Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this sign does NOT mean move over now

279 replies

DappledThings · 07/07/2022 18:41

Roadworks going on near me, a section of dual carriageway is temporarily reduced to one lane. As you join that section from a roundabout there is this sign (except with only one black arrow for the one lane staying open not two).

The second lane closes in 800 yards. At the closure point there is a standard circular blue sign with a white arrow to the left indicating the lane closes there and to merge into the left lane.

So every day I do that, merrily overtaking 50 or so cars sitting in the left lane for the entire 800 yards.

AIBU to consider that this sign means lane closing in 800 yards and merge where the arrow tells you to and not please pointlessly queue from this point leaving the lane empty for the full 800 yards.

Nobody ever looks pissed off at the merge point and I wouldn't think they had the right to be. I don't understand why everyone queues from so far back. It's so inefficient.

To say this sign does NOT mean move over now
OP posts:
swimlyn · 08/07/2022 01:01

WonderingWanda · 07/07/2022 21:32

BTW I have nothing against BMW drivers....my dh is one!

Audi drivers however...
😁😁😁

swimlyn · 08/07/2022 00:57

WonderingWanda · 07/07/2022 21:29

People who don't leave gap for other cars to merge at the front making the whole bloody queue slower. If everyone just drove with a big enough gap between them and the car in front.....and knobheads didn't try and fill that gap before the merge then the merge would be a lot smoother.

In reality what happens in the UK is some people in the left lane approach the merge. Several idiots on the right see the sign and slam on their brakes and pull into the spaces on the left, other cars on the left have to brake because their stopping distance has decreased. Now everyone is on the left but going 20 mpg slower. Some new faster people have arrived in the right hand lane and are now slowing down and attempting to filter in between the cars on the left still about a week away from the merge. One of the slow lefties brakes to let a rightie in and then because they are all so close everyone has to break and now they are all doing 10 mph. Meanwhile a BMW doing 80 in the outside lane brakes sharply at the sight of the slow convoy of plonkers and pulls in just in time at the front of the merge. Another 20 cars have joined the back of the queue. They've all just watched the BMW whizz past and decide he's a cock and no one else is pushing in front of them. Now they stop letting people merge and a queue has formed in the righthand lane too. Traffic is now almost stationary whilst every pair at the front of the queue play out a game of chicken, inching in front of each other, bumper to bumper with the car in front, hearts racing at the fucking cheek of that knob head next to them to push in.

Just leave a bigger bloody gap and stay in your lane till the end!!!

This is a perfect summary of how it all goes wrong and you all end up stationary.

swimlyn · 08/07/2022 00:50

Likeli · 07/07/2022 20:00

@swimlyn huh?? How does anyone ever get home if you’re stationary and not ever going to move anywhere?

Seriously?

What's a queue then?

Autun · 08/07/2022 00:45

Driving at 90, slamming on your brakes like you haven’t been warned about the lane closure for the last 3 miles, then cutting someone up who is driving at the speed limit isn’t ‘zip merging’ though is it

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:23

The biggest hurdle most learner drivers face is working out the difference between safe a correct.
You may have right of way at a junction but if another car is breaking the law re right of way you don’t blindly ignore them and claim the accident was their fault despite being able to take avoiding action.
This concept was the hardest thing to teach my DS. Just because you have right of way doesn’t mean it is safe.
Good drivers anticipate and accommodate bad drivers which is why people let you in. I’d rather let someone in than have them drive into me regardless of whether they are right or wrong. This is why bad drivers constantly get away with it.
We are not being polite, we are driving defensively.

SirChenjins · 08/07/2022 00:22

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:16

But the point where you change lane is not relevant. The blue sign is the last point at which you can change lane. Some drivers appear to have a little bit more common sense and look for a space to move into as soon as it is safe to do so when they recognise that their lane is closing.

Exactly this. There’s absolutely no point in cars in the right lane driving faster than the cars in the left lane, then coming up to the lane closed point, leaving it till the last minute to brake, then all trying to squeeze into traffic that is by that point going faster than them. It just doesn’t work. Use a bit of common sense - you don’t need to change lanes the second you see the 800, but if you change somewhere between there and the 200 means traffic moves smoothly forward at the same speed through the closure.

JustMaggie · 08/07/2022 00:19

If everyone followed the zip method all would be hunky dory. Unfortunately you get jerks who fly up the outside lane then slam on their brakes and swerve into your lane causing you and the guy behind you to slam on your brakes in order to let them in. Just merge when it's safe to do so. It's not hard.

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:16

wendywoopywoo222 · 08/07/2022 00:12

I use roads like this everyday and can't understand the mentality of queuing and will happily use an empty lane. If everyone stayed in the lane they are in until it's time to merge there wouldn't be the bad feeling from the people who like to queue as no one would be passing them at speed and would get to the merge point about the same time as the car you were near at the first sign. Curious that people don't understand that.

But the point where you change lane is not relevant. The blue sign is the last point at which you can change lane. Some drivers appear to have a little bit more common sense and look for a space to move into as soon as it is safe to do so when they recognise that their lane is closing.

Covidagainandagain · 08/07/2022 00:13

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:08

I believe the big blue sign is actually there for drivers who have no idea what the closed lane means. It’s telling you to “MOVE THE F**CK OVER BEFORE YOU TOTAL YOUR CAR”

I believe you would benefit from redoing your driving theory...

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:13

SirChenjins · 08/07/2022 00:07

Oh - and for merge in my post substitute change if that helps. Merge/change/swap/etc - go into the lane that’s remaining open from the one that is closing up ahead

Merge is a bit of a strange word for traffic management, “move into the lane remaining open ahead” is possibly more explanatory but at 70mph you probably wouldn’t see it.
The modern theory test is actually a brilliant addition to the driving test because you do have to learn what all the signs mean.

wendywoopywoo222 · 08/07/2022 00:12

I use roads like this everyday and can't understand the mentality of queuing and will happily use an empty lane. If everyone stayed in the lane they are in until it's time to merge there wouldn't be the bad feeling from the people who like to queue as no one would be passing them at speed and would get to the merge point about the same time as the car you were near at the first sign. Curious that people don't understand that.

JustLyra · 08/07/2022 00:12

StepAwayFromGoogling · 07/07/2022 23:45

The zip method works if both lanes and queuing. If everyone has already merged into one lane at, say, 400yds out, then you're just a dick to speed along the outside lane and bob in at the last minute. At that point you're not helping the flow of traffic at all. You're just demonstrating you think you're more important than everyone else.

The only thing they’d be demonstrating would be that they were the only person in the vicinity that knew how to drive properly.

This thread is basically highlighting why driving standards are so low - the number of clueless people is quite shocking.

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:08

I believe the big blue sign is actually there for drivers who have no idea what the closed lane means. It’s telling you to “MOVE THE F**CK OVER BEFORE YOU TOTAL YOUR CAR”

SirChenjins · 08/07/2022 00:07

Oh - and for merge in my post substitute change if that helps. Merge/change/swap/etc - go into the lane that’s remaining open from the one that is closing up ahead

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:00

Wesson?? Swop

Angrymum22 · 08/07/2022 00:00

If you merge at the blue sign it is likely that you will have stopped or slowed down so your speed is less than the moving traffic. To allow you in they have to slow down to allow you time to merge at a slower speed thereby slowing the whole lane down. Far better to merge at the speed of the lane of moving traffic when it’s safe than expect the traffic to slow for you at the blue sign. Again work it out.
It’s exactly the same principle as people who continually Wesson lanes on congested motorways. When you move out of a lane that lane has less cars in it so will move faster. The lane you move into will have more cars so will move slower. Obviously the effect is more marked the more cars that do it.
Modern traffic management on motorways now enforces staying in the same lane when going into speed limited contra flows for this very reason. It keeps the traffic flowing rather than constant, dangerous stop start traffic.

SirChenjins · 07/07/2022 23:55

DappledThings · 07/07/2022 23:04

How do you know they have no issue - have you asked them? They’re letting you in, yes, but if you had slowed down and merged in turn at their speed further down then you and all the other right hand lane drivers wouldn’t be bunched up at the zip point - you’d already be in the left lane and everyone would be moving forward at the same speed.
Well there's been not a single flash, angry gesture or expression, passive aggressive keeping unnaturally close to the car in front to prevent me merging appropriately so yes I'm making the assumption that despite insisting on sitting in one lane themselves they generally recognise I'm just merging in turn as I should.

"Merging at their speed further down" makes no sense. Firstly you cannot merge except at a merge point where 2 lanes become one. It's changing lane, not merging. Secondly that would mean travelling the 800 yards at about 15 miles an hour rather than 50. Everyone choosing to do that is just bonkers.

There is no bunching the merge point because hardly anyone else chooses to drive correctly so it's usually just me overtaking everyone and then merging at the end. And if lots more people drove better and there were two full lanes which then merge in turn it wouldn't be bunching either, just everyone travelling at roughly the same speed but in a layout that causes fewer issues down the road.

If I were selfish I'd prefer it to stay as it is so I can still flypast all the voluntary queuers. But I'm being terribly nice alerting people to the idea that they can and should take up both lanes. If everyone does it better I'll lose my own advantage!

Most drivers will just let you in, roll their eyes and focus on their driving. Merging further down makes perfect sense - adjust your speed down (where on earth are you driving that allows you to do 50mph up to the lane closed point?) then merge in turn so that you and all the other cars in the right hand lane slot into moving traffic (which won’t be going at 15mph) before the lane closed point. It’s so easy, it’s not affected by varying speed levels, does away with bunching (which I have seen many times - surprised you haven’t) and works in practice as opposed to what ‘should’ happen in theory.

Getoff · 07/07/2022 23:46

Every driver lets one car from the other lane, left out "other".

Covidagainandagain · 07/07/2022 23:46

StepAwayFromGoogling · 07/07/2022 23:45

The zip method works if both lanes and queuing. If everyone has already merged into one lane at, say, 400yds out, then you're just a dick to speed along the outside lane and bob in at the last minute. At that point you're not helping the flow of traffic at all. You're just demonstrating you think you're more important than everyone else.

So if everyone else has refused to follow the rules if you follow the rules you are the one in the wrong?

Sounds like the logic of the girls behind the bike shed trying to convince me to smoke because everyone else does it.

Getoff · 07/07/2022 23:45

swimlyn · 07/07/2022 19:52

Difficult, if not impossible, to zip if you're stationary.

When all lanes are stop-start is when it works perfectly and safely. The Blackwall tunnel northbound reduces from 3 to 2 lanes just before the entrance, it's actually the leftmost two lanes that merge with each other, and almost every time I go through it the traffic is stop-start, and every single driver in lanes 1 and 2 lets one car from the lane go between them and the car that was in front of them in their lane.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 07/07/2022 23:45

The zip method works if both lanes and queuing. If everyone has already merged into one lane at, say, 400yds out, then you're just a dick to speed along the outside lane and bob in at the last minute. At that point you're not helping the flow of traffic at all. You're just demonstrating you think you're more important than everyone else.

Angrymum22 · 07/07/2022 23:44

I have just taught my son to drive so have spent the last 4 months immersed in the Highway Code and driving skills.
During one memorable commute to school we were stuck in traffic due to temporary lights. We eventually got to the front of the queue and had to stop at the lights. All good lots of points learned about patience and arriving safely. Then the lights turned off. MyDs slowly turned to me wide eyed and slightly panicked and said “ what the f*ck do I do now mum” I was thinking the exact same thing. Visions of Madge from Coronation street’s demise flashed briefly in my head ( I’m very old you may need to google it), but since “mums know everything I had to come up with a solution. Fortunately we could see the oncoming traffic so in my best authoritative tone I calmly told him to treat it like a long row of parked cars.
In all my 40 yrs of driving I have never had a set of traffic lights temp or permanent switch off in front of me.

TrashPandas · 07/07/2022 23:34

Queues would be FAR shorter if people drove properly and used all lanes until the closure, like the OP does.

Angrymum22 · 07/07/2022 23:32

We have a merging system around our one way system in our small town. Merging depends on everyone driving at the same speed with a decent gap so everyone keeps moving. It has taken many years for old school drivers to not stop and create a huge log jam.
If applied correctly to your situation OP what you should do is slow down to the same speed as the traffic in the lane you are merging into and move over when it is safe to do so. This can be at the end of the lane or anywhere in the 800yds leading up to it it. Driving at 70 mph when everyone else is doing 30mph means that you saturate the merging lane ( more cars trying to merge into too few places - do the physics calculation) and create congestion.
On motorways you often get lorry drivers moving into the lane that is closing down to deliberately slow the speed of merging traffic. They are professional drivers who have seen far two many BMW drivers ( who are exempt from Highway Code rules) drive into the blue sign when they run out of road.
The M5 has a fantastic arse clenching merging point just south of Bristol. It’s a permanent feature and frequently catches BMW drivers out. It’s a clever test if your driving skills, judgement and observation. As a frequent flyer on that part of the M5 I have a little chuckle every time I see an idiot thinking they are being clever on the outside lane, breezing past at 90mph. You only do it once.

BogRollBOGOF · 07/07/2022 23:27

The simplest solution is to update the signage to "queue in both lanes" and then left and right laners will both be happy 🙃

There's a few roundabouts near me where straight on is marked in lane 1 & lane 2 with a short space to merge after the roundabout. It's just too dangerous to use lane 2 because of the high chance that a lane 1 driver will decide you're a cheeky fucker for having the audacity to jump the queue use the lanes as marked, undertake and attempt to leave you with nowhere to go other than into oncoming traffic in the middle of the road.

Swipe left for the next trending thread