Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dyslexia

85 replies

Hurstlandshome · 08/07/2022 14:16

My daughter has dyslexia. She is a couple of years behind, can read and write, but simply cannot process phonics. I'm unsure how this will translate to exam results in the future.

AIBU to feel annoyed that if she were a boy her job prospects would still be pretty good; tradesmen can earn a fortune, but because she's female her options are limited?

Can anyone give me a steer on possible job routes? And before anyone says 'she can still be an electrician/plumber/builder' - I feel it's unlikely she'll go down this route.

OP posts:
Summerwhereareyou · 08/07/2022 15:30

Sorry I forgot to add friend teacher is still insistent that phonics was the only Way? What's going on why are teachers like a cult over it??

Summerwhereareyou · 08/07/2022 15:29

@ApplePippa

Phonics is like a cult.

The aim here is getting the child to read.
If phonics works for them,great but if it's not working,drop it!

It's absolutely terrifying to think of how many DC are being held back and stunted because of this one track illogical obsession with bloody phonics!

I have a friend, teacher who knows my DC journey,how She couldn't read, how I got her reading through flash cards, Peter and Jane, site reading, breaking down words into prefix and suffix....new spelling techniques.
She went up 4 reading levels in a few months!she's a bright girl but couldn't fathom What was asked of her in phonics!

Summerwhereareyou · 08/07/2022 15:22

I missed /senco/ blue paper .

Has she had a test to show she even needs blue paper?

All this is coming out now,with the internet etc.

How on earth has this state of affairs been left like this!!

Discovereads · 08/07/2022 15:20

My DD20 has severe dyslexia. Phonics do not work for many dyslexics including my DD which is why reading/writing is delayed because the way it is taught in school just doesn’t work with their brains. I got a specialist cognitive therapist who used the Linda Mood Bell method for my DD at age 10 per recommendation of the private education psychologist who did a full battery of tests and assessments of DD to determine her exact type of dyslexia and therefore, what interventions she needed to reach her potential. So first step for you is to get a full assessment done so you know more about your DDs dyslexia. There are many types and for example, the typical things like coloured paper and one on one teaching not geared to her type of dyslexia also did not help my DD. The school SENCO then had a specific list from the education psychologist of the support my DD needed which included 25% extra time, breaks between exams, oral exams whenever possible over written, lower word count and extensions for written papers and such, copies of class notes (she can’t listen in class and write notes fast enough), etc. At her Uni she gets DSA and part of that includes free printing (reading on a screen is hard for her) and free audio textbooks.

Dyslexia doesn’t rule out being academic or getting a degree at all. You have to fight the culture of low expectations that abounds….we did. We had many teachers and even sencos tell us our DD could not succeed. When all the cognitive therapy was done (3yrs) and the accommodations were in place so she had a level playing field her grades jumped massively, these same “professionals” started to disbelieve she had dyslexia and tried to chip away at her accommodations so it was a fight to keep them every year, sometimes several times a year. We just kept a savings account with funds enough for repeat private assessments to prove her dyslexia had not been “cured.”

She’s just finished her 2nd year at Uni is on the Deans list and is on track for a 1st.

Wilkolampshade · 08/07/2022 15:16

Ooh, and I forgot, one of DD1's mates, also severely dyslexic, just graduated with a 1st in Astrophysics and is currently finishing his MA before going off to work at CERNE laboratories.

Never forget. It's not an intellectual impairment.

Take some time to process then get busy finding the work-around - there will be one!

Summerwhereareyou · 08/07/2022 15:16

Hi op.

You need to help your child yourself.

It's shocking but true that primary schools that know what to do with dyslexia are the exception not the rule.
So any Sen are not taught at pgce level.

So a teacher may think a child can't read because their parents are not reading with them or they don't treasure book's.

The school should have a designated senco.

Ideally this person should be highly trained in Sen, tips, strategies, resources to help children.

Unfortunately, again if your school has one who is little more than a "co ordinator", you are very lucky.

I got my DC reading by forgoing phonics.
Going back to Peter and Jane books and using flash cards.
Phonics was a barrier not a help to DDS reading journey.

She has a tutor for maths who understands she needs visual aids to help her.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with tradespeople!

If that's what your dd want's.

However having dyslexia doesn't mean she can't do what she wants.

ApplePippa · 08/07/2022 15:14

Hurstlandshome · 08/07/2022 14:28

I probably do have a narrow view, but my viewpoint at the moment is a child of 9 who can barely read and and write and I find it terrifying.
She has Senco support at school but it's just 'blue paper' and a little bit more time with the TA. Nothing that's making any difference.
A PP mentioned a degree and I just can't see how she'd complete that.

Sadly it sounds like the school are not really giving her much support.

My DS is dyslexic (and autistic) and was behind at your DDs age. He also has massive problems with phonics - phonological awareness is the root of his dyslexia problems. His school gave him extra phonics interventions, access to Nessy online to practice phonics, and word mats to help him with his writing. In Y4 they introduced him to Symwriter - symbol based word processing software which enabled him to produce written work independently. He's Y8 now and does all his work on a laptop using a spellchecker and is on target for a decent set of GCSEs. A degree doesn't seem the impossibility it did when he was 9. He does have an EHCP, but none of the dyslexia support he receives is specified in it.

It's not easy, but I think perhaps you should push the school a little harder. And don't worry too much about possible careers yet - your DD is still very young.

Wilkolampshade · 08/07/2022 15:09

Sorry you're struggling with this OP. It can be tough.

FWIW, my DD2 has dyslexia.
She is currently at the Royal College of Music as an undergraduate violinist and is doing extremely well. It's a performance based degree and although there is plenty of written work her value there is measured in her performance, which she excels at. (sorry, proud mummy)
When it became clear around yr1/2 that she had difficulties with reading/writing and organisation we made a deliberate effort to identify and support those areas of competence she DID have, in her case music.
In her part time job she is brilliant at solving all sorts of practical problems: arranging concerts, coordinating and dealing with trades, staging fundraising events, prepping and decorating when needed and liaising with artists and performers. Her huge strength is holding all these tasks in her head simultaneously and seeing the wider picture they need to make in completion.
Sometimes she has a wobble when things a more fluent reader would take in their stride throw her, but we'll work on ways together she can approach these less 'friendly' jobs to get to the other side.

What has worked for her is playing to her strengths. As someone once said to me, 'you wouldn' t ask a fish to climb a tree'

But I know all this may sound glib, whilst you're there in the thick of it. School can be very 'one size fits all' and it has taken many hard years for her to get where she is. Good luck. X

Goldencarp · 08/07/2022 15:02

My daughter is 16 just finished school and is dyslexic. We aren’t hopeful that she’ll pass any of her GCSE’s but she took 2 Btecs and has done really well in bith with distinctions. Those have been taken into account for the courses she’s applied for at college. She will have to take maths and English again if she doesn’t pass them.

She had extra support at school and a scribe and extra time for exams but I should have pushed for an EHCP when she was first diagnosed in year 7. Having so much time out due to covid didn’t help.

LittleOwl153 · 08/07/2022 15:02

Getting a diagnosis is a big deal. Take some time as a parent to process that before you start stressing. (I know - I have been there...).

My dd12 has recently been diagnosed with dyslexia (to add to a list of issues/diagnoses).

My daughters English teacher - who is also the Head of English in big secondary is very dyslexic! Ive had alot of correspondance from her recently due to my daughter issues. I can tell when she has written an email to me herself and when others have scribed for her - her spelling is awful. She often sends voice notes rather than text. She will phone rather than respond to an email.

Try and focus on what your daughter is good at. She good with her hands - maybe she is more practical? Is she good at drawing or playing with colours? Maybe design will be good for her. Is she of a caring personality - maybe a professional allied to medicine.

But she's 9. Concentrate on getting her the support she needs to through primary. Make sure she is happy and not picked on because of her issues. Make sure they are building in other forms of assessment to enable her to show what she knows. They hate this at primary and will push her to write like everyone else but she doesn't have to. Encourage them to let her use a computer. Teach her to type and how to get her way around ms office, or Google workspace or whatever.

Focus on her being brilliant in her own way. These sort of diagnoses generally come with confidence issues so have your cry by your self - and then slap your smile on and help her thrive by being who she is! She can do anything!

calmlakes · 08/07/2022 14:57

He learned to read using whole word recognition and just learns in a different way.

I also learned to read this way.

calmlakes · 08/07/2022 14:56

I'm dyslexic and didn't learn to read until I was 8.
I have several degrees including a RG one.

My dsis had a scribe at her exams, again a couple of degrees, chartered in her field and senior job.

Being dyslexic is a pain, particularly at school but it doesn't mean you can't succeed either academically or in the world of work.

whataloadabullocks · 08/07/2022 14:51

Has she got other learning disabilities? I ask because plenty of people with dyslexia go on into higher education and professional careers. Yes dyslexia makes life harder (through the academic years) but unless she has other difficulties I'd say don't write off her job prospects just yet! The most important strategies for her:
1)keep the reading going through the holidays, keep it short 10 mins a day is enough
2) get her to write a diary everyday through the holidays (again keep it short and stick photos in or let her do some drawings)
3) make sure her work is rewarded (ie do 10mins writing and I'll take you to the park/ get you an ice cream / play a game with you etc)
Set a timer so she doesn't go over the time.
4) make sure she has everything she needs before she starts so she doesn't distract herself!
5) make sure there is a clear space for to work (I know this can be really hard, but if you don't have a table, have a look at using a camping table)
6)encourage, encourage, encourage
7) don't give up....if one day she's really struggling shorten the 10 mins to 5.
It's so so important to keep these skills up over the six week summer holiday.
Finally it's estimated that 1 in 5 children are dyslexic, and most of those children will go on into good careers.
(I know plenty of dyslexic professionals so try not to worry) as she gets older there are techniques she can use to help her manage her dyslexia, particularly for exams, the most important aspect is getting it recognised and having extra time in her exams when she starts doing mocks.

Four4me · 08/07/2022 14:46

My DS couldn't read at 8, he was diagnosed and had extra learning support.
Once his reading improved at about 11 his academic levels sky rocketed!
He is doing Chemistry, Biology, Geography and Maths A levels at a very academic school and is predicted A's and A*'s.
He learned to read using whole word recognition and just learns in a different way.
We now say his dyslexia is his super power!
Star

Roselilly36 · 08/07/2022 14:44

My DS2 is 19 & severely dyslexic, really struggled at school, he left school with one GCSE. He has got a brilliant work ethic and works in a specialist area of business tech that really interests him. He is doing really, really well. Honestly try not to stress, I was very worried about my DS and it was completely unnecessary. Once he found his niche he hasn’t looked back, the skills he has (all self taught) mean to can earn well and no one in the area he works in are interested in exam results, more the case of can you do it or not. It requires a lot of trial & error and creative thinking.

Unbored · 08/07/2022 14:40

Your DD will be able to read and write with the correct support.

Ask the SENDCO to refer to your LAs dyslexia service (if they have one).

Get an Ed psych assessment to see exactly where your DDs strengths and weaknesses are - a private one will be much more comprehensive than an LA commissioned one. It’s very difficult to get an LA Ed psych assessment at the moment.

If your DD isn’t getting the level of support she needs then consider applying for an EHCP.

You could also consider sending your DD to a dyslexia specialist school. My DS goes to one, it’s amazing. DS is funded by the LA it’s private) and is provided with a taxi.

Alliumpoppyrose · 08/07/2022 14:39

Hurstlandshome · 08/07/2022 14:29

Perhaps I should rephrase: what jobs can people do who cannot read and write?

Honestly OP when I went to school and highschool, they did not have any care about special needs. I went through school thinking I was stupid and spent most of time ignored by teachers. I grew up with shitty manual jobs thinking I was worthless. Midlife I wanted more people said I would not hack uni.

Uni identified my needs during a foundation course, and it changed my life. Please understand some of us develop alot slower and need more time, but that does not mean we do not have potential. I still sometimes feel like a fraud but my employer values me and my grades cannot be taken away.

Your daughter has a bright future if she wants it and is encouraged to work hard.

serenghetti2011 · 08/07/2022 14:39

She can’t read and write now, not to say she never will be able to?
can you afford outside of school support and go back to school and fight for more support, Ed psych to say what she needs to help her reach her potential. I know it’s really hard but try to be more positive, think about all the things your daughter can do. Praise her and do those things, then praise her for trying the things she struggles with.

I am dyslexic, there was a lot of negativity surrounding what I could not do at school, rather than focusing on what I could do then praise and encouragement to boost confidence which then translated to the things I struggled with, it made me want to try harder - with the correct support of course. This was 30 years ago though so things have moved on since then. My nephew is also severely dyslexic and I think my youngest son is too. I went to dyslexia summer schools, camps, etc. My mum spent a lot of time with me, my sister used lots of online resources and pays a specialist tutor - they go without stuff to pay for some of this.

I wanted to be a nurse, I was told I would never get the grades, I could never achieve that. However I worked very hard, it took me longer than others - did an access course to get in and I worked in a residential home to get experience pre applying. I have now been a nurse for 16 years. I have a son with Asd and adhd so I know what it’s like to fight for your child and what they need, it’s mentally and emotionally draining, but I hope your daughter gets the help and support she needs to succeed in whatever she wants to do.

LIZS · 08/07/2022 14:35

Has she had an EP assessment and an EHCP? Senco sounds a bit lacking but it is way too young to assume the worst.

spagbog5 · 08/07/2022 14:33

All our dd's are dyslexic and dd1 is also dyspraxic .
She has an oxbridge degree and a very high earning job at 26.
Dd2 has a first from a Russell group uni and is also high earning at 24
Dd3 is predicted all 9's in her just sat GCSE's.
They have all needed our support and help in different ways but are doing brilliantly.
Don't write her off at 9 years old.
Ours couldn't spell / do phonics for toffee at that age but have excelled in high school.
She can also do any trade she wants , why write stuff off because she's a girl !!!

jobnockey · 08/07/2022 14:32

I work in a university and we have hundreds of students with dyslexia successfully graduating every year, including in medicine. Dyslexia does not necessarily have to be a barrier to any career. I would however be looking into the school senco provision and pushing for better support.

Hurstlandshome · 08/07/2022 14:30

She's also super happy and confident - I don't let her see my concerns.

OP posts:
Hurstlandshome · 08/07/2022 14:29

Perhaps I should rephrase: what jobs can people do who cannot read and write?

OP posts:
Hurstlandshome · 08/07/2022 14:28

I probably do have a narrow view, but my viewpoint at the moment is a child of 9 who can barely read and and write and I find it terrifying.
She has Senco support at school but it's just 'blue paper' and a little bit more time with the TA. Nothing that's making any difference.
A PP mentioned a degree and I just can't see how she'd complete that.

OP posts:
GingersHaveSoulsToo · 08/07/2022 14:28

Sorry cross post. Primary is the most difficult. As said, focus on getting the help she needs for assessments.

Swipe left for the next trending thread