Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fine for taking kid out of school- 8 days?

271 replies

NeedToGoOut · 08/07/2022 10:41

Just got penalty notice letters for DH and I.

We only took DC out of school last month for 8 days, first ever time. I didn’t think a penalty was given unless DC is taken out for 10 days?

DC had 100% attendance outside of that and is top of year. No effect on education at all. Had assessments the week after we returned and got 97-100%!

AIBU to be a bit pissed off the school ran straight to LA to rat on us?

OP posts:
Rivtry2 · 23/11/2022 13:04

Do you find it relatively mundane? Cause you keep sticking your nose in don’t you? Do you always stick your nose into things you find immature? Maybe, you could use your time more constructively and stand up for low income families, children, and what’s actually right.

To be clear:

Tell the truth - get a fine.
Lie - avoid a fine and enjoy a holiday.

Really not that extreme. More common sense.

I hope that gives you some perspective.

PiggyInTheLidl · 23/11/2022 13:03

ZOMBIE

@Rivtry2 Did you deliberately revive a zombie thread to have your day on this?

TimeForMeToF1y · 23/11/2022 12:54

Rivtry2 · 23/11/2022 12:50

No, you mean Perceptive.

No, I really really don't, you have no idea of my views on term time absence, only that I think lying is immature and that I find your extreme views on a relatively mundane subject are rather strange

Rivtry2 · 23/11/2022 12:50

No, you mean Perceptive.

TimeForMeToF1y · 23/11/2022 12:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You've got me, that describes me to a T 😂😂how perceptive you are

Or do I mean bonkers?

Rivtry2 · 23/11/2022 12:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TimeForMeToF1y · 23/11/2022 12:26

Rivtry2 · 23/11/2022 12:18

The amount of SH!tty opinions on here is vile!

YES!!! You do have a right to be annoyed with getting a fine for taking YOUR child on holiday. Holidays cost enough as it is, and the cost of holidays go up substantially if you go out of term time.

I am pretty sure your child got more from that holiday than they would have done during that week of school.

lesson…. NEVER TELL THE TRUTH!! Report them sick, turn your phone off when you’re away and have someone phone in each day for you.

Telling the truth = fine!

Sad world we live in.

How can differing opinions about children missing school be vile? That's not an appropriate word to use at all

Well done you though for having such a grown up attitude to telling the truth, a shining example to your own children.

Rivtry2 · 23/11/2022 12:18

The amount of SH!tty opinions on here is vile!

YES!!! You do have a right to be annoyed with getting a fine for taking YOUR child on holiday. Holidays cost enough as it is, and the cost of holidays go up substantially if you go out of term time.

I am pretty sure your child got more from that holiday than they would have done during that week of school.

lesson…. NEVER TELL THE TRUTH!! Report them sick, turn your phone off when you’re away and have someone phone in each day for you.

Telling the truth = fine!

Sad world we live in.

Bertieboo82 · 11/07/2022 06:04

Miisty · 11/07/2022 02:49

Went on holiday to Corfu No fine fine for learning support assistants children out of school!!.My son who was one of the first children to be diagnosed withADHD in south Somerset spent more time at home than school No learning for months no catch up but that was alright for he was doomed to fail by school and the school had concerns about the head’s attitude

The most shocking thing is that your son’s learning support was able to afford months of holiday in a year on their salary!

Miisty · 11/07/2022 02:49

Went on holiday to Corfu No fine fine for learning support assistants children out of school!!.My son who was one of the first children to be diagnosed withADHD in south Somerset spent more time at home than school No learning for months no catch up but that was alright for he was doomed to fail by school and the school had concerns about the head’s attitude

CelestiaNoctis · 10/07/2022 16:11

Did you at least tell the school where you were? Like why they weren't coming in?

CharlieBIB · 10/07/2022 15:38

VioletToes · 08/07/2022 11:02

Ffs this attitude 😂

We took dc out for 10 days to visit family on the other side of the world. Thankfully in Aus you don't have this ridiculous rule regarding fines.

DC school actually said enjoy the time with your family, it's priceless.

Aus now do have the same policy in some areas and are in the process of bringing it in across the country

Maymaymay · 10/07/2022 14:37

MaryShelley1818 · 08/07/2022 10:58

As everyone says it's 10 sessions not 10 days.
Also "ran to rat on you" What sort of adult speaks like that?
I'll be taking my 4yr old out of reception next year, I know the rules and therefore will pay the fine.

School isn't compulsory at 4 - extra spending money for you! X

ApplesandBunions · 10/07/2022 14:05

newname12345 · 10/07/2022 13:33

@ApplesandBunions Its not really bizarre, as if you want totally flexibility then home schooling is the only answer. If its not for you which I admit for many it isn't (including us for a mixture of reasons), you need to stick to term time holidays or pay the fines without complaining.

I agree the fines aren't enough - should be increased as children get older/repeat offenders for obvious holidays.

I could afford to take my DC out of school for term time holidays a couple of times a year and pay the fine each time Not sure this is really a boast as you admit its cheaper? We can afford to go away on holiday at least a couple of times year during school holidays.

It's completely bizarre, which you obviously know because you're moving the goalposts here. What you said is that parents have a choice because they can homeschool if they want. This is obviously a ridiculous claim. Nobody is saying that homeschooling doesn't provide more flexibility, it's you saying that everyone can choose it that is wrong.

Also, you're quite right it isn't a boast at all. It's a statement of fact. That's the whole point, which appears to have sailed over your head. You being another family for whom it wouldn't serve as a deterrent is further evidence of what I was saying.

newname12345 · 10/07/2022 13:33

@ApplesandBunions Its not really bizarre, as if you want totally flexibility then home schooling is the only answer. If its not for you which I admit for many it isn't (including us for a mixture of reasons), you need to stick to term time holidays or pay the fines without complaining.

I agree the fines aren't enough - should be increased as children get older/repeat offenders for obvious holidays.

I could afford to take my DC out of school for term time holidays a couple of times a year and pay the fine each time Not sure this is really a boast as you admit its cheaper? We can afford to go away on holiday at least a couple of times year during school holidays.

honkeytonkwoman38 · 10/07/2022 12:16

You clearly didn't research it enough before you took the kids out. If it was that easy to disappear off for two weeks we would all do it!

ApplesandBunions · 10/07/2022 11:41

Bizarre way to frame the discussion, since the question of whether most parents could in reality homeschool is one of fact, whereas the best way to deal with school absences is more one of opinion. In terms of parameters, I prefer option C which is for people not to come out with things that are so obviously nonsense, and for us to start from the understanding that most parents don't have any choice at all about using the state system so it does actually need to be done right. Especially as you can admit that and still be in support of fines for term time holidays.

In general though, I don't think the system we have in England is working very well. The pandemic and response to it didn't help, but these problems existed beforehand. There's no denying however that whatever moral legitimacy there might have been in fining parents for removing their children from school for a couple of weeks prior to March 2020 has been firmly eroded by the state decision to do so for millions of them for several months.

I don't think fining as a way to combat missing school deals with the underlying reasons behind the DC who have the worst absence records, the evidence for that isn't there, and that was the case both pre covid and now. It's also the case that those with more money and privilege don't need to care whereas those on lower incomes find it harder. Some families can't afford even a UK break other than in term time, and anything that's a fine based approach disproportionately advantages people who have the money to pay it quickly and also the resources to challenge it. I could afford to take my DC out of school for term time holidays a couple of times a year and pay the fine each time, it wouldn't serve as much of a deterrent and I'm not scared of authorities because navigating these systems isn't something I'm scared of. That's money and educational privilege. We have heard already from a number of parents on this thread who simply factor it into the costs of the holiday.

newname12345 · 10/07/2022 11:19

ApplesandBunions · 10/07/2022 11:01

Yes, it's hardly as if this is all set in stone. Also, the idea that the majority of parents in this country are realistically in a position to educate their children in anything other than the state system is completely fucking hatstand.

Do you think making attendance totally optional for any child signed up to the state school system any less fucking hatstand?

So what should the rules be? All children can have an extra 10 days off year? Maybe only though who exceed expectations can have time off?

ApplesandBunions · 10/07/2022 11:01

Crocsandshocks · 10/07/2022 09:33

Parents do have a choice, they can home school if they like. If though they want to use schools then need to follow their rules. This is the way life works.

Bit of a hobsons choice that. And no its not the way life works. Its a set of man made rules that can be changed at a y time.

Yes, it's hardly as if this is all set in stone. Also, the idea that the majority of parents in this country are realistically in a position to educate their children in anything other than the state system is completely fucking hatstand.

newname12345 · 10/07/2022 10:57

Crocsandshocks · 10/07/2022 09:33

Parents do have a choice, they can home school if they like. If though they want to use schools then need to follow their rules. This is the way life works.

Bit of a hobsons choice that. And no its not the way life works. Its a set of man made rules that can be changed at a y time.

Of course rules can be changed, never said they can't be. Anyone though managed to get their LEA to change their rules (rather than maybe winning a one-off appeal) with regards to fines for unauthorised attendances?

marktayloruk · 10/07/2022 09:38

I had an abysmal attendance record but still got 5 O levels, 3 As and a degree. This policy is an example of control freakery started by Michael.Gove's banning the term time holidays which were all some parents could afford. Couldn't some schools tactfully forget to report some cases? School.is in my opinion overrated- especially with this ridiculous RSHE which they have the PC gall to make compulsory.

Crocsandshocks · 10/07/2022 09:33

Parents do have a choice, they can home school if they like. If though they want to use schools then need to follow their rules. This is the way life works.

Bit of a hobsons choice that. And no its not the way life works. Its a set of man made rules that can be changed at a y time.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 10/07/2022 09:17

Bertieboo82 · 08/07/2022 16:23

I actually once even emailed her teacher to say that we were having a quiet day as she needed it and wanted to spend my day off with me

teacher’s response…. “Enjoy!”

When I was a kid my mum - who was completely committed to us 'getting an education' - had a rule where once a term we could say, "I don't want to go to school today," and she'd say, "Okay. Don't."

Once a term, strictly.

It was a great feeling to know you had that in the bank. And, actually, on the days when you just really didn't feel like going to school, you'd think, "Do I want to use my day off today? No. Not yet." And you'd go.

So it had the effect of actually improving attendance.

She's a clever woman, my mum.

Parentsofaprincess · 10/07/2022 08:07

NeedToGoOut · 08/07/2022 10:41

Just got penalty notice letters for DH and I.

We only took DC out of school last month for 8 days, first ever time. I didn’t think a penalty was given unless DC is taken out for 10 days?

DC had 100% attendance outside of that and is top of year. No effect on education at all. Had assessments the week after we returned and got 97-100%!

AIBU to be a bit pissed off the school ran straight to LA to rat on us?

Pay the fine and get on with life. The system in this country is rubbish though and like everything else seems very broken but as with NHS etc. politicians are too scared to mend anything for fear of their careers. I lived in Australia with a family for a month and they are allowed to take their kids out of school for other educational purposes. For example I went out with dad and 12 year old son for a walk along coast to Bondi beach when he should have been at school. As it was with me and he was learning about me and my life into the UK it was deemed educational!