Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about MIL not saying happy birthday

37 replies

WishingAndHoping11 · 07/07/2022 20:41

It's my daughter's first birthday today and so far my MIL hasn't said happy birthday in any sort of message. We weren't due to be seeing my inlaws today but I thought they might phone or message. My PIL said happy birthday on my Facebook post but not MIL. I know this all sounds silly but I just feel like it's a bit unfriendly and tbh it's annoyed me. MIL is always on Facebook. She loves posting stuff about what she's doing and photos of herself and PIL. I've seen her commenting on other people's posts today but not on her DIL's post about her own granddaughter. My post was quite heartfelt as I'd had a really worrying, tough pregnancy with dd and her arrival a year ago was a real blessing. So maybe that's made me a little more sensitive.

AIBU or would a message on Facebook, WhatsApp, etc or just a quick phone have been expected on a birthday from grandparents? Yes a one year won't have a clue but just to show a little bit of interest would be nice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dishwashersaurous · 08/07/2022 22:37

You are utterly overinvested in Facebook, but just to repeat the algorithms are very very real and it's incredibly likely that she hasn't seen your post as it hasn't appeared in her feed.

Player001 · 08/07/2022 04:21

ManateeFair · 08/07/2022 01:27

PIL - parents in law Don't know why I put that and not just inlaws

But… you said MIL said nothing, but ‘PIL’ said happy birthday? Surely your mother-in-law is one of your parents-in-law?!

Yeah.... this has got my confused as well.

Cadot · 08/07/2022 04:14

I think you're investing way too much time and meaning into interactions on Facebook. Just forget about that and concentrate on the relationship in the real world.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/07/2022 04:08

You cringe at her braggy posts, I tend to cringe at overly emotional posts. Maybe your MIL is like me and avoiding that.

And going back over posts to check what she's liked? Put the internet down.

GiltEdges · 08/07/2022 03:49

We weren't due to be seeing my inlaws today but I thought they might phone or message

Was this your idea or theirs? Could MIL be unhappy about it?

Maverick101 · 08/07/2022 03:19

If you don't like her posts then she probably hasn't seen yours.

Newsfeed algorithms -- they're a real thing.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 08/07/2022 02:47

Storm in a teacup. You don't like her posts and can't be bothered to comment on them but you expect her to pay homage to your one-year old?

What has your DP/DH said about it?

Rtmhwales · 08/07/2022 02:39

"I don't put much on Facebook these days and when I do, it's usually something sincere and meaningful. I'm also very down to earth with what I say. MIL isn't like that, it's very much all for show."

I was with you a bit until that comment. Maybe your MIL thought your birthday post to a one year old was all for show. I think you're focusing a bit too much on the Facebook aspect of it.

onlythreenow · 08/07/2022 02:01

YABU. Maybe stop giving Facebook such a prominent place in your life. Anyway, you said PIL had posted - is your MIL not part of that? Even if not, what on earth does it matter - your DD is not going to be aware.

icklekid · 08/07/2022 01:54

I agree with others if PIL have posted surely that’s on behalf of MIL and FIL unless they aren’t together but then I can’t understand why you would post PIL then? No need for them to message separately? My mum messaged me on my birthday and it was from both my parents… I didn’t expect separate message from my dad!

CelestiaNoctis · 08/07/2022 01:47

I'm petty so I'd just post like, thanks for all the cards, gifts and messages everyone, very appreciated and hope that she gets the dig 😆

ChampagneLassie · 08/07/2022 01:37

Or its FB algorithms and she hasn't seen your post? If you only post rarely and you don't interact with her on FB (liking her posts), she may literally not have seen your post. But yeah if you never like her stuff this maybe a return snub which us a snub to you for that rather than DD birthday. As you say you're seeing them weekend, I'd give benefit of doubt.

My family sent 0 when I had my first LO... they TRFd me some money but no card or gift. I thought this quite cold but my family are a bit cold so I didn't mention. A few weeks later transpires my my has sent stuff to an old address. My point being they may have sent something got lost in post or something happened.

ManateeFair · 08/07/2022 01:27

PIL - parents in law Don't know why I put that and not just inlaws

But… you said MIL said nothing, but ‘PIL’ said happy birthday? Surely your mother-in-law is one of your parents-in-law?!

DixonD · 07/07/2022 23:11

SonicHg · 07/07/2022 21:04

If that's the worst your mil has done, you are so lucky. grow up.

Oh come on. She’s not made any comment or recognition of her grandchild’s birthday. It’s a hurtful thing to do.

Heartofglass12345 · 07/07/2022 23:03

My sons birthday was not long ago and my mum forgot last year and this year and he's 9! It did bother me but I tried not to let it. I can see why you're upset though, even though she's a baby it's still nice to have it acknowledged!

mummabubs · 07/07/2022 23:01

Yanbu OP. My in laws make such a huge fuss of SiL's two children every year. Last year my son went completely ignored on his birthday and this year our daughter turned one - nothing from either PiLs or SiL. I felt very hurt by this, so understand how you feel.

WishingAndHoping11 · 07/07/2022 22:50

justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 22:38

I do think it's rubbish that she hasn't been in touch today but, if you're seeing them on the weekend, I'd reserve judgment until then - if they turn up with a card and a thoughtful gift, and make a big fuss, then I'd see it that they've redeemed themselves .

You might be right about fb though. If you never like her stuff, she may have noticed and feel hurt. You say she uses it to brag but presumably it is stuff that's important to her. So a bit rich to complain that she didn't like your post today.

True, I get your point. Maybe she is a bit miffed by the Facebook thing. It's very hard for me to like stuff that's just so materialistic, braggy and name dropping. I have to scroll past as its total cringe! Dh and I aren't like that at all. I don't put much on Facebook these days and when I do, it's usually something sincere and meaningful. I'm also very down to earth with what I say. MIL isn't like that, it's very much all for show.

Could it be that she's just not as interested by the second grandchild? Does the novelty wear off for grandparents?

OP posts:
WishingAndHoping11 · 07/07/2022 22:43

blueskyeve · 07/07/2022 22:30

Does seem odd! I would be upset by this too. So there was no card/present in the post? What is your relationship like generally?

Sorry if I'm being dim, but who is PIL?

No card or present today although we may see them at the weekend so could be something then.
Relationship is OK but only OK. In laws are moving away in a few months and are busy doing their thing with all that. They've gradually become more distant since that decision was made.

PIL - parents in law
Don't know why I put that and not just inlaws 😂

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 22:38

I do think it's rubbish that she hasn't been in touch today but, if you're seeing them on the weekend, I'd reserve judgment until then - if they turn up with a card and a thoughtful gift, and make a big fuss, then I'd see it that they've redeemed themselves .

You might be right about fb though. If you never like her stuff, she may have noticed and feel hurt. You say she uses it to brag but presumably it is stuff that's important to her. So a bit rich to complain that she didn't like your post today.

FrenchBoule · 07/07/2022 22:33

YANBU,that’s shitty of her.

blueskyeve · 07/07/2022 22:30

Does seem odd! I would be upset by this too. So there was no card/present in the post? What is your relationship like generally?

Sorry if I'm being dim, but who is PIL?

airrrrAIRRRRiELLLL · 07/07/2022 22:13

But Fil posted isn't that enough? If Mil had posted and not Fil would you be upset with him? Do they both normally post?

Dishwashersaurous · 07/07/2022 21:43

Is there a planned event at the weekend, a family party or similar? If so then would expect the card then.

WishingAndHoping11 · 07/07/2022 21:18

It's just strange that she's such a Facebook person. I've just looked back and she's put birthday posts on for other people with photos and for another child in the family.
This sounds really petit but I'm wondering if it's because I rarely like her posts. They're often showing off type posts that just make me cringe. So I genuinely don't like them.

Facebook aside, we might be seeing PIL this weekend so I'm sure dd will get a card or gift. However, DH and I would have appreciated a message, even if it's just to say, I hope dd had a lovely day. What makes it more obvious to me is that they made a huge fuss of ds's first birthday. I do wonder if the novelty has worn off for the second grandchild.

OP posts:
CatSeany · 07/07/2022 21:14

I feel like contact via a message or preferably phone call is really important on birthdays if it's somebody I'm close to. I would be quite upset if my kids didn't get a message from their grandparents. Especially since their grandparents are messaging all the time with loads of other stuff!