Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to exclude one girl?

186 replies

ExplodingCarrots · 07/07/2022 17:43

It’s a party one.

DD party coming up. Having a party in the house so can’t invite whole class. We’ve never done whole class parties , only a couple of friends so never excluding a small number.

We had an issue the last time we had a party at the house where the boys who were invited were badly behaved so DD has said she wants to invite girls only.

The issue we have is that there is one girl in the class who is very mean to other kids and disruptive. She joined the school a year and a half ago and I know numerous parents have been in to school to complain because their child has been bullied , hit and called names. My DD started playing with the girl but it ended up in numerous dramas and my DD ending up being upset so she’s been told by the teacher and myself to stay away from each other. The other day my DD and her best friend were sat in the playground and the girl approached them and called them fat and told them to kill themselves. Obviously this upset them.

Because of this , DD doesn’t want to invite this girl. I completely agree as to why she don’t want her there BUT there’s this moral dilemma of obviously excluding 1 girl. DH is of the stance of this girl is not setting foot in the house and that’s that after she has said these things. But I’ve read on here so many posts saying you can’t exclude one child. I feel guilty but want to protect my DD too.

This girl tends to play with other boys and girls in other year group class so not a case of her not having friends. I obviously feel for her because she’s 8 and sounds very unhappy.

In these circumstances would it be ok not to invite? Other girls in the class who have been friends with DD since age 4 are terrified of this girl too. Invitations would be directly given to parents and not handed out in school to avoid other kids noticing .

Kids are 8 , DD will be turning 9.

YANBU - don’t invite
YABU - can’t exclude

OP posts:
Memyselfandfood · 07/07/2022 19:07

I wouldn’t invite, nor would i feel bad about only not inviting her.
i would not feel bad about not inviting a child who has told your dd they were fat and ‘to kill themselves’
nope, not a chance

carefullycourageous · 07/07/2022 19:05

YANBU to invite whichever children you like but your DD hopefully will be encouraged to understand not all boys are badly behaved, be careful you are not raising an old-fashioned sexist!

devildeepbluesea · 07/07/2022 19:03

I’m afraid I think excluding one girl isn’t in, regardless of your DD’s feelings. The kid is new, god knows what’s going on in her background and further isolation really isn’t going to help her behaviour is it.

If you really want to exclude her then I’d consider a smaller party altogether, maybe just 5 or 6 close friends.

user1471457751 · 07/07/2022 19:02

If the OP goes with a smaller party then she is just punishing other children for the behaviour of this girl. Why should others miss out? It also doesn't benefit the girl herself, she needs to realise that actions have consequences and people won't want to be friends with a violent person.

SherbertLemonDrop · 07/07/2022 19:01

Of course you can exclude. I wouldn't invite my bully to my party.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 07/07/2022 19:01

She told your child to kill herself, of course she shouldn’t be invited.

user1471457751 · 07/07/2022 19:00

@MajorCarolDanvers would you invite someone to your own party if they were aggressive towards you and told you to kill yourself? There's nothing awful about having boundaries.

lljkk · 07/07/2022 18:59

Is OP only inviting girls & no lads?

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 07/07/2022 18:56

Well the way shes talking there must be deeper issues. Telling fellow kids at 8 years old to 'go and kill themselves' is highly disturbing. She's hearing that somewhere. Therefore I'd be speaking to teacher as the child obviously needs help. Some may say it's not your/my/their business or problem but potential/ child abuse is everyone's business.

I do think it's a tad mean to leave one girl out. This child may be a bully but exclusion also comes under bullying, op. That said though I can fully understand why you and your DD don't want her there.

LetMeInYourWindow · 07/07/2022 18:55

Bullying by exclusion is still bullying.

I’d have to have a smaller party, regardless of her behaviour, I couldn’t actively invite every girl except one.

namechange496829 · 07/07/2022 18:48

I was going to come on and say you can't exclude one child.However given the circumstances and I would not be inviting her either.

MichelleScarn · 07/07/2022 18:48

Clymene · 07/07/2022 18:45

You haven't said how many girls there are in the class but there's no reason you have to invite them all except one. You could have a smaller party. But you've justified it to yourself I see so not sure why you're asking.

I'm not sure what you expect the long term outcome of this to be but I'd expect this girl to up her harassment of your DD. If that feels like the right price to pay, then go ahead.

So the dd should plan her party around not wanting to upset the bully, and accept that the bully is going to make her life worse if she doesn't get invited?

Mally100 · 07/07/2022 18:45

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/07/2022 18:11

I think excluding one 8 year old girl is pretty awful.

She's obviously got some problems but they are unlikely to improve by being singled out for exclusion from the parties.

You could ask the parent to stay to help supervise - after all she is only 8 years old.

More awful than telling another child to kill themselves? Give over.

Clymene · 07/07/2022 18:45

You haven't said how many girls there are in the class but there's no reason you have to invite them all except one. You could have a smaller party. But you've justified it to yourself I see so not sure why you're asking.

I'm not sure what you expect the long term outcome of this to be but I'd expect this girl to up her harassment of your DD. If that feels like the right price to pay, then go ahead.

Mally100 · 07/07/2022 18:45

ColettesEarrings · 07/07/2022 17:47

I wouldn't give a flying shit about it, I'm with your dh, she wouldn't step foot in my house.

This. Anything other than this and I would question your parenting. Would you seriously care more about someone who told your child to kill themselves??

Lennybenny · 07/07/2022 18:39

YANBU
Expect the girl to find out and either harass your dd(before and definitely after) or try very hard to get an invite. The girl would probably ruin the party in one way or another. Its not worth spoiling it for your dd and her actual friends.

Aprilx · 07/07/2022 18:38

I think your voting options are not really want you mean as you have already decided that she is not coming. So is it really a case of working out whether you exclude only this girl or exclude her and a few others so it isn’t so obvious.

ExplodingCarrots · 07/07/2022 18:38

Thank you . I do feel a bit better about it now . DD always comes first. I do feel for the girl. I don't know if there's SEN and I have no idea what her home life is like and it's not my business. Mum seems to be called in a lot. The girls older sibling is worse and has been violent to the younger children .

To the poster above that said to invite the mum along . I don't know if I'd feel comfortable with that . And yes ..there's the catch 22 of bullying , not being invited to things and then the behaviour escalating more. But I don't want to risk DD and the other girls being subjected to abuse at the party .

OP posts:
ChimChimeny · 07/07/2022 18:34

after all she is only 8 years old.

Yes she's plenty old enough to understand you don't tell people to kill themselves

EllieRosesMammy · 07/07/2022 18:25

You're not being unreasonable to exclude her, I'd do the same. Like hell would i let a bully into my home or daughters party. And if she goes crying to her parents about how she's not invited I'd be happy to have a word with them too about how nasty their child is. It might be the lesson she needs to learn to stop being so nasty to everyone.

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/07/2022 18:11

I think excluding one 8 year old girl is pretty awful.

She's obviously got some problems but they are unlikely to improve by being singled out for exclusion from the parties.

You could ask the parent to stay to help supervise - after all she is only 8 years old.

SparkyBlue · 07/07/2022 18:11

Yanbu to exclude her. And I say this as the parent of a child with additional needs who often gets left out.

MarshaBradyo · 07/07/2022 18:10

It’s a tough one but I think you need to listen to your dd

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 07/07/2022 18:06

You can't ask the teacher. They won't say anything.

And your seeming solution just means that nobody does anything and more children, girls, get taught to 'be nice'

Exclude her and tell school why.

If there is anything to know safeguarding will sort it out.

SheepingStandingUp · 07/07/2022 18:06

Cavviesarethebest · 07/07/2022 17:54

I think this is hard - imagine what abuse they poor girl is likely to be subject to to sct
like
that.

csn you talk to the teacher and maybe get more understanding of the situation?

You want school to disclose personal family details to any random parent who wants to arrange a party?? Just wanted to check if Britney is being abused in the home before I decide whether to invite her or not. Oh yeah sure random Mom, no problem!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread