Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our NHS isn't working?

144 replies

Nhs2022 · 07/07/2022 18:40

In many ways I can't fault the NHS, they saved my son and my mum's lives. They gave my aunt 4 years longer than first predicted with AML.

However, I also think there needs to be a conversation about the less life threatening and more mundane services of the NHS. The ones that won't kill you but significantly impact quality of life. These have absolutely fallen apart and the system isn't sustainable.

Why is it so wrong to say key aspects of the NHS are no longer fit for purpose and adults and children are being left miserable but alive?

Is there any sensible solution?

I think I'd happily go for a part and part system.

OP posts:
KangarooKenny · 08/07/2022 07:12

I’ve worked for the NHS for over 30 years and it’s pretty much been the same. The political party in charge makes no difference.
‘Lots of the NHS is already privatised, including the area I work in, and I’m pleasantly surprised by how well we get to do our job and how much better we are treated by our company.
My opinion has always been that we need to go back to basics, to stop doing things that should be paid for by the patient if they choose to have it done.

Galvantula · 08/07/2022 06:50

ChrisReasBathEggs · 07/07/2022 18:52

I'm having issues with my son getting treatment for hearing issues and speech therapy.

I don't think privatising is the answer. I have worked for private companies providing care and they are very exploitative. We would still get a shit service but pay more for it. It might be in a nice pretty hospital or clinic, but the staffing issues, training and culture would be shit.

It just needs to be fucking funded properly and pay and conditions need to attract staff. It's not rocket science.

^^This.

The more open to profiteering the system is, the less it'll actually benefit patients.

If the system is funded, staffed and managed properly it's much better to have it free at the point of use. But it's a huge system, different areas working all a bit differently etc.

You still have the option of paying for private appointments, if you can afford it.

And the NHS has clearly been neglected and poorly run, plus the last few years between ill staff and those deciding to leave has made it horrendous for those that I know working in the NHS.

TullyApplebottom · 08/07/2022 06:40

sst1234 · 07/07/2022 18:58

Would anyone care to explain what is ‘proper’ funding? This organization is spending 27% more this year compared with 2010. How much is enough? Or should we accept that it’s a bottomless pit?

This. The proportion of GDP it eats up is unsustainable. It’s literally devouring other critical public services (the criminal justice system is on its knees). Choices have to be made.

DillonPanthersFNL · 08/07/2022 06:39

Each and every operation is costed to the nth degree it's scary how much stuff costs, there is a cannula that costs £900 maybe £1500 if it's a certain brand. My colleague dropped 3 in one operation one after another and the surgeon was losing his mind at her because it's coming out of his budget and the perfusionists!

During the worst peak of Covid we had to turn down pregnant women who needed ECMO (massive heart lung machine that gives the body a break by oxygenating blood outside the body) because nhs England only agreed to pay for 8, it took a massive argument with top surgeons to get them to increase our funding, at one point we had 20 on ecmo after that but we've been left with the bill as a department.

paddingtonstares · 08/07/2022 06:38

Mental health services are woeful.

Northernsoullover · 08/07/2022 06:34

My father has just received excellent care but only because it was an emergency. I've just had to go private for a skin lesion. As they didn't think it was melanoma I've been told up to a year wait for dermatology. It might still be cancerous. I don't have insurance so it was a huge chunk of money to find but I did find it.
As a public health student we spent many a lecture on health inequality and whilst it's too simplistic to say that inequality is caused by profession and habits there is a lot of emphasis on this. I was lucky enough to have the means to go private. There is zero chance for the lowest incomes. There's your inequality.

DillonPanthersFNL · 08/07/2022 06:33

I've said this before but the nightingale in Manchester was a disaster because they put the contracts up for grabs and private firms who had never set up a hospital before were charging the nhs 3k plus vat a day to help set up a hospital. The only thing the nhs got out of that was a bill and allowed them to glean some good info about the nhs

Onlyrainbows · 08/07/2022 06:32

In my expat FB group this is a conversation that comes up all the time. The majority definitely Hayes the NHS

DillonPanthersFNL · 08/07/2022 06:31

It's no better in Australia or Europe at the
Moment. Go for it though! Pay for your own treatment

Assanctamonioysastheycome · 08/07/2022 06:30

So how will a european system magic up new nurses, docs and better services ?

ArtichokeAardvark · 08/07/2022 06:25

The NHS haemorrhages cash, and has done so since long before the Tories (as much as it's convenient to blame them). Increased funding isn't going to help, it already gets the lion's share of taxpayer funding. What it needs a massive overhaul to focus on how the money is spent, so much of it is wasted on administration.

But it's sacrilegious to criticise the NHS. It's the closest thing we have now to a state religion.

Sirzy · 08/07/2022 06:17

90% of the care DS has had over the years has been fantastic. Most of the issues come from lack of joined up systems and the bureaucracy.

he had blood tests done at one trust meaning a consultant from another trust couldn’t access them without having to make multiple phone calls

he has to wear a specially made suit these are massively expensive to the NHS but the amount of time wasted because it has been made wrong is amazing.

even stupid little things like not being able to order his medication online because of his age so having to spend ages in a phone queue to do it doesn’t make sense

Bertieboo82 · 08/07/2022 06:16

I think the nhs rocks tbh!

i have a superb GP
i have received superb treatment and during my pregnancies
and I am eternally grateful for fact they saved my daughters life

Darbs76 · 08/07/2022 06:15

Some services are amazing, I found a breast lump on a Saturday evening, by Monday evening I’d been referred to the breast clinic and had a text from them to say I’d be hearing from someone soon. By Wednesday I’d been seen by a doctor, had a scan and a mammogram. Amazing service. My chronic disease, not even a hope of seeing anyone anytime soon. I’m just grateful that my condition is stable since a major surgery 5yrs ago. I think how grateful I am it’s not now that I was having constant endoscopes / ERCP’s and appointments as it would have been a nightmare

Gensola · 08/07/2022 06:05

People are mostly ignorant of how health care works in eg Netherlands or Germany and determined to believe NHS is better when it manifestly isn’t. It’s one reason I’m making plans to leave in 4-5 years time once DH can retire and live in France. I don’t believe it will be fixed in my lifetime and I’m sick of being let down by NHS and then told I should be grateful for it.
I had a life threatening condition in 2014 that manifested as agonising stomach pain. I couldn’t eat for 8 months, dropped to 45kg. Was repeatedly ignored and fobbed off until I went private, had an MRI, was diagnosed and had surgery. Pain free and able to eat within 7 days from seeing private surgeon. I’d have died if I hadn’t had insurance because the NHS were passing me from pillar to post.
More recently I have been diagnosed with a chronic illness which affects mobility and which is treated with surgery in most EU countries and US/Australia. Only surgery can help, there is no medication or conservative treatment that works. NHS denies any treatment for the condition, citing that it needs more research to be done while thousands suffer and lose their mobility. So again I went private for the surgery.
I am also infertile and because my DH has adult kids, I was denied NHS help to have a baby. Again, I had to pay. Why should I contribute anything to a service which has done nothing but let me down?

Nhs2022 · 08/07/2022 05:54

mumda · 07/07/2022 21:09

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_employers

It's number 8 on that list.

Could it work better? Yes. Does it need more staff (not agency or doctors running private work at the same time), yes.

Should we just keep throwing money at it like a bottomless pit? No.

Can we remove some of the levels of bureaucracy that make it bloated? Maybe.

Can we remove some of the expenses?
We probably can't touch the pensions
www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2021-07/CCS001_CCS0521624740-001_NHS%20Pension%20Accounts%202020-21_Web%20Accessible.pdf

Or the Compensation payouts
lordslibrary.parliament.uk/negligence-in-the-nhs-liability-costs/#:~:text=Annual%20cash%20payments%20have%20quadrupled,are%20forecast%20to%20continue%20rising.

Consequently, the wage bill for the NHS makes up a substantial proportion of its budget. In 2019/20, the total cost of NHS staff was £56.1 billion which amounted to 46.6 per cent of the NHS budget.

For an individual at a major A&E department who receives more complex investigation and treatment the costs start at £359.
Can we reverse the trend of people going to the A&E instead of a GP? Perhaps if we triage people off to a GP surgery at the door.

A recent study estimated that, in 2020, the average 9-minute GP consultation costs £39.23. (How do they calculate that cost? Rents/Bills/reception staff etc?)

n June 2021 there were 123,727 doctors, 332,341 nursing staff (including midwives and health visitors) and 33,907 managers in the NHS out of a total workforce of 1.2 million
So there's 710,025 other staff involved in getting the NHS to work. (Cleaners, porters, reception? who else. I would like a better breakdown of that)

All NHS hospitals are managed by acute, mental health, specialist or community trusts
Sounds like management speak for "have more bosses than workers" to me.

Not being able to get GP appointments easily is not helpful for the A&E situation.

I recently had to get DS's school nurse involved as I needed a GP appointment to complete an aspect of a referral form. Receptionist absolutely wouldn't let me book an appointment. I tried 3 times, then asked the school nurse who went direct to the GP. Receptionists shouldn't be able to determine what qualifies for an appointment.

OP posts:
SunscreenCentral · 07/07/2022 21:12

What does "have a paddy" mean?

mumda · 07/07/2022 21:09

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_employers

It's number 8 on that list.

Could it work better? Yes. Does it need more staff (not agency or doctors running private work at the same time), yes.

Should we just keep throwing money at it like a bottomless pit? No.

Can we remove some of the levels of bureaucracy that make it bloated? Maybe.

Can we remove some of the expenses?
We probably can't touch the pensions
www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2021-07/CCS001_CCS0521624740-001_NHS%20Pension%20Accounts%202020-21_Web%20Accessible.pdf

Or the Compensation payouts
lordslibrary.parliament.uk/negligence-in-the-nhs-liability-costs/#:~:text=Annual%20cash%20payments%20have%20quadrupled,are%20forecast%20to%20continue%20rising.

Consequently, the wage bill for the NHS makes up a substantial proportion of its budget. In 2019/20, the total cost of NHS staff was £56.1 billion which amounted to 46.6 per cent of the NHS budget.

For an individual at a major A&E department who receives more complex investigation and treatment the costs start at £359.
Can we reverse the trend of people going to the A&E instead of a GP? Perhaps if we triage people off to a GP surgery at the door.

A recent study estimated that, in 2020, the average 9-minute GP consultation costs £39.23. (How do they calculate that cost? Rents/Bills/reception staff etc?)

n June 2021 there were 123,727 doctors, 332,341 nursing staff (including midwives and health visitors) and 33,907 managers in the NHS out of a total workforce of 1.2 million
So there's 710,025 other staff involved in getting the NHS to work. (Cleaners, porters, reception? who else. I would like a better breakdown of that)

All NHS hospitals are managed by acute, mental health, specialist or community trusts
Sounds like management speak for "have more bosses than workers" to me.

shootme69 · 07/07/2022 20:38

I went into hospital under a labour government and came out 5 months later to a conservative government. I had gallstones, it should have been simple, 12 years later I'm still taking medication daily and my health is shit. The NHS has been failing for years regardless of government, it's lost its way and needs a bloody good shake up.

Zigzagzoozoo · 07/07/2022 20:31

Funding for the NHS, as a percentage, is above the EU average although, in common with many other nations it faced a real terms squeeze after the 2008 financial crisis. According to the ONS, spending per head of population in the UK is around the average for industrialised nations.

The problem is not simply funding, as the NHS in its current form is a money pit and however much it is given, it will never be enough. The problems are structural, societal and financial and simply repeating the tired old “Tory cuts” mantra is a misleading oversimplification.

Everything needs more money. Where is it all supposed to come from? The tax burden on UK households is currently at the highest level it has been since the 1940s.

Our expectation of what the state should do and provide has increased dramatically over the past 100 years but our ability to fund it has not. When the welfare state was founded, it was intended as a safety blanket to be used for short periods; the NHS was never designed or expected to deliver the plethora of services that are needed now; social care was never the problem that it is now because people died younger of diseases that are now treated by the NHS. As a society, we were more tolerant of horrific levels of poverty.

Obviously the significant improvements in quality and length of life that have come about as a result of the NHS and the welfare state etc are incredible and so many peoples lives are immeasurably better as a result. However, the simple fact is that now we expect much much more of our public services than we are able or willing to pay for. It’s an impossible situation.

midairchallenger · 07/07/2022 20:27

But our cancer survival rates are behind Europe, so why are you ringfencing that as beyond reproach? You have a shorter life expectancy under NHS care.

cecilthehungryspider · 07/07/2022 20:27

sst1234 · 07/07/2022 18:58

Would anyone care to explain what is ‘proper’ funding? This organization is spending 27% more this year compared with 2010. How much is enough? Or should we accept that it’s a bottomless pit?

We are over 2 years into a global pandemic that has hospitalised hundreds of thousands of people. That plus inflation. Of course spending has increased from 11 years ago.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 07/07/2022 20:24

It hasn’t functioned properly in my adult lifetime…that’s 30 years. It got worse under labour in the 90s from a joined up care perspective, and it never recovered. It was lumbered with debt via PFI and constant political meddling of all sides, combined with a staff centric not patient centric mentality, has got us here. It killed my husband through sheet incompetence, blinkered silo thinking and a complete inability to listen to the patient. It’s no exaggeration to say that treatment in Indian and African hospitals was more patient centric. It should be completely dismantled and rebuilt. It won’t be though.

JudgeJ · 07/07/2022 20:23

cardibach · 07/07/2022 18:42

Anything that isn’t working is due to 12 years of neglect by Tories. It can work. It would with proper funding and leadership. We spend less than most as a % of GDP.

Bingo! It was always marvelous before, unless you're old enough to remember when it wasn't. The NHS has had so many things dumped on it that of course it's at breaking point. it was designed to deal with illness not all the addiction things etc. it now is expected to pander to. For example, not being able to keep your house clean and tidy, to hoard a load of junk for years is now classed as an 'illness' and the NHS is left to deal with it.

Nhs2022 · 07/07/2022 20:22

I think I'd be happy with a more European system. I think until you've been stuck in never ending waiting lists, repeat appointments because info was lost, hours on the phone trying to get a referral decline reconsidered its hard to realise just how dire the middle services are.

My source of frustration is for a DC where it definitely isn't lifestyle choices.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread