Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think primary schools are stuck in the 50s?

271 replies

Desperado40 · 07/07/2022 18:37

I need to get this off my chest somewhere...maybe I am unreasonable, but my kids' primary school is stuck in another decade. They constantly bombard us with things to attend or assist kids to do at home (and I am not talking spellings here, but proper projects). We both work full time! It is hard enough to organise wrap around childcare and we share as much as possible between us, but I really don't want to be wasting the only family time we have on catching up with projects and homework. We received over 60(!) School emails in the last 4 weeks about various things. I am at my wit's end, there is something to remember to bring or do almost daily. And of course the guilt when I cannot attend every single sports day, market day, school fayre, school concert, parents assembly, wave child off on the 100th school trip... I am afraid that it is all designed for a stay at home parents... I know that working full time, I am in the minority of mums in our school. AIBU to think schools should assume that both parents DO work and be more inclusive?

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 20:30

"So my opinion is homework in primary school is completely and utterly unnecessary and I wouldn't pressure any child to do it!"

I bet most teachers would agree with you. We don't want to set or mark it. We know they often have help so is not a fair assessment of what the child can do. We know it causes conflict and stress in some homes. We feel sorry for the kids who don't get help with it, or get in trouble because their parents don't remind them to do it or bring it. Very occasionally it can be useful - parents see their child struggling and help them, or realise there's a problem.

Unfortunately at our school a parental questionnaire revealed that the vast majority of parents wanted it to stay - they preferred dry boring stuff like worksheets and spellings to projects.

But not all schools have homework. For those parents who disagree with their prospective schools homework policy, why not look for other schools?

LondonQueen · 07/07/2022 20:28

Pinkflipflop85 · 07/07/2022 18:39

We know most of our parents work.

Ofsted still expect us to have lots of parental engagement/communicatiom/events/etc.

Exactly this.

Rosewaterblossom · 07/07/2022 20:25

Jedsnewstar · 07/07/2022 20:13

I disagree with the homework completely, it's good to get in the habit of doing this earlier otherwise secondary is gonna be a real shock to the system

I disagree with you. I rarely had homework in primary school it was something to be expected in secondary. I remember thinking how grown up I’d be to have homework. It wasn’t a shock at all to the system.

Agreed. I never had homework on primary but just accepted it was part of secondary. My dd had horrendous anxiety and tantrums with primary school homework, so much so I was dreading secondary school with her. She took it all in her stride in secondary school and just accepted it.

So my opinion is homework in primary school is completely and utterly unnecessary and I wouldn't pressure any child to do it!

justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 20:23

orangeisthenewpuce · 07/07/2022 20:20

I was at school in the 60's and it wasn't like it is today. I can't believe the amount of stuff my grandchildren bring home for parents to be involved in, days when uniform isn't to be worn, requests for money, trips, homework, dressing up days, projects etc. I walked to and from school alone from a v early age. There was no school fairs, parent assemblies, nothing that food had to be taken in for and the only time my parent saw a teacher was once a year a parents evening. It wasn't even as bad as it is now when my grown up children were young. I feel sorry for parents now.

Schools work hard to involve and engage parents because it's been shown to have an impact on the children's well-being and attainment.

justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 20:22

"but I think if the school can't cover events with staff members, just cut down on the number of events"

But I'm sure you know that most of the children, and a lot of the parents, would disagree with this. Many parents are happy to volunteer. Unless you are forced to do it at gunpoint, why not just let the nice things happen and the keen parents volunteer so they can happen?

orangeisthenewpuce · 07/07/2022 20:20

I was at school in the 60's and it wasn't like it is today. I can't believe the amount of stuff my grandchildren bring home for parents to be involved in, days when uniform isn't to be worn, requests for money, trips, homework, dressing up days, projects etc. I walked to and from school alone from a v early age. There was no school fairs, parent assemblies, nothing that food had to be taken in for and the only time my parent saw a teacher was once a year a parents evening. It wasn't even as bad as it is now when my grown up children were young. I feel sorry for parents now.

justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 20:19

We can't win really. Sometimes we get parents complaining that we send too many messages. Sometimes we get parents complaining that we only reminded them twice to send their kids to school in a PE kit.

Most schools try their best I think. We're busy and don't especially enjoy spending time on messages, or annoying parents, or handling complaints. We communicate when there is something to say.

Regarding volunteers - yes we ask because we rely on them. Your child's school experience is nicer because of volunteers. It's not a court summons though and we don't mind if you can't do it.

Regarding trips - if you have more than one per term I'd be suggesting fewer, that gets expensive.

Desperado40 · 07/07/2022 20:18

I would not mind if the experiences did not constantly involve parents' time. This include school trips that would not take place unless they'd have x number of parent volunteering. There is a constant pressure to be present very frequently. I don't mind the odd special event, but I think if the school can't cover events with staff members, just cut down on the number of events, it is becoming unmanageable. Something's gotta give, and soon it will be my sanity.

OP posts:
Quietmouse · 07/07/2022 20:18

Absolutely this!!

Phineyj · 07/07/2022 20:17

It's a bit of an own goal. Parents' time and energy is taken up with these things, and teachers' -- It's all a giant distraction from the purpose of education if you ask me.

You can be engaged with your child's education by having a conversation with them. Models of Roman shields and cake sales are neither here nor there.

But the disagreement between parents on homework is real. I can only assume that the ones who want loads of it have more compliant/studious DC than me. Or nannies.

Jedsnewstar · 07/07/2022 20:13

I disagree with the homework completely, it's good to get in the habit of doing this earlier otherwise secondary is gonna be a real shock to the system

I disagree with you. I rarely had homework in primary school it was something to be expected in secondary. I remember thinking how grown up I’d be to have homework. It wasn’t a shock at all to the system.

Schoolchoicesucks · 07/07/2022 20:12

arethereanyleftatall · 07/07/2022 19:00

Whilst I don't disagree, your post is a little confused.
You've said you know you're in the minority with both parents working (and I would agree with that, I only know 1 family that do), so why should they assume both work full time when most don't? It's probably better to go with the majority who do want involvement.

Do you really only know 1 family where both parents work? How unusual. Do you know any single parents who work?

Schoolchoicesucks · 07/07/2022 20:10

MoveBitch · 07/07/2022 18:49

You know teachers are parents too right?
Yes we can't do everything but it it's nice for children to have some parental engagement where possible.

I disagree with the homework completely, it's good to get in the habit of doing this earlier otherwise secondary is gonna be a real shock to the system

60 emails in 4 weeks is ridiculous. As a parent would you be able to engage with those 60 emails on top of your teaching workload?

Dc's school scrapped homework that had to be marked. They are meant to read daily, have weekly spellings and encouraged to use mathletics and tt rockstars to practise maths.

During covid the emails got out of hand - not so much the frequency, but the content. 8 or 9 pages per email, with many parents having English as a second language. What was needed was short, clear communications. The head did take parent feedback on board and cut this down.

manysummersago · 07/07/2022 20:09

It’s a shame when people react defensively. Besides, I think the problem is a lot of these things are really not fun for the child when they are the one without a parent there.

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 07/07/2022 20:07

It doesn’t last forever. Once they start secondary school you won’t hear anything.

Classicblunder · 07/07/2022 20:04

Smartiepants79 · 07/07/2022 20:03

Another one of these conversations where schools cannot win.
For every parent who thinks there’s too much homework, trips, sports days, dress up, concerts etc etc there is another parent who thinks they don’t get enough homework, trips and dress up…..
These threads make me cross.
These things are planned, carefully, involving teachers time and energy for the benefit of YOUR CHILD. To give them a fun and memorable school experience. All the moaning is so depressing.

Perhaps as part of the careful planning process, they could give more than 3 days notice

Smartiepants79 · 07/07/2022 20:03

Another one of these conversations where schools cannot win.
For every parent who thinks there’s too much homework, trips, sports days, dress up, concerts etc etc there is another parent who thinks they don’t get enough homework, trips and dress up…..
These threads make me cross.
These things are planned, carefully, involving teachers time and energy for the benefit of YOUR CHILD. To give them a fun and memorable school experience. All the moaning is so depressing.

NannyGythaOgg · 07/07/2022 19:53

Babdoc · 07/07/2022 19:02

Homework? In primary school? What on earth for?
I started primary school in 1959. We had no homework whatsoever until we started secondary school at age 11.
I venture to suggest our education was actually superior to the modern version, even without homework. We knew our tables up to 12X by age 7, many of us could read fluently in reception, and we were doing algebra and geometry by age 10.
Our parents did not get involved in any school projects at all, and we completed these during school hours.

Parental involvement was simply to send some cake or biscuits (which could be shop bought) for the annual class Christmas party.
I sympathise with you, OP, that sounds totally unreasonable.

Totally agree - I'm the same age.

Parents didn't come to school. Mum may not have paid work but with a washing machine that had to be dragged in front of the sink and filled from the kitchen sink taps, coal fires and NO car or convenience foods, there simply wasn't time for her to come to school on a regular basis.

School hours were 9 until 3.30 for infants and until 4 for juniors, so I went to school with my brothers but (at 4.5 years) caught the bus home on my own after the first couple of weeks

I was also caned twice before I was 7 for silly things (humming in class and making a noise in the corridor)

and when I got a head injury aged 5, my 10 year old brother was taken out of class to take me home (a bus ride away).

You may not like how it is now but the 50s it certainly isn't

Bunnycat101 · 07/07/2022 19:47

I have struggled this year. I get that schools need to offer opportunities and if lots of parents can make it that’s great but there are some things that just cumulatively make it tricky so the 1/2 day finishes at the end of term, the let’s come and look at work at 3pm on the days that must children are in wrap around, the random excursions that require picking up from a different school at 11.15 etc.

Annual leave is so precious give the amount of school holidays it becomes tricky to use it for things that aren’t the big things like nativity/sports days but you still feel like shit when your child is disappointed you can’t make it.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 07/07/2022 19:47

My DDs school manages to be simultaneously rubbish and over eager on communication.

Sports day for example... one email mid afternoon the day before. Only other mention was a date on the calendar.

But we got multiple emails about which gates would be open on election day.

Getting a lot of emails at the moment for Yr6 what with Camp, Transition, Prom, Assembly, trips reports etc happening. Which is understandable.

On school trip days we get a 15min warning of the coach arriving back if its after normal finish time which is useful.

Worst thing I've had over the years was an email at 8.07am saying no school buses were running due to strike action... no prior warning. The buses started pick ups at 8am! In our case, DH had to drive home from work to drive them to school.

Desperado40 · 07/07/2022 19:43

I don't mind taking time off for some school events, it's the amount of school events that I have a problem with. It's really excessive! They also book school trips and constantly pester parents to volunteer to help out or they'd get cancelled! I kid you not. School sleepovers and school discos also need parent volunteers.

OP posts:
artisanbread · 07/07/2022 19:41

They didn’t know my teachers names or anything I was doing - this was normal in the 70s and the standard of my state primary was incredibly high especially when I compare it to all the fluff and nonsense primary schools do now - ridiculous amounts of junk craft making etc which the parents were invited to and other equally inane stuff.

That seems strange as the 70s and 80s were renowned for poor educational standards. I went to school in the 80s and the only thing I can remember is constantly making things out of cardboard boxes. The curriculum for primary now is completely different. I teach KS1 and have no time for model making - things have swung much too far in the opposite direction.

I do agree that parents didn't come in for many things in those days but then there was no Ofsted tick-box for parental engagement.

Bumblenums · 07/07/2022 19:37

I'm with you OP - I work full time and my husband does shift work- it's simply not set up for working parents. I would love to do all the sports days, productions, graduations, assembly's, moving up days, stay and play, summer fayre, carol concerts, look at work afternoons. Huge amount of emails, school fundraising groups asking for a couple of quid a week for something. Its simply not fair for the kids who dont have someone to attend/dont have the money to.

artisanbread · 07/07/2022 19:37

I'm a primary school teacher and I always roll my eyes whenever SLT start trying to put on events for parents during the day. Most of the teachers in my school are also parents and they don't give us time off for things like that at our own kids' schools.

00100001 · 07/07/2022 19:36

MoveBitch · 07/07/2022 18:49

You know teachers are parents too right?
Yes we can't do everything but it it's nice for children to have some parental engagement where possible.

I disagree with the homework completely, it's good to get in the habit of doing this earlier otherwise secondary is gonna be a real shock to the system

Nonsense, we never had homework at primary in the late 80s/early 90s. Homework at secondary was just fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread