Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Police officers 'shared images of person who died by suicide' - Warning: graphic descriptions

211 replies

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 14:01

Warning: graphic descriptions follow, in BBC News article and BBC video interview with the family:

Two NI police officers have been investigated for more than three years over allegations they manipulated a person who died by suicide's body and shared photos and a video online.

One of the officers has been suspended with full pay while the Police Ombudsman investigates. It is part of a wider investigation encompassing 11 separate but related incidents spanning several years. There are multiple suspects, including police officers and civilians, in Northern Ireland as well as in England. The investigation is looking at a range of possible offences including misconduct, harassment and the suspected supply of drugs.

The allegations around the two Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) officers are harrowing. The police officers asked the family to leave the room. The victim's body was moved around the room and posed for photographs and a video. His trousers were taken down and his genitalia exposed for one of the photographs. The images were then photoshopped with speech bubbles mocking the victim, including using a derogatory term for his religion and shared.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-62012268

The victim died in 2017 in Belfast. That is five years ago and still the police (PSNI) have not charged these sick and callous individuals. Only 30 hours of interviews have taken place in 5 years. When two disgraceful Met police officers similarly shared images of the bodies of murdered sisters Nicole Smallman and Bibaa Henry, they were quite rightly prosecuted and sent to prison - even by the Met.

The BBC recently broadcast interviews with two Police Service of Northern Ireland whistleblowers speaking publicly for the first time about serious allegations of misconduct and negligence within the PSNI:
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017yyn

Some Mumsnetters will have also seen my threads and those of others about the death and disappearance of young Noah Donohoe, also in Belfast, in 2020. After he had been missing for 6 days, Noah's naked body was retrieved from a drain. Two years later, his mother Fiona is still having to fight for the truth about her son's death and for justice for him. It is the same police force: the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), and the same Chief Constable: Simon Byrne.
Here is a factual and reliable pinned Twitter thread for people new to Noah's story or wanting to know more:
mobile.twitter.com/MarymoBelfast/status/1370453351616425985
Here is Fiona's podcast:

Here is a Channel 4 News report: www.channel4.com/news/noah-donohoe-family-seek-answers-over-belfast-teenagers-death And please do sign Fiona's petition if you haven't already: www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4573833-noah-donohoe-his-mothers-fight-for-the-truth-and-justice-please-help-stop-the-police-coroner-and-brandon-lewis-from-keeping-investigation-files-into-the-death-of-a-child-secret-thread-3?

These are only three examples of many serious failings from the PSNI. Victims' families have lost trust in them. Decent, whistleblowing officers have lost trust in them. The Metropolitan Police have recently been put into special measures for their failings. AIBU to believe that the same must happen with the lazy, corrupt, incompetent, racist and bigoted PSNI?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
39
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 11:42

IncessantNameChanger · 09/07/2022 00:26

Its indefensible. Simple as that. How any mother couldnt agree.that this is not the worse type of injustice is beyound me.

The truth will out. Have faith. But at what cost to the families? I honestly cant believe that no one could read these stories and defend those in power to protect.

It's only when your the other end of needing help in your most vulnerable time can you ever really understand the utter contempt for justice.

My friend is almost four years into a rape trail. Do the met care about justice or a conviction? Like fuck do they. Justice doesnt register.get one member of the met to tell me they care and would call bullshit in their face.

But like the two sisters mothers, time will not hold back the truth. It will come. One day

Thank you very much for your post @IncessantNameChanger and all the very best to your friend.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 11:36

montysma1 · 09/07/2022 02:32

Both cases are rank sectarianism by bigots a bigoted organisation.

It's hard not to come to that conclusion.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 10:45

When I read the BBC and Independent.ie reports above and watched the BBC interview with the victim's family, these things - apart from the abject horror of what the police officers had done to the person's body, of course - particularly struck me:

"Those police officers were in the house while I was there - asked me to leave the room - and I done everything they asked me to at the time,” he said.
The family trusted the police officers. Such a gross breach of that trust and when the family were at their most vulnerable. This family had just tried to resuscitate their loved one and the father was kneeling by the side of his dead son's body.

"And all that keeps coming back to me is why did I leave the room, because that must have been when they done it, when they took the photographs.”
They've got this grieving father blaming himself for leaving them with his son's body, for trusting them, for doing what most of us would have done in that situation.

This also brought me back to Fiona Donohoe, Noah's grieving mummy. She trusted the police, she didn't know any better, when Noah tragically disappeared and his body was found. The PSNI told her to trust them, told her they would do all they could to find Noah and then to investigate his death. The PSNI - all the ranks involved from top to bottom - soon and increasingly lost that trust by their own actions. Like the family above, Fiona learnt the hard way that the PSNI couldn't be trusted at all.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 10:15

Hardbackwriter · 09/07/2022 09:36

Brilliant post.

It really frustrates me that people use the 'few bad apples' thing without using the whole quote. It's 'a few bad apples spoils the barrel'. You can't shrug and say it's a few bad apples and no big deal but that's exactly how the rest of the barrel gets spoilt (or bruised, to use your very good analogy). I think it's pretty clear that this is now a spoilt barrel.

Thank you for these posts @IncompleteSenten and @Hardbackwriter

'a few bad apples spoils the barrel'.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 10:09

Two Northern Ireland police officers investigated for sharing photos of man who died by suicide
www.independent.ie/news/two-northern-ireland-police-officers-investigated-for-sharing-photos-of-man-who-died-by-suicide-41824693.html

'After his son’s death, the victim’s father said it was 18 months before he was made aware of the claims. The family said the incident has added to their trauma. The man’s father said he is “physically sick” to this day by the way his deceased son was treated.

UUP MLA Mike Nesbitt described the revelations as “an absolute scandal”.

Speaking to the BBC, policing board member Mr Nesbitt said he has grave concerns about transparency in the flow of information from the police.
It comes after it was revealed that around 130 police officers are currently being investigated for gross misconduct in Northern Ireland, revealed at the latest public Northern Ireland Policing Board meeting on Thursday.
The former Ulster Unionist Party leader said he suspects that’s “a very high number” compared to other forces around the UK.
“If it’s true – then it’s an absolute scandal… I have grave concerns and have had for some time about the flow of information from the PSNI to the Policing Board,” he said.
“We can only hold them to account for what we know is happening.”

The victim’s family's lawyer Pádraig Ó Muirigh said the five-year wait for justice was unacceptable.'

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 09/07/2022 09:36

IncompleteSenten · 09/07/2022 09:28

I'm so tired of the "few bad apples" thing that always gets thrown about.

Let's talk apples.

There many only be a 'few' bad apples but there's a fuckton of heavily bruised ones.

Every police officer who hears about or sees bad conduct and says nothing is a 'bruised apple'.

Every police officer who knows their colleague's nickname is 'the rapist' is a bruised apple.

You don't get to the point where officers can do horrendous things and have WhatsApp groups of dozens and dozens of colleagues laughing about it if these 'few bad apples' aren't surrounded by apples so badly bruised no fucker would eat them and Tesco would gather them up and chuck them in the bin out back.

Bad apples rape, abuse, threaten, expose the genitals of the dead and laugh about it in groups of 50.

Bruised apples know all of this happens and say nothing.

Brilliant post.

It really frustrates me that people use the 'few bad apples' thing without using the whole quote. It's 'a few bad apples spoils the barrel'. You can't shrug and say it's a few bad apples and no big deal but that's exactly how the rest of the barrel gets spoilt (or bruised, to use your very good analogy). I think it's pretty clear that this is now a spoilt barrel.

IncompleteSenten · 09/07/2022 09:28

I'm so tired of the "few bad apples" thing that always gets thrown about.

Let's talk apples.

There many only be a 'few' bad apples but there's a fuckton of heavily bruised ones.

Every police officer who hears about or sees bad conduct and says nothing is a 'bruised apple'.

Every police officer who knows their colleague's nickname is 'the rapist' is a bruised apple.

You don't get to the point where officers can do horrendous things and have WhatsApp groups of dozens and dozens of colleagues laughing about it if these 'few bad apples' aren't surrounded by apples so badly bruised no fucker would eat them and Tesco would gather them up and chuck them in the bin out back.

Bad apples rape, abuse, threaten, expose the genitals of the dead and laugh about it in groups of 50.

Bruised apples know all of this happens and say nothing.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 08:43

I hope the 3 families from Catholic backgrounds get an honest investigation and the bad eggs are removed from the system.

Wishful thinking.

Adding Shona Gillan to the list. ❤️

LaSavoie · 09/07/2022 04:57

Sick idiots. Who does that?!

cottagegardenflower · 09/07/2022 04:29

There are bad apples in every barrel, police included. The vast majority are good people, just like all professions, but I agree when people in authority behave badly it knocks confidence in them all

miltonj · 09/07/2022 04:15

Ownedbymycats · 08/07/2022 23:13

"Do you have any sympathy for them, these victims?"
Everyone has sympathy with the victims but that doesn't mean we have to castigate an entire police force. Some police officers, who are suspended, have behaved atrociously but that doesn't mean their colleagues have all behaved in a similar fashion.

The police officers who posed with the bodies of murdered sisters Nicole and bibba, sent those images on a WhatsApp group with 50 + members of the police in it. Indicating that they knew at least 50 other members of the met would find that funny or acceptable. These are no isolated incidents, these are just the stories which are exposed and make the news. The toxicity of the culture in our police runs deep and we need to completely reject it.

montysma1 · 09/07/2022 02:32

Both cases are rank sectarianism by bigots a bigoted organisation.

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 00:34

Twitter thread about what these PSNI officers have done to the poor man and his family. You don't have to be on Twitter to read it. Just click on 'show more replies' if the thread stops:

twitter.com/GrantSana/status/1544933598670864385

OP posts:
IncessantNameChanger · 09/07/2022 00:26

Its indefensible. Simple as that. How any mother couldnt agree.that this is not the worse type of injustice is beyound me.

The truth will out. Have faith. But at what cost to the families? I honestly cant believe that no one could read these stories and defend those in power to protect.

It's only when your the other end of needing help in your most vulnerable time can you ever really understand the utter contempt for justice.

My friend is almost four years into a rape trail. Do the met care about justice or a conviction? Like fuck do they. Justice doesnt register.get one member of the met to tell me they care and would call bullshit in their face.

But like the two sisters mothers, time will not hold back the truth. It will come. One day

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 00:08

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/07/2022 20:56

He had so much potential a gifted academic with a huge heart who wanted to change the world.

Heartbreaking.

Thank you for mentioning this @EmeraldShamrock1 It is really important that people know this. Noah was completely innocent. He was beautiful inside and out, a very bright boy who wanted to be a doctor to help people, sporty, musical, kind, gentle, funny, loving and much loved at home and at school. Danger found him that day. He was no threat to anyone. He did not deserve what happened to him and he did not deserve the sort of police 'investigation' he has been given. And nor does his mother.

And what threat was the person who died by suicide to those police officers? What had he done to deserve what they did to his body and to his family?

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 23:49

Ownedbymycats · 08/07/2022 23:13

"Do you have any sympathy for them, these victims?"
Everyone has sympathy with the victims but that doesn't mean we have to castigate an entire police force. Some police officers, who are suspended, have behaved atrociously but that doesn't mean their colleagues have all behaved in a similar fashion.

I don't believe that everyone does have sympathy with the victims, sadly. Again, you want to focus on NAPALT. Again, we know this. Not all the police officers are suspended. What about the colleagues who turn a blind eye or cover up for their colleagues? Have you watched the BBC Spotlight PSNI whistleblowers programme I have linked to yet? It was the whistleblowers themselves who suffered the most. Wayne Couzens colleagues in the Met also spring to mind, although there are many other examples. The PSNI officers involved in Noah Donohoe's poor excuse for an investigation are still at work. Perhaps you also think that the Met shouldn't be in special measures either?

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 23:36

I hadn't even thought of it from a GDPR point of view @Rahrahrahrahannoyed - yes, completely immoral.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 23:29

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/07/2022 22:12

@Ownedbymycats I apologise for calling you a sympathiser.

I have seen the word wrote in very recent times in relation to the IRA/UVF in newspapers off the back of Brexit.

But pp is right, some comments are an par with NAMALT.

And NAPALT.

But certainly not as bad as the derogatory name those police officers used in a speech bubble about the person who had died by suicide.

OP posts:
Rahrahrahrahannoyed · 08/07/2022 23:13

Shocking given GDPR laws and such.
Then there's morality on top of that of which they have none.

Ownedbymycats · 08/07/2022 23:13

"Do you have any sympathy for them, these victims?"
Everyone has sympathy with the victims but that doesn't mean we have to castigate an entire police force. Some police officers, who are suspended, have behaved atrociously but that doesn't mean their colleagues have all behaved in a similar fashion.

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 23:04

beautyisthefaceisee · 08/07/2022 22:19

No, shes right.

Are you under the impression the force act as one? this is what happened with BLM, and it didnt help anyone.

And yes, I'm a sympathiser of the police. Is there an issue with that?

And finally to deal with this, are you under the impression that institutional bigotry, misogyny and racism do not exist, including within the PSNI? Are you under the impression that this is all the fault of a few bad apples, a tiny minority, one or two individuals? Are you under the impression that, even if this was the case, those bad apples are dealt with swiftly, decisively and appropriately? The experience of many with the PSNI and other forces, including the cases I link to, says that you have the wrong impression.

Are you a police office, serving or retired, or related to one? You keep posting about and against the BLM movement - why is that? I haven't posted about BLM once and nor has anyone else except you, making it an issue. I have to ask: are you racist?

And yes, I'm a sympathiser of the police. Is there an issue with that?
The issue is that yes, on this thread about victims of the police, that NAPALT is tone deaf. Do you have any sympathy for them, these victims?

OP posts:
IdiotCreatures · 08/07/2022 22:53

@EmeraldShamrock1 I have just done some brief reading about Shona Gillian. Where she was found is very close to Belfast.
There seems to be some parallels going on between these two tragedies.
I knew someone who died in strange circumstances and the investigation was bungled by the (London based) police
It's just horrible not getting the answers around this kind of unpredictable and horrific event.

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 22:47

beautyisthefaceisee · 08/07/2022 22:16

You have an agenda. So say it!

Post about Noah. Post about the hurt.

Don't post a sensationalist headline and then drop it in later. Why do this?

I have answered you quite clearly already. You choose to ignore or dismiss my answer for reasons best known to yourself. You clearly have an agenda, which appears to be pro-police and anti-BLM. I get that. This thread isn't the place for your agenda and distraction techniques. Most posters are posting about the full range of issues in my OP. Please don't try to derail the thread further.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 22:37

Sensationalist headlines don't help .
They are honest headlines. They might be uncomfortable to read, but they are honest. And most importantly, they are about real people, including an innocent child, who were loved and deserved better from those paid and entrusted to provide a decent and fair service for all the public.

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 08/07/2022 22:19

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/07/2022 19:34

"with the lazy, corrupt, incompetent, racist and bigoted PSNI?"

That's a very strong statement and doesn't represent the police force I'm familiar with.

Wow sympathisers are out.

Have you read the evidence in the OP regarding the actions of the PSNI?

No, shes right.

Are you under the impression the force act as one? this is what happened with BLM, and it didnt help anyone.

And yes, I'm a sympathiser of the police. Is there an issue with that?