that's an achievement. give that kid a certificate for his improved behaviour / attitude. But your average kid who's never sick and who goes to school compliantly, that isn't an achievement, that's a basic minimum.

Harridance · 11/07/2022 12:58

Or adults not turning up for work

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 11/07/2022 12:04

I agree. It's something entirely oputside the children's control and encourages a sentiment that attendance is more important than wellbeing. And then people complain when adults turn up to the office clearly ill.....

Johnnysgirl · 11/07/2022 12:02

Attendance awards are punishments for people who are genuinely sick
Oh, of course they aren't Hmm. If every child had perfect attendance there'd be no need for it to be acknowledged at all.

Plumbear2 · 11/07/2022 11:58

blubberyboo · 08/07/2022 19:27

My eldest never got sick. We could all be dosed in the house and he just sailed through without a sniffle.
at school he was very middle of the road, never best at academics, sports, not musically talented or into drama

one thing he was good at was showing up every day and being reliable, so some kids do deserve these fucking awards and the other kids get something else. Seriously some people get so offended by nothing!

My son is also reliable and will show up every day. He also has had sick days where I've kept him at home. That does not stop him being reliable and showing up every day that he physically can. Attendance awards are punishments for people who are genuinely sick, great that your kid is never sick but that does that mean kids who do get sick are any less reliable.

Johnnysgirl · 11/07/2022 11:51

Some other acknowledgment, perhaps, but not an attendance award.

Johnnysgirl · 11/07/2022 11:50

If you've got a child who school refuses who does a whole term, by all means reward. That's an achievement.
Not sure I'm on board with school refusers being rewarded for showing up, tbh.

Replacethis · 11/07/2022 11:47

My DC will never win one but I am all for other children getting rewarded for things. I hate the attitude 'ohhhh, my wee precious Amelia can't win this (sports day, singing contest, attendance award, whatever) so nobody else should'. It's a chance for a child to realise it doesn't matter if other people are recognised for things. It really is no big deal.

Harridance · 11/07/2022 11:26

But they do work for some kids

Johnnysgirl · 11/07/2022 11:23

What makes it worse is that attendance prizes are often in the form of treats or attendance at special parties or outings
Are these schools that struggle with attendance issues for one reason or another? Literally never experienced this sort of fanfare, and I had three in three different primaries for a (mercifully brief) time.

SheepingStandingUp · 11/07/2022 10:25

Ultimately, fulfilling the basic legal requirement of attending school every day at an age where its actually on your parents to ensure you get there and any absence would be seen as their responsibility, is not an achievement.

If you've got a child who school refuses who does a whole term, by all means reward. That's an achievement.

If you've got a child with a chronic condition who has appropriately worked to come into school more often when they're borderline unwell, by all means reward. That's an achievement.

General kid with no issues doing the legal minimum every day. Not an achievement.