Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Police officers 'shared images of person who died by suicide' - Warning: graphic descriptions

211 replies

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 14:01

Warning: graphic descriptions follow, in BBC News article and BBC video interview with the family:

Two NI police officers have been investigated for more than three years over allegations they manipulated a person who died by suicide's body and shared photos and a video online.

One of the officers has been suspended with full pay while the Police Ombudsman investigates. It is part of a wider investigation encompassing 11 separate but related incidents spanning several years. There are multiple suspects, including police officers and civilians, in Northern Ireland as well as in England. The investigation is looking at a range of possible offences including misconduct, harassment and the suspected supply of drugs.

The allegations around the two Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) officers are harrowing. The police officers asked the family to leave the room. The victim's body was moved around the room and posed for photographs and a video. His trousers were taken down and his genitalia exposed for one of the photographs. The images were then photoshopped with speech bubbles mocking the victim, including using a derogatory term for his religion and shared.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-62012268

The victim died in 2017 in Belfast. That is five years ago and still the police (PSNI) have not charged these sick and callous individuals. Only 30 hours of interviews have taken place in 5 years. When two disgraceful Met police officers similarly shared images of the bodies of murdered sisters Nicole Smallman and Bibaa Henry, they were quite rightly prosecuted and sent to prison - even by the Met.

The BBC recently broadcast interviews with two Police Service of Northern Ireland whistleblowers speaking publicly for the first time about serious allegations of misconduct and negligence within the PSNI:
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017yyn

Some Mumsnetters will have also seen my threads and those of others about the death and disappearance of young Noah Donohoe, also in Belfast, in 2020. After he had been missing for 6 days, Noah's naked body was retrieved from a drain. Two years later, his mother Fiona is still having to fight for the truth about her son's death and for justice for him. It is the same police force: the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), and the same Chief Constable: Simon Byrne.
Here is a factual and reliable pinned Twitter thread for people new to Noah's story or wanting to know more:
mobile.twitter.com/MarymoBelfast/status/1370453351616425985
Here is Fiona's podcast:

Here is a Channel 4 News report: www.channel4.com/news/noah-donohoe-family-seek-answers-over-belfast-teenagers-death And please do sign Fiona's petition if you haven't already: www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4573833-noah-donohoe-his-mothers-fight-for-the-truth-and-justice-please-help-stop-the-police-coroner-and-brandon-lewis-from-keeping-investigation-files-into-the-death-of-a-child-secret-thread-3?

These are only three examples of many serious failings from the PSNI. Victims' families have lost trust in them. Decent, whistleblowing officers have lost trust in them. The Metropolitan Police have recently been put into special measures for their failings. AIBU to believe that the same must happen with the lazy, corrupt, incompetent, racist and bigoted PSNI?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
39
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 10/07/2022 22:02

thedancingbear · 10/07/2022 08:00

but if you don’t bother to do or say anything to change the underlying culture, you are complicit. You are as bad as them.

and we’ve no way of knowing who the good apples are. I imagine every copper says the same as you. But, clearly, far too many are rotten.

so I’ll judge you by your deeds. Instead of discussing how things can be improved, you come on here to stick up for your corrupt, misogynist, violent organisation. You come on here as a man to tell women they are wrong.

and you do it all the fucking time.

I also wonder how many of the self-identified 'good apples' and their 'good apple' colleagues are good apples to all members of our community, or whether they are just good apples to the ones who look, sound and pray like them.

Would the police officers who moved, posed, photographed, videoed, exposed and ridiculed the body of the man who died by suicide have been good apples if he hadn't been Catholic? Probably. Did they appear to be good apples to their colleagues and senior officers who are more like them? Probably. Would the police officers responsible for finding Noah alive and investigating his death have been good apples if Noah hadn't been bi-racial and Catholic - never mind the people responsible for his disappearance and death and for not helping him? Probably.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 10/07/2022 17:04

The PSNI Chief Constable Simon Byrne has just published his end of year report:
www.psni.police.uk/globalassets/news-and-appeals/latest-news/070722-chief-constables-accountability-report---july-2022/chief-constables-end-of-year-report-to-the-northern-ireland-policing-board-2021-2022.pdf

Northern Ireland has one of the lowest crime rates (page 40) when compared to England and Wales. You would think then that the PSNI had the time to deal with the serious wrongdoing of its officers in less than 5 years, to properly try to find poor Noah as a critical incident when he disappeared and correctly investigate his death, wouldn't you? But then, if they are recording that what happened to Noah Donohoe was not a crime, perhaps the crime rate is not as low as the Chief Constable reports.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 10/07/2022 15:32

Policing Board to hold special meeting over suicide victim's pictures:
www.irishnews.com/news/northernirelandnews/2022/07/09/news/policing_board_to_hold_special_meeting_over_suicide_victim_s_pictures-2767929/

'The Police Federation said the incident was distressing adding that there were wider implications for the PSNI.'
Absolutely there are.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 10/07/2022 14:33

Also in the Guardian:
Belfast police accused of posing man’s body for photos after suicide after images shared online, including speech bubble with derogatory language
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jul/08/belfast-police-accused-of-posing-mans-body-for-photos-after-suicide

OP posts:
thedancingbear · 10/07/2022 08:00

Felix125 · 10/07/2022 06:09

You could say the same about every profession though - teachers, nurses, taxi-drivers, air crew etc etc

I would class myself as good apple - not 'bad' or 'bruised' as are my shift who I work with. So where would I fit in....?

but if you don’t bother to do or say anything to change the underlying culture, you are complicit. You are as bad as them.

and we’ve no way of knowing who the good apples are. I imagine every copper says the same as you. But, clearly, far too many are rotten.

so I’ll judge you by your deeds. Instead of discussing how things can be improved, you come on here to stick up for your corrupt, misogynist, violent organisation. You come on here as a man to tell women they are wrong.

and you do it all the fucking time.

Felix125 · 10/07/2022 06:09

IncompleteSenten · 09/07/2022 09:28

I'm so tired of the "few bad apples" thing that always gets thrown about.

Let's talk apples.

There many only be a 'few' bad apples but there's a fuckton of heavily bruised ones.

Every police officer who hears about or sees bad conduct and says nothing is a 'bruised apple'.

Every police officer who knows their colleague's nickname is 'the rapist' is a bruised apple.

You don't get to the point where officers can do horrendous things and have WhatsApp groups of dozens and dozens of colleagues laughing about it if these 'few bad apples' aren't surrounded by apples so badly bruised no fucker would eat them and Tesco would gather them up and chuck them in the bin out back.

Bad apples rape, abuse, threaten, expose the genitals of the dead and laugh about it in groups of 50.

Bruised apples know all of this happens and say nothing.

You could say the same about every profession though - teachers, nurses, taxi-drivers, air crew etc etc

I would class myself as good apple - not 'bad' or 'bruised' as are my shift who I work with. So where would I fit in....?

thedancingbear · 09/07/2022 22:10

stillvicarinatutu · 08/07/2022 19:14

Firstly the police in NI operate in a very different way to the rest of the uk .

This undermines the majority of good police officers who are out there - me being one . I'm a 50 year old woman , and I've put my life on the line more than once for the public .
I am proud of the job I do and I'm proud to say I serve the public and the queen even when I'm jaded at times with tales like this .

If found to be proven those officers need dealing with . But there are literally thousands of good decent police officers out there who run toward danger to protect the general public and do it well .

Police are made up of the society they police - yes some bad apples and they need weeding out and dealing with - but the vast majority of my colleagues are people I'm proud of and who do a good job .

Sensationalist headlines don't help . I worked right through lockdown, we haven't had a real pay rise in years . I have never encountered so much violence than during lockdown, people - the public - were drinking more , arguing more , getting more violent and 6 of my shift were seriously assaulted on duty , one sustained a broken leg , one a broken jaw , one was beaten and left for dead at 3am in the middle of a road .
Police officers are assaulted daily and yet this never makes the news unless they're killed .

Please don't tar all officers with the same brush .
And like everyone else in the uk - innocent till proven guilty.

NACALT (not all coppers are like that)

there’s always one or two serving police officers who come on these threads to defend the indefensible

gamerchick · 09/07/2022 22:01

I'm not the one posting a sensationalist MN title knowing no one is going to disagree with you and then posting about your own cause and agenda. Totally disingenuous

Yeah, why I voted yabu. Some people choose to avoid threads about Noah.

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 21:05

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 08:43

I hope the 3 families from Catholic backgrounds get an honest investigation and the bad eggs are removed from the system.

Wishful thinking.

Adding Shona Gillan to the list. ❤️

I'd like to add Arlene Arkinson to the list, a 15 year old child who was raped and murdered by Robert Howard and her body never found. She was another victim of the PSNI. They applied and were granted a Public Interest Immunity Certificate to protect Robert Howard and keep information about him secret. He was an informant and a known violent sex offender. Ben Wallace, current Conservative MP for Wyre and Preston North and Defence Minister, was Northern Ireland Secretary at the time and granted it. Robert Howard got away with Arlene's rape and murder. He was also then free to travel widely in Ireland, England and Scotland and, as a prolific and predatory violent sex offender, committed other similar crimes. He was finally brought to justice by Kent Police, after he had raped and murdered another girl in England. I'd like to add her name to the list too: Hannah Williams, aged 14.

I know that some people see this as 'just a Northern Ireland problem', but the case of Robert Howard reminds us that it isn't. He was free to travel. The police officer mentioned in the Belfast Telegraph report posted upthread worked for Greater Manchester Police.

And the PSNI don't learn. As I mentioned in the OP, they have applied for a Public Interest Immunity Certificate in Noah's investigation too, to keep 500 pages secret. Brandon Wallace, Conservative MP for Great Yarmouth, was no doubt considering granting it but has now resigned from Boris Johnson's cabinet as Northern Ireland Secretary. The task now falls to Shailesh Vara , Conservative MP for North West Cambridgeshire and new NI Secretary - but for how long with the situation in No 10, who knows?!

OP posts:
billy1966 · 09/07/2022 21:02

Having a background where involvement with the police was negligible and raised to view them positively, my own experiences have all been hugely positive.
But the last couple of years cases seem to be piling up.

The case of taking a child from her exam, strip searching her, whilst on her period, without her parents being contacted, because a teacher randomly smelt weed has had a profound affect on me.

I think of her and her poor mum, faced with her distressed child coming in from school with this unbelievably story.

I spoke at length about it with my husband and wondered how we both wouldn't go completely fxxking mad, at our child being sexually assaulted by the state whilst two teachers stood guard outside the room.

It has forever changed forever how I view both teachers and the police.

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 20:26

I agree @billy1966 - thanks for reading and posting.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 20:24

I think some attempts to change this have been made in recent years in some police areas @SpongeBobJudgeyPants . A huge problem remains though for the spouses and partners on the receiving end of Domestic Abuse from serving and ex police officers in reporting it and getting help. Like you say, it's the culture, and is somebody going to watch your back when on patrol if you report them for any wrong-doing? The whistleblowers in the BBC Spotlight programme I've linked to in the OP had a very hard time, from senior officers and not just colleagues, and they are the tip of the iceberg in the PSNI.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 18:01

Thank you @Herejustforthisone - hopefully we can get back to just posting about the subjects of the thread now.

OP posts:
SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 09/07/2022 15:51

Many years ago, about 30? there was a film on tv called Closing Ranks about how a PC's physical abuse of his wife was ignored. As a then serving Police Officer I recognised the culture. That would go a long way to explaining why other people daren't whistle blow, unless they want there career to be over. I've seen similar things happen re someone trying to do the right thing. Sad, but true. Make/still makes me both Angry and Sad.

billy1966 · 09/07/2022 15:48

So shocking.

All those families absolutely failed when they were so vulnerable.

It takes a particular type of scum to disrespect a corpse.

Thanks for posting OP, I was unaware.

beautyisthefaceisee · 09/07/2022 15:10

Herejustforthisone · 09/07/2022 15:07

I thought you were going to leave the thread? May I suggest you do as you pledged? You arguably have form for this sort of thing on threads.

You can suggest, but it's nothing to do with you (nor is what I do on other threads, so I'm not sure why you're involving yourself in that too and bringing it over here, which is against MN etiquette). If by "sort of thing" you mean not allowing MN to turn into one big echo chambers by entitled posters, I absolutely do. The only reason I'm going is what tends to happen is MN suspends posters to appease the bullies like yourself, and I'm not giving you that, so please don't think I'm unwatching for any other reason (certainly not cause you've told me to). Thanks for your input!

Herejustforthisone · 09/07/2022 15:07

beautyisthefaceisee · 09/07/2022 14:45

Interesting that I apologised to MN yet you said thank you as if you played no part in it whatsoever and we answer to you.

I dont think I've ever come across such an entitled poster.

I thought you were going to leave the thread? May I suggest you do as you pledged? You arguably have form for this sort of thing on threads.

beautyisthefaceisee · 09/07/2022 14:45

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 13:25

Thank you @YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet

Interesting that I apologised to MN yet you said thank you as if you played no part in it whatsoever and we answer to you.

I dont think I've ever come across such an entitled poster.

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 14:16

Trigger warning - suicide:

'The Belfast Telegraph can reveal that a Twitter account linked to one of the accused tweeted in April 2017: “Awesome, couple of hangings in the last couple of days.” The same account also tweeted: “Is it bad that hanging bodies make me laugh?”

The family would have been unaware of the gross breach of their grief only for the overt activities of a number of officers who had been publicly abusing high-profile figures, including Alliance leader Naomi Long. After the Police Ombudsman was called in to investigate the online activities of several officers, the pictures, along with a number of other alleged offences, were identified.

There has been criticism of how long the case has taken, with the officers at the centre of the investigation suspended on full pay for almost five years.

The investigation into the police troll accounts led to the arrest of Bangor-born ex-police officer Lee Howard, who ran an anonymous Twitter profile. Howard, who spent much of his youth in Coleraine, was convicted in 2020 of eight offences involving unauthorised access to computer data and disclosing personal data. However, the 32-year-old walked free from court after a judge was told he was mentally ill and undergoing treatment. Until his arrest, Howard was a serving officer with Greater Manchester Police. The delay in the Ombudsman’s investigation, in comparison to how promptly the Manchester Policing Authority dealt with the case, led to criticism and questions being asked at the NI Policing Board.'

Just to be clear, as I understand it, Lee Howard is not one of the officers who took the photos and video or posed and exposed the body of the person who died by suicide. Apparently you're ok if you abuse ordinary people, just not high profile people like Alliance Party Leader/Justice Minister Naomi Long. That is the only reason it came to light.

OP posts:
MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 13:25

Thank you @YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/07/2022 12:42

@IncompleteSenten Excellent post.

@beautyisthefaceisee What is your issue? Are you a PSNI officer?
Why can't you see that both cases are related to unprofessional behaviour from PSNI officers against members of the Catholic community.

I added Shona Gillan's name to the thread too, another victim whose death wasn't seen as suspicious despite the circumstances until they released the body for her wake to be embalmed before deciding her death was suspicious.

Those cases are a drop in the ocean when it comes to the Catholic community in NI.

These families are left without any investigations or justice. Noah included.

Why are you defending years of ignorance towards 50% of the population from NI.

beautyisthefaceisee · 09/07/2022 12:38

Apologies @YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet - I will unwatch and hide and leave Op to it.

YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · 09/07/2022 12:36

Hello - can we ask that everyone considers our Talk guidelines before posting? Disagreements are absolutely fine but please do so politely.

beautyisthefaceisee · 09/07/2022 12:08

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 09/07/2022 10:45

When I read the BBC and Independent.ie reports above and watched the BBC interview with the victim's family, these things - apart from the abject horror of what the police officers had done to the person's body, of course - particularly struck me:

"Those police officers were in the house while I was there - asked me to leave the room - and I done everything they asked me to at the time,” he said.
The family trusted the police officers. Such a gross breach of that trust and when the family were at their most vulnerable. This family had just tried to resuscitate their loved one and the father was kneeling by the side of his dead son's body.

"And all that keeps coming back to me is why did I leave the room, because that must have been when they done it, when they took the photographs.”
They've got this grieving father blaming himself for leaving them with his son's body, for trusting them, for doing what most of us would have done in that situation.

This also brought me back to Fiona Donohoe, Noah's grieving mummy. She trusted the police, she didn't know any better, when Noah tragically disappeared and his body was found. The PSNI told her to trust them, told her they would do all they could to find Noah and then to investigate his death. The PSNI - all the ranks involved from top to bottom - soon and increasingly lost that trust by their own actions. Like the family above, Fiona learnt the hard way that the PSNI couldn't be trusted at all.

Ans this isnt distracting and derailing, no?

beautyisthefaceisee · 09/07/2022 12:07

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 08/07/2022 22:47

I have answered you quite clearly already. You choose to ignore or dismiss my answer for reasons best known to yourself. You clearly have an agenda, which appears to be pro-police and anti-BLM. I get that. This thread isn't the place for your agenda and distraction techniques. Most posters are posting about the full range of issues in my OP. Please don't try to derail the thread further.

Excuse me??! How rude are you?

I'm not the one posting a sensationalist MN title knowing no one is going to disagree with you and then posting about your own cause and agenda. Totally disingenuous.

I never said I was anti BLM or pro police. What I said was thankfully the days of police being slagged off all over social media had auietened down and you are stirring it all up again with your agenda.

I'm not derailing your thread, but equally you dont own Mn and cannot instruct us all to fall in line. 'Distraction' techniques indeed.

Nasty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread