Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you take both or you don't get DD

588 replies

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 14:43

I have two children, DS is nearly eight, autistic and has additional needs. DD is four and neurotypical.

Neither side of the family has ever offered us practical support or help with DS, never offered to babysit or take him out. The only help I received with him was a few hours while I had planned c section for DD and then my husband had to go home by teatime to put him to bed.

DD is growing and developing at the same rate as her peers, she's a very funny and outgoing little girl who makes us all laugh. We put a lot of effort into giving her our attention and support so that she doesn't feel resentful of time that we have to give to her brother, who she loves.

She is getting to the age now where both sets of grandparents are talking about having her go to their houses to stay, or taking her on holiday. But when they talk about this they only ever mention her. Never my son.

My heart says you don't get to pick and choose which of my kids you give this attention to. But I don't want to deny DD happy memories. AIBU?

OP posts:
sashh · 08/07/2022 07:54

I think this is about being fair to both children. Do they both want to stay over with grand parents?
Being fair doesn't mean treating them the same. I resent some of the things I had to do because my older brother had done them. At 17 I had no interest in learning to drive, but I got driving lessons for my birthday because my brother had.

I think you need to talk to both sets of grandparents and ask them why they have never asked for your son to stay over or visit?

If they don't want him then could you arrange something special for him if/when your DD goes to stay?

That is assuming he doesn't want to go or isn't bothered. If he does, then it is a totally different situation.

I know what the GP are doing is hurtful to you, but it might not be to your children.

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/07/2022 07:33

Yanbu op. Please ignore the ableist replies and follow your gut.

Rosebel · 08/07/2022 07:26

All or nothing. I have two DDs and youngest is autistic (I think DS is too) but my parents have always had both to stay. MIL wanted just DD1 to stay round and the answer is always no. Both or neither.
DS is too young to sleep over without us so that's not an issue and tbh I think both sets of grandparents would struggle with a toddler.
My MIL gets annoyed that I say no but she shows favouritism to another grandchild which is bad enough. I'm certainly not going to let her cause resentment between my children.

Colourfulrainbows · 08/07/2022 07:21

@jamoncrumpets go with your gut. It's there for a reason.

Have you asked them why this is?
Sorry but if they can not cope with ds due to needs that is thier boundaries.
But then they don't get to treat dd different.

How would you feel if this was the case and ds didn't have needs?

Just my opinion coming from someone who has a 20 year old son with SEN.

My family treat him no different and don't exclude him. He is part of the family.

I get you I understand why you are feeling like you do. All this don't deny dd this views.
What to teach her more sigregation of her brother?

Hope I am wrong but that's what that is.

Another oh he has needs so let's not take him on holiday or day trips stuff.

He is a child with feelings also... Will notice will feel it just maybe not express it.

Take care xx

Pipsquiggle · 08/07/2022 07:09

It sounds like a shit situation.

Are you able to talk openly with the grandparents as you have on this thread? Tell them how you feel about treating DS & DD so differently?

It sounds like you hold a lot of resentment over their lack of involvement with your DS and inadvertently you may be taking it out on your daughter.

I am guessing they may be shit scared of being in charge of your DS, they might feel they don't have the skills to look after him, particularly if they are getting old. I know I would feel anxious about looking after an additional needs child

Sounds like they need educating but that you will need to bring them on this journey in baby steps.

Please don't deny them access to your DD

CelestiaNoctis · 08/07/2022 01:21

Of course they should watch both! My son has additional needs and my parents take both. Sometimes they take one so they can have individual attention but usually always both. No it's not fair and yes they could figure out a way to be with him, you do every single day. From the sounds of it he sounds lovely anyway and they're missing out. I would just be serious with them and tell them that they need to put effort into both or stop asking.

SharpLily · 08/07/2022 01:07

OP, I'm not sure what you really want from the thread. Of course the grandparents' behaviour isn't fair on your son, of course it shouldn't be this way, of course he is derserving. I don't see anyone saying any different. It's not fair, you are correct - but I'm not sure any of us can really help you with it.

Have you actually sat down and discussed this with the grandparents? Not ranted at them but explained how and why you feel it's unfair and ask if, with your support, they would be prepared to make an effort?

Quietwing · 08/07/2022 00:44

OP you've built up a lot of resentment and its not unfounded. These situations though call for equity not equality. Only you can decide if you want your children around their grandparents. If yes, then I think you need to foster common ground. What can they do to take time with your son and daughter in the ways that will benefit their relationship the most? Maybe that will look different for each child.

I have a severely disabled child and a neurotypical child. They get seperate time with family members, they both need that. It isnt the ideal to do so much separately but it is realistic and what works best. We do some things all together when the situation allows.

My disabled child is all that list of extreme behaviours and more. He is deserving of time, love and attention. He gets that and more from his extended family.

I'm sorry op that this hasn't been your experience. The moments my child has been excluded or thought less of have been rage inducing and heart breaking in equal measure. To have that come from family, well its even worse.

However you know the difficulties, what can they handle? What can your son handle?

My disabled son adores his grandfathers. My father is too ill to care for him on his own now but he always visits my son and brings his favourite drink. We don't buy this for him any other time. He knows it's a treat from his grandpa. Thats their relationship now and it works, there is still mutual love and care. My fil is able to be more hands on and he is, he can mind him for up to 2 hours but that's all.

My worry for your situation is that the battle lines are already drawn. They've made hurtful comments and that is hard to come back from. However if you are continuing the relationship then your DD needs to benefit from that too and you can work on their relationship with DS. I think you are rightfully angry with them. I would be appalled in your situation at the lack of care after 8 years and it would be hard to come back from.

I believe you can though, maybe they just need guidance and opportunity. If you give them a chance and they let him down then you don't need to worry about letting either of your children spend time with people who treat family in that manner. If they step up then everyone will benefit.

It lies with you OP as frustrating as it is. To answer your original question I don't think you can have one child without the other but I do think that inevitably the relationships will look different at least for now.

Kanaloa · 07/07/2022 23:40

knitnerd90 · 07/07/2022 22:58

It strikes me that all the "what about the NT sibling" responders haven't addressed the possibility that OP might be willing to let her DD do things with her grandparents alone as long as the overall burden were fairer. There's accusations of autistic people projecting, but I think these siblings are as well. The GPs never offer to do anything with her DS and that's the kicker for me. It's not "DS wouldn't enjoy a caravan holiday but we'll do a different activity with him". I would find it absolutely fair if my DC's grandparents did something like that.

To be fair I think the problem is that the op hasn’t been clear in her opening post. She implies that her son is high functioning and the main issue she brings up is that they haven’t had practical support like ‘babysitting or taking him out.’ It then transpires that the child has relatively complex and difficult needs and is adverse to change and prefers to be with his mum, to the point of climbing baby gates and jumping on the beds without having cleaned himself after the toilet/unable to sit and eat a meal. If op had been clearer in her opening post that they spend no time with her child and have made horrible comments (which she only revealed after many posters disagreed with her) then she would have got a different response. But her op was about babysitting and taking him out ie sole care of this child, which it’s reasonable that grandparents couldn’t provide.

Makesmilingyourbesthobby · 07/07/2022 23:26

I’m a mam to 3 DD’s NT,
within our family each of my girls has a closer relationship with separate family members, GP, aunt, uncle members personality’s match more and enjoyment of each other’s company more and enjoy the same things, often each do things solely with different family members but all are loved by all family members for who they are.
I love and bother with all my nieces and nephews but I have one nephew who no matter the time or effort I make we just don’t have a connection other than our love for one another and you feel the strain radiating from him when we are interacting the only thing I have found works for him when it comes to our relationship is nerf wars but the second that’s over it’s back the same.
my youngest DD has a different father than my older two, they visit their auntie for a few hours every week, my youngest DD asks can she go sometimes and she doesn’t get to go but I word it as me and her time and doing something fun which she soon feels fine about now going.
My youngest DD goes over her friends houses loads whilst my middle DD’s friends parents hardly ever invite her to theirs despite me inviting her friends over every week she often asks can she go or can she go to her friends house I again use the me and her time.
If I have planned something to do or go and one of my DD’s are bard, my other two often are told we are not doing it now or can’t go because their sister is not well.
My DD’s all have different activities and needs and I have to work out ways to fit it all in but no matter how I try I often have to prioritise which activity or need comes first at that time.
I have 3 siblings one who is amazing with my DD’s, but one who loves spending time with her over all outer family members, one who doesn’t have children of his own and struggles to care for children but gets on very well my eldest DD my other sibling obviously has her favourite of my DD, this is the only thing I dislike that I have mentioned I don’t like it but hey she’s a crap aunt to them all and they learnt it themselves.
Isn’t not always being invited part of life. Isn't not always being able to go because of other things with other family members or situations. Isn’t having one to one with each family member and time together as a whole big family the healthiest, isn’t it that we all have different connections with different family members, I could go on, but I don’t think your issue here has anything to do with weather they take your DD away by herself and not her brother.
I think your issue here is solely about GP and DS relationship either about lack of effort made with your son from grandparents or the fact they make it obvious they have favourites maybe both, because if they were no favourites and they made the effort with their relationship with DS as GP I don’t think them offering to take DD away would upset you like this.
if this is the case as GP their relationship with DS needs discussing.

knitnerd90 · 07/07/2022 22:58

It strikes me that all the "what about the NT sibling" responders haven't addressed the possibility that OP might be willing to let her DD do things with her grandparents alone as long as the overall burden were fairer. There's accusations of autistic people projecting, but I think these siblings are as well. The GPs never offer to do anything with her DS and that's the kicker for me. It's not "DS wouldn't enjoy a caravan holiday but we'll do a different activity with him". I would find it absolutely fair if my DC's grandparents did something like that.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 07/07/2022 22:29

It is the place of reasonable adults to make all children feel loved equally.

If the behaviour of other adults is not in line with yours and your partner's beliefs, especially regarding equality and fairness, then neither child should spend time around these other adults.

Their role as adults are to be role models and if they can only role model favouritism then that is not behaviour that I suspect you want either of your children to pick up on.

Autism or not.

So yes, if they can't take both, or care about both, or show an interest in both, then they get neither.

TournamentIgloo · 07/07/2022 22:25

Also he's bloody 8 years old. How fucking DARE they make no effort in 8 years to foster a relationship or get to know him. They don't deserve to have fun with your daughter just because she's easy and funny and 'appealing' to their limited sense of socially acceptable, when they have made 0 effort in 8 years to find what your DS enjoys and have fun times with him too.

I bet there is plenty they could have forged a connection with him about. Lazy, ablest and now opportunistic with your 'normal' child. It's disgusting.

babyboybabygirl · 07/07/2022 22:22

If both of your children were neuro typical would they be treated in the same way? Because if this is the case it’s appalling. Having additional needs doesn’t mean that they should be left out. I feel for your son as he will realise he’s been treated differently to your daughter.
i don’t think there’s anything with inviting one child to do something, as long as the other child gets the same opportunity at some point too. I would have a chat with your parents. Not sure why you’re getting such a hard time, OP. It’s not unrealistic to expect family to treat your kids the same.

TournamentIgloo · 07/07/2022 22:21

YANBU

I am absolutely positive that the casual and accepted ableism without our society is why you are getting the responses you are.

EVEN IF your sons needs were complex, you would not be unreasonable.

You are NOT trying to force your family to care for your Son (and from what I have gathered you would be correctly hesitant of this anyway given their non-interest in him). You are NOT trying to wrangle childcare for either child.
You are expressing very understandable and logical concern about Grandparents obviously and unashamedly favouring one child greatly over the other.

Both kids will notice, eventually. Which leave me completely agreeing that until they are both fully armed with the information and confidence needed to protect themselves emotionally, you get to do that for them by restricting access to toxic people.

And that's what it is, to completely ignore one child due to additional needs but favour the other. Toxic.

It sounds as if your kids have a good relationship, and it sounds as though your DD would be able to hear and understand an explanation of why she doesn't go on these holidays/stays once she's a bit older? I'm sure you're arming them both with age appropriate info about discrimination and both of them will witness a LOT of it given your families circumstances.

You have said your DD is not missing out on developmentally appropriate activities because of an incredibly high level of 121 care for your son. But can I say as someone who grew up with a sibling with needs so far eclipsing anything approaching normal, (DSis's disability was so extensive that any caregiver needed training really) - that despite the challenges this presented and the fact that yes, adjustments had to be made for us other kids at times so we could do things while Dsis did an alternative or was home or at school...
Not a single family member (who remained in our lives and wasn't themselves just a toxic sort) would have EVER opted out of my DSis life just because she was difficult to care for.

And if they had, we would have dropped them faster than a burning poker, without looking back or regretting it. DSis was a person, and despite being non-ambulatory, non-verbal, tube fed and with regular seizures, she was a real human child and our family pretending she didn't exist would have hurt ALL of us.

You sound like a good parent. Do not doubt yourself because of the responses you have had here.

Leanne12321 · 07/07/2022 22:12

My son has autism i have 5 kids my mum took them all.She sadly passed 2 years ago but before that she made a massive effort in understanding my ds needs she built a strong bond with him.She would simply just ask him if he wanted to go if he said no that would be fine but she loved it when he said yes!She was like a second mother to all my children.Also she would always sit down with my kids before taking them somewhere and explain un detail what they were doing and at what time so my ds felt more at ease 😌

Silverswirl · 07/07/2022 22:07

I think it’s awful that they want to spend time with one and not the other.
even having your son for an hour with something he could do every now and then would have been something and would have meant they got to know each other better. Even an hour in his own home whist you popped out.
Taking your DD away on night and holidays but not him is totally cruel and I would have thought made him feel crap and unworthy longer term.
for me it would be spend time with both (in ways they can manage) or neither.

SomePosters · 07/07/2022 22:01

I’m sorry op, I know it’s heart breaking to see your son left out and feel like he is being rejected.

Im a disability parent and the one who everyone leaves their kids with but no one offers to have my kid because ultimately people are shite!

I don’t have other children but if I did I would let them go.
Siblings shouldn’t miss out on any more than they have to accommodating their siblings needs and cutting off her nose to spite someone’s else’s face isn’t actually going to improve anything for your son, only take away from your daughters experience.

So I would feel just as cross and resentful and protective as you do of your son, but I would send her on the holiday and day trips anyway because that’s what’s best for her

Mamajunebugjones · 07/07/2022 21:56

Please can I ask what you wanted from this thread OP?

Was it to simply to verify your thoughts that family who don’t spend time with your DS don’t get to spend time with DD?

Or was it to try and see other people’s points of view and potential solutions? You do seem upset about people trying to do this, although the stance of some members of your family is understandably causing you resentment for the sake of your DS.

What would you like to see happen in the long term? I imagine that ideally you would like your family to be involved in the lives of both of your children in a way that supports them in a positive way. Like it or not, if this is any chance this may happen you might have to try and enable it. If it doesn’t work- it would be a dreadful shame, but at least you tried.

Sally872 · 07/07/2022 21:46

Not offering to take ds out alone doesn't mean they don't love him.

Do they engage with him? take an interest when you talk about him? Buy equal Christmas presents? If so then they do give him attention and love they just dont feel able to take him alone.

Purplelion · 07/07/2022 21:46

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 18:01

How old is that thread? Because DS uses the toilet now and has done for over a year. And why does my autism have anything to do with this?

It was in May this year to be fair OP so 5/6 weeks ago that’s how you were describing your sons needs

Happyher · 07/07/2022 21:43

I had the same as you. DS with autism and younger DD. She’s not bitter but I think my DD always thought her DB got more attention because of his needs. They’re both adults now and DS has overcome a lot of his issues, but don’t deny your DD nice things for the sake of your DS. Don’t forget grandparents don’t have the same understanding of autism that you do and the may think they couldn’t cope with DS

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:40

GrinAndVomit · 07/07/2022 21:34

But that isn’t an option. The option is the daughter gets to spend time away with her grandparents alone or she doesn’t.
Whose best interest is it that she doesn’t?

Spending time with GPs who aren't interested in a vulnerable little boy who happens to be their GC? Doesn't seem a great option, I think she's better off with OP who seems a very caring and involved mother.

Maybe someone needs to have a word with the GPs about their attitude and the upset it is causing.

GrinAndVomit · 07/07/2022 21:34

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:28

Having time away from your siblings doesn't have to mean you go off with GPs or aunts/uncles or whoever. The ND child could actually go and have some time with relatives and the other child have some time away from whilst staying with their parents. It doesn't have to be the ND being left behind all the time.

But that isn’t an option. The option is the daughter gets to spend time away with her grandparents alone or she doesn’t.
Whose best interest is it that she doesn’t?

Isaidno22 · 07/07/2022 21:32

YANBU. I wouldn’t. They need to recognise you have two children, they have two grandchildren, who are both worthy of their attention.
I’ve seen the other side of the imbalance of attention. My current and previous partners were both the least favoured child, which continued into adulthood, and that also brings issues. I remember my mum being so upset when my auntie took me and my cousins to the cinema. She said she’d take my brother, who had some behaviour issues, on his own another time but never did. Kids know and whilst it would be great for your DD it would equally be not-great for your DS.
The grandparents need to start small with activities with both children (or one and then the other like suggested earlier) before they build up a relationship and enough experience to take them away. Is this something you and your DH could facilitate?