Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think primary schools are stuck in the 50s?

271 replies

Desperado40 · 07/07/2022 18:37

I need to get this off my chest somewhere...maybe I am unreasonable, but my kids' primary school is stuck in another decade. They constantly bombard us with things to attend or assist kids to do at home (and I am not talking spellings here, but proper projects). We both work full time! It is hard enough to organise wrap around childcare and we share as much as possible between us, but I really don't want to be wasting the only family time we have on catching up with projects and homework. We received over 60(!) School emails in the last 4 weeks about various things. I am at my wit's end, there is something to remember to bring or do almost daily. And of course the guilt when I cannot attend every single sports day, market day, school fayre, school concert, parents assembly, wave child off on the 100th school trip... I am afraid that it is all designed for a stay at home parents... I know that working full time, I am in the minority of mums in our school. AIBU to think schools should assume that both parents DO work and be more inclusive?

OP posts:
FancyFelix · 09/07/2022 14:32

However, I really do believe working parents need to let go of some of their guilt. We’re a 2 teacher household. Often we can’t go to our DCs’ events. Yep, it’s a bit disappointing for them but then the trade off is they get 13 weeks a year when we are all together as a family.

Yeah. Most FT working parents don't get to assuage their guilt with 3 months of holiday though! I find the holidays make me feel far guiltier as I have to send my kids to holiday clubs. At least school is compulsory.

MyBrilliantFriend · 09/07/2022 13:39

HereBeFuckery · 08/07/2022 16:36

@Mumdiva99
"just because you and your husband work should the other kids not have a sports day attended by parents? Or the play not be put on? Or the music student not play a concert? Or parents not be invited into sew what their kids have been learning? It's those things the kids remember beyond school too."

Just because I'm a teacher and my husband works full time should my DD be the only kid in class today whose parents could not attend to look at her work this year? She has come home in tears saying no one looked at her books and why isn't her work as good as everyone else in her class? Is there not any solution that allows FT working parents to engage with primary education? There are NO external supply teachers in the whole of my city who have any availability today and probably for most of next week. We cancelled y12 classes to free up enough internal cover for the rest of the school. There is no way I could be there.

I don't think it needs to be binary - it's not 'have the in school events or don't' - but I think there could be a creative way to allow those of us who don't have the luxury of booking time off when we want to, to attend/engage with school events in some fashion. Could the teacher not have had a little compassion for a hard working kid crying on her own (asked a nice parent to go and look at her book? Get her to show a TA?) because a 2pm event is just not feasible if you have a FT job? It seems unnecessarily divisive.

Yes but that’s just your DD’s school being a bit crap.

We had this exact event this week - work sharing - but we make sure all the children with no parent able to attend have some interested adults to show (usually the head teacher). Plus we contact all the parents who weren’t able to attend to offer other times to come & look at their child’s work (within our working hours so between 8-4ish). In that way we are as accommodating & supportive as possible within our school hours.

It is possible to have events but also be as inclusive as possible. However, I really do believe working parents need to let go of some of their guilt. We’re a 2 teacher household. Often we can’t go to our DCs’ events. Yep, it’s a bit disappointing for them but then the trade off is they get 13 weeks a year when we are all together as a family. Plus loads of nice financial perks of 2 FT working parents. So I refuse to feel guilty about overall doing the thing that works best for us as a family. Or to push that onto their lovely school who are just trying to support and encourage as many families as possible.

UndertheCedartree · 09/07/2022 09:53

Joyfultoes · 08/07/2022 13:01

@Goodskin46 the idea of phoning up a large 550 pupil city primary and asking them to sign a sheet for your one child is laughable. Even Emails have a 3-5 day allotted response time and calling is in only for emergencies.

550 pupils large?? My DD's Primary has over 1000 pupils and the office staff would be more than happy to do something like this. I am surprised at physical sign up sheets, though as they do everything over Parentmail. Calling is not just for emergencies and emails are usually answered within a day.

BellePeppa · 09/07/2022 08:38

Also, just to add - 11+ was available to everyone and no one did private tutoring - it was actually done in the school! There were two very prestigious private schools who offered only 2 full scholarships (100%) to the best performing pupils of schools in our large area (a London suburb) two girls in the same year (including my sister) were offered (and took) those places - that’s how high the standard of my state primary was.

BellePeppa · 09/07/2022 08:30

artisanbread · 07/07/2022 19:41

They didn’t know my teachers names or anything I was doing - this was normal in the 70s and the standard of my state primary was incredibly high especially when I compare it to all the fluff and nonsense primary schools do now - ridiculous amounts of junk craft making etc which the parents were invited to and other equally inane stuff.

That seems strange as the 70s and 80s were renowned for poor educational standards. I went to school in the 80s and the only thing I can remember is constantly making things out of cardboard boxes. The curriculum for primary now is completely different. I teach KS1 and have no time for model making - things have swung much too far in the opposite direction.

I do agree that parents didn't come in for many things in those days but then there was no Ofsted tick-box for parental engagement.

I was at infants then primary between about 1965 to 1974 and my memories of primary are really strong, for some reason I can remember huge chunks of it, even all my form teachers names 😁 We had one teacher per form (no TAs) who absolutely ruled the roost (41 kids in the class - I still have my school reports stating this). A very scary head who patrolled the corridors with a cane he wasn't afraid to use (I am dead against this though) and exceptionally high standards of teaching. Admittedly there was very little in the way of ‘fun’ at school - no crafts or dressing up days, no fairs or bake sales, which would have been nice. When I compare what my children did/learn in primary in the 2000s to what I did it’s no wonder my very clever son was bored stiff and complained a lot about too much pointless and inane stuff going on (I had my children later in life so there is a big gap between my primary years and theirs). Also we had no homework.

Mumdiva99 · 09/07/2022 08:15

@HereBeFuckery firstly - absolutely your school should have noticed your daughter was the only one without a parent in. (I've been to a lot of these.....before I worked in a school and now can't go......there was never just 1 kid without a parent. I would always make a fuss of any kids on their own too. But that should be driven by the teachers/staff not really down to parents to fill the gap (Obviously I never minded but as your daughter experienced - what if no one came for them).

What solution do you suggest? Because I bet you've thought of it.......what did your child's school say when you suggested it? (If it works I'm pinching to suggest where I work and where my kids go to school....).

Phineyj · 09/07/2022 08:12

Aw HereBe I would definitely look at a and make a fuss of DD's classmates' work in that situation and I have.

It would be fascinating to know if Ofsted have ever tried weighing up benefit to children of all this "engagement" versus mental load on mums and teachers (lots of whom are mums).

Most Ofsted and ISI inspectors I've met have been men...

BellePeppa · 09/07/2022 08:12

justfiveminutes · 07/07/2022 20:23

Schools work hard to involve and engage parents because it's been shown to have an impact on the children's well-being and attainment.

I went to primary in the 60s and I would have cringed if my parents had been involved in my day to day school stuff. The waving and loud ‘cooee’ from my mum when she watched the school play still haunts me to this day😁

artisanbread · 09/07/2022 07:17

As a two teacher household our kids are the ones whose parents are never there for anything. I might be lucky to get the time once a year for something big like the Nativity but only if there is someone who can cover me. My Mum, who lives an hour and a half away, has been up for some of the sports days. Nobody can ever go to the displays of work etc. They are also never able to compete in the various inter-school sports events which always seem to require a parent to come out in the middle of the day and take them somewhere.

I have explained to my DC it's just the way it is and they have got used to it. Mine do quite a lot of shows etc with extra-curricular activities which I can always go to, luckily.

FrippEnos · 08/07/2022 21:45

Joyfultoes

Schools are full of staff that wouldn’t survive a day in the private sector - and I’m not really even talking about the teachers….

That's alright because the private sector is full of people that wouldn't survive a day working in a school

UndertheCedartree · 08/07/2022 21:22

HereBeFuckery · 08/07/2022 16:36

@Mumdiva99
"just because you and your husband work should the other kids not have a sports day attended by parents? Or the play not be put on? Or the music student not play a concert? Or parents not be invited into sew what their kids have been learning? It's those things the kids remember beyond school too."

Just because I'm a teacher and my husband works full time should my DD be the only kid in class today whose parents could not attend to look at her work this year? She has come home in tears saying no one looked at her books and why isn't her work as good as everyone else in her class? Is there not any solution that allows FT working parents to engage with primary education? There are NO external supply teachers in the whole of my city who have any availability today and probably for most of next week. We cancelled y12 classes to free up enough internal cover for the rest of the school. There is no way I could be there.

I don't think it needs to be binary - it's not 'have the in school events or don't' - but I think there could be a creative way to allow those of us who don't have the luxury of booking time off when we want to, to attend/engage with school events in some fashion. Could the teacher not have had a little compassion for a hard working kid crying on her own (asked a nice parent to go and look at her book? Get her to show a TA?) because a 2pm event is just not feasible if you have a FT job? It seems unnecessarily divisive.

Whenever I go in for something with my DD I always interact with DC who don't have a parent in and other parents do it for my DD when I'm not there. Most of the class don't usually have someone in. Could your DH not take annual leave, though? 2pm is a strange time, though. And tbh, I think you might have bigger problems if the teacher and TA left your DC to cry. At my DD's school the open afternoon for looking at books/meeting new teacher started at 3.30 and went on til 6pm.

FancyAnOlive · 08/07/2022 21:19

There's always masses of stuff going on in the last three weeks of the year though - maybe because of Covid it didn't really happen for the last couple of years so people have forgotten. Also, people who work in school offices and send out these emails often do lots of other work at the same time and don't necessarily have time to wait and collate information into fewer emails, they just have to ping the info out when they get it.
Sports day should be on online calendars though!

bigfootisreal · 08/07/2022 21:15

Desperado40 · 07/07/2022 18:37

I need to get this off my chest somewhere...maybe I am unreasonable, but my kids' primary school is stuck in another decade. They constantly bombard us with things to attend or assist kids to do at home (and I am not talking spellings here, but proper projects). We both work full time! It is hard enough to organise wrap around childcare and we share as much as possible between us, but I really don't want to be wasting the only family time we have on catching up with projects and homework. We received over 60(!) School emails in the last 4 weeks about various things. I am at my wit's end, there is something to remember to bring or do almost daily. And of course the guilt when I cannot attend every single sports day, market day, school fayre, school concert, parents assembly, wave child off on the 100th school trip... I am afraid that it is all designed for a stay at home parents... I know that working full time, I am in the minority of mums in our school. AIBU to think schools should assume that both parents DO work and be more inclusive?

You do realise that people who work in schools also are often parents so yes they do realise. They also miss out on sports days etc. Do you not realise this?

Goodskin46 · 08/07/2022 21:11

Joyfultoes · 08/07/2022 13:01

@Goodskin46 the idea of phoning up a large 550 pupil city primary and asking them to sign a sheet for your one child is laughable. Even Emails have a 3-5 day allotted response time and calling is in only for emergencies.

Fair enough there were 90 in my DC's primary. I am really surprised that a 550 pupil school is using a sign up sheey in the playground tbh

toomuchlaundry · 08/07/2022 18:44

Schools are struggling to recruit for admin posts never mind top notch admins!

Inertia · 08/07/2022 18:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Schools can't afford top-notch admin!

After a decade of budget cuts, the massive financial impact of covid, and the impact of the current high-costs crisis, admin staffing is at a bare minimum in most schools . Schools are making teachers and TAs redundant because they can't afford to pay them- I can't see any state school having the money to hire a top-notch admin person just to consolidate emails.

Teachers are doing the admin, emails, event organising, report collation and sending (as well as writing), SEND paperwork, parents' evening scheduling and appointment communication, curriculum communications, sports day notices etc, on top of their actual job. We're sending messages out in odd moments between duties/ lesson prep in our lunchtimes- there isn't time to package them up attractively.

I would love to pass all this on to a top-notch admin assistant, but teacher's time doesn't cost the school any money. School admin colleagues are brilliant and work hard, but schools don't have the money to pay enough of them for the number of hours required.

takeitandleaveit · 08/07/2022 17:25

No, they're not stuck in the 50's. Not by a long, long way (speaking as someone who was a primary school in the 60's, so I remember what it was like then, and I dare say the 50's were similar).

Parents came to school four times a year. Parents' evening, sports day, summer fete and the christmas concert. The fete was on a Saturday, so only two events were in daytime during the week.

Apart from spelling once a week, we had no homework at all.

We were asked to bring in things like empty washing liquid bottles and cardboard cereal boxes, a tea towel to put on your head for the nativity, and maybe a tin of something for the fete tombola stall.

That is literally it.

saraclara · 08/07/2022 16:56

My kids' school used to have a monthly 'come and look at your kids' work' session after school. I was a sahm for most of the first year, and used to go and ooh and ah over a friend's child's work as well as my own, as the friend couldn't go.

When I started working, either a friend or the child minder would do the same for me, as like my friend, I had no family near by who would step in for me.

HereBeFuckery · 08/07/2022 16:36

@Mumdiva99
"just because you and your husband work should the other kids not have a sports day attended by parents? Or the play not be put on? Or the music student not play a concert? Or parents not be invited into sew what their kids have been learning? It's those things the kids remember beyond school too."

Just because I'm a teacher and my husband works full time should my DD be the only kid in class today whose parents could not attend to look at her work this year? She has come home in tears saying no one looked at her books and why isn't her work as good as everyone else in her class? Is there not any solution that allows FT working parents to engage with primary education? There are NO external supply teachers in the whole of my city who have any availability today and probably for most of next week. We cancelled y12 classes to free up enough internal cover for the rest of the school. There is no way I could be there.

I don't think it needs to be binary - it's not 'have the in school events or don't' - but I think there could be a creative way to allow those of us who don't have the luxury of booking time off when we want to, to attend/engage with school events in some fashion. Could the teacher not have had a little compassion for a hard working kid crying on her own (asked a nice parent to go and look at her book? Get her to show a TA?) because a 2pm event is just not feasible if you have a FT job? It seems unnecessarily divisive.

LoudingVoice · 08/07/2022 16:19

WendellGeez · 08/07/2022 15:46

@LoudingVoice What method did your mum use to teach you? I'm interested in doing this with my grandchildren.
Were the teachers encouraging that you already knew how to read? I have heard some don't like it and accuse the parents of meddling or even doing damage.

I don’t know the exact method, just lots of reading to me, sounding out the words, think we had flash cards.

I can’t remember what the teachers thought tbh, it was a long time ago, and my mum died a few years ago so I can’t ask her. I remember being given reading books when the others were learning but that’s about it.

I can’t see how it would be a bad thing? Bit odd tbh!

WendellGeez · 08/07/2022 15:46

LoudingVoice · 08/07/2022 08:12

Don’t know about that person but my mum taught me to read, I could already read well when I started reception.

@LoudingVoice What method did your mum use to teach you? I'm interested in doing this with my grandchildren.
Were the teachers encouraging that you already knew how to read? I have heard some don't like it and accuse the parents of meddling or even doing damage.

RidingMyBike · 08/07/2022 14:16

Although we don't get homework at this school (other than a weekly reading book), no uniform which cuts down on the dress up days. And no requests for craft projects so it sounds like we've got off lightly.

RidingMyBike · 08/07/2022 14:13

And I really really would love to support the school. It's a fabulous school and they do loads of great things, but if they only let you know about events at the last minute, especially if they're in the middle of the day, then I'm going to struggle to do anything about them.

And since when has parents' evening not been in the evening? Last year it ran between 3.30 and 5.30pm but on Zoom which meant we were able to slot it in relatively easily during a work day. This year (different school) last slot was 5.00pm and all in person. That meant another half day of leave used up to be able to get there...

Autumnterm · 08/07/2022 13:55

my DC used to go to a VA school like this.
The head was a very religious woman who believed deep down that children should have two married parents, one of which should not work. As a result there was no proper wrap around care offered; events like parent/teacher « evenings » were held with minimal notice and starting at 2pm; there was constant pressure to volunteer at bake sales and school events during the working day; masses of homework projects that required adult assistance and supervision; and communications were a mess - loads of emails with notifications and instructions all the time, often sent at very short notice and sometimes contradicting emails that had just been sent….yet at the same time WE weren’t allowed to email the teachers - the only way to contact them was to write a letter or attempt to catch their eye at pick up - if that is you were outside the school and not at work at 3pm.

We stuck it for two years and then I’d had enough. Some mothers (and fathers) with nothing else to do loved it because it filled their days, but for those of us who were working it was a nightmare.

So DC went to another school, which was MUCH better - the comms were better organised, you got adequate notice of when things were happening so you could book time off or try to shuffle things about, and there were proper before and after school clubs that ran come hell or high water. Still a bunch of craft projects, tbh, but the other things made life so much easier I didn’t mind the craft much.

RidingMyBike · 08/07/2022 13:47

Last year, for Reception, we had about five events within a fortnight at this time of year. I know it was partly uncertainty over Covid meant things were last minute. But each of those would have meant at least a half day of leave, more for the things that were after school lunchtime and timed to finish at 3pm. Which is hopeless if your kid is in after school club until 6pm! I can't just come out of work for 3 hours in the middle of the work day!
So that's nearly a week of annual leave lost to school events.

This year, we've just had ten days' notice of sports day taking place. Sadly I'd already booked a site visit for work 200 miles away so there was no way I could attend. If they'd sent out a term's worth of dates at Easter I could have arranged it.