Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the teacher shouldn’t have said this?

29 replies

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 21:44

DD & her friend were pulled to one side in class and told they are going to be separated in class going forward as another child has complained that they have been talking about and laughing about her. DD swears they haven’t but obviously no way of knowing the truth. The child who has made the report, is diagnosed with ASD (relevant to the next part). We know this because she was encouraged to announce her diagnosis to the class so they could talk about ASD and raise awareness.

During the telling off, the teacher apparently said ‘both you girls should know better as you both have siblings with disabilities’. Now I’m not sure this should have been said. He has no idea whether we have discussed her siblings fairly recent diagnosis’s, even if my DD knows, surely it’s confidential and shouldn’t be shared with other children? And it’s almost shaming them into making them feel guilty.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
18thCpanniers · 24/03/2023 20:04

You ABU.

While the behaviours of individual autistic children vary greatly, telling outright lies falls into a category of ‘generally not what they do.’ They might sometimes use words that are stronger than the situation warrants (what is normally considered exaggeration, but in the case of children with autism, it may be because of vocabulary limitations, or perhaps otherwise because their perception of an event requires stronger language than another person might use) but it’s unlikely that the autistic child is telling lies about your daughter and her friend.

Few parents want to think their child might choose be unkind to other children, nor to believe that their child might be the instigator of unkindness towards or the bullying of another child, but the fact remains that children are unkind to each other, they do form groups or pairs and bully or otherwise target other children, and regardless of what the teacher said about your other children (no doubt in an exhausted, end-of-term attempt to arouse some empathy for the autistic child), you need to accept that it is likely that your daughter and her friend have been unkind, and that you need to act on it.

There are no excuses for unkind behaviour.
That applies to parents as well as children and teachers.

This is an opportunity for you to practise some empathy & kindness, both to the teacher (cut her a break) and to the child who has, quite rightly, told the teacher about what was making her unhappy. The teacher probably realised that she shouldn’t have mentioned your other child’s disability, nor that of your daughter’s friend’s sibling, as soon as the words left her mouth.
Let it go. If it happens again, whether privately or in front of the class, then call her to have a chat about it, but it could well just be a one-off. It might be helpful to have a chat with your daughter and to reflect together on whether a disability on the family needs to be a private shame rather than something that can be openly talked about.

Teach your daughter to be her best self. She doesn’t have to like everyone, but she does need to be pleasant and respectful towards everyone, and kind when the situation warrants it. Explore with her the thoughts & feelings that trigger unkindness, but do not allow them as excuses: help her to find better ways of managing those feelings, and check in with her regularly (I’d say at least thrice weekly) about how she managed a situation that wasn’t her choice or preference at school (e.g. if she was put in a group or a pair with someone she didn’t know well or didn’t like for some reason).

I know it’s hard. I wish you luck.

VincaBlue · 07/07/2022 22:32

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 22:15

If others can sit with friends they are being punished though and the fact that they appear to be found guilty automatically is unfair.

I can see the point about listening to the child but it is giving her tremendous power over the other children if she can make accusations without any attempt to investigate.

None of it sounds right to me and your poor son is definitely entitled to his privacy. Is he at the same school?

Op said it's class time so no one can sit with their friends. Normally the teacher decides where kids sit. She just happened to be near her friend

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:31

MichelleScarn · 07/07/2022 22:27

Yet again its being assumed that this actually did occur?
@FawnFrenchieMum did the teacher give your dd a chance to give her 'side' or was it straight to 'you did this end of'?

According to DD (I haven’t actually spoken to the teacher and no report has been made to me as yet), he said this child says your laughing at her and talking about her, they both said they weren’t and then he went on to say well he will have to move them seats to stop it happening and went on to say about their siblings.
They had a cover teacher in class all day, but it was the normal class teacher that came in at the end of the day to have this conversation with them. So I doubt he’s personally witnessed it as he wasn’t in the room all day. I don’t know if any other children have been asked what happened either.

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:28

12cats · 07/07/2022 22:24

It's not sharing confidential information or shaming them into feeling guilty. It's making reference to relevant details, to educate and encourage empathy.

As the teacher is right, and your child does have additional needs or difficulties, someone ought to take some responsibility for teaching the sibling not to behave unkindly.

So where does that stop, could they say they shouldn’t hit other people because Jonny’s dad hit Jonny’s mum and now she’s in hospital?

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 07/07/2022 22:27

12cats · 07/07/2022 22:24

It's not sharing confidential information or shaming them into feeling guilty. It's making reference to relevant details, to educate and encourage empathy.

As the teacher is right, and your child does have additional needs or difficulties, someone ought to take some responsibility for teaching the sibling not to behave unkindly.

Yet again its being assumed that this actually did occur?
@FawnFrenchieMum did the teacher give your dd a chance to give her 'side' or was it straight to 'you did this end of'?

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:26

No one in the class is allowed to choose to sit with friends, they have a seating plan. DD was just lucky she was given a seat next to one of her best friends. So I don’t think I can complain they have been moved as they do move children that are not working as well as they hoped around. DD has been lucky to sit next to her friend for the rest of this year. (But this also tells me they don’t generally cause any trouble or would have been moved a long time ago).

OP posts:
12cats · 07/07/2022 22:24

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 21:58

I’ve absolutely spoken to my DD about what has happened, she is totally adamant it didn’t happen. I genuinely don’t know who is telling the truth, there is a chance DD is lying and has been unkind with her friend, the other child is also well known for thinking people are talking about her or causing issues within friendships that she may also be mistaken over what happened. I’ve spoken to my DD about how disappointed I would be if it’s true and she is no longer able to sit with her friend in class so she’s definitely had her punishment if she did do it.

Im just not sure it’s the teachers job to share my other child’s personal disabilities. He doesn’t like people knowing and doesn’t like me telling people.

It's not sharing confidential information or shaming them into feeling guilty. It's making reference to relevant details, to educate and encourage empathy.

As the teacher is right, and your child does have additional needs or difficulties, someone ought to take some responsibility for teaching the sibling not to behave unkindly.

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:22

This maybe classed as drip feeding but I think I’m more upset as the teacher only knows about DS’s diagnosis’s as I have raised concerns about DD also being on the spectrum and explained that DS had now been diagnosed. This teacher taught DS several years ago pre-diagnosis. I have not told DD my thoughts on her as I wouldn’t tell her unless she also gets a diagnosis.

OP posts:
FriedTomatoe · 07/07/2022 22:21

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 22:15

If others can sit with friends they are being punished though and the fact that they appear to be found guilty automatically is unfair.

I can see the point about listening to the child but it is giving her tremendous power over the other children if she can make accusations without any attempt to investigate.

None of it sounds right to me and your poor son is definitely entitled to his privacy. Is he at the same school?

Why are you assuming they are being punished unfairly? Maybe this hasn't been dealt with in the most tactful way but teachers don't usually randomly take sides (unless one child has form for behaving in a particular way). Some people on these boards have a really bad opinion of teachers.

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:20

I did speak to DDs friends mum about it and she agreed it wasn’t the right thing to say. She was less concerned about the privacy part as her other DD also goes to the school and has a more obvious disability, all the children in DD class know her quite well. She was concerned that the girls were almost made to feel more guilty if it was true because of their siblings.

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:17

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 22:15

If others can sit with friends they are being punished though and the fact that they appear to be found guilty automatically is unfair.

I can see the point about listening to the child but it is giving her tremendous power over the other children if she can make accusations without any attempt to investigate.

None of it sounds right to me and your poor son is definitely entitled to his privacy. Is he at the same school?

Thankfully not any more, he’s in senior school and the girls are in primary.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/07/2022 22:17

You are correct - the teacher should not have disclosed to your daughter's friend that your other chold has a disability, and likewise should not have disclosed to your daughter that her friend's sibling has a disability.

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 22:15

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:02

Well there is that too. It’s class time so no one has a right to sit with their friends. They have sat together all year though without issue until now. i think they are keen to show the other child she’s is listened to.

If others can sit with friends they are being punished though and the fact that they appear to be found guilty automatically is unfair.

I can see the point about listening to the child but it is giving her tremendous power over the other children if she can make accusations without any attempt to investigate.

None of it sounds right to me and your poor son is definitely entitled to his privacy. Is he at the same school?

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:12

Teeturtle · 07/07/2022 22:06

Why is it whenever anybody child is found to be doing something, the parent always looks to deflect! I think there was a similar thread when somebody child was bullying and that parent raised some trivial point of the teacher dealing with it rather than actually acknowledge that their child was a bully? 🙄

I’ve acknowledged what my child may or may not have done. We’ve had a long chat about if she has been mean how that would make the other child feel. It was during this conversation that she told me what the teacher had said about them both having siblings with disabilities and should know better.
Im not deflected or ignoring what may have happened. As the school haven’t notified me I assume they feel that they have dealt with it from a behaviour perspective. I only know this has happened by my DD telling me. She didn’t have to tell me and end up in trouble at home as well.

OP posts:
Rosehugger · 07/07/2022 22:11

I agree that whether it was unkindness or misinterpretation, it should have been dealt with by speaking to the kids privately about what happened. And YANBU about the teacher revealing sensitive family information.

MichelleScarn · 07/07/2022 22:10

Teeturtle · 07/07/2022 22:06

Why is it whenever anybody child is found to be doing something, the parent always looks to deflect! I think there was a similar thread when somebody child was bullying and that parent raised some trivial point of the teacher dealing with it rather than actually acknowledge that their child was a bully? 🙄

@Teeturtle so if a classmate of your child said 'mini teeturtle did xyz' you'd say absolutely they did, no questions asked!

Teeturtle · 07/07/2022 22:06

Why is it whenever anybody child is found to be doing something, the parent always looks to deflect! I think there was a similar thread when somebody child was bullying and that parent raised some trivial point of the teacher dealing with it rather than actually acknowledge that their child was a bully? 🙄

Windinmyhair · 07/07/2022 22:03

As a member of school staff I wouldn't have had that sort of conversation just pulled aside in a classroom. I also would have asked what happened rather than just punish people without hearing both sides of the story.

But yes, I agree, if it wasn't open knowledge about your other DC's disabilities, mentioning like that wasn't on. I can see how it was meant, but not on. A simple email asking them not to mention it as if it is public knowledge will be enough though. I'd be more angry that they didn't discuss what had happened rather than just assume to be honest.

MichelleScarn · 07/07/2022 22:02

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:59

So one girl makes an accusation and that's it, DD and her friend are guilty and punished? Doesn't seem fair to me before you even get to informing people about other children's, disabiliites.

Exactly, so is teacher saying they've witnessed this, or have they taken a statement and made themselves judge and jury?

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 22:02

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:59

So one girl makes an accusation and that's it, DD and her friend are guilty and punished? Doesn't seem fair to me before you even get to informing people about other children's, disabiliites.

Well there is that too. It’s class time so no one has a right to sit with their friends. They have sat together all year though without issue until now. i think they are keen to show the other child she’s is listened to.

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 07/07/2022 22:02

YANBU. It was inappropriate of the teacher to reveal personal family information in front of the class. I'm a teacher and I absolutely wouldn't have done so. And it sounds as though you have dealt with the matter appropriately with your dd - I'm not sure why other posters jumped to the conclusion that you hadn't.

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:59

So one girl makes an accusation and that's it, DD and her friend are guilty and punished? Doesn't seem fair to me before you even get to informing people about other children's, disabiliites.

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 21:59

Friendship101 · 07/07/2022 21:56

Aren’t most people open about disabilities now?

Not all teenagers who are desperately trying to come to terms with their conditions and want to fit in with their friends.

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 07/07/2022 21:58

I’ve absolutely spoken to my DD about what has happened, she is totally adamant it didn’t happen. I genuinely don’t know who is telling the truth, there is a chance DD is lying and has been unkind with her friend, the other child is also well known for thinking people are talking about her or causing issues within friendships that she may also be mistaken over what happened. I’ve spoken to my DD about how disappointed I would be if it’s true and she is no longer able to sit with her friend in class so she’s definitely had her punishment if she did do it.

Im just not sure it’s the teachers job to share my other child’s personal disabilities. He doesn’t like people knowing and doesn’t like me telling people.

OP posts:
BlackbirdsSinging · 07/07/2022 21:57

I would let it go. Have you ever said anything you regretted? I know I have. The teacher is probably very tired this close to the end of term. Use it as a way to talk about adults making mistakes etc