Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to exclude one girl?

186 replies

ExplodingCarrots · 07/07/2022 17:43

It’s a party one.

DD party coming up. Having a party in the house so can’t invite whole class. We’ve never done whole class parties , only a couple of friends so never excluding a small number.

We had an issue the last time we had a party at the house where the boys who were invited were badly behaved so DD has said she wants to invite girls only.

The issue we have is that there is one girl in the class who is very mean to other kids and disruptive. She joined the school a year and a half ago and I know numerous parents have been in to school to complain because their child has been bullied , hit and called names. My DD started playing with the girl but it ended up in numerous dramas and my DD ending up being upset so she’s been told by the teacher and myself to stay away from each other. The other day my DD and her best friend were sat in the playground and the girl approached them and called them fat and told them to kill themselves. Obviously this upset them.

Because of this , DD doesn’t want to invite this girl. I completely agree as to why she don’t want her there BUT there’s this moral dilemma of obviously excluding 1 girl. DH is of the stance of this girl is not setting foot in the house and that’s that after she has said these things. But I’ve read on here so many posts saying you can’t exclude one child. I feel guilty but want to protect my DD too.

This girl tends to play with other boys and girls in other year group class so not a case of her not having friends. I obviously feel for her because she’s 8 and sounds very unhappy.

In these circumstances would it be ok not to invite? Other girls in the class who have been friends with DD since age 4 are terrified of this girl too. Invitations would be directly given to parents and not handed out in school to avoid other kids noticing .

Kids are 8 , DD will be turning 9.

YANBU - don’t invite
YABU - can’t exclude

OP posts:
MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 21:44

Feelfreetocallme · 08/07/2022 21:25

I think I found a good solution! Invite some of the boys (only the well behaved ones obviously) then it’s less obvious when you don’t invite this one girl. Then you’ve invited some of the class instead of all the girls minus one.. I think that sounds better and I would personally feel less guilty doing it that way.

This - as a mum of boys (and a girl)

Penguinwaddles · 08/07/2022 21:38

No it's not right to exclude one girl. And it is setting a poor example imho. BUT I would pay a teenager to monitor her individually throughout the entire party so she didn't t get a chance to misbehave or upset your DD or any other guest. That way, she learns how to behave for next time. Excluding does nothing except make the person feel more angry and alone and therefore more likely to misbehave.

Bethany7 · 08/07/2022 21:30

You are definitely NBU.
I say that as a mother and a teacher.
I also tell my children often that kindness is the most important thing and that if you are unkind people will not want to spend their time with you. This child needs to see that to learn that.

Feelfreetocallme · 08/07/2022 21:29

strawberrylacey · 07/07/2022 19:42

It'd be so satisfying if you booked a community hall and invited the whole class except her

No it really wouldn’t be.

Feelfreetocallme · 08/07/2022 21:25

ExplodingCarrots · 07/07/2022 19:15

Seriously ?? 😂 Obviously she knows not all boys are badly behaved . Not all the boys were badly behaved last time but the ones that were trashed my house , squirted jelly up my walls and were diving over my furniture . DD was mortified The girls always behave and are polite. As are some of the boys .. So she has decided to just have girls this time ..nothing to do with being sexist 🙄.

I think I found a good solution! Invite some of the boys (only the well behaved ones obviously) then it’s less obvious when you don’t invite this one girl. Then you’ve invited some of the class instead of all the girls minus one.. I think that sounds better and I would personally feel less guilty doing it that way.

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 21:11

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2022 21:03

Absolutely @Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim I want my child to know when they are feeling unhappy and under threat, I bloody stood up for them and didn't acquiesce to the usual 'oh be kind and don't think about yourself'.

100% agree.

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2022 21:03

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 08/07/2022 20:52

OP isn't raising this girl and I would rather raise girls who hold their boundaries against abusers

Absolutely @Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim I want my child to know when they are feeling unhappy and under threat, I bloody stood up for them and didn't acquiesce to the usual 'oh be kind and don't think about yourself'.

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 21:00

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 08/07/2022 20:52

OP isn't raising this girl and I would rather raise girls who hold their boundaries against abusers

Totally agree. So I would say "DD you can invite 8 girls to your party. Who do you want to invite? You shouldn't invite anyone who upsets you."

I think this solves this issue with minimum upset to all kids.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 08/07/2022 20:52

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 20:48

She's 8. And as adults we have the responsibility of raising the next generation. Excluding the girl is not the issue. Excluding 1 girl is.

OP isn't raising this girl and I would rather raise girls who hold their boundaries against abusers

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 08/07/2022 20:51

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 20:28

There are no easy options here. But imo excluding one girl is worse than a few girls missing out. It is normal for a group of girls to miss out on a party. It is not normal for one girl to be excluded.

It's not normal for an 8 year old to shout death threats either

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 20:48

She's 8. And as adults we have the responsibility of raising the next generation. Excluding the girl is not the issue. Excluding 1 girl is.

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 08/07/2022 20:45

Don't invite her... if you do, your daughter will think that you don't have her back. Then where will you be?

amykg · 08/07/2022 20:42

your daughter doesn’t like this girl because she bullies her, so why would you even consider inviting her into your home? if there was someone at your work who was nasty to you, you wouldn’t invite them round would you?

these people saying you shouldn’t ‘exclude’ her are totally deluded. if she ends up being upset by not being invited, maybe she’ll start to see there’s consequences to her behaviour.

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 20:28

Threetulips · 08/07/2022 20:24

Why should the others miss out?

There are no easy options here. But imo excluding one girl is worse than a few girls missing out. It is normal for a group of girls to miss out on a party. It is not normal for one girl to be excluded.

Threetulips · 08/07/2022 20:24

Why should the others miss out?

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 20:14

I would just omit some of the other tricky girls in the class so it doesn't appear like you are punishing one child.

Livingtothefull · 08/07/2022 19:10

Your DD's teacher advised her as well that your DD and this other girl should stay away from each other. That's your excuse if anyone complains - that in not inviting her you were following the advice from the school.

That's only if you feel you need an excuse. I think this is simple - your DD invites whoever she wants and has the party she wants. Anyone who is disappointed at being excluded just needs to deal with it.

MrsDooDaa · 08/07/2022 18:42

I wouldn't invite her but there is no way I would invite 13/14 girls and exclude just her. That's unkind.

Is it really the case that your DD is equally friends with the other 13 girls who are all lovely and there is one new bully girl? That would be really unusual in a class of girls.

HeckyPeck · 08/07/2022 18:31

Greensleeves · 08/07/2022 18:11

Why on earth should OP ignore the posters on one side of the discussion, when she expressly asked for opinions? Very odd advice Confused

I wouldn't do it, personally. I think excluding one 8yo out of a group of 14 is cruel and sets a poor example. If you feel you can't have this child in the house, and DD doesn't want her there, then I would invite fewer children so there isn't one obviously excluded child.

I disagree vehemently with the pp who said that there isn't always a reason for this sort of disturbed behaviour, and that some children are just "awful little shits". That's completely wrong, and it's a lazy, nasty attitude for an adult to have. I do agree though that the reasons for this child's behaviour aren't OP's or her DD's problem to solve. I hope parents are keeping the school abreast of all these incidents, and that someone is doing something to help this little girl.

I think it's a worse example to say that her friends that are nice to her should miss out and her daughter shouldn't get the party she wants incase it upsets the person who bullies her and tells her to kill herself.

You don't have to be nice to people who are nasty to you.

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2022 18:15

*Actually yes, I would make an effort with a person who was always alone and angry.

Not so much the cliques who get a little frisson from leaving one person out.*

Even if that person was calling you fat and telling you to kill yourself?

Greensleeves · 08/07/2022 18:11

spongbob · 07/07/2022 19:38

Ignore the people on here implying YABU. There's always people will have a problem. Don't invite her, and you don't have to feel bad - you have good reason not too. Your DD and her friends shouldn't have to miss out for one bullying child.

Why on earth should OP ignore the posters on one side of the discussion, when she expressly asked for opinions? Very odd advice Confused

I wouldn't do it, personally. I think excluding one 8yo out of a group of 14 is cruel and sets a poor example. If you feel you can't have this child in the house, and DD doesn't want her there, then I would invite fewer children so there isn't one obviously excluded child.

I disagree vehemently with the pp who said that there isn't always a reason for this sort of disturbed behaviour, and that some children are just "awful little shits". That's completely wrong, and it's a lazy, nasty attitude for an adult to have. I do agree though that the reasons for this child's behaviour aren't OP's or her DD's problem to solve. I hope parents are keeping the school abreast of all these incidents, and that someone is doing something to help this little girl.

MyrrAgain · 08/07/2022 18:10

@Thereisnolight let me know how it goes inviting abusers over to your house then.
Also 1. This girl is not alone. She has a gang that she manipulates through fear and 2. OP and DD are not getting any joy out of excluding her. She's specifically asking about it AND it's not being done for pleasure. It's being done for safety

forrestgreen · 08/07/2022 18:10

I wouldn't invite her, but I'd tell dd not to tell her friends that x is excluded.
It'd be mean to let the child feel like that on purpose.

It is a hard call but I wouldn't let someone in who'd behaved like that

Thereisnolight · 08/07/2022 18:03

If she does have a gang of friends then that’s different and absolutely not your duty to invite her.

Thereisnolight · 08/07/2022 18:00

MyrrAgain · 08/07/2022 14:24

Haha are you joking?! Seriously.
No this is bollocks. Bullying is malicious intent. It's purposefully hurtful and abusing others. OP is not "excluding" the nasty bully with any intention of hurting them. OP is protecting their child and ensuring she's having a lovely birthday. Totally different from being told to go away and die. Just for an example.

Why don't you invite the office bitch over for a drink in your living room? Or find an abusive partner to scream you're fat and why don't you die in your face for a few minutes. No?? Well how bullying and excluding of you!!!

Actually yes, I would make an effort with a person who was always alone and angry.

Not so much the cliques who get a little frisson from leaving one person out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread