Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you take both or you don't get DD

588 replies

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 14:43

I have two children, DS is nearly eight, autistic and has additional needs. DD is four and neurotypical.

Neither side of the family has ever offered us practical support or help with DS, never offered to babysit or take him out. The only help I received with him was a few hours while I had planned c section for DD and then my husband had to go home by teatime to put him to bed.

DD is growing and developing at the same rate as her peers, she's a very funny and outgoing little girl who makes us all laugh. We put a lot of effort into giving her our attention and support so that she doesn't feel resentful of time that we have to give to her brother, who she loves.

She is getting to the age now where both sets of grandparents are talking about having her go to their houses to stay, or taking her on holiday. But when they talk about this they only ever mention her. Never my son.

My heart says you don't get to pick and choose which of my kids you give this attention to. But I don't want to deny DD happy memories. AIBU?

OP posts:
ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:28

GrinAndVomit · 07/07/2022 21:06

It’s interesting the the majority of parents with ND children are saying it’s both children or nothing. Cut contact etc.

Yet most of the people who have ND siblings are saying how it would have been very helpful for them to have this time away from their sibling.

So OP, it seems to be your choice is to appease your own feelings or appease your daughter’s (even if she feels too guilty to voice those feelings)

Having time away from your siblings doesn't have to mean you go off with GPs or aunts/uncles or whoever. The ND child could actually go and have some time with relatives and the other child have some time away from whilst staying with their parents. It doesn't have to be the ND being left behind all the time.

SemperIdem · 07/07/2022 21:23

I know that in your shoes, I would feel equally aggrieved. However, I can understand the perspective of the grandparents just as easily .

Can you have an open conversation with them about how they spent time with your son? Taking him away for a few days may feel too challenging for them but they could spend one on one time with him in shorter, regular bursts?

Your children can’t be treated equally they have very different needs but they absolutely can be treated equitably in terms of quality time spent with each.

Crazycrazylady · 07/07/2022 21:15

I think your not wrong in that it would be lovely if your parents stepped up and got more involved with your son but the reality is that seems unlikely based on what you've said. ( what ever they're reasons)). The question is around is it fair to deny your dd this opportunity as a result. I'm not sure that it is )

Tigofigo · 07/07/2022 21:13

Well I'm going to say YANBU - it's one thing if they had expressed equal interest in them until now and said something like, "obviously we'd love to take him on holiday but we're assuming DS wouldn't like a break with us because he'd become distressed out of his routine".

But they clearly haven't.

GrinAndVomit · 07/07/2022 21:06

It’s interesting the the majority of parents with ND children are saying it’s both children or nothing. Cut contact etc.

Yet most of the people who have ND siblings are saying how it would have been very helpful for them to have this time away from their sibling.

So OP, it seems to be your choice is to appease your own feelings or appease your daughter’s (even if she feels too guilty to voice those feelings)

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 07/07/2022 21:03

OP,

I've seen from another poster that you've also got autism. How were your parents with you growing up? Did they treat you the same as your siblings (if you have them)?

Herejustforthisone · 07/07/2022 20:54

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 17:24

Thanks for providing your vies @Herejustforthisone - this is the way we want to raise our children too

No worries. I think one poster read my post wrong. As I said, my sister has ‘extensive difficulties’, including LD. She’s not just ‘in a wheelchair’, as they said.

What I was trying to illustrate is that while she’s clearly, obviously, apparently very disabled, because we’d all been raised the same, treated the same, no exceptions made for anyone, I didn’t define her by her disability(ies). And I never really put a label on it until I was a teen, when I had this moment of weird realisation. Which I quickly moved on from.

We never felt angered or hard done by because her needs were probably greater than ours. We didn’t see it. We all had chores and responsibilities at home, our grandparents took us all or none at all, and as such we all have a great relationship and I think a very healthy and inclusive mindset about any ‘differences’ a person might have.

Woolybear · 07/07/2022 20:54

PinguIglu · 07/07/2022 16:12

I read your your latest update OP.

I agree with you.

what message will it send to your DD as she grows up? That her brother isn’t acceptable?

I grew up with a sister with additional needs. Yes she was harder work but other family members could have learned how to support her, she wasn’t THAT hard. Instead, I grew up feeling like she was the dirty secret and I was the “perfect” one and I felt guilt about that. It didn’t have to be that way:

I’d be distancing myself from the whole lot of them if I were you though OP. How dare they act like your DS is lesser and only show an interest in being grandparents when they have a cute NT little grandparent. They have done nothing to support you or to build a relationship with your DS and I don’t think they deserve relationships with any of you.

Horrified by all the posters justifying this behaviour 😞

Well said @PinguIglu

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 07/07/2022 20:52

@MolliciousIntent Yes, for example, my NT sister resented me so much - and I'm very, very high functioning - that she joined in with my school bullies tormenting me for it. I don't speak to her now if I can avoid it so it's not like the resentment can only work one way, nor is it always poor saintly put-upon normal siblings.
Again, I'm not being naive, I know OP's DD will have her own difficulties, but I hate the undertones of how her life will be so difficult etc etc because of her brother with no care for how the brother's disabilities affect his life. And from what OP's said about the grandparents' attitudes, that as soon as his disabilities became apparent their interest tailed right off, and that they're relieved that the DD is "normal" - it's not unreasonable to think that these attitudes are fundamentally ableist because they are. How more blatant do you have to get?!

Woolybear · 07/07/2022 20:49

XmasElf10 · 07/07/2022 14:58

Depending on the severity of additional needs I think you are being quite reasonable. My DD is NT. My niece has ASD, ADHD, APD and some pretty severe ticks. She can be a handful but she is never left out of family activities and spends time with me and her grandparents. I’d expect family to put the effort into learning how to cope with your sons needs so that he can be included successfully. Shame on them.

I agree with XmasElf10 and your family sound great.
@jamoncrumpets if your family can’t or won’t do the same for both children it is a shame. It’s very hurtful to exclude one child, sadly a child with ASD is going to be left out in lots of situations during their lifetime they don’t need grandparents adding to this.

Herejustforthisone · 07/07/2022 20:46

Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 17:18

@Herejustforthisone

a physical disability leaving your sister in a wheelchair is very different for an autistic child with additional needs, who’s mother is his full time carer and the situation is severe enough that a system of locks is required to all accessible cupboards etc in the kitchen

You did not just say that…

My sister isn’t just ‘in a wheelchair’…

MolliciousIntent · 07/07/2022 20:40

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 07/07/2022 20:32

I don't like the "what about the poor suffering NORMAL child" vibe of a lot of the responses.

I think it's very naïve to downplay the significant impact an ND sibling can have on a child's life. The siblings of children with additional needs most often find that their needs and wants are sidelined and overlooked on a near-constant basis, through no fault of their parents or their siblings.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 07/07/2022 20:35

@PinguIglu Exactly. It always - ALWAYS - comes out on Mumsnet threads about autism but it's best to know that that's what people secretly think of us no matter how nicely they try to dress it up.

AbbieWhelan · 07/07/2022 20:34

I agree with you OP. They shouldn’t just be making all the effort with one child, it’s lovely your DD gets to spend time with them and clearly has a great relationship with them. It’s also nice that they want to make the effort but…

why the need to just offer your DD to go? Even if your DS needs are more greater and he needs more care, could they not have suggested you all go? This way if DS doesn’t like being away from you or isn’t used to being away from you for long lengths of time, he can still go on holiday with his sister and you will all be there!?

I would just politely say to them “thank you for offering to take DD, I feel it would be nice for us to all go so the children can go on holiday together?” See what there responses are. I don’t agree with leaving one child out, this in my eyes isn’t fair. There is plenty of compromise here, everyone on here is saying “you can’t expect them to look after your DS aswell” etc etc but if you was to go along with them, your not expecting them to take care of DS OR DD but they still have the opportunity to have quality time with BOTH of them? This to me sounds fair.. this is how I would approach this tbh xx

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 07/07/2022 20:32

I don't like the "what about the poor suffering NORMAL child" vibe of a lot of the responses.

unname · 07/07/2022 20:28

I get the sense that if they spent time with and showed interest in DS in a way that worked for him and them, OP would not have any reluctance about them spending time alone with and maybe even taking DD on holiday.

It's their complete lack of interest and willingness to have a relationship with one of two children that is causing the issue. It's like they want to pretend he does not exist or is not related to them. That's not how a loving family handles having a child with additional needs.

My Aunt had down's syndrome and all of the complexities that can come with that. She still had full relationships with our entire family. We didn't ignore her or refuse to engage with her, or love her any less for it. Perhaps we enjoyed her more actually. Her existence didn't mean other children in the family were ignored or their experiences were limited. But they would not have wanted to spend time around people that only loved them and not their sister, too.

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/07/2022 20:24

@jamoncrumpets

“In May you posted about having locks on cupboards, how if anyone other than you did the school run DS will have a meltdown, how he jumps all over the bed having done a poo and not wiped. None of these things mean he is less worthy of love and affection, but it does mean it is going to be difficult for others to take him away. How do they treat your son when you are all together?”

if this is true Op surely you must be able to see why grandparents would not be offering to have him overnight?

Mellowyellow222 · 07/07/2022 20:23

Op your key question is should people who failed to connect with your son be able to have a relationship with your daughter, because they perceive her to be easier.

from your responses to this thread I suspect it might be difficult for people to talk to you about your sons needs: you come across incredibly defensive and aggressive.

I am not saying that to take the grandparents side - I am just saying if you get angry every time someone expresses a concern about they might care for your son I can see why tThis has gone unresolved for so long

ideally you would sit down with the grandparents and explain you think it is unfair that they are only willing to spend time alone with one of your children. You should be able to explore with them why that is and work with them to build their confidence and relationship with your son.

if they aren’t willing to try then I suspect you need to explain that it would be too painful for your son to watch them build a relationship with his sister when they make no effort with him.

bit this all takes emotional maturity in both sides, and you need to accept that caring for your son will be haunting for some.

SaySomethingMan · 07/07/2022 20:23

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 16:30

She loves her brother. Why do you think she needs a break from him?

Mine are a few years older. As they’ve grown, I’ve come to appreciate how important it is for my NT DC, who is also younger, to have their own activity away from their ND sibling.

They’re each other’s best cheerleaders and the love between them is clear for everyone to see but they are growing on their own terms.

Initially I was in agreement with you, in that you should not let them see your DD either but I now I’m unsure. It’s taken years for you to mow your DS inside out. Sure maybe they should’ve been interested.
Fostering a close relationship is for the good of both of your children. I would take in board the suggestion of helping them know how to look after your DS step by step.

FWIW, I’ve never received much help from my family in terms of overnight stays, etc. I just remind myself that they owe me nothing and get on with it. Expect nothing and you’ll never be disappointed kind of thing.

All the best.

unname · 07/07/2022 20:20

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 18:10

Initially he was the golden child. His needs were apparent by about 18 months and then we experienced a significant withdrawal in interest. Throughout the diagnosis process we had to field a lot of comments such as 'you've got a problem there haven't you?' and had a lot of pointed comments about him not being potty trained yet etc etc.

As his sister developed more in line with her peers we had comments such as 'well you've got nothing to worry about there' and 'well SHE'S alright', so yes I have a bad taste in my mouth about it all.

I would be very upset with these comments and would be prone to limiting my time with them.

It's not just a situation where they are unable to meet your DS's needs if he spent time with them, or even just simple discomfort. If that were the case I would be a bit more understanding. But they sound like bigots.

I was prepared to say that you were being unreasonable, but I really don't think I would want to be around people that think like this, never mind have my kids hang out alone with them.

Do you think they are in any way educable?

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 07/07/2022 20:20

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 18:52

He. Still. Deserves. Affection. And. Attention.

But again, one of the points of your OP is about your DD not being able to go on this holiday and you've avoided all posts about that.

She. Might. Still. Be. OK. To. Go. On. The. Holiday.

It's obvious now YABU but still an unenviable situation.

Pyewhacket · 07/07/2022 20:20

sweeneytoddsrazor · 07/07/2022 20:01

Do they spend time with your son with you OP. ? In May you posted about having locks on cupboards, how if anyone other than you did the school run DS will have a meltdown, how he jumps all over the bed having done a poo and not wiped. None of these things mean he is less worthy of love and affection, but it does mean it is going to be difficult for others to take him away. How do they treat your son when you are all together?

If that is the case, with an eight-year-old, then I think it's quite obvious why his GP are less than enthusiastic in taking him away on holiday.

If you are insistent on it being both or none then they'll probably politely decline your kind offer and keep their distance.

Read Mamanchen's comments. You'll find the reality of it there.

Hadtochangeitforthis · 07/07/2022 20:19

StationaryMagpie · 07/07/2022 19:05

bottomfeeders?

Are you missing the fact that the OP (like me) is her sons carer as well as parent? By asking his GP's to take him on holiday, she's expecting them to take that role on, but doesn't seem to be willing to encourage them to learn HOW to be his carer.

Also, his GP's aren't obliged to have to take that role on, but spiting her DD because their GP's aren't upto/capable of/want to be a Carer isnt fair either.

Both kids are deserving of love, care and attention, but equality/fair doesn't mean the same, you have to differentiate for what each child needs and will serve them best.

Exactly!

Covidagainandagain · 07/07/2022 20:17

MiniPiccolo · 07/07/2022 19:50

OP, you're also failing to divulge on this thread that you're also Autistic. Which means that no matter what a lot of people say, you still will likely hold your point of view, and you just wanted a vent and rant. So this is futile.

And when all the autistic people come along, who are able to change their point of view, tell you that you are wrong, I wonder whether you will hold to your point of view. I have this strange idea you will...

Have you considered whether you are autistic?

(the last line was sarcastic)

Doveyouknow · 07/07/2022 20:16

I can't imagine how hurt my ND ds would be if his grandparents started favouring his NT younger brother over him because he is 'harder work'. Yes, sometimes his grandparents take his younger brother out without him to do something he might like but they do the same with him. That way they BOTH get from each other because ND siblings don't have monopoly on being annoying! This thread says everything about people's attitudes to children with SN.