Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think in many roles the higher up the ladder the less stressful the job can be?

36 replies

user34632 · 08/07/2022 12:40

I know this won't be true in a lot of jobs. I also know the higher up you are the higher your responsibility. But in terms of day to day stress and workload unless the team/people your responsible for really messes up.
This seems to be the case for many of the companies I have work for and DH also agreed it's the same with him. DH is now in management for a call centre and he says his job is far easier than when he worked in the centre on the phones. It was literally pressure to hit targets constantly, taking back to back calls, managers down your neck. Now he is in management he obviously gets pressure from higher up to hit the targets but he just passes that on. His days just consists of performance reviews, rotas, admin etc.

I work in a admin role where the workload is ridiculous. We are constantly get more work and always behind. Management here are just in constant meetings of which we sometimes attend. They often just seem like chats were it's agreed what work needs to be done and how me and other admin colleagues will do it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MsFogi · 08/07/2022 15:08

I don't think there is less stress however I do think that there more autonomy as you get more senior. This can lead to it being less stressful trying to juggle work and home life because eg you don't have to ask your boss if it is okay to do x on Thursday afternoon, you just block a few hours out in your diary on Thursday afternoon and do x (and then get the work done at some other point).

Thebeastofsleep · 08/07/2022 15:00

My work load has lessened but my responsibility and level of accountability is much higher. Overall I'm less stressed though.

DH is more stressed, and his workload has increased, but his job is much more flexible when not in a run period.

Thinkbiglittleone · 08/07/2022 14:32

I think there is the accountability aspect. So you may not be responsible for completing tasks, but you are now accountable for other teams actions completing those tasks.

You also get to have a lot more control over your day, which is a bonus as you know what works.

I always think sometimes middle management is the worst place to be as you manage people so are accountable for their actions but in the same breath are not senior enough to implement better ways of working and processes to resolve issues.

Once you get above that level the stresses are still there, the hands on work load may change, but the stresses are there, they have just changed.

Yodaisawally · 08/07/2022 14:23

I'm now responsible for people's lives as in financially. It's a whole lot more fucking stressful. If the business goes tits up I have to make people redundant. I'm thinking of going back a stage and chilling out a bit.

Eeiliethya · 08/07/2022 14:19

It's a completely different kind of stress.
Whilst I can delegate to people the nature of my role only allows me to delegate tasks but not responsibility (as per legal and regulatory requirements) so if one of them cocks up then i'm the fucker in the firing line from my own management and a regulatory body on top to boot. I could end up in prison for someone else's error.

Whilst I do less of the day to day manual output, I'm a decision maker and have targets to meet as well as the task of managing people and the development of skills within my team, which is ever changing due to the nature of the industry.

So whilst it's less stress in the sense that I'm not shuffling workload to meet demand, I'm juggling a lot of balls at once, and dropping one could result in catastrophic personal and professional consequences.

Don't get me wrong, I adore my job and the pressures but I often dream of the day when I can semi-retire and become a trolly collector at Sainsbury's.

summer4509 · 08/07/2022 14:18

I would say the workload increases but in a less defined way. At a lower level you can have a lot of work to do but it will tend to be specific tasks so it is obvious to everyone else in the team how much there is to do.

At a more senior level your role is usually more vague, with a lot of your work being based on improving things or developing new ways of working. From the outside it would be easy to think 'what do they do?' as the timelines for producing an end result are much longer and the end result less defined. This is in addition to managing a team and all that entails.

Having recently moved into a management role I think that the stress and workload is more in most senior jobs but it is difficult to understand why until you are doing it.

senua · 08/07/2022 14:18

I read This is Going to Hurt by Adam Kay. He used to complain about his higher-ups and implied that all they did was swan about and then knock off early to play golf. Then he got promoted on an acting-up basis. Couldn't hack it and left the HNS due to the stress. Turns out that it wasn't that easy after all; it was just that those who could do it made light work of it.

InvincibleInvisibility · 08/07/2022 14:12

Some excellent posts from PPs.

I remember when we discovered a compliance mistake made by someone. It was made by somone 4 levels lower than my director but it was my director who would go to prison if we didn't sort it out asap.

And a good manager never passes the pressure down from above. A good manager acts as a buffer and protector.

Badgirlriri · 08/07/2022 14:06

YANBU. Look at how many people, who say they’re on six figure salaries, sit on mumsnet all day 🙄😂

EBearhug · 08/07/2022 14:04

I think the stresses are different - you do have more flexibility about things like leaving early, but being responsible for people's livelihoods and careers - going through a round of redundancies as a manager can be massively stressful.

Zeus44 · 08/07/2022 14:01

Different type of stress and volume pressures. I have to deliver less than I did when I was junior 10 years ago, but what I have to deliver has to be right first time and on point.

EthicalNonMahogany · 08/07/2022 13:58

I've just taken a pretty senior role and while there are still only the same number of hours in the day, I am finding it's harder work for several reasons.

  1. Constant code switching and no "down hours". Every hour packed with meetings all of which I'm required at and need to make decisions in - and the decisions need to be good ones. Every meeting about something different with a different cast of characters all with needs! I never have anything at which I can coast, any more.

  2. Visibility, tone and constant, constant attention to culture and change management. If I turn up and say something irritated or flippant this might make others feel disheartened or might stop them taking on a project I really need them to take on because I need to move the whole organisation in a certain direction. If they don't bother all my plans stall. Basically...

  3. I have no objectives I can achieve alone. They all depend on persuading others, all the time, to do stuff. Every day I have to display that surface calm and cheeriness, yet boiling invisible irritation, of getting a toddler to put their shoes on when we are already late. Staying up late to write a report is nice and soothing in a way.

  4. It's a bit lonely. You can't complain, you have to model good and respectful behaviour all the time. It's not a good look to eye roll about your own staff , either shape them up or shut up. You can't say you're tired and fed up.

  5. Unlimited to do list. Even if targets are "Make 27 million pounds this year" you don't just stop work when you've done it. Everything can always improve. Service and product quality. Staff wellbeing. Training, efficiency. Systems and processes. Why not have the whole office redecorated? If you are very senior, capitalism makes you push for unremitting, constant improvement on every front.

But yes studies of workplace stress show that autonomy is correlated with feeling less stressed. Within the constraints above, I have total freedom.

Lochroy · 08/07/2022 13:56

That doesn't sound like great management skills from your OH. A good manager manages upwards and relieves pressure downwards.

hamstersarse · 08/07/2022 13:56

i am very familiar with the ‘stress’ data and in the high positions (slt) there is less stress, at an aggregated level. They have more autonomy, are ‘in the know’ and obviously paid much better. They also tend to be quite resilient anyway, so more resistant to stress just by the very nature of their path to that job.

middle management is where the huge stress lies

Testina · 08/07/2022 13:51

Hard to compare, because stress isn’t one clearly defined thing, and even if it was, people react differently to it.

I’m senior management taking fast decisions on matters with legal and financial impact - I love it! It’s a rush, and I get a certain amount of esteem from the fact that I’m good at it. I often have to work early / late / weekends / away from home, and it’s hard to just switch off from a problem once I do log off - I’m often still thinking about something.

My sister works on a checkout. It’s a small cliquey store. The other staff are often horrible to her - or whoever they’ve decided to have it in for this week. She gets really stressed by it - understandably.

She works hard - but no-one values it.
I work harder - but I get noticed for it.

She gets stressed by people skiving and not pulling their weight.
I see those people in my organisation and think, “I’m still getting paid - and I’ll get promoted over you” (usually!)

I think one reason people can feel less stressed in more senior roles, is because they’re more likely to rise to them or actively go for them if they don’t mind stressful situations or thrive on them. Confidence is an anti-dote to stress too.

Honestly think Bojo has had an incredibly hard job (Bexit, Covid, Ukraine, recession…) but does he feel the slightest stress? Nah.

Floraanddougal · 08/07/2022 13:41

I’m surprised it’s like that for your husband, generally managing people is very stressful.

the more senior you get the more different the stress is, you don’t leave ththe job at the door and go home afte your shift.

QueSyrahSyrah · 08/07/2022 13:38

I agree. I'm in a management position now and my day to day workload is (usually) less than it was, but the ultimate responsibility load is significantly higher.

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 08/07/2022 13:34

Yep. Shit falls. As my manager told me when I was a junior and he was giving me something else horrible to do.

though as I told him, you have to watch out for the splashback.

I think the difference in a more senior role is you have more control and more autonomy. There’s lots of stress and responsibility- my decisions impact whether the organisation survives and 1,000 people keep their jobs or not (and yes it’s been that precarious at some points recently) but when I was in a junior role I also used to worry about the small stuff. I also now get the influence the outcome, so things being awful for the business but having an action plan feels better than having a manager shout at you because you missed a little detail.

Covidagainandagain · 08/07/2022 13:31

Having worked in admin and call centre roles both entry level and management I completely agree.

I guess it depends on the business but I am on nearly three times the salary I was on in a call centre role and I work no where near as hard, I am not micromanaged, have achievable targets and I am treated like a grown up who is capable of doing her job instead of someone who needs to account for every second I spend on the toilet

puffyisgood · 08/07/2022 13:29

i daresay not unheard of, but rarely true in my experience.

ShirleyPhallus · 08/07/2022 13:26

Lily073 · 08/07/2022 12:49

I agree. I'm always surprised by the number of people that assume that six figure salaries are associated with stressful and demanding roles when this is not always the case. We need to dispel this myth.

Agree!

VladmirsPoutine · 08/07/2022 13:25

I disagree because the higher you go the more likely it is that you're managing people and that in itself can be immensely challenging regardless of the 'job' itself iyswim? I really like my manager but I just couldn't deal with people on the scale he does daily.

riesenrad · 08/07/2022 13:03

I think it depends - if you are senior, you have a track record and you can have more control over your work. It's easier for a senior person to leave the office early to collect a sick child than a junior member of staff, because the senior person has the status.

Not always, but I think there are definitely cases where this is true.

rainyskylight · 08/07/2022 13:03

I find that day to day the stress is less, but the overall responsibility (including legal accountability) is stressful in a completely different way.

Neves7 · 08/07/2022 13:02

In my industry this is not true. I’m in tech - stress definitely increases as you go up. Most people who I have heard say it doesn’t have never done a more senior/management role. Many people take a step down later in their careers for this reason.

Swipe left for the next trending thread