Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you take both or you don't get DD

588 replies

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 14:43

I have two children, DS is nearly eight, autistic and has additional needs. DD is four and neurotypical.

Neither side of the family has ever offered us practical support or help with DS, never offered to babysit or take him out. The only help I received with him was a few hours while I had planned c section for DD and then my husband had to go home by teatime to put him to bed.

DD is growing and developing at the same rate as her peers, she's a very funny and outgoing little girl who makes us all laugh. We put a lot of effort into giving her our attention and support so that she doesn't feel resentful of time that we have to give to her brother, who she loves.

She is getting to the age now where both sets of grandparents are talking about having her go to their houses to stay, or taking her on holiday. But when they talk about this they only ever mention her. Never my son.

My heart says you don't get to pick and choose which of my kids you give this attention to. But I don't want to deny DD happy memories. AIBU?

OP posts:
GeologyBedRock · 08/07/2022 14:46

OP I get where you are coming from and understand why you feel like you do. Although I think if your DP/Dp in laws had tried more with your DS you would feel happier about your DD now getting their attention (and probably to you feels like their love).

My DD is NT and my DS is ND. He does have violent meltdowns, he bolts, he is very hard work. However he is also amazing, clever and kind. My mum has my DD regularly and not my DS however this is because routine is better for him. She spends time at my house playing with him. She finds things like books he would like in charity shops and sends them to him. She has a bond with him, she loves him and respects his way of doing things. Therefore I am happy for my DD to spend time alone with my mum and grateful DD gets to do things we would find tricky with him as well.

This I think is the difference - the acceptance of DS needs and treating them fairly albeit not the same but within their ability. Whereas I gather from your posts you do not feel they are treating your children fairly.

Kanaloa · 08/07/2022 14:28

However if there was some bad tone to my post I apologise - it’s hard to convey tone over these posts! I was just more saying that if you had been clearer about the previous issues people might have been able to offer better advice. But it isn’t unreasonable that grandparents can’t provide babysitting for a child with quite complex needs.

I do understand as I have an autistic son myself. It is a very very difficult balance between his needs and his siblings’ needs. And just like you I feel so protective of him because I don’t want people to ‘judge’ him on his behaviours as I know they’re not his fault. It’s very hard and I’m sorry you’re having such a rubbish time.

Kanaloa · 08/07/2022 14:23

jamoncrumpets · 08/07/2022 08:46

He's a human being with feelings @Kanaloa, not a dangerous dog.

Of course he’s a human being with feelings. That doesn’t make any difference to the fact that he has complex needs which may mean grandparents can’t provide babysitting and sole care of him. I didn’t say or imply he was a dangerous dog at all and I wouldn’t do such a thing.

Authenticity2020 · 08/07/2022 13:47

I think the issue here is: are the family not interested in DS? Or are they lacking confidence and willing to still make an effort, to the extent that they can. Even if they don’t do an all day and night with DS, could they manage an hour or two? At least then there’s an opportunity for both children to have A relationship with grandparents.

At the moment it sounds like they’re showing no interest in DS and favouring DD and that’s what’s upsetting OP.

Authenticity2020 · 08/07/2022 13:42

YANBU. Children deserve to be treated fairly. Even if DD stays with grandparents, it means she’s losing one on one time with you, that DS enjoys but then DS does
not get that special time with grandparents. It’s not fair for either of them.

There’s nothing to say that they both have to always go at the same time? They could start with time one on one with your son for a few hours in the day and see how they get on, maybe they need some support with that initially if they are worried; but then they can also do the same with your daughter. And once they are happy & confident to look after each of them separately, they can progress to have both at once in the daytime and then eventually, to overnights if that’s something everyone is happy with, including your son.

I don’t think DD should lose out, but neither should DS. And they should want a relationship with both grandchildren. I think that’s the root of the issue and you’re within your right to be bothered by it IMO.

I wouldn’t want grandparents looking after my child if they didn’t really want to. If it’s simply a lack of confidence, that’s different, but that needs to be established. If they’re not interested in one child, that would be a problem for me because why is their love and support conditional based on whether they are ND or NT?

calmlakes · 08/07/2022 13:27

jamoncrumpets · 08/07/2022 08:46

He's a human being with feelings @Kanaloa, not a dangerous dog.

OP the poster wrote a measured and not particularly unsupportive post.
You are reading things that haven't been written.

It sounds as though you're previous experiences with family mean that you don't want your dd to have a relationship with them, that is your choice to make.

It is worth thinking about where in the future your dd can get individual one to one support out of the immediate family. Many posters have highlighted how important this is going to be in the years to come.

TheSummerPalace · 08/07/2022 12:58

I had three DC, two of them with SEN.

We now have two grandchildren. I used to look after DGD, the first one, two days a week from 9 months old, while DDIL went to work. Apart from getting meals and changing nappies, I spent all day playing with DGD. She came in the house and was happy to play with the toys all day. DGS, two years younger was a whole different ball game - if we took our eyes off him for a minute, he was doing something potentially dangerous! Chewing electric cables; opening the front door (and another minute more, he would probably have been off down the road, looking for his mother); climbing up the settee to stand on the window ledge to look for his mother; getting rubbish out the bin to put in his mouth……Really, we needed to move the whole contents of the house upwards out of his reach, and we couldn’t do that! His parents said the same thing - he was always climbing, falling and banging his head; and he did things that never occurred to his sister!

I think she is a typical girl (actually an extremely active one), and he is a typical boy - but I did not feel at all confident about looking after him at 18 months, when he had no sense and was mouthing everything. There is a reason people have babies in their 20s; and we find it far more exhausting, looking after young children at our age!

I can well understand other grandparents do not have the confidence to look after a child with additional needs!

ManateeFair · 08/07/2022 12:44

Of course your son’s grandparents should be showing him love and affection, and of course they should want to have a good, close relationship with him, and should value him as much as his sister. I don’t think anyone would argue against that, and I haven’t seen anyone suggest otherwise. YANBU to expect that.

However, that wasn’t what you asked in your original post - your issue was that they didn’t babysit, take him out, assist with his care etc. And that’s a very different thing.

Your son, as your other threads make clear, has some very specific needs. Among other things, you mention in other threads that he finds new situations very stressful and upsetting and that this can cause severe meltdowns, etc. Nobody here is criticising your son for this. Nobody is saying he isn’t a lovely little boy. All they are pointing out is that he has needs that not everyone would be capable of meeting.

I would not want to take a child out for the day, for example, if that child was likely to become intensely upset and overwhelmed by the experience. I would also not want to babysit a child whose needs I didn’t think I was capable of meeting. Not because I didn’t love the child, but because I would simply be out of my depth and unable to keep them happy and safe. That wouldn’t necessarily be disability related - for example, I would happily babysit a three-year-old but not their young baby sibling because I simply wouldn’t have the confidence or knowledge to meet a baby’s needs properly.

That’s why your son’s particular needs and behaviours are relevant to your question. Nothing to do with his likeability or his worth or how deserving he is of love and kindness. It’s just a question of whether people can cope with meeting his needs, for his sake more than theirs. Not everyone could.

Mellowyellow222 · 08/07/2022 12:08

As an aunt I have tried to put myself in the grandparents position.

while I do understand being nervous about taking the child alone, given his special needs, I don’t understand how they haven’t built a relationship with him over the years.

this can’t be a close family or else they would have spent a lot of time on the boys company with one or both parent there. They would have got to know and understand his needs and would at least have been able to c are for him for short bursts in his own home.

they just seem to have written him off

user29 · 08/07/2022 12:05

I am a sibling of a disabled child..I loved and hated my DB so much at the same time. Everything being arranged around DB's needs , with mine as an afterthought. The stab of pain and protectiveness, when people stared and whispered or sometimes just outright said horrible things about DB. As i got older being embarassed to have friends over because of DB. Mother pushing me to have friends over and the stress of having to make excuses to spare her feelings as to the reason why i wouldn't.
DB's presence in some way spoiling everything that would have been nice, holidays, meals out parties. I am ashamed that i felt that way, but that is the reality . And the worst thing there is nobody you can share these feelings with without initiating a shit storm of pain guilt and hurt feelings.It wasn't until i went to university the weight of guilt, responsibility and resentment lifted that i realised the burden i had been carrying

Your DD is 4 and this won't really have started for her yet.Please do not deny her any little bit of pleasure or opportunity that comes her way.

Manamala · 08/07/2022 11:45

TournamentIgloo · 07/07/2022 22:25

Also he's bloody 8 years old. How fucking DARE they make no effort in 8 years to foster a relationship or get to know him. They don't deserve to have fun with your daughter just because she's easy and funny and 'appealing' to their limited sense of socially acceptable, when they have made 0 effort in 8 years to find what your DS enjoys and have fun times with him too.

I bet there is plenty they could have forged a connection with him about. Lazy, ablest and now opportunistic with your 'normal' child. It's disgusting.

This!

YANBU and you are right this thread is full of ableist attitudes.

It sounds like the grandparents desperately need to educate themselves and have long think about how they perceive their DGS.

GrinAndVomit · 08/07/2022 11:38

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 21:40

Spending time with GPs who aren't interested in a vulnerable little boy who happens to be their GC? Doesn't seem a great option, I think she's better off with OP who seems a very caring and involved mother.

Maybe someone needs to have a word with the GPs about their attitude and the upset it is causing.

The grandparents obviously don’t feel confident that they could cope with their grandson and his very complex and extreme needs alone.

By not allowing the daughter to go, nothing would be achieved except the daughter missing out on time with her grandparents and getting a break from the very full on needs of her brother.

It would be cutting the OP’s nose of to spite her daughter’s face.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 08/07/2022 11:27

I know you've riled yourself up to a state where you can't undig your heels, but from a disabled person... please let her go. If she doesn't like it then fair enough, but give it a chance. Even just a one-night sleepover with her gandparents.

Runnerbeansflower · 08/07/2022 11:17

Mariposista · 08/07/2022 10:37

The GP need to be bonding with both children but doing it together all the time is not fair on either child. On the one hand, it would put your SN son who needs routine in a situation that may overwhelm him, potentially provoking a huge tantrum (not his fault) and forcing the activity to be cut short. Yet accommodating his needs and choosing an activity that he may be comfortable with would limit the scope of your daughter’s experiences (also not fair - how much of your home life is already like this?)
they can see your son at home, bond with him in a safe, calm environment and then take your daughter for some well deserved crazy fun!

But they don't bother with DS at all...

Mariposista · 08/07/2022 10:37

The GP need to be bonding with both children but doing it together all the time is not fair on either child. On the one hand, it would put your SN son who needs routine in a situation that may overwhelm him, potentially provoking a huge tantrum (not his fault) and forcing the activity to be cut short. Yet accommodating his needs and choosing an activity that he may be comfortable with would limit the scope of your daughter’s experiences (also not fair - how much of your home life is already like this?)
they can see your son at home, bond with him in a safe, calm environment and then take your daughter for some well deserved crazy fun!

alphapie · 08/07/2022 10:20

Op I can understand your hurt, but you need to look at this objectively.

Your sons needs are high, you claim they are not but from your posts in May this isn't the case. Not wiping and jumping on soft furnishings, not being able to be left near unsecured cupboards and melting down if you're not around aren't easy to manage, especially for older people.

You seem to really be fixating on the 'normal' comments and I think this is down to you being autistic yourself and feeling triggered by this, wondering if that's what they thought about you growing up, that you weren't 'normal'

Regardless of their attitude or comments towards your son, at the end of the day it's unreasonable to hold your DD back from experiences with her grandparents. They feel able to cope with her, she will enjoy the time outside of the immediate family environment.

You also seem to be conflating siblings of ND children needing s break and not loving their siblings. Both can be true, my brother was diagnosed with Asperger's years ago (when that was a separate diagnosis) and was high functioning, no toileting issues or communication issues but it was amazing for me to have breaks growing up. I still love him, but his existence made my childhood very different and not in a good way either. When younger I resented him a lot and needed that time for me, to go to Pizza Hut (he could never go as the smell of melted cheese triggered him) or to go bowling (he could never handle all the noise and taking turns)

I still have a limited diet as an adult due to him, growing up as DM didn't want to have to cook 3 different meals I was only fed things he would eat, which wasn't a wide range and it has led to me having still restricted eating now, as those prime 'trying new foods and textures' phases went past me, who lived on nuggets, chips and bread until secondary when I started cooking for myself.

My parents made a lot of effort to try and limit the impact of his needs on me, it wasn't enough and never would have been. You don't seem able to understand just because you give her 121 attention, at some point that won't be enough. Your needs are clouding your judgement on this and it's very clear from your posts.

You are minimising his needs, you've already made your decision which is the wrong one for your DD.

youcantparktheresir · 08/07/2022 10:16

Mally100 · 07/07/2022 14:52

Yabvu to deny her this, even though it is unfair. Your ds needs might be just too much to cope with / restrictive for holidays and non routine activities. So why deny your dd these opportunities and respite when she has to deal with alot at home?

Agreed

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/07/2022 10:00

Try to see it objectively as you can OP

if your son has behaviours such as not wiping when he goes to the loo and then making mess - that’s hard for people to deal with. It really is. It will not bother you to the same extent because he is your son, but it’s different for others.

KatherineJaneway · 08/07/2022 09:46

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 18:52

He. Still. Deserves. Affection. And. Attention.

No one is saying he doesn't. However from your other posts you are underplaying how complex his needs are.

Rickrollme · 08/07/2022 09:43

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 15:56

Suggesting a few people here also read

For those with SEN child how much do your family help? http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4584971-for-those-with-sen-child-how-much-do-your-family-help

Quite eye opening.

Is it though? If you posted the same thing about NT children you’d get plenty of people whose families aren’t interested. It would be so lovely if we all had hands-on relatives willing to take the kids off our hands but for a million reasons many of us don’t. Your case is a bit different as you are talking about family members who do want to be with one of the children but not the other. I agree you should try to get your parents to show interest in your son but you can’t expect them to take him as much or in the same way as your daughter. Or if you do, you need to be ready for them to say thanks but no thanks and not take either of them. If that is what’s necessary to protect your son’s feelings it’s worth it but if he doesn’t really notice or care you would be wasting the opportunity for your DD to do fun things and for you to get some time with just one child. There’s no right or wrong here but be careful in making ultimatums unless you are OK e with it not working out the way you want. You can’t control other people and they often don’t react well when you try.

GrinAndVomit · 08/07/2022 09:26

jamoncrumpets · 08/07/2022 08:46

He's a human being with feelings @Kanaloa, not a dangerous dog.

You’re spiralling. No one has said anything that could be anywhere close to justifying this reply.

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/07/2022 09:15

jamoncrumpets · 08/07/2022 08:46

He's a human being with feelings @Kanaloa, not a dangerous dog.

@jamoncrumpets

where has she said anything of the sort??

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 08/07/2022 09:12

jamoncrumpets · 08/07/2022 08:46

He's a human being with feelings @Kanaloa, not a dangerous dog.

I have read that posters response and don't see how this reply fits with that.

The post you challenged was from May which shows that his needs are higher then what you have alluded to here

You also don't answer what you have done in your home with you present to build a bond.
You seem fixated on them taking sole care of him. Which you may need to accept will never happen.

jamoncrumpets · 08/07/2022 08:46

He's a human being with feelings @Kanaloa, not a dangerous dog.

OP posts:
Oranges555 · 08/07/2022 08:16

I think talk to grandparents and find out where the issue lies, if it’s favouritism then definitely no to having your DD, it’s not fair on your DS and will only prove as close example of inequality. It may be they are just not confident having him in which case you could work out a plan for them to gradually spend more 1:1 time with him with your guidance until they are more confident.

On the other note ignore everyone commenting negatively regarding DD, in my opinion she’ll grow up a lovely well rounded individual who will be more compassionate about the world and the different people in it!

Regardless of how autistic your DS is or not he deserves the exact same treatment as anybody else