Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Autism isn't a fucking superpower !!

162 replies

lollipoprainbow · 08/07/2022 12:57

Sorry but it's really not. I'm currently doing an online autism course with a lovely bunch of parents and the teacher of the course is sweet but she will keep referring to autism as a superpower and everyone chuckles and agrees!! If they could see how distressed my dd10 is every day, having massive meltdowns about her looks etc they'd have a different view.

Anyone else agree with me ??

OP posts:
drspouse · 08/07/2022 14:59

DS has ADHD and some traits of autism. We are forever being told about all the celebs who have ADHD. Let's forget the huge number in the prison population, eh?

Goldencarp · 08/07/2022 14:57

KingofLoss · 08/07/2022 14:18

Jinx. Glad you’ve said it too.

i hate when you see parents asking for support and advice when they’ve found out their baby might have DS. All they receive is comments saying that the only difference between a child with and without DS is the latter’s boundless capacity for love 🙄 it does nobody any favours to pretend that certain conditions are only problematic due to stigma. People deserve the full range of experiences to prepare themselves and make the right decision for them.

Agree I worked with young people with DS and it’s very much a spectrum like autism.

HailAdrian · 08/07/2022 14:57

It helps SOME autistic people to think of it like that. I have a severely autistic son and I'm not bothered by that personally.

Sweatinglikeabitch · 08/07/2022 14:56

Sweatinglikeabitch · 08/07/2022 14:54

We have this argument every few weeks on here. A double edged sword is a good description for many. Obviously with it being a spectrum some struggle more than they benefit, some benefit more than they struggle. As an autistic though I do find it offensive/demoralising/dehumanising when parents of autistic children so fiercely insist that it's just all bad and their kid is nothing but a sufferer. My mum and I are both autistic, she was talking about a struggle she has at work when she tells her colleagues to think a certain way to problem solve, and I'm like "yeah... neurotypicals aren't very good at that." (It's a way of visualising that's hugely helpful and allows me to solve complicated maths problems in my head, I just put the whiteboard up and write it down. Like if anyone's seen the queen's bandit how you see the chessboard is how I can actually see it.) I struggle s

Thumb slipped. I struggle socially and with sensory stuff. But if everyone was autistic I'd be fine, it's neurotypicals and their unnecessary physical contact and complicated "social norms" that are the problem for me.
Not the case for all autistics, it's a spectrum but don't make sweeping statements about autism when you don't like hearing sweeping statements about autism.

Willowcat77 · 08/07/2022 14:55

I am autistic, as are my children, and we get annoyed when people talk about our 'superpowers'. It's such a cliché. Even autistic 'influencers' on social media etc keep parroting this phrase and boast about how incredibly special and successful they are because of their Autism. It makes me feel rubbish, like I'm not properly autistic and can't succeed at life like them. My son is actually a maths & musical genius (Maths MA distinction etc) but can't get a proper job because he doesn't come across as neurotypical. My daughter has had to drop out of university because of the stress. For us our Autism just seems to hold us back.

Yodaisawally · 08/07/2022 14:54

I'm autistic. It is definitely a double edged sword and I'm glad there is more awareness now BUT the recent trend for basing everyone in this 'superpower' group is harmful for those at the more severe end of the spectrum. It seems to me at the moment that it's trendy to be autistic. It's a fucking pain in the arse.

Sweatinglikeabitch · 08/07/2022 14:54

We have this argument every few weeks on here. A double edged sword is a good description for many. Obviously with it being a spectrum some struggle more than they benefit, some benefit more than they struggle. As an autistic though I do find it offensive/demoralising/dehumanising when parents of autistic children so fiercely insist that it's just all bad and their kid is nothing but a sufferer. My mum and I are both autistic, she was talking about a struggle she has at work when she tells her colleagues to think a certain way to problem solve, and I'm like "yeah... neurotypicals aren't very good at that." (It's a way of visualising that's hugely helpful and allows me to solve complicated maths problems in my head, I just put the whiteboard up and write it down. Like if anyone's seen the queen's bandit how you see the chessboard is how I can actually see it.) I struggle s

Staffy1 · 08/07/2022 14:53

Agreed. Also “I wouldn’t change a thing about my child, they are perfect as they are” - good for you, I would change autism if I could, for my child’s sake.

Turquoise651 · 08/07/2022 14:52

My son has recently been diagnosed with ASD and it’s frustrating to find how many preconceived ideas people have about what it means. I’d definitely be annoyed if someone described it as a “superpower” (very patronising for a start!)

MargaretThursday · 08/07/2022 14:51

I think there is an aspect that thinking around disability in general has been changed over the last 20 years.
I have a dd who is nearly 20yo who with a physical disability, and I've seen a of a change in attitude over that time. Some of it is positive, but I'm not sure it is totally.

When she was born I found the attitude was much quieter around it. The children got on and almost always did what "normal" children did. If they didn't manage though, there wasn't much help available.
Now I see blogs/news with "this amazing child who has done XYZ" and I'm more bemused that they thought they wouldn't do it than anything else because all the children I knew did it without more than a minor hiccup.

But the other way too. When there's things they will struggle to do, if anyone says that, then there's great indignation that they should be able to do anything and everything and an aspect of thinking if money is thrown (normally other people's) at it, then it can be solved. Or if it isn't then everyone else should adjust to them.
Unfortunately there are some things that this group of children will find very difficult and will struggle to compete/achieve at the same level as their peers who don't have this disability. That's why we have things like the Paralympics.

It is positive in that there is more assistance available. On the whole children don't get excluded from an activity because it's assumed they can't, and parents and teachers take the line of how can we make sure everyone is included rather than "just sit down quietly over there and don't make a fuss, dear". And if they do try that, then there are lines of complaint that should take it seriously.
Children are more inclined to accept difference and it's great that on TV we see more inclusivity, and children do get very excited at seeing someone "like me" and it boosts their self esteem.

But I'm not sure the attitude of "isn't it amazing" is always helpful. My dd commented one time that she found it far more insulting that they thought she wouldn't manage something than nice to be praised, for example.

I have seen recently someone describing dd's disability as a "superpower". It isn't. It really isn't. It seems amazing to anyone who hasn't got it that she can do some things, but to her it's just as normal as your body is to you. And it does cause problems, both directly due to her disability, and in later life when I can confidently tell you which parts of her body are going to wear out sooner due to overwork.
It does mean she has done things that her siblings haven't. Her disability has given her some opportunities that most children don't get. It still isn't a superpower, and those opportunities don't compensate for what she's missing.

PollyEsther · 08/07/2022 14:49

It's one of those phrases that REALLY fucks me off. It undermines the pain and struggle that most some people with Autism go through on a daily basis. It's ableist. It suggests the viewpoint of those who have a negative experience is not valid. It's just shit, as most trite phrases are tbh.

TorviShieldMaiden · 08/07/2022 14:49

I don't think my dd would agree either, but I once asked her if she would prefer not to be autistic (or something like that- i think I phrased it differently) and she said no, as it is what makes her, her.

If you use the social model of disability (which you should) it isn't autism that disables, but the society and neurotypical world.

So no, it isn't a superpower, but I also don't agree with some of the ways it is described here.

hollyivysaurus · 08/07/2022 14:48

It’s a phrase that really bugs me. I’m glad that some autistic people do see it that way, but I don’t think you can make a statement like that for everyone. My DS is in the process of being assessed and diagnosed at age 4, and although high functioning I can see how much more challenging it’s making his life.

He had a haircut yesterday, with a different lovely hairdresser to usual as his old one has gone on maternity leave and closed her salon. It was a minefield and SO hard for him. Little everyday things like that are so challenging. He needs a TA to support him at school, to remind and prompt him and help with transitions even though he’s a very clever boy. And although kids are kind and inclusive now, I know there will almost certainly be issues as he gets older. I adore my son, but last week he had a horrendous meltdown, told me he didn’t love me and kicked me repeatedly. It’s hard to see that as any kind of superpower 😭

LynneBenfield · 08/07/2022 14:48

If people want to frame their own autism as a superpower then I have little issue with that. However I can appreciate that it can bring problems when/if that is then generalised to the wider population with regards to assumptions around individual feelings, abilities and levels of need.

Floogal · 08/07/2022 14:45

I have ASD as does my 7 yo son. Unfortunately, he's non verbal. He's actually clever and affectionate but certainly not a superpower
I remember years ago I used to go to an ASD support group for young adults. Some of us got sick of the fact news paper or articles would only focus on successful people with ASD and how alienating it was for those who were struggling with adulthood. Finding employment, friendship and love was a challenge for example. Seemed a bit insensitive

Sirzy · 08/07/2022 14:44

Comments like that annoy me as much as when people say “only special people are given special children” and other such bullshit.

I think they can be very dangerous messages as they give the idea that everything is rosy and you just need to keep on smiling through when actually it’s fine to say sometimes things are a bit shit. (Or a lot shit!)

Eviesmum29 · 08/07/2022 14:44

Absolutely not a super power, and unacceptable for anybody other than, say, a child saying it about themselves.

I would be annoyed if somebody tried to downplay my sons disability as a super power. Unfortunately somebody did use that line within earshot of him once and now he says he has 'weaponised' autism 😁

SharlaShanti · 08/07/2022 14:44

Your teacher sounds like an idiot!! She should spend some time with my 27 year old autistic adult with high anxiety issues which makes him really aggressive. She'll change her mind in 5 minutes.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 08/07/2022 14:42

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/07/2022 14:02

Calling it a "superpower" is so bloody tone-deaf

I agree, but it's noticeable that nobody said that when Greta Thunberg coined the phrase - at least I think it was her?

At the time folk were repeating it constantly on the back of this "wonderful person" and anyone who dissented was slaughtered

It's the difference between someone who's been through a hard time and come out the other side saying, "You know, losing my job turned out to be a blessing" and an employment coach telling a classroom full of jobseekers, "Losing your job is a blessing".

SummerLobelia · 08/07/2022 14:42

And yy to a previous poster. I do think my child is absolutely super. He is funny. He is extremely kind. He tries so hard to think of the feelings of others which is extra difficult because he is not great at reading social cues. he adores his cats, one of whom we share with an elderly and very ill neighbour. When he found out that our shared cat was terminally ill, and after our neighbour had finally gone into a care home he said ; 'Let's not tell XXXXX. It will only confuse and upset her and it would be better if she did not have to go through that pain of knowing'.

Every second Saturday morning he puts our shared cat into her cat box and we trot off to the care home so our neighbour can give her a cuddle (the care home allows it). That was his idea as well. (So that other trope- that autistic people lack empathy can fucking fuck off as well).

Arenanewbie · 08/07/2022 14:41

Of course it’s not, it sounds so patronising and undermines everyday struggles of parents and children.
you can say something like this to a group of 6 y.o. to explain them autism positively but not on online autism course.

Mumofsend · 08/07/2022 14:39

I absolutely hate this. For my DD is absolutely is not a superpower. There are some positive traits she has bit the actual condition is miserable

Zezet · 08/07/2022 14:36

I think in my case it's sort if true that autism gave me very difficult teenage years but made me very successful in my twenties and early thirties, because I happened to have read a few advice blogs that I followed to the max and my life worked out great as a result. My one sibling is equally successful with their aspergers. We make a lot of money for very little effort (super powers of analysis!), happily married, happy in our respective circles off basically-all-undiagnosed-also-autistic-and-adhd-friends, and so on.

Of course, none of us got a diagnosis until our thirties.

My other sibling, since years, struggles with deep depression as a result of aspergers. She would have been so highfunctioning as to be undiagnosed until she got her depression.

No comparison either with my nephews who are non-verbal autistic (diagnosed at young age) and who, despite having certain strong powers as a result of autism, have a life I wouldn't wish on anyone.

To meaningfully talk about autism, I think you have to presume it's a gift for almost no one. The exceptions don't prove anything, just that some people will inevitable get lucky with a given set of circumstances - and that "autism" covers such a range of symptoms and severity as to be almost meaningless as a term.

SummerLobelia · 08/07/2022 14:34

actiongirl1978 · 08/07/2022 13:09

Definitely not a super power here.

Tho DS12 would be considered 'high functioning'.

He refers to his stupid brain that makes him autistic.

We try to cheer lead but frankly it's a bum deal.

I agree with tis and could have written it. Same age DS and he also refers to his stupid brain. We try and point out the ways in which his autism affects HIM in a good way. There are a few ways but mostly it is a daily struggle for him and us all.

I recall very well our first meeting with the SENCO at his school. He has been diagnosed with autism (with accompanying learning difficulties), ADHD, dyspraxia, a number of auto immune conditions and had just that week been diagnosed finally with tourettes. I sighed at one poiint when we were talking about the bullying he was receiving at school due to his tic and commented as an aside 'poor kid'. The SENCO got very firm with me and contradicted me and said 'No, you can't say that. This is his super power!!!'. I felt well and truly dressed down.

Well, I am not seeing any superpowers. I see the bullying. I see the social anxiety. I see the inability to truly connect with peers. I see the meltdowns. I see the falling behind academically and socially. I see the fact that I am called several times a week by the school because they need my help to get him backl to class. I see the friends who are now pulling away from him because they are developing and maturing and he is not. I see the lack of party invitations. I see the utter confusion when he does not have a goddamned clue what is going on. I see the confusion when he cannot work out if people are making fund of him or not and comes down on the side of they must be.

So fuck off with your superpower trope. Oh and by the way, he's not a maths genious, even though apparently everyone who is autistic simply must be and he probably will never be able to live independently.

AffIt · 08/07/2022 14:33

Ponderingwindow · 08/07/2022 14:30

It helps me to frame my life by acknowledging the very real strengths my autism brings. I can see data and numbers in ways other people can’t. I can intensely focus on a project. I make connections other people don’t. I have built an amazing career and an excellent reputation because of these skills. I wouldn’t give that up for anything and I do think of it as a superpower

when the moments of ostracism from my childhood, the memories of how things were handled so incredibly poorly back then start creeping into my head, it’s important for me to focus on the positive.

it’s also necessary to have a good sense of humor and acknowledge my limitations. If I were to treat it as all doom and gloom it would be depressing. Instead, when I start to melt down because there is a change in the plans and I have to make a decision on the fly, it helps so much to just stop and acknowledge to myself, and if I am with family or trusted friends others, that this is one of those ridiculous autism moments and just try to just laugh about it instead. It’s taken time to get to that point, but that is the wisdom of middle age and life experience.

As a fellow autistic person, I completely agree with you.