Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to exclude one girl?

186 replies

ExplodingCarrots · 07/07/2022 17:43

It’s a party one.

DD party coming up. Having a party in the house so can’t invite whole class. We’ve never done whole class parties , only a couple of friends so never excluding a small number.

We had an issue the last time we had a party at the house where the boys who were invited were badly behaved so DD has said she wants to invite girls only.

The issue we have is that there is one girl in the class who is very mean to other kids and disruptive. She joined the school a year and a half ago and I know numerous parents have been in to school to complain because their child has been bullied , hit and called names. My DD started playing with the girl but it ended up in numerous dramas and my DD ending up being upset so she’s been told by the teacher and myself to stay away from each other. The other day my DD and her best friend were sat in the playground and the girl approached them and called them fat and told them to kill themselves. Obviously this upset them.

Because of this , DD doesn’t want to invite this girl. I completely agree as to why she don’t want her there BUT there’s this moral dilemma of obviously excluding 1 girl. DH is of the stance of this girl is not setting foot in the house and that’s that after she has said these things. But I’ve read on here so many posts saying you can’t exclude one child. I feel guilty but want to protect my DD too.

This girl tends to play with other boys and girls in other year group class so not a case of her not having friends. I obviously feel for her because she’s 8 and sounds very unhappy.

In these circumstances would it be ok not to invite? Other girls in the class who have been friends with DD since age 4 are terrified of this girl too. Invitations would be directly given to parents and not handed out in school to avoid other kids noticing .

Kids are 8 , DD will be turning 9.

YANBU - don’t invite
YABU - can’t exclude

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 08/07/2022 01:33

I had this same issue with my kids. Ended up inviting a smaller group (which was easier on me, so a bit of a bonus). I totally agree with (almost) everyone else about not inviting the bully. I think that’s an awful message to give your kids (which is what I told their teacher when he suggested we be “inclusive”). But I also think you make it harder for any of the help the bully is getting to be effective if they are singled out as the only one not accepted. And I expected my kids to be with this kid for another 4 years. So trying to balance the short and long term impact of decisions, I compromised on a smaller party.

This year is the last year they’ll all be in the same class, bully hasn’t really improved, school try a bit but parents don’t seem bothered so this year, if my kids want to exclude just the bully, I’m okay with that. They may not want one though. Despite complaining about having a smaller one the first year they seemed to enjoy it a lot and didn’t moan the next year when I said again that we couldn’t do the whole class minus one.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 08/07/2022 00:37

Hmmmm. I do think it is a tough call because I disagree with excluding one child and think her bad behaviour may escalate because of that. On the other hand, the girl is nasty and bullying.

I think I would (as you have already said) give invitations direct to the parents with a request to tell them not to talk about ir at school as not everyone is invited. I wouldn’t tell them that just one girl isn’t invited.

I may approach the girl’s parent and say something along the lines of ‘I feel bad about not inviting her but DD is still very upset about being called fat and being told that someone hopes she dies. I hope will change and that they can play together in the future’.

That may (or may not) help the parents with managing the girl’s overall behaviour if they can see the social consequences it is have for her.

Mariposista · 08/07/2022 00:06

Your child has decided she doesn’t want to invite boys because of their bad behaviour, and is worried that they will spoil her party (and that’s absolutely fine). So she also doesn’t want to invite this brat girl neither because she is a nasty bully who will almost definitely ruin the party. Don’t think twice. She has no God given right to an invite just for being female. I’m sure not all the girls in the class are your daughter’s best best friends but as they are generally nice kids they will rub along fine together. This gil is a fly in the ointment. Your husband is quite right - I wouldn’t have her in my house upsetting my child on their birthday neither.

MorningMountainDew · 08/07/2022 00:04

At the end of the day you’re not responsible for how the bully or their parents will feel with not being invited. What you are responsible for is your own child and their feelings. Exclude the bully and don’t think twice about it. Your children and their happiness come first.

Spookysparkles · 07/07/2022 23:53

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 07/07/2022 19:34

Obviously the bully isn’t invited. If your daughter wants to invite all the others, she should. By not inviting some of the others, the bully is having some control over your daughters life. Fuck that.

what She said , 100%

Thepossibility · 07/07/2022 23:37

Like hell would I invite my DD's bully into her safe space to keep other people happy. If she is upset she's not invited it's a good lesson for her that her awful behaviour is resulting in kids not wanting to invite her to things. Her getting an invite regardless of her behaviour is giving her the message that her behaviour is ok, there is no incentive to stop. And she is given even closer access to her victims by their wet parents! She's not the only one being excluded, lots of others are also. DD is having her FRIENDS at her party, as it should be.

maddening · 07/07/2022 23:22

Don't invite but the invites should not be handed out at school or by the teacher imo.

Jellybean23 · 07/07/2022 23:21

I wouldn't dream of inviting the girl.

MyrrAgain · 07/07/2022 23:13

No. You're under NO obligation to invite her. Imagine a bully coming into your house and intruding upon your daughter's safe space - her bedroom - her house. That's your child's safe space. Don't let her in. And it could exacerbate things if this girl starts mocking her for the party, or things in the house etc. No. No way.

Sorry but it's not your problem

pastypirate · 07/07/2022 23:07

I very much believe at the very least that children should be able to rely on their parents to put them first, no matter what.

lastminutedotcom22 · 07/07/2022 22:59

ColettesEarrings · 07/07/2022 17:47

I wouldn't give a flying shit about it, I'm with your dh, she wouldn't step foot in my house.

I agree
Don't invite her
It's more trouble than it's worth and it might put other friends off coming

If I was me I just wouldn't invite her

SarahSissions · 07/07/2022 22:56

Don’t look at it as excluding one girl. She is in a class of 30 and is inviting 1( of her classmates. Just don’t hand out the invitations in class and you’ll be fine

Memyselfandfood · 07/07/2022 22:53

Ignore the people saying you're in the wrong.
the moment the girl told your dd to kill herself it was game over. Your dd deserves the party she wants, this girl can learn actions have consequences.
Your dd learns that abusers do not get to ruin her big events.
if she feels left out it’s not on you.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 07/07/2022 21:03

Yanbu at all.

in my opinion you should never exclude one child if they are naughty at school (but not towards your child) because they have special needs, because they are quiet but this child told your daughter to kill herself.

also please don’t listen to the people telling you to exclude perfectly nice girls so this vile child isn’t the only one - why should those have to miss out?

and the people saying she shouldn’t be left out as she will probably behave worse if you do? What a dreadful attitude to have letting nasty bullies win just because they will behave worse if they don’t. I can imagine how utterly vile your kids are if this is the way you behave towards them.

Notjustanymum · 07/07/2022 20:41

So you said “The other day my DD and her best friend were sat in the playground and the girl approached them and called them fat and told them to kill themselves.”, and you feel YOU have a moral dilemma?
I think your moral ( and natural) instinct should be to protect your DD from her abuser. YANBU!

champagnetruffleshuffle · 07/07/2022 20:23

YANB at all U. This is not a child who is a bit mean that you could try and accommodate. This child told your daughter to kill herself! WTH. Sorry, but that's way over the mark to me. It isn't a random gathering, it is your daughter's birthday. Those saying you should try and invite are wrong.

pastypirate · 07/07/2022 20:22

Yikes. Your kid gets one birthday party a year!!! Of course you don't have to invite her!

My dds have big parties. The rule is if the kid does my head in I'll still invite them. If the kid does the dds head in I won't. One of dd1's friends did my head in for years. She's lovely now.

RanOutOfSky · 07/07/2022 20:20

You’re putting way too much thought into it. Just invite the children that your daughter wants, nothing else matters.

Georgeskitchen · 07/07/2022 20:19

Yanbu I wouldn't have this child in my house ruining my DCs party

Purplebunnie · 07/07/2022 20:19

Similar situation and no we didn't invite the girl because if we had other children would not have come.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 07/07/2022 20:15

Clymene · 07/07/2022 19:32

And please can anyone give any examples of children being excluded and learning the error of their ways.

Because that isn't how children work.

Have we found the girls mother? Or just another parent with a bullying child?

Maybe it should be the actual parent of the child that teaches them to behave, not other parents? It's got nothing to do with op, what would you suggest she does if she invites the girl and she behaves badly? Or hurts another child?

If your child does bully, do you just expect everyone to accept them for how they are and ignore it? Hope it goes away by not acknowledging it and letting them get away with it, even given rewards of parties for it? What is your actual solution, because that's what it sounds like you'd do?

ExplodingCarrots · 07/07/2022 20:14

cadburyegg · 07/07/2022 20:06

I don't think you should exclude just one child. Have a smaller party, 8 or so. My ds7 wouldn't have a problem in making a list of 8 of his closest friends. I also think that 14 8 year olds is a lot of kids for a party at your house!! I wouldn't have that many , personally

I think if you just excluded her then her behaviour is likely to worsen and that will make your DD's life harder at school.

I hope you've let the teacher know about the comments your DD has had aimed at her

Luckily we have a big garden and the 'activity' we've booked is based in the garden .
DD would struggle to pick out of the group of girls . It's so tricky 😢

Teacher was made aware of what was said yes.

OP posts:
ddl1 · 07/07/2022 20:09

I wouldn't invite her, but I also wouldn't let her be the ONLY girl not invited; that is also a form of bullying. I would either scale down the party, or invite some people (relatives? neighbours? children whom your dd knows from an extracurricular activity?) and, either way, not invite all the girls in your dd's class.

minuette1 · 07/07/2022 20:06

Cavviesarethebest · 07/07/2022 17:54

I think this is hard - imagine what abuse they poor girl is likely to be subject to to sct
like
that.

csn you talk to the teacher and maybe get more understanding of the situation?

I'm sorry but if a kid was bullying mine I wouldn't be trying to play therapist to them I'd just want them nowhere near my child. And do you really think a teacher is going to disclose personal information about one of their pupils to a random woman? It would be more than their job was worth.

OP I'm with your husband on this one, actions have consequences. There's a boy in my son's class who was bullying others a couple of years ago. He found out he wasn't invited to a party for this reason and has done a complete 180 and is now on friendly terms with his classmates and is no longer violent towards them..

chilledbubble · 07/07/2022 20:06

Clymene · 07/07/2022 19:31

So you're inviting 13/14 girls.

Now that is bullying. From an adult.

Slow handclap

No its not. They've been told to stay away from each other so presumably DD won't be invited to her party. I think it's sensible in order to keep everyone safe.

Swipe left for the next trending thread