Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you take both or you don't get DD

588 replies

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 14:43

I have two children, DS is nearly eight, autistic and has additional needs. DD is four and neurotypical.

Neither side of the family has ever offered us practical support or help with DS, never offered to babysit or take him out. The only help I received with him was a few hours while I had planned c section for DD and then my husband had to go home by teatime to put him to bed.

DD is growing and developing at the same rate as her peers, she's a very funny and outgoing little girl who makes us all laugh. We put a lot of effort into giving her our attention and support so that she doesn't feel resentful of time that we have to give to her brother, who she loves.

She is getting to the age now where both sets of grandparents are talking about having her go to their houses to stay, or taking her on holiday. But when they talk about this they only ever mention her. Never my son.

My heart says you don't get to pick and choose which of my kids you give this attention to. But I don't want to deny DD happy memories. AIBU?

OP posts:
HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:22

Even if they could cope with DS and made an effort to do that too, it would still be okay and probably very nice for DD to have time alone wit them as well.

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:21

Two children with completely different needs are never going to have the exact same childhood. It's sad but it's also not DDs fault.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2022 15:21

Quoted the wrong post!

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2022 15:20

SpaceJamtart · 07/07/2022 15:10

It is so sad when families do this and it isn't fair. Would he be happy to go and stay with them if they would have him

I would let her go on trips with them- as it would be nice for her to have time with extended family, and as the sister to many siblings with additional needs and disabilities- I did really value the time where I got to do activities that would never be suitable for my siblings. Not because I didn't love them or love the things we did together or even that I wanted to be away from them. But my auntie took me to a model village and to a museum that my brothers would have broken and screamed through and it was so fun, I got to chat with her and to sit up at a table in a cafe and read the plaques and not be the family that everyone stared at for a day.

And even though it is sad that they are not offering him a similar experience, it does give you more individual time to do activities and have experiences with your son that he would enjoy, especially things that his sister might stop enjoying.

Have you asked the family to look after him? Do they engage with him when you see them as a family?

That's for his needs. Completely different.

I now feel fortunate that my parents only have one GC, DD who is ND. She was hard to manage for a while but they did. Now I could hire them out as babysitters for DC with severe ADHD. They have skills.

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:20

Stuff being fair to them

It's not so much about them it's about her daughter. She shouldn't miss out because family find it difficult to cope with her brother. It would be nice for her to have some time focused on her, as much as OP I'm sure does this too, I can imagine she does have some restrictions on this having a sibling with complex needs. It's okay to let her do normal things her brother may be unable to do / cope with.

MaxOverTheMoon · 07/07/2022 15:16

It all depends on how hard it is to look after him OP. It's not fair to deny your dd those experiences.

I don't really understand why close family don't help out, even if it's not full days. My family have helped me loads with my dd and I'm looking forward to doing the same with her children if she has any. Have you asked them to babysit, even in your home rather than their home before?

StoppinBy · 07/07/2022 15:16

I think there is a compromise to be had here.

Allow your youngest the time with family, it will be a good opportunity for you to have 1:1 time with your eldest but in exchange make a time for either you or your husband to go with your eldest to do similar activities with family so that they also get that special time but one of you is on hand.

As sad as it is they may just not be coping with your eldest, you might find though that if one of you is on hand but also allow them to take the lead that they become more comfortable with looking after them and may come to see that they can do it.

I can imagine how heartbreaking this is but I do think a compromise would be something to look at. Be open with them about how you feel and offer positive solutions for them, hopefully it will work out well for everyone.

Meraas · 07/07/2022 15:11

I'm with you, OP. 4 years is not much of an age difference. I would have been very upset to see a younger sibling being favoured in this way, especially if you already have a sense that you're different from other kids.

Wombat27A · 07/07/2022 15:10

I think the issue here is the silence about the older DC. If they were open and fair and discussed the issues or looked for a compromise or solution or even said we'd love to look after him but can't cope, then it would be fine to discuss plans for the little one. But they haven't and I think that's rude and unfair.

Stuff being fair to them.

Plenty of other kids haven't had GP look after and them and we grew up with a severely ill older sibling, so I have some sympathy but they're not being fair or equitable. They don't get to make plans for your DC.

SpaceJamtart · 07/07/2022 15:10

It is so sad when families do this and it isn't fair. Would he be happy to go and stay with them if they would have him

I would let her go on trips with them- as it would be nice for her to have time with extended family, and as the sister to many siblings with additional needs and disabilities- I did really value the time where I got to do activities that would never be suitable for my siblings. Not because I didn't love them or love the things we did together or even that I wanted to be away from them. But my auntie took me to a model village and to a museum that my brothers would have broken and screamed through and it was so fun, I got to chat with her and to sit up at a table in a cafe and read the plaques and not be the family that everyone stared at for a day.

And even though it is sad that they are not offering him a similar experience, it does give you more individual time to do activities and have experiences with your son that he would enjoy, especially things that his sister might stop enjoying.

Have you asked the family to look after him? Do they engage with him when you see them as a family?

CrazyBaubles · 07/07/2022 15:10

I think it depends on their reasons tbh.

I have a niece and nephew who are a year apart in age. Nephew has a physical disability and is being investigated for autism. Niece is NT.

I love them both. I've taken niece for days out and have her regularly on her own. She loves being at my house, she enjoys the one on one time and it helps dsis out.

I very rarely see nephew without dsis - this is because he wouldn't be comfortable with just me for longer than an hour or 2.

I used to feel bad about this but in our case being fair to both means treating them differently - if I pushed to take nephew out the way I do with niece he would be so upset I think he's associate me with being scared and I would hate that.

Sirzy · 07/07/2022 15:09

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2022 15:06

Surely the relatives are punishing her. She likes spending time with her brother.

But that doesn’t mean she won’t enjoy, or even benefit from, trips out with family without him.

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:09

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2022 15:06

Surely the relatives are punishing her. She likes spending time with her brother.

I don't think so. OP needs to accept, as hard as it is, that having one child with additional needs and the other NT, there will always be differences in what they can do, the opportunities they can reasonably have etc...

Saying 'no, DD can't do that because DS can't' is not fair when we are talking about two children with such vastly different needs (if they are vastly different, OP hasn't specified really).

11Hawkins · 07/07/2022 15:08

YANBU. It can cause so many problems leaving one child out not just for your son but your daughter too.

It's all or nothing in my eyes.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 07/07/2022 15:08

How severe are your sons' needs? I mean, are they physically capable of doing the necessary care for him? I mean, for example, if he needs changing or has meltdowns, can they do those things without help and without getting injured?

Overall, I don't think it's fair to restrict your DD because your DS has additional needs that the grandparents might struggle with.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2022 15:06

Dotjones · 07/07/2022 15:05

YABU to punish her for having a brother with special needs. That's not anyone's fault, especially not her's.

Surely the relatives are punishing her. She likes spending time with her brother.

Dotjones · 07/07/2022 15:05

YABU to punish her for having a brother with special needs. That's not anyone's fault, especially not her's.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 07/07/2022 15:04

I think it depends , my youngest has asd and when he was little the only person I really felt comfortable having him was my sister who is a LD nurse.

My mum has taken away his brother who is just under 2 years older than him along with my dn who is the same age. She also had my elder children separately and together though (big age gaps)

Now ds4 is older (9) my family have him either with his brother or on his own but he's in ms school, doesn't need 1:1 and no longer jas meltdowns etc

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:04

it's not her fault she has a sibling with special needs. She'll probably have limitations all her childhood because of it, and possibly into adulthood as well, so don't hold her back when she doesn't need holding back.

And yes sorry I agree with this.

TheDepthsOfDespair · 07/07/2022 15:03

Yabu.
you can’t insist that they care for DS if they don’t feel able to. And it’s unfair for dd to miss out.

dd regularly stays at grandmas house but DS hasn’t and they’re both nt.

Buythebag40 · 07/07/2022 15:02

I think that's awful - if the reason is that they're scared of his issues then it's on them to learn how to deal with problems that may arise. However, could it be ignorance on their part? Do they assume you wouldn't want to leave him in anyone else's care in case they couldn't look after him as well as you?

id like to think if it was my grandchild I'd make the effort to learn about how to deal with his needs - and I'd want to give my DD\SIL a break now and then.

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:02

Well it does depend on the severity of your son's additional needs.

But if they are such that it's unlikely family members can cope taking him away or having him stay by themselves then I do think you are being unreasonable.

It of course comes across as unfair to you but I do believe your DD should be given some opportunities for normality i.e. holidays with grandparents and shouldn't be stopped from doing that because her brother has more complex needs than she does. I think you need to see it from both angles, not just your son's. It would be unfair on your daughter though too to miss out on these opportunities.

JustLyra · 07/07/2022 15:02

It entirely depends on the needs of your DS.

I would never deny my other kids time with people who don’t have the ability or confidence to cope with my youngest. Her needs are extensive and daunting.

in fact I’d much rather people were honest about their capabilities and confidence than try and bluster their way through it in a bid to be fair, or just not bother with any of the kids at all

XmasElf10 · 07/07/2022 14:58

Depending on the severity of additional needs I think you are being quite reasonable. My DD is NT. My niece has ASD, ADHD, APD and some pretty severe ticks. She can be a handful but she is never left out of family activities and spends time with me and her grandparents. I’d expect family to put the effort into learning how to cope with your sons needs so that he can be included successfully. Shame on them.

missdemeanors · 07/07/2022 14:58

To expand on my post, if it's the case that the gp's aren't putting any effort into having a relationship with your son then I think they're wrong. However Unsure they might feel, they should at least be trying to have a loving relationship.

But babysitting, days out, sleepovers and holidays - these are different. Being fair doesn't mean treating them identically, given that one has a disability and as I said earlier, for many autistic children, the disruption to their routine would be the opposite of enjoyable anyway

Swipe left for the next trending thread