Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our NHS isn't working?

144 replies

Nhs2022 · 07/07/2022 18:40

In many ways I can't fault the NHS, they saved my son and my mum's lives. They gave my aunt 4 years longer than first predicted with AML.

However, I also think there needs to be a conversation about the less life threatening and more mundane services of the NHS. The ones that won't kill you but significantly impact quality of life. These have absolutely fallen apart and the system isn't sustainable.

Why is it so wrong to say key aspects of the NHS are no longer fit for purpose and adults and children are being left miserable but alive?

Is there any sensible solution?

I think I'd happily go for a part and part system.

OP posts:
itsjustnotok · 08/07/2022 21:52

The NHS was set up to save lives but society’s ever changing idea of life saving has dramatically changed and it’s now expected to offer varying treatments because of say, the impact it might have on Mental Health. Our view on MH have drastically changed and people regularly pop into A&E because they are having a bad day. The sad fact is medical staff have been leaving in droves. It’s been awful working for the NHS there’s too many patients and not enough physical room
or staff to effectively manage. Very high expectations are placed on staff that are left and abuse has gone through the roof. Social care in the community has a massive impact but so does self care. We are terrible at self care. I can live how I want to cos it’s my body mentality means people expect a quick fix when something does go wrong, people actually come to A&E frequently for ‘just in case’ scenarios. It was quite quoted that there were approximately 45,000 GP’s for a population of 68 million. And we are actually wondering why they are being so difficult offering appointments.

MsOllie · 08/07/2022 21:49

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:46

If it gets worse get help, please don't wait until August, thrush or not !

I will, I just don't feel I can take time off work as I've had two lots of tonsillitis back to back and time off for my mums death all in 6 weeks
That plus 3 courses of antibiotics in a month.. my body hates me!

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:46

If it gets worse get help, please don't wait until August, thrush or not !

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:43

Or try out of hours GP's over the weekend ?

MsOllie · 08/07/2022 21:39

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:38

@MsOllie does your GP have an online system ? You could fill in an online form stating you have completed the antibiotics but still have an issue and they can either see you or prescribe another dose to get rid of the infection.

Nope
I have another course of antibiotics here but I can't face taking them as I still have raging thrush from the last course (same antibiotics, chemist accidentally gave me 2 courses)
It doesn't seem infected, it's just a lump now so I'm going to ignore it until my next annual leave in august and book then

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:38

@MsOllie does your GP have an online system ? You could fill in an online form stating you have completed the antibiotics but still have an issue and they can either see you or prescribe another dose to get rid of the infection.

MsOllie · 08/07/2022 21:32

It's the minor stuff that gets left
Example, I have an abscess in my boob. Had antibiotics
It's gone down but hasn't gone. I'm putting off an appointment because
Trying to get one - it means taking time off work, and my work isn't flexible and neither is the doctors surgery
Worrying about treatment - I had an abscess under my arm and they wouldn't close it so I was left with a hole for 6 months (the abscess is right where my underwire goes and I can't face that)
I can't take time off work to keep ringing the doctors at 8am to be told the appointments have all gone

rwalker · 08/07/2022 21:27

cardibach · 07/07/2022 18:42

Anything that isn’t working is due to 12 years of neglect by Tories. It can work. It would with proper funding and leadership. We spend less than most as a % of GDP.

Thats the problem people are thick and stupid enough to think throw money at it and you will fix it .

whilst more money would be a help as an nation
14% smoke
we are one of the fattest nations in Europe

people need to make better choices with
Diet
smoking
drugs
alcohol
exercise
all of the above would make a massive reduction on the demand for health services

Waste and inefficient process in the NHS waste millions ask anyone who works for it.
NHS loose through fraud an estimated 5.7 billion a year yes 5.7 billion a year

Personally had to ring 111 for my parents spoke to triage rung back by nurse practitioner ,who said we needed to speak to a doctor ,doctor rung said we need a senior doctor ,senior doctor rung said he would send a doctor how many HCP dread to think how much that cost .
Youngest had a follow up letter with appt for consultant turned up consultants said he'd been discharged wasted appt
Dad died loads of NHS aids supplied by occupational health working frames ,bath step ,Toilet frame (still in wrapper cost NHS £48 never been near a toilet )
walking sticks told to bin wouldn't take them back.
Tried to cancel his prescriptions they kept sending them carrier bag of drugs all sealed boxes told to bin.

Our lifestyles/shit choices and NHS inefficiencies will be the downfall of the service not any government .

But us the great British public like nothing better than taking zero responibilty for our actions and take the easy option of point the finger elsewhere .

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:10

And I suspect would cost significantly less than the much promised but not yet delivered 40 brand spankety new hospitals !

DillonPanthersFNL · 08/07/2022 21:03

@Alexandra2001 absolutely! Sort out the social care system and you've got so much more leeway in the nhs

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 21:02

Ask any top management of any UK hospital if they think they could manage the bed situation better if they had one extra ward of elderly care beds and I imagine the answer would be a resounding 'yes' . That would still be less than elderly care provision back in the 80's.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 20:34

There's Tory neglect and there's also the fact that, sadly, the NHS was not set up to cope with so many long-term unwell elderly people.

There used to about 50k long term elderly care beds or Geriatric beds as they used to be known in the NHS, most of these disappeared in the late 80's. So historically speaking the NHS was actually set up to cope with long term unwell elderly people.

The population and especially the elderly population has been increasing at a steady pace for at least the last 50 years. It isn't a situation that has suddenly occurred and that nobody could have predicted.

Alexandra2001 · 08/07/2022 19:53

Echobelly · 08/07/2022 19:30

There's Tory neglect and there's also the fact that, sadly, the NHS was not set up to cope with so many long-term unwell elderly people. The assumption was that we'd all live longer and be healthier, but what's actually happened is there are large numbers of frail, older people who need long-term care. I think a German-style 'those who afford pay up' type system might be the only way to deal with this.

Also, the link between health and social care is totally broken, especially impacting these older people and the chronically ill.

In Germany the top up TH is over 70k euros.

Biggest thing we could do to improve NHS is nationalise adult social care.

One of the tragedies of the NHS is in vascular, folk have poor circulation and need surgery, delays in treatment mean they walk in for surgery and come out without a leg.
I thought what my DD told me about Neuro was bad but know she is on acute, its even worse :(

Biggest cause for delay is lack of staff and little/no social care, so folk bed block.

Echobelly · 08/07/2022 19:30

There's Tory neglect and there's also the fact that, sadly, the NHS was not set up to cope with so many long-term unwell elderly people. The assumption was that we'd all live longer and be healthier, but what's actually happened is there are large numbers of frail, older people who need long-term care. I think a German-style 'those who afford pay up' type system might be the only way to deal with this.

Also, the link between health and social care is totally broken, especially impacting these older people and the chronically ill.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 19:27

They have about three times the number of hospital beds in France, as we do in the UK, for a similar size population, which must help with providing a better service ?

Justthisonceharold · 08/07/2022 18:59

Either, depending on the facilities at your local clinic/hospital

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 18:38

We can claim for GP appts, prescriptions, scans, surgery etc. We don't have private insurance, no. But we do have the means to cover any gaps, so for example we pay €25 for a GP appt, but we might only get back circa €20.

Thank you @Justthisonceharold if you need a scan do you go to the local hospital or is there a clinic which provides this service ?

TheABC · 08/07/2022 16:10

Hyperion100 · 08/07/2022 12:36

This is exactly what the tories want you to think.

We have an ageing population with treatment for conditions that would have killed patients a few years back and that costs money.

Yes it needs a huge review to remove levels of bureaucracy but dont let the tories convince you that it can only work through privatisation.

Brexit has made recruitment a huge problem and is currently one of the most pressing issues within the NHS. We cannot make working in the NHS attractive when the costs and hurdles have been added in.

Sadly, I think we'll see the end of the NHS as we know it within a decade.

This.
We are about to enter a reckoning for health, care and pensions as the over 65's and over 90s are our fastest-growing demographic. We will need to rethink the way we structure our entire taxation system to pay for it all. Despite being the 6th-largest economy in the world, the median average salary is only £25k.

Having said all of that, I am still pissed at Labour's PFI trick.

Lbnc2021 · 08/07/2022 15:50

Justthisonceharold · 08/07/2022 07:38

That's untrue. It's much better in France for example. The other day I had a GP appointment, OP XRay and the results, all in less than 24 hours. Not an emergency, and no cancer suspected.

That process would have taken at least 6 weeks, and probably much longer in the UK.That's entirely usual, I could give you many more examples.

You’re right. My eldest daughter was treated for ‘depression and anxiety’ for 8 years on the NHS, put on all different tablets for years despite us both telling the GPs that we were sure it was something else, the best years of her life ruined. Not once did any of the GPs listen to our concerns. She moved to Belgium and within 8 weeks was diagnosed with a tumour on her pituitary gland and Crohn’s disease, had surgery, seen a dietician, new medications, is getting counselling to deal with how she was treated here, she’s like a different person now. The same NHS insisted my dads bowel cancer was just piles for a year.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 08/07/2022 15:45

We have a short-term planning and strategic culture in the UK, across a lot of sectors actually (manufacturing etc) as well as healthcare. From government down to management level (so I'm not talking about the actual frontline workers here, to be clear).

Politicians never think beyond the next electoral cycle. So you end up with sticking plasters to fix broken legs, over and over again, for decades.

The state of the NHS now has been building since the 1970s.

AchatAVendre · 08/07/2022 15:44

I agree OP. Its interesting that polls on this subject on mumsnet always seem to be around the 70% mark agreeing that the NHS is not fit for purpose now. More people are talking about how poor the NHS is now.

Equally, there always seems to be 2 or 3 poster who come onto the post to speak in very psuedo authoritative tones about how the UK can't possibly have any other kind of health service and how every poster who has had poor experiences is wrong or misguided. Theres a particular poster who does this and constantly just asks questions of anyone who dislikes the NHS.

Then theres always the handful of posters who know of no other countries in the world than the UK and the US that have healthcare systems.

Justthisonceharold · 08/07/2022 15:37

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 09:54

We live in France half the year, so not as visitors really. We self fund, then get reimbursed through the reciprocal agreement

So does that mean you don't have to pay for private health insurance in France ? You pay at point of contact and then claim it back when you are back in the UK ? Does the reciprical arrangement cover all your cost's or only treatment ?

Do you happen to know how elderly care/social care is managed in France ?

Some care (emergency for example) is covered by EHIC so no need to pay anything for that up front or ever. The rest of it we claim back the same percentage as a French person is entitled to. We can claim for GP appts, prescriptions, scans, surgery etc. We don't have private insurance, no. But we do have the means to cover any gaps, so for example we pay €25 for a GP appt, but we might only get back circa €20.

No idea how elderly and social care are managed, no. Presumably it works well, given how pivotal it is to a functioning health service.

Newnameforthistopic · 08/07/2022 15:34

The managing of individual departments is appallingly bad. Poor Management is a British problem because almost nobody bothers to train for it. Managing people is a learned skill it is not some natural flair that a few people have. The very best managers might be 'naturals' but everyone can be 90% good.
There are some at Sister level that cannot understand that staff need to see rosters at least 2 weeks ahead. Sure things change at short notice but let's have a target that we all see.
Currently office is recruiting and signing up new staff from Philippines they need an induction and exam course. No one is rostered to do this. Any one from the office does what they can. Complain to Matron, shrugged shoulders "Do the best you can Love, we are all short staffed."

bigbluebus · 08/07/2022 15:02

My DH had an accident in Southern Spain few years ago which could have been life changing but thankfully wasn't.
The emergency services wouldn't come as we were at a villa 1/2 mile from the main road. The travel reps had to take him to the emergency clinic where a porter wouldn't get him out of the car until he'd seen our EU passports. They checked him over straight away and sent him away with paracetamol and instructions re concussion/head injuries. The reps offered to take him to the main hospital in Malaga for a 2nd opinion but told us I'd have to stay with him overnight to care for him and take our own water as this wouldn't be provided at the hospital.
I'd had vast experience of the NHS with it's strengths and weaknesses and was very surprised by the Spanish system and what it wouldn't do.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 08/07/2022 14:40

The NHS needs a fully functioning social care sector to be able to function efficiently.

Although it sounds as though France is starting to go the same way as the NHS, lets see how things pan out for them.

www.connexionfrance.com/article/French-news/Why-has-France-lost-80-000-hospital-beds-in-20-years

Swipe left for the next trending thread